HomeMy WebLinkAboutBid Tally -7225 LP TRANSFORMERS 75KVA & 300KVABID TALLY SHEET
Bid:7225 LP Transformers 75kVA & 300kVA
Bid Date and Time:3:00 PM, April 12, 2011
BIDDER
75kVA Base Bid Each
75kVA Base Bid
300kVA Base Bid
300kVA Base Bid
Extended Cost
Each
Extended Cost
Stuart C Irby
$7,540.00
$37,700.00
$11,440.00
$57,200.00
KVA Supply
$6,506.20
$32,531.00
$9,506,20
$47.531.00
Wesco Distribution
$6.600.00
$33,000.00
$11,237.00
$56.185.00
Western United — Pauwels
$5,340.00
$26,700.00
Western United - Howard
$5,085.00
$25,425.00
$9,660.00
$48,300.00
R U.I.
5
IStd Doc) DID TALLY
Apn115. 2011
Size
75 eVA
aid
7225
NIL LOSS Cost
$ 39U
FL LOSS Cost
5 2 3V
Specified
Importance
R.. S. on
Rv4 B. tin
Rasa 0q
Mem. DoC
0.(I. red
Ever. IW (I is
Baia
Btl SI
Evaluated
E.I.I. Cuss
Gum No loaf WLoss
-NL
Gum FW FL Lou'FL
Gum Time
2010
SuppW'
Uiuvm)
m n aet
Exlr
Bid
(rule st Mir Iri
Deks
YW
Loss LaC
uAL
Lima Loss ss LoC.
LOW Lou InyLussas
..advice?alm.
Esh MW advice?
LVA Soppy
3
$
6 W620
S 9,281 ]U
S 32,531 W Cenbal Moli
10
190 9
2I220
871 S 200331I
1043
1. W Yes
is nor
No. Not on approved L51 yet.
Wvaian Wua
1
1
$
50lU Uu
S 7.M20
S 25425W NOWam
61.8
209 S
615.10
802 S 1,8W.10
1010
2.IU Yes
is nut
yea
Wrsmarn uli
2
2
S
5 ]40. W
5 7,769 W
S 26 ]00.00 Pauwes
6 m B
245 5
9150
641 $ 1474. W
886
1.95 Yee
Is not
yes
Wesco
4
3
5
6.13W LU
S 9.160tO
S 35.00() W ABB
10
233 5
90810
710 S 165140
951
I Yes
is not
yes
51—n C wy
5
5
$
] 51000
S 10 311 i0
$ 37.700.UO Coapor
um B
182 $
729-W
Gum 5 2,Oa240
1025
1.95 Yes
is not
yes
Ni
I Cenval Moloney is rich an approved manufacturer an this revis= of the spacocabon.
2 ABB Exceptmn on testing costs noted Iw sound level and Impulse lasting. Testing cost added W extended Cost for evaluated bid as follows,
temperature rise Not a required production test
Imuuise test $1,000
Souno level $1,W0
Power Facmor Not a reywretl cdducean teal
3 Based on the evaluated bid. Western United has offered the best option with their Howard offer.
9 Units 5 ($W Doc) BID TALLY April 15,2011
$iae 300 kill BM Is 2225
NLLoss Cost $ 3.90
FL Lass Cost $ 2.30
Specified
Impedance
Rao'. Bares on Relk Based an
Base Bid
M¢eIs DOE
Big It is oast
Evaluated ry (1
Base M $ I
Evaluated
Exlawed Cost
Guar No Wao NL loss' NIL
Gus Full FL Less' FL
Guar TOW
2010
Sulxsaer
c ma)
Haas, n.,ae)
Ed.
Boo
ITmal SI MIN M"
DtlANrs
Loss Lass Cast
Load Loss Loss Cast
LOW Loss lopeIXvae Losses
Escalation
Meet Specs?
.VA Sapply
2
-
$ 9.50620
$16.742.20
$ 47,531.W Can,,., Moloney
10
841 $2,523.30
2049 $4,I12. 10
2696
2.31 Yes
is not
No. Not on approved list
Western Wulzu
3
3
$ 9660.00
$17.14440
$ 48,300.00 Noward
6to8
528 $2,254.20
2274 $5,230,20
2852
2.60 Yes
.snot
Yes
Western Unnud
1
1
S 8.580.00
$15.934.20
$ 42900.00 Pauwels
6to6
649 $2531.10
2097 $4,82310
2746
249 Yes
.snot
Yes
Wescd
4
4
$ 11,23700
$18.919.60
S 58, 185A0 ABB
10
602 S2,361.30
2311 $5,315.30
2918
2.50 Yes
.s net
Yes
StuanC Ire,
5
4
$ 11440.00
$IB.913T.30
$ 52,200.00 Cooper
6toa
632 $2,464.80
2175 $ 5,002.W
2807
2,51 Yes
Is not
Yes
Notes:
1 C.Enaal Moloney i5 rat an approved manufacturer on ins revision of me specification.
2 ABB Exception on testing costs noted for sound level and Impulse testing. Testing Mal added to wanted cost for evaluated bid as Follows'
temperature iis; Not a required Moductwn test
onpulse test $1;000
Sound level $1,000
Power Faclor Not a required prod ucbon test
3 Based on the results of this evaluated bid, Western United has offered the best option with their Pauwels offer.