Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPARAGON POINT AMENDED OVERALL DEVELOPMENT PLAN 7.26.93 P AND Z BOARD HEARING - 48 91H - DECISION - MINUTES/NOTESPLANNING AND ZONING BOARD MEETING MINUTES July 26, 1993 Council Liaison: Gerry Horak Staff Support Liaison: Tom Peterson The July 26, 1993 regular meeting of the Planning and Zoning Board was called to order at 6:35 p.m. in the Council Chambers of City Hall West, 300 LaPorte Avenue, Fort Collins, Colorado. Board members present included Chair Lloyd Walker, Sharon Winfree, Jim Klataske, Jennifer Fontane, Jan Cottier and Rene Clements -Cooney. Member Bernie Strom was absent. Staff members present included Planning Director Tom Peterson, City Attorney Steve Roy, Ted Shepard, Steve Olt, Kirsten Whetstone, Kerrie Ashbeck and Kayla Ballard. AGENDA REVIEW Mr. Peterson reviewed the Consent Agenda which consisted of: Item 1 - Minutes of the June 28, 1993 Minutes; Item 2 - Southside Service Center, Amended Site Plan Advisory Review, Case #52-82E; Item 3 - Dakota Ridge PUD, 2nd Filing, Final, Case #60-91J; Item 4 - Greenstone PUD, Phase Three, Final, Case #54-92F; Item 5 - Castle Ridge at Miramont PUD, Preliminary and Final, Case #54-87J; Item 6 - Centre for Advance Technology 15th, Tract 3, New Mercer Office PUD, Final, Case #53-85E; Item 7 - Sunstone Village PUD, 8th Filing, Preliminary, Case #57-86L; Item 8 - Fox Creek PUD, Final, Case #5-93C and; Item 9 - Modifications of Conditions of Final Approval. Mr. Peterson reviewed the Discussion Agenda which included: Item 10 - Topanga at Hillpond PUD, Preliminary, Case #2-87H; Item 11 - Cobblestone Corners PUD, Preliminary, Case #55-87E; Item 12 - Paragon Point PUD, Amended Overall Development Plan, Case #48-91H and; Item 13 - Paragon Point PUD, 4th Filing, Preliminary and Final, Case #48-91I. Mr. Peterson added that the Board proceed with the election of a Vice -Chair to the P&Z Board. 1 '11 :••'1 & 15% 0,'" Chairman Walker introduced and welcomed Sharon Winfree and Jennifer Fontane as the new P&Z Board members. ELECTION OF VICE -CHAIR Member Cottier nominated Member Clements -Cooney as Vice -Chair. Member Klataske seconded the nomination. Upon a vote of 6-0, Member Clements -Cooney was elected as Vice -Chair. • Member Cottier asked that Item 5, Castle Ridge at Miramont PUD Preliminary and Final be pulled from Consent for discussion. Planning and Zoning Board Meeting Minutes July 26, 1993 Page 18 Member Cottier believed that this could be voted upon on a preliminary basis since the applicant stated that the four -bedroom units would become three -bedroom units. Member Fontane moved to approve this proposal with the condition that the four -bedroom units would be three -bedroom units and with the following Staff conditions: 1) At the time of F'mal PUD, the PUD shall indicate graphically, and the developer shall indicate in writing, a commitment to financially participate in design and construction of the "Arthur Spur" to mitigate the potential impact of bicycle traffic generated by the PUD.; 2) At the time of Final PUD, the easterly buffered zone shall contain a mix of plant material whereby 33% of the trees are speed to exceed the minimum of 6 to 8 feet in height for evergreen trees and 2 inches in caliper for deciduous trees. 3) At the time of Final PUD, Building "T", illustrated to be a three story 12-plex, shall be substituted by a building with a smaller envelope and reduced height in order to provide the necessary transition in scale and mass on the east side of the site. 4) At the time of Final PUD, the landscaping along the side elevations of the 6-plex and 10-plex structures shall be upgraded with increased plant material in order to mitigate height and promote neighborhood compatibility. Member Cottier seconded the motion with the condition that additional buffering be indicated on the south side. Member Fontane agreed to the condition set forth by Member Cottier. Member Cottier stated that, in supporting of this project, it does meet all the City's policies for where a project of high density should locate. She added that this project also encourages alternate modes of transportation. Chairman Walker believed that the Board is attempting to redesign the project and felt uncomfortable doing this. He believed that this project should be postponed. Member Winfree commented that she did not believe that she was seeing the project as it will be presented at final. She had concerns on whether it would meet the neighborhood compatibility for All Development Criteria 4. The motion to approve failed on a 3-3 vote. Members Winfree, Walker and Clements - Cooney were in the negative. Member Clements -Cooney moved to postpone this project to the August 23 regular P&Z meeting. Member Fontane seconded the motion. The motion to postpone passed 6-0. Chairman Walker stated that Paragon Point PUD Amended Overall Development Plan and Paragon Point PUD 4th Filing Preliminary and Final would be continued to the August 2, 1993 meeting.