HomeMy WebLinkAbout374454 ARTHUR J GALLAGHER RISK MGT SERVICES - CONTRACT - RFP - P1158 INUSRANCE (3)Administrative Services
Purchasing Division
City of Fort Collins
April 28, 2009
Ms. Karen Graham
ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO.
6399 S. Fiddler's Green Circle
Greenwood Village, CO 80111
VIA E-MAIL
KAREN_GRAHAM@AJG.COM
RE: CITY OF FORT COLLINS - 2009/10 INSURANCE PROGRAM
LETTER OF AGREEMENT
Dear Karen:
On behalf of the City of Fort Collins, Poudre Fire Authority, Poudre Fire Protection
District and the Loveland/Fort Collins Airport, I would like to confirm our agreement to
bind the coverages you have proposed with the following carriers, for twelve months
effective May 1, 2009.
➢ Property: Lexington
➢ Fiduciary Liability and Public Dishonesty: Travelers
➢ Excess Workers' Compensation: Midwest Employers
➢ Boiler & Machinery: Zurich
➢ Inland Marine — Fine Arts: AXA
➢ PFA/PFPD Workers' Compensation: Pinnacol
The agreement to bind coverage is based upon your compliance with your proposal,
subsequent correspondence and this Letter of Agreement which outlines below those
areas modified or needing additional clarification. The two attachments further clarify
our understanding of your offering and form a part of this agreement. Further, all carriers
except for Inland Marine and Fiduciary constitute renewal placements based on existing
coverage except where noted in the attached summary taken from your proposal entitled,
"Major Changes to Expiring Program." Therefore, coverage will be reviewed in that
context, as well.
215 Nor1A tt'hr5i?41`• 2nd Floor • P.O. Box 580 • Fort Collins, CO 80522-0580 • (970) 221-6775 • FAX (970) 221-6707
Ms. Karen Graham
April 28, 2009
Page 2
1. You will endeavor to have copies of all policies provided to COFC within 90 days
of the coverage effective date, if possible.
2. Premiums, and coverages serving as a basis for this agreement are per
Attachments I and 11, Cost and Coverage Comparisons, respectively. Limits,
deductibles and rates are per your proposal and supporting exhibits.
3. All required binders and certificates will be issued prior to May 1, 2009. See
certificate list attached.
4. We recognize AJGs efforts to review coverage forms and complete coverage
checklists represent an effort to inventory coverages. This was done since the
carriers themselves were not able or willing to complete these. While the City
recognizes that these are for illustration purposes and the actual policy language
will prevail. We relied on these representations in the process of analyzing the
bids received. These serve as a basis for future review efforts of actual policies.
Therefore, please take a look at these and forward to the carriers, if appropriate. A
complete policy review will be done after policy issuance.
5. The City is aware of the fact that signatures on renewal applications have been
requested as a condition of binding and these are being completed and will be
forwarded to you shortly.
6. Our portfolio of coverages with the exception of the liability package is all being
placed with Gallagher. The liability package (excess general liability, public
officials, errors and omissions, and automobile liability and employment practices
liability) is being placed directly with States.
7. In addition to the renewal of expiring lines, excluding the liability package, we
request that you serve as our broker on PFA/PFPD's workers compensation
program with Pinnacol Assurance effective 5/l/09. (A copy of their proposal is
attached.) Payrolls have been verified as being correct.
8. A brokerage fee of $52,000 has been quoted and accepted. Any commission paid
on the fine arts and workers' compensation will serve as off -sets on this amount.
Therefore, ultimately the difference will be returned to the City. Although a
schedule will be generated to disclose levels of commissions received based on
premium payment structures, it is anticipated by the City based on the fairly large
commission paid by Pinnacol that the ultimate level of expense to the City for
brokerage fees will be no greater than $10,000.
Ms. Karen Graham
April 28, 2009
Page 3
If the terms of this Letter of Agreement are correct, please sign the letter returning the
original to me with binders today.
Sincerely,
Y—
?Jaes II,102NI�G�P
rof Purchasing and Risk Management
ARTHUR J. GALLAGHER & CO.
Signed:
Enclosures
Date
cc: Mr. James Graham, Applied Risk Solutions
Mr. Lance Murray, Risk Manager, City of Fort Collins
M:\COFC\2003 Services\Correspondence\cov_agree _Itr_AJG.doc
CLIENT OPT -OUT ELECTION
Supplemental or Contingent Commission
Dated: 4/19/1 l
Effective January 1 of the next calendar year after the above date, the undersigned client of the
undersigned retail brokerage subsidiary of Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. ("Gallagher") requests that
the insurance policy(ies) issued by the insurance company(ies) indicated below, insuring the risks
listed below in the column titled "INSURANCE COVERAGE" for each such insurance
company, be EXCLUDED from the following forms of additional compensation that may be
payable to Gallagher (SELECT A or B, or Both):
A. _xx_ Supplemental commissions
B. _xx_ Contingent commissions
INSURANCE COMPANY
INSURANCE COVERAGE
Midwest Employers
Excess Workers' Compensation
Travelers Casualty & Surety Company
Crime and Fiduciary Liability
Lexington Insurance Company
Commercial Property
Zurich American Insurance Company
Equipment Breakdown
Fidelity Insurance
Flood — National Flood Insurance Program
Federal Insurance Company
Builders Risk
Hartford Life and Accident Insurance
Accident & Health
AXA Art Insurance Company/Huntington
T. Block
Fine Arts — Inland Marine
Pinnacol Assurance
Poudre Fire Authority— Workers'
Compensation Insurance
By-o Fort ollrins�
Y�
James . O' eill II Director of Purchasing and Risk Management
Submitted by Karen Graham, Arthur J. Gallagher Risk Management Services Denver
Branch