HomeMy WebLinkAboutBid Tally -7169 PAD-MOUNTED COMPARTMENTAL-TYPE THREE-PHASE DISTRIBUTION TRANSFORMERS3 Phase Padmounted Transformer Bid Evaluation
# Units
1
Bid #: 7169
Size
2000 kVA
Date:
NIL Loss Cost
$
3.90
FL Loss Cost
$
2.30
Specified
Impedance %
5.75 (See Impedance Requirements Table in Specification)
Escalation
Base Bid
Rank Based on Rank Based on
Base Bid $ / Delivery Guar Full
(is / is not) Guar Total
Impedance NIL Loss' NIL Loss FL Loss' FL Loss
Extended Cost
Bid (1 is best Evaluated bid (1
Supplier
Manufacturer
Each (Weeks) Guar No Load Loss Load Loss
Impedance Meets Specs?
a factor? Load Loss
Variance Cost
Cost
(Total $) Evaluated Bid
choice) is best choice)
Western United
Pauwels
$ 29,457.00 11 to 13 2122 11588
5.75 Yes
is not 13710
0.00% $
8,275.80 $ 26,652.40
$ 29,457.00 $ 64,385.20
2 1
Wesco
ABB
$ 25,135.48 8 to 10 2606 13609
5.75 Yes
16215
0.00% $
10,163.40 $ 31.300.70
$ 25,135.48 $ 70,599.58
1 2
Stuart C. Irby
Cooper
$ 29,517.40 10 2223 12496
0.00 Yes
14719
-100.00% $
8,669.70 $ 28,740.80
$ 29,517.40 $ 72,427.90
3 3
Notes:
1) Cooper evaluated bid price adjusted to include the cost of audible noise testing and temperature testing.
2) Cooper exception to undercoating is accepted
3) ABB Evaluated bid price adjusted to include the cost of audible noise testing, impulse testing and temperature testing.
4) ABB exceptions to PT/CT Mounting plate and secondary bushing replacement accepted.
Opal Dick Re Fwd.- 7169 2000 kVA P- `=nounted Transformers Page 1 .1
From: Kraig Bader
To: Opal Dick
Date: 9/9/2010 6:00:41 PM
Subject: Re: Fwd: 7169 2000 kVA Padmounted Transformers
Opal,
Based on the quoted losses and the additional cost of the testing (from ABB and Cooper) we request in
our specification, the evaluated bid suggests that Pauwels is our best choice for this order.
Please see attached evaluation.
Thanks,
Kraig
Kraig Bader
Standards Engineering Manager
700 Wood Street
Fort Collins, CO 80521
Tel: 970-416-2481
Fax: 970-221-6619
kbader@fcgov.com
Fort Collins Utilities: Inspiring community leadership by reducing environmental impact while benefitting
customers, the economy, and society.
>>> Opal Dick 8/27/2010 3:17 PM >>>
Here is the other bid - please review, evaluate and make a recommendation on Both 7169 and 7167.
Thanks.