HomeMy WebLinkAboutKING SOOPERS #146, MIDTOWN GARDENS MARKETPLACE (FORMERLY KMART REDEVELOPMENT ) - PDP - PDP160043 - SUBMITTAL DOCUMENTS - ROUND 1 - LUC REQUIREMENTS (2)KING SOOPERS #146: COMPARISON OF MIDTOWN PLAN POLICIES and PROPOSED DESIGN FOR
MIDTOWN GARDENS MARKETPLACE
June 2, 2016 Comment Response letter addressed 28 planning service request changes to overall site
plan and development, 18 engineering development requests, 7 environmental planning comments,
7 light & power comments, 7 fire authority comments, 8 stormwater comments, 10
traffic/transportation comments, 5 wastewater comments, and 10 zoning comments PROVING an
intense effort in compliance and satisfaction of not only the cities requirements but also of the
general requests and preferences for the Planned Development area.
November 2, 2016 a public neighborhood meeting was held to gain public feedback and to comply
with planning department requirements for PDP Submittal. Changes were made to the proposed site
plan to satisfy concerns voiced by public at this meeting, including but not limited to the removal of a
retail pad site for additional parking.
Category Midtown Plan Policies (Midtown Plan,
2013)
How addressed by The Design
Team(Galloway + CR Architecture and
Design (based on Comment Response
Letter, and proposed site development
plan)
Major
Overview
Points
In Garden thematic segment (to be
expressed in streetscape elements)
and reflecting of inherent features.
Utilize “floral” or “natural”(less
manicured) theme to reinforce
connection to the university’s agrarian
roots
Coordination of redevelopment on
abutting sites (urban in nature with
active street edges and generous
amount of transparency at ground
level)
Integration and coordination with
existing retail structures (efficient
flow of parking lot and walkways
continuously from MAX station to
access points)
Redevelopment plan fully
developed within the existing curb-
to-curb dimensions of the property
Areas dedicated to encouraging
sitting/eating/drinking shaded by
large deciduous shade trees for
comfort and enjoyment
Landscape plan uses natural theme
and design and creates an inviting
approach
Design
Elements
Active street frontages
Pedestrian oriented entries
Street facing windows
Small public spaces attached to
sidewalk
Public art (complementary to primary
structure)
Entrance oriented towards College
Ave, with Plaza and seating on the
Consider use of garage-like doors
along southeast and south elevations
to activate plaza (no blank walls facing
streets)
Encouraged use of locally-source
stone
Follow LCUASS for design of public
improvements
building
Plaza on the South side of the
building includes seating and
access that will incorporate natural
design theme
Window glazing along store front
Building
Specifics
Utilize materials that are durable and
well detailed. Masonry is encouraged
to convey permanence
Buildings to align at sidewalk edge,
entrances to face a primary street or
sidewalk and clearly identifiable
All sides of a building to have
architectural details
Drive-thru pharmacy and online
pick up locations moved to north
side of building in order to not
inhibit pedestrian connectivity
between MAX and store entrance
+ reduction in number of drive-
thru lanes
Building oriented to utilize existing
access points + provide access to
MAX station + provide sufficient
parking for new building
Primary entrance faces College
Avenue
Landscapes
High quality plant and material to
create identity. Utilize some cohesive
elements but also distinct elements
specific to the district
Generous tree row adjacent to curb
and sidewalks next to buildings
Landscape buffers to have more dense
planting of drip-irrigated shrub beds
If right-of-way permits, utilize
stormwater filtration beds
Landscape islands in parking lot every
15 spaces
Explore mitigation techniques to break
down large expanse of asphalt and
break up monotonous parking
surfaces
Fluid walkways that encourage
pedestrian circulation to/from
MAX station – walkways
continuous from College Ave
through to MAX station
Landscaping in plaza designed to
connectivity for pedestrians and
bicycle users
Sidewalk added along main
internal roadway to proposed
building to satisfy detached +
parkway sidewalk request
Bicycle parking to be provided at
main entrance of building and in
plaza area
LCUASS standards incorporated
Detached and widened sidewalk
along College and Drake per the
Master Plan
Parking Incorporate transit-oriented parking
solutions
Locate parking area to interior of site
if feasible, or near rear of site, beside
the building or wherever less visible
Maintain maximum parking ratios for
commercial development
Use buffering to create a visual filter
that softens view of parked cars (low
wall or planted buffer may be used)
Transition away from large surface
parking areas
Landscape islands every 15 spaces +
continuous screen of plant material or
solid, decorative screen wall
Shared commuter lot for MAX
station (60 spaces)
Inclusion of bicycle parking
Landscape islands within parking
lot included + two pedestrian
corridors to bring pedestrians
safely onsite
Landscape islands included within
site plan + perimeter landscaping
to be designed and installed along
Drake Street and College Ave
Street (in
TOD overlay
district)
Street sections to provide street-like
drives for properties with large
parking areas (cross-property
connection improvement)
Able to still utilize current parking
supply at site with redevelopment
Inviting streetscapes in theme with
Upper Midtown area delegation
Inviting to bicyclists/pedestrians as
well as vehicular activity
Inviting streetscapes
Developer will repair curb, gutter,
sidewalks and streets where
applicable
Where applicable, developer will
replace public driveways and
ramps to meet ADA standards
Provide street section along
feature
Bus Stop
(existing stop
on the north
side of Drake)
Should be elevated to meet quality of
bus stop on MAX corridor, should fit
with recommended streetscape
Bus pull in lane for safety and ease
of traffic
Detached sidewalk with more
narrow tree lawn to reduce the
impact to the existing parking lot
Minor Open
Spaces
(developer
driven,
privately
managed)
Courtyards, plazas, dining areas
Accessible to general public and
connect to pedestrian/bike areas and
include seating
Utilize shade structures based on sun
exposure and combine
landscaping/hardscaping with direct
access to indoor function
Should be less than ½ acre (21,780 sq.
ft.)
Comfortable scale and utilize solar
access
Incorporation of patios on existing
retail and on anchor building
Utilization of sitting area tables for
public and customer use
Plaza on south side of building has
been expanded into a larger area
that connects MAX station &
pedestrian walkway to College
Ave.
Access from plaza to Grand
Promenade on west side of
property
Accessible parking spaces added at
requested locations (Larkburger
building)
Drive-thru Minimize conflict with pedestrians,
locate to interior of property
Space between sidewalk and
driveway/waiting lane to be
landscaped
Drive–thru relocated to north side
of building and reduced in number
per staff recommendation, away
from view from Drake Road (avoids
inhibiting pedestrian activity)
College and Drake where
applicable to comply with Master
Plan
Service Areas Minimize visual impact, and orient
toward service lane or alley (away
from major streets)
Screen from view with a solid wall,
opaque fence, or landscaping *if on
street screen with architectural
Dock walls and screening of
mechanical equipment added to
the back of building
Service area oriented away from
the main traffic to the South and
East
reflect the Gardens natural theme
Tree grates at pedestrian walkways
will be included and shown on
Landscape plan adjacent to Plaza
Met with City Forestry and plan
designed to include many existing
trees into the new development
Building façade has been softened
with upright evergreens, perennial
and grass beds
Access and
Circulation
Support multi-modal circulation to
promote use of the Max and make
pedestrians and bicyclists feel
comfortable
Pedestrian connections through lot
north to south and east to west
connecting the public streets to
building and to the MAX BRT
Station
Promenade at West Side of
Building allows for future
South side of the building
Architectural elements
incorporated into plaza as site
design progresses
Promenade along West side of the