Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSCOTT PLAZA - PDP - PDP130032 - REPORTS - RECOMMENDATION/REPORT W/ATTACHMENTSSchedule B General Terms and Conditions 1. Obligations of the Parties; Relationship of the Parties. Subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, each parry will perform the obligations set forth in Schedule A. The relationship of the parties to this Agreement is solely that of independent contractors. Neither party will have any authority to contract With third parties on behalf of the other party or to expressly or impliedly represent that it has any such authority, to any person. 2. Term; Termination. Term of Agreement. The initial tens of this Agreement will commerice on the Effective Date and, unless terminated earlier in accordance herewith, Will continue for a period of one (1) year. This Agreement will automatically renew for successive one (1) year periods unless either party gives the other written notice of termination at least thirty (30)days prior to the end of the then current term. If either party breaches this Agreement and fails to cure such breach within thirty (30) days after receipt of notice of that breach from the other party then the other party, then the other parry may terminate this Agreement effective as of the end of such thirty (30) day period. Either party may terminate this Agreement immediately if the other party (i) ceases to do business in the ordinary course or (n) commits an act of bankruptcy (such as a giving general assignment for the benefit of creditors) or files a bankruptcy petition which is not vacated within thirty (30) days of filing. No termination for cause Will be deemed a waiver of any claim for damages by the terminating party. Sections 5, 7, and 8 of this Agreement shall survive any termination or expiration of this Agreement 3. Representations and Warranties. Each party represents and warrants to the other that (i) it has the authority to enter into this Agreement and is not under any obligation to any third party that would conflict with this Agreement and (ii) it will comply with all applicable federal, state and local laws. Zipcar agrees to maintain the following insurance: (a) Commercial General Liability in the amount of $1,000,000 each occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate; and (b) Commercial Excess Insurance in an amount of $1,000,000 each occurrence and annual aggregate; and Zicpar agrees to name Company as an additional insured on Zipcar's Commercial General Liability Policy. Company represents, warrants and covenants that (i) there is no other tenant or occupant that has or Will have any right to use or occupy the parking spaces assigned to Zipear on a permanent basis hereunder, once said spaces are mutually agreed to; provided, however, that if the vehicles are valet parked, this warranty shall be deemed to have been met provided Company has at least the agreed upon number of spaces available for Zipcar vehicles; (ii) it shall deliver the parking spaces in broom clean condition maintain the parking spaces in good condition; and (iii) it shall keep and maintain the portion of the facilities in which the parking spaces are located in good condition and repair and remove all snow, ice and other debris therefrom. 4. Publicity. Neither parry will use the other party's name, logos, trademarks or service marks in any manner Without the other parry's prior written approval. Company hereby gives Zipcar the right to use Company's name, logos, trademarks and service marks to notify members of the availability of Zipcar vehicles atCompany's facilities. 5. DISCLAIMER OF WARRANTIES; LIMITATION OF LIABILITY. ZIPCAR MAKES No WARRANTms wr H REsPECTTO THE SERVICES OR THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS AGREEMENT AND HEREBY DISCLAIMS ALL OTHER WARRANTIES, EXPRESS, IMPLIED, OR STATUTORY, INCLUDING WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE, T1TI1; AND NON - INFRINGEMENT. EXCEPT FOR THEIR RFPSEC IVE INDEMNIFICATION OBLIGATIONS, N EITHER PARTY WILL BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER PARTY FOR ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL OR Confidential — Zipicar, Inc. Page 3 CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LAST PROFITS, EVEN IF SUCH PARTY HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH LOSS. EXCEPT FOR THEIR RESPECTIVE INDEMNIFICATION OBLIGATIONS, NEITHER PARTY's LIABILITY HEREUNDER WILL EXCEED $5,000. EACH PARTY ACKNOWLEDGES THAT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION REPRESENT A REASONABLE ALLOCATION OF RISK THAT IS REFLECTED IN THE FEES PAYABLE BY ZIPCAR HEREUNDER. THE FOREGOING LIMITATION OF LIABILITY IS NOT INTENDED TO LIMIT EITHER PARTY's LIABILITY FOR GROSS NEGLIGENCE OR WILLFUL MISCONDUCT. 7. Indemnification. Each party (the "Indemnifying Party') shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless the other parry (the "Indemnified Party') its successors, subsidiaries, affiliates, employees, officers, trustees, agents and assigns from and against any and all third party claims brought against the Indemnified Party by any person or entity (i) for personal injury or property damage and (ii) arising out of the Indemnifying Party's negligence or willful misconduct. The Indemnifying Party will pay all damages agreed to in settlement or awarded by a court of competentjurisdiction; provided, however, that no settlement shall be effective without consent of the Indemnified Party. This indemnification obligation shall be effective only if the Indemnified Party has given prompt written notice of the claim to the Indemnifying Party, permitted the Indemnifying Party an opportunity to defend, and reasonably cooperated in the defense of the claim at the Indemnifying Party's expense. 8. Miscellaneous. This Agreement is the entire agreement between the parties with resepct to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all other prior and contempoaneous agreements and understandings, oral and written, between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof Additional or different terms in any purchase order or similar document will not modify or add to the terms of this Agreement. This Agreement may be amended only by a written agreement between the parties. If one party fails to enforce any provision of this Agreement, such patty will not be precluded from enforcing the same provision at another time. This Agreement and the rights granted under it may not be assigned or transferred by either party Without the written consent of the other party; provided, however, either party will have the right to assign this Agreement to its successor in the event of a merger, acquisition or other consolidation, including without limitation the sale of all or substantially all of its assets or stock or business to which this Agreement relates. in the event that airy provision of this Agreement is held by a court or other tribunal of competent jurisdiction to be unenforceable, such provision will be deemed modified to the minimum extent necessary to render the provision enforceable in a manner that most closely represents the original intent of the parties and the remaining terns and conditions of this Agreement will remain in full force and effect. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with law of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts without regard to conflicts of laws provisions thereof. The parties agree that the sole jurisdiction and venue for actions related to the subject matter hereof shall be the state and federal courts located in Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, and consent to the exclusive jurisdiction of such courts. In the event of any adjudication of any dispute under this Agreement, the prevailing patty in such action will be entitled to reimbursement of its attorneys' fees and related costs by the other parry. Neither parry Will be responsible for delays or failures in performance resulting from acts beyond its control. Such acts include but are not be limited to acts of God, labor conflicts, acts of war or civil disruption, governmental regulations imposed after the fact, public utility out failures, industry wide shortages of labor or material, or natural disasters. 67 lie Schedule A Parking Terms and Conditions 1. Number of Parking Spaces. Company will make available to Zipcar, at no charge, the following number of parking spaces at Company's parking facility indicated below. Two (2) with option of 3`d if needed ScottPlaza. 80521 Final Address TBD Currently known as 1205 Plum St Fort Collins, CO 2. Parking Space Availability and Use. The location of the parking spaces assigned to Zipcar shall be mutually agreed by the parties. The parking spaces made available to Zipcar will be used by Zipcar for the purpose of providing car sharing services to Zipcar members, and Zipcar and its members shall have right to use the parking spaces, including without limitation the right to park, operate, clean, and otherwise use the Zipcar vehicles. Company shall provide Zipcar, its members, and its third party personnel with 24x7x365 unrestricted access to the parking spaces and shall otherwise provide the same amenities and services it affords to other parking tenants. Zipcar shall have the right to decrease the number of parking spaces at any time and for any reason, including without limitation for seasonal fleet management purposes, without penalty by providing thirty (30) days prior notice to Company. 3. Signage. Zipcar shall have the right to place Zipcar signage advertising the Zipcar services in such locations at the Company's parking facilities as Zipcar and Company may mutually agree from time to time. At a minimum, Company agrees that Zipcar may (i) install a drop box at the entrance to each facility, in high traffic areas, and at each parking space, and (ii)mark off reserved parking spaces assigned to Zipcar by displaying one 12" by 18" "Tow Zone" sign, and one 2'by 2' "Zipcars Live Here" sign at each space. 4. Sole Car Sharing Service. Company agrees that Zipcar shall be the only car sharing service with vehicles parked at the Company's parking facilities. Confidential — Zipcar, Inc. Page 2 PARKING AGREEMENT Effective Date: November 21, 20 i car` z p This Agreement consists of this signature page and the following schedules, which are incorporated by reference and made a part of this Agreement: Schedule A: Parking Terms and Conditions Schedule B: General Terms and Conditions Notices: All notices, requests and demands, and other communications required or permitted under this Agreement will be in writing and sent to the addresses set forth below. A notice will be deemed effective: (a) upon delivery, if delivered personally to a party; (b) 1 business day after deposit, if delivered to a nationally recognized courier service offering guaranteed overnight delivery; or (c) 3 business days after having been deposited in the United States mail, certified mail, postage prepaid, return receipt requested. This Agreement may be executed in one or more counterparts, each of which will be deemed to be an original and which together will constitute one and the same instrument. The signature of any of the parties may be evidenced by a facsimile copy of this Agreement bearing such signature and such signature will be valid and binding as if an original executed copy of the Agreement has been delivered. A duly authorized representative of each party has executed this Agreement as of the Effective Date. Zipcar, Inc. ("Zipcar") TF Real Estate OVortuni und, LLC ("Company") By: By: Name: ./� �, �i,,,n� Name: _Jake Ta 1 r Title: 4f ;x��c t Address: REV IEWEY , Zipcar Legal Des,. Confidential — Zipcar, Inc. Page 1 Title: Manager Address: 7825 East Gelding Dr #102 Scottsdale, AZ 85260 65 Q 10. Question: (Citizen) I am a member of Zipcar and find it to be a great service. 11.Question: (Citizen) On what level is the deck? Response: (Applicant) It is on the fourth floor. 12.Comment: (Citizen) Are there ways to cut through to Elizabeth, especially with the new project (The District, with approximately 700 bedrooms) across the street to the north on Plum? Response: (City) It would be ideal for there to be a road to connect Plum to Elizabeth, but the property to the south would need to redevelop for this to happen. People currently angle to the southwest out of this area to get to Elizabeth. 13. Comment: (Citizen) Will the units be for rent or for purchase? Response: (Applicant) These will be rental units. 14.Question: (Citizen) Will there be a manager on site? Response: (Applicant) Yes 15.Comment: (Citizen) Could you describe the security lighting? Response: (Applicant) We plan overhead strings of lights over the present Scott Avenue, and security lighting in the garage. The City's requirements prohibit lighting to spill out from the property. 16.Comment: (Citizen) Will pets be allowed? I am concerned about people walking dogs and not cleaning up. Response: (Applicant) No. 3 Response: (Applicant) Yes, we might consider raising the sidewalk along Plum to slow traffic entering the Scott Avenue spine. 4. Comment: (City) Please describe the woonerf concept. Response: (Applicant) This is a Dutch concept where pedestrians, bikes and cars share streets, similar to some of the upgraded alleys in Old Town Fort Collins. A high priority is placed on bike and pedestrian traffic. This is the vision we have for the Scott Avenue spine. 5. Comment: (Citizen) How long will Plum Street be closed during construction? Response: (Applicant) Plum Street will not be closed due to the construction. The City plans to upgrade sanitary sewer in Plum Street, but that will be scheduled separately by the City. 6. Question: (Citizen) What does the City feel about hot tubs on the property's roof? Response: (City) We will have to discuss this during the review process. 7. Question: (Citizen) What parking will be provided? Response: (Applicant) The project is in the Transit Oriented Development (TOD) Overlay Zone, which means that no parking is required. We are going to offer parking, though, because it would be unrealistic not to. We will be providing about .5 parking spaces per bedroom. We are also investigating becoming a Zipcar host site. Zipcar is a car -sharing business that could reduce the need for personal cars. Response: (City) Although there is no specified minimum parking level in the TOD, the expectation is that adequate parking be provided. Currently about the ratio of parking spaces to bedrooms in TOD projects is about 58%. A minimum will be established in the near future; this is currently under review by City Council. 8. Question: (Citizen) How many beds will the project have? Response: (Applicant) 196 9. Comment: (Citizen) What will happen to Scott Avenue? ( Response: (Applicant) .A city planning document calls for a through street or pedestrian spine in this location to connect Plum and Elizabeth. We are asking to keep the intent of this by requesting to vacate the Scott Avenue right of way and to create a pedestrian spine along the west side of the property. 2 63 NEIGHBORHOOD INFORMATION MEETING PROJECT: 1201 West Plum Street DATE: August 22, 2013 LOCATION: Blessed John XXIII Church, 1220 University Avenue APPLICANT: Stephanie Sigler of Ripley Design CITY PLANNER: Seth Lorson Seth Lorson opened the meeting by introducing himself and Sarah Burnett, Neighborhood Development Review Liaison, and by providing a brief explanation of the City development review process as well as an overview of the neighborhood meeting agenda. Stephanie Sigler, Landscape Architect with Ripley Design, presented the proposed project concept site plan. The design calls for a four-story student -oriented apartment building. The current Scott Street is proposed to become a pedestrian spine with decorative pavers along the west side of the property, with a turn to the west to channel foot traffic out the southwest corner of the property. (The Campus West Community Commercial District Planning Study Report for the area calls for a street or pedestrian spine to connect Plum to Elizabeth.) A deck on the fourth floor would provide recreational space, with options such as hot tubs, bar/grill, sunbathing, big screens for movies, and table tennis as possible options. Seth Lorson then opened the meeting for questions. QUESTIONS, CONCERNS, COMMENTS AND RESPONSES: 1. Question: (Citizen) What are the density rules about how many can be housed on this site? Response: (City) There are no minimum or maximum density requirements. 2. Question: (Citizen) Does the Scott Avenue spine have parking on it? Response: (Applicant) Yes, it would be a driveway to parking, but the bumpy pavers should help slow traffic. It is intended to be for pedestrians first, and cars second. There will be a nine -foot landscape buffer to the east. The current right of way for the street is 25 feet, and there will be an additional several feet before the building starts to the west. 3. Question: (Citizen) Have you thought about a raised walk? 62 D-Series L _ LED Parking Garage r— �9�6l�I1llrr � C` ..::: errr TMwr�nYaeoY�raYM r.aawYia+exlMMw,wxYwv 1)M'TYM1YMYYY. WM.ywi eY•rylYa nMaYNlwn10'A�MwxIW„MG aaa I-y. � amuonYYev wale nwYl«IYIr Y/w /� Iarsl,uMw,wlp_ r-� n.ar.waw�„mwnr-wan+ 4 Y IMDf.w M1Yp O.,q M..wY�,.w �... e � wimp iwaunlyw anwxnwM..n MLaarV YnwiW. .Yewtiun. YIM4..=wlDoa I..,. a ww,wr ti • w.YwMwX ti ,wY• ..r nw�a,r ra}ry .wariw • I� See Dries -Se LED Area Luminaire ---- - ---- w.LYww 7W7 �'� IM.w.��wwYau.ax..waYw• M.bn.w.. •.•n0-YW V gan,n cannon, mn w n IYnLL.wi.1/ MF a y Mw.. IT .R[a. bipll.I,nw.IMwvBry dgan.wln,Iwn.a.,nW nw..,,nn r ..... I � � .ux.nwaw,axQwwva. a.wewa Y.bw r �r� �w—aw+tio+-a.aM �+uerow •nw.uw,wm.w y r-w w.,e, w.n.• rN/Mla, DiMV 1FD IX IDtl YK r]Y War W COe� M—M x,....,a 4_ xrtaaaaYar WST MchMrne�eMSmnn IF7 — -- Yn.a..la )Malr[bM.W/YW1me.m. nM4Y wY, Iln YYtl w IN wd^y WI IM 4aerlee wuil,.x Y,Y14.^�waWaPweawY, �+aYtw pen.leawewn xy..,e.wylaxnm.D.eaw.w YYYn Yyn IWYwsTMMgaE�x«Jyan•, r ..Y � W+4waiwy9w.Ya9.ewlex a.Maea a era. o,w. �w/rY.. uby uir Y r,Q nnvewrr �Iw4r..nxpry cage l'•'• .. nwwsrleo.e.aa,wnab•w.urow- I_wJTLpJ suwu asr uo x len>mua w Wqr msrxo wa aeaeaxseelwyeaaalYl � GW�O'aik�}'jiCSi� CAuxenxee ..�n.�.-...,u.,....,..-.,... n..uw. _._....... caner ..................� LIGHT FIXTURE TYPE 'A' ILIGHT FIXTURE TYPE 'AA' I LIGHT FIXTURE TYPE 'BB' LIGHTING FIXTURE SCHEDULE rae Incas urum+nor rvua. Yauxm� YMancnucN ur. xa cars wa��rrwo'rror,wrn uarr cam mr aw NQe lle•_e� unrown � ��r -yn_Ns_osw ,ra �.er Nw.v mr swno Yro+a mru wnrrl °B .w r ere mr w.0 wamreo uwr wm can nuwr ca r-mow ernes NnQ/ar .ro'o.ir v"nrn^ u�a �:uyxo Mr•r nNIN. 1!V PNWWR f.WNnQ ,irlW. MW411 n�IntMAn) 1 Qq /M u0 r .Nx) r.[N cam eormu a¢nvs �¢ .•'-o'.rr U//Iwn YrwM-am» •awY �Yor.,wrt•.ewn.•xorwrwwnn a/awa wo caw. a,w ,,. ,.m+awaw n,axmu m++a we u.wn�r.�ross�Ya�mMmmwswmm„u D•Nr.. /«x. rwDw.. ,car mn•an air Ma w¢ an.wn w car a..Mr. n w,.ww a.asvn m mua,er w. owe ser a ne u¢ a +•¢ wn.orrs w .�vi« now ra wu�.0 snmv..urrs n smvn..ne""wim imi.'n mx sa+e wrroimr./ s as x SCOTT PLAZA PDP raeT c UN3.00L r PHOTOMETRIC PLAN eM,L; PM.2 I b'i' HVON M1VSMI. V( f!Nl WIPUM81REET"mn:i,.'v.®:, a.+vmm nu.H" - - --- — - - H"..,ffima Ha .Ur r r 4i� � ,.i Pre •^'-�•,, 4 �lr .. \Y t' � ,iri•l • ' i. "j u . ILA i} idYd OFIOO „,WsaN UE fMJ Ir � Va u u�,• V v®u �u 'v u u ,. u�raw iQ .pleas w u ti u u w w a w mal Y Q H u Ir 4 �" a,,n.rlee • h • 1 Y \ —_ fY (XWYLY uI 1 UMNMK lfll®J4E M. iW 4 at!re� >n .q_Hmy� a wW. . uni.. Vlo*m t mM1, , ue �• ...Y rm u. W gtiwNp rc44moi w rm w PHOTOMETRIC PLAN ��� .wv�OSH �R M(�wpF YS.hw.YMiuMW 9[d1#K� �WM��4lY �QY �OM �, vS�0.rt4��MrW ��QOWfIQYCt. FrVWR ��mMMR�OT�W�,Y�O),O,O�✓[K SCOT IPLAZA POP ramrcwlHscaannoo PLAN 1. PMA SCOTT PLAZA A TRACT OF LAND LOCATED IN THE NORTHEAST QUARTER OF SECTION 15, TOWNSHIP 7 NORTH, RANGE 69 WEST OF THE 6TH PRINCIPAL MERIDIAN, CITY OF FORT COLLINS, COUNTY OF LARIMER, STATE OF COLORADO W. PLUM STREEI 1]ti.5' ROW PER THE DISTRICT AT CAMPUS WEHJ I w�1J�PINRR'IIN ax I �rr euMlw ol���.n I I rIM�'in Y� r([I T� F' Nwevw�rur NBBBN ar�v[ m v e oxartl,K I 1 I I � _ 1 na•'nn ne 1 I I I THE gBTRICT AT I --J ----- CdMPUS WEST---------� W. PLUM STREET' IGx 6' ROW PEµ THE DISTRICT AT CANWUB wEST'1 X - - rcwu ,- 1rME'9Y]Y2l.W ronwxNlusi Ul.r ��NIxM Ytlalaw�'1/.tl4 131JD�- IUWH SDU.RE =Q w CUNWMINIIIMB µ irw.¢rrrnnarn 1 SCOTT AVE. II6'ROW) E 1 1 1 _ 1 un errn,nr �wmnarx.'a nuw.`rxi�. nr�irwrrv.. Q I � I 1 I r-ru CURVETML 14L _ _i ----- t4 _ 61 �e�w.ianrwn.i w, N.rnT u�~. j � �• J I Y raxx I � � cAMRRIDAE.IrnIRE UNIT. A 1 EXISTING LOT LINEGHT-OF-WAYS AND EASEMES.NTS TORIBE VACATED PDINi W 8[DINNING .0 nw:l`n TOWN SOkIMiE CONDOMINIUMS = ww el =w �ppnu7pnl 1. II r� U 1 y PDInOF9EOINNINO .uiumnnr'n F—O •`.,,`n M J wren in, O 0 LL LLO TOWNyOIYd• GMPUS WEST &gPPINGCENTER µ_ G N LL id OF mwrw COMINILEMExI � L --b— 4 � — �%,..p//' ® NORTH .1 I.a na.l Or ] Shoals w' SCOTT PLAZA A TRACT OF LAND LOCATED IN THE NORTHEAST QUARTER OF SECTION 15, TOWNSHIP 7 NORTH, RANGE 69 WEST OF THE 6TH PRINCIPAL MERIDIAN, CITY OF FORT COLLINS, COUNTY OF LARIMER, STATE OF COLORADO I.- Al11Ibx gmxr,. AN Ib r6rulxY nwsnN.n INWI.III I IWJ: A wxlul NJINANN. I. W NVIpwI QW W m l Inl4n„ ww4N 1A'u14 LY' AA W+Y nl lb n1\ VM, I' I., III Iw[JWw[a , lI-ANI. DY, ul fWxxJ, WAN --N,W Y4 NNx t'w,Ju Wrnl WravYlwYy,uui o114 MWwui (Awxrul WJL+mn 11 nbuNIN.. N IN WxNW wIOW buup •xurJ trr,u xW,,, Ws. I. —A, I IN 1— `-1—f.A,x:Mul111 xuul\IYw.,fW 4wbII DIAN, 1W NA,. NNNA, IN Al WN, W1..N.1— NW,W W 11'kut ID I_ 1.. Ix nu WMf I'll MMINO,.—DIIY N.IP{, WVY, 14 M 4A1:.— Nwi W'R ]l• 11.1:11 nl A.N, IIwo.Hmx AV M' W' W.,l, AI N. . I . INw.. A." A. DI II IN, I II, II, I—, WnA A'. DY V" DII, Y1.W Fu: WO. iNAN.1 a, l l' G . k fY M, N— b.. AV 1N 11^Yul l21 IY NA1:IbpeI. LVIW W' 1YII• Wm. Ny11 Nn4w W MY NID OAAA, tY. ANN. xWurlx I I fA Apu, M« I I N A. — I, mr W. ANNA. u Yl--IAJ Aipl waY rnl lx.IN u xuy fn. I— Aid W NmwI,WNn„W1'( --, Ina vA,xJ Ilw Wew N-.. bo w N IWIFOJ AW ANIWM Nu lm.nnu AW N, NYrI, r W, kNl N b Yuonu'Al II'11LA/A nW •IY„LNw4"I, .1'. w All.—I.A. nW ny ..NI r,v,ur u11-1 A uxnuY •I, WIWW u WA fIY h,yN,wlublMl,w Wl W.1W Na In wxNs W. ul,ey YwYrYNIII, A, W 1., rwl M Y WdYNWII un I J JI -I 11L. AIIILI�I YWwuN 4 II Y prawn.l IN, pArWM'Sa I I xNx AA I.�Ie /D run wmr/ 1'wawIW NA r— M m, Ire.uµx I. wws aura «,III—+A.I ill nII. .Nl...Yw�I....I..A.�II,.II...w.�,�„rn III..wIII--m In A,,-.WN.Y,.A,nr.A. �I,AA Ilu I1. ,uI< ,1xvN-IJ I 1.1,1I.Ip—.,mwNunm.e...1..m.mwrxJ AA l.,NADD.1.-1. I. IWuMMluuuullev nV.Ino-W,. xw Nv xrq,IUII< 11 1LIII-. W I1 Jw. IwI Al,Y xl uuurN'<.1 AN I.rmmrr. u .NbYv a:l, I Ar'r.Il mu.w.n Yv xrW,Irf1l,�li.sWANNmiry NAAN-xllnmlaw. u.Ixxv.JW.NW vl..11u l ( p J W wN CNy I.n 6 I.A, 41W ( nJ .oJ uN W aM 411 u vlav '('III W D1 IlD 1. IDI,II W bWIa. 14 110 I 1 u <'IWwII mp ,n uA IorinrNo.n .xw. W.nunu. hlnn vtr Nn uWn Y Irr N.w+IY xlrNJuy ur, wDE u. 11. ue,w A— "I iI, ., A11m 1W —w lb.. el W CI'V. V Wy Inpm, W W'. VA tq.nMM I tWN1Y 1N WYLLII I ib lANNA'. NWewNwxuwwby,JbW, m NJ_AN, NI N .M x of W'A I,,f,Il nW.0,A —I Al, Nm —I A-. 1� Ib,bm keaxl amrxeuW Wnnern I. mllll.Iu _ uww.wx..n.wpxr nxw wr ...puo. I.r Wr /w'ol Jx nBlwva/rr ralam.l brr.IlWl, ix. .n lu..oµ.v..weu.ry a.naxi.uJ WYx UrrvY 1.I.l1Y.F IA I -IN I. pwwu-11xn.mhrve xnx lJn Cln IAx Ii ••a •..um, inmlllnwl Ivu 1. MI'xn6unll.,I.11 qTl t, aAWLn w W Wwu A, AI wxn "" NrvNwam, IYY'w�I.1.a..Il1I.- ,,A.—Nwpw In'IUJIry ANiLLWlWmbt -ANy r,I11- Iv. uuliwl yvW nnY xulwwmVu ulWr,T4Wx WIYm,WIItraxNW+IN VIN ila rnmx/ u,IAI— �"M'..InInI -Nwll w+xe,xpWs WvnslWW INN Y N, 1—.-uuW1- mll"m�wu lnxl ll�rxmiwl III.I.m�.�µlulvlI..... �.I lbx C4Y D,,IMxr IDN' Nw vmn, 1., ,,,a D,la—,w4IN! '-U. III W IV�"^'Y^ NIW mw Jn,4gmmu....I .n IwI1144 ..1 ADIA In IN nw W INiu WN w Julw'. wmWlu Jury,..'I bry •AI ..I—nm'e IAv,ut We wx4 Yuxrc.rw' II„—W q W,1 D, xul N, wu ad —N. YAW m xW ryJ AMJwI 14(:IY uuII YU lwr rr wbr lnnJlr. nnWlvwlln«141nJb L, A Iya/,r WnA,mI,NpYvu114,ry al.. wu ItII PIN nJ ml.x., I.,III. A. 4<mlwlm nl,rle P•.N JUII..mIn I> I.pxn.Nly.1 N, DIwI vl W ,m,n Al IY Al. I.I NI. AN ally InIW.L nvwW,.r.w.In A Yx I. Jul ulnrnfl.w.a.M Ill"%:r' .I"IIv,11,ofIF.Innxa�Iwnlrtw Ix.'wuu. Nv III, 11. ..A L.IAaal`gm n.vlr 1, iNU Wllu IµI, N.I AI'lll flu nId nll rlI". uv of wJJu' xnry ulrPur II rW V..I'InxA NII p b�..'NAp..AneinArw I".— I., hn��IW y,AnWw I.4NeW II`(I�I bwlnA vIW, IYy.xl nu YILL eI 1 ,mY rc4.. tl11.yw.nAun. µ u wW WNx. 111,111w M1A1ww1.vIN4Vn AN AUJnp. iIA w Wx —ANINV NVIbk B.. .A.,—trVrm IPW ...-WI Ib—...'.Jl, —I I,.. ... --ING lv 1N.1'Ww•mw NNIN7ryNYitrW All I—Wex n 11. llr. Wewn I JA AJ nlWw MMIMwblme I. uwe IIII rr -A—II F.w r II,h NL11V,r ex vu�W s4lYewwmY wWN lav I'lu II Jlm fln/IIv. wti.#JnIml.W wln Olh ls�MA.—L N4\uII I-h,— 11-1r. MI,.�yo i.mxe uw 'A — All, 'AA,I,lINw.AINNADu w. AylAxm W m., wynm.q I IWNM NNW WI WA YWNwin I'WWMu.1-w xmlWwJ AN-. Al S,m1m t I K I, III.0 1. 1 u,Nura u1 N, I.W Ilx LIYW W CW xl 1., CUNN W WrAYA w..r Wf, Pbul.1Nf N-NN.- nu,Yn mliy wr JNr ANA,. IImmN. mN. W W. m W BAN of IWW1sY raw [II1b+m N A..J Wx W Ixw Nr W clm.J Mxwb W 1.Im. [w.Ik. [dnW xNr Ih Wlevr NxaWn vNWNNNAfm I.bmYn Nun,M b/s WNyAIwiklyNyWnIW nNYYrm1 bf bn4nll NCNINDorm mW VwcaY. N,1mYSNa. BYW[YYIyAm WWCtlY WIw I'WWu[WUN.YUI._ A, AV..1Y_ 1"p B/1-r,l MANNINO M1,DIrJ. yWRx,aN11WArym[Iyaffnl'eIY,.CdatloW _YYof___AD.. JY_ Dru4t orPl✓nYY .. ... Ib I IwAND, NI Il1, Ay, I'n NaN.nYu W'rNurw Nx W I...nruF lm pu VICINITY Mill' NORTH 7� 9VRVAY[ RA1FHkNf I,,irtYJD. WWNUL N 1.,. P,YxuM I'—., -11 .11 ryu N N..r Yx NY --I. IIN, - A rwYl,wrY. ,,,YI..-Iwl-,I...n.WN We II..I.I.I-w lnuI.-mrm.,w""A I. l WI I.III,, 11,1 I. Anwullxu.mmnll.Ilw Ibmlf. Au Ih. 4, Ylalw.1, I-INn, m rnnlYWA NN NA,N G,Ab D .iANNJ [awWrllNpurJm.NWnn Llq YwvvNm Nu. I1pI NWID, V D. WwA ufBrMV i, Ib , Ww AID, }wlw tyy,w.111w Nw Yww gwxvuf 6mWn 11 x Prnlg MINI F W'2TY,'s DIANINDmNp W —II eiwAnib Jl AY Ylbwnn iNNAl Nw�N I,NIULwy w 1Lr IN . tyJeN byWxNG "'N'ywA [amiss I= .Y,N DMI. B4WtF lW W1vWn [wNmr. 11 M11xJ W1alox-NAIN, fm u V 8.5mryfrw. ND NDDN.1q. aB (no ZD 00 C) iI-00 LLLL LL� LOW r UU) Of 2SIDID, N No Text 4 0 IL .1 MENOW . . 0 �'ilil�l�����r�l�i� ��i r��� MIIII�I IIIt11 1, �Jqt r :. L Collins, CO RTH SIDE OF PLUM STREET _ Rr. !� a n �oa n s j'ii sa i a1s�i:g . .. a ,. I. . � oa a wt � ii Pn !!>fdl#'�#� -- ••; • i:a � :: e District PLAN AND CONCEPT SECTIONS SOUTH SIDE OF PLUM STREET CIO 0 N M U W u 2 " 3 r _.LIUIR fVRRIR 1•I , SIN NMVI4RV uvv,Nan I District Building 2 I.NMM WMON'M Proposed Scoff Plaza Perspectives Contextual Building Elevations n�R� aMaa 'L waI s e District Building 3 a ea I® 3t�a m • .M:vi Ni -R. NI;WI'I P. 11JIM YT. TRR OIM'IIMT Townsquare Condos m 4Wf June 21, 9:00 AM Dec. 21. 9:00 AM Juno 21. 12:00 PM AW Dec. 21, 12:00 PM Shadow Analysis June 21. 3:00 PM Dec. 21. 3:00 PM Fort Collins, CO. Mar. 21. 9 00 AM W, C) June 21. 9:00 AM N 0- Mm. 21. 12:00PM June 21, 12:00 PM I /` Shadow Analysis 41e Ma, 21, 3 00 PM June 21, 3:00 PM 6LZA s, i m! 11 IN ■i , IM 11 OF E111 i .. min milli �o ji' a Ila Islam • .111 11,11 I D- is i I "I n I II 11 11 a 11 111�111u � 11 11 u 11 11 II � 1 11 u 11 11 11 li 11 11 11 11 11 u � 1 11 2 II Nil 1 i 11 llrll 11� 11111111111 If If ME 111i1 1f 11 II 11 m 11 11 11 11 11 11 lil�■111 II II.II 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 II it 11 II� 1 1111 11 11 11 _Ili 11 _ 1111 11 11 11 11 11 111 i it 11 11 11 E11 11 11 11 11 11 11 11 � 11 II 11 II [.=� it 11 71 1 11 111 1 11 11; I t, VIL11h i l-4 �,PROPOSEO EAST EL. EVATION iT"Ca �'�T[d"Ta OEAST-WALL SECTION] TEASTWALL SEC11 2N (1� T,111ALL SFCT➢ON 1_ m1 1 lamu m E}iIPoCR FlWWLICCNp HO. Ll.1EpWL MW.1F. KIOR LOEIEIENf mOi PmTERMM M ATE OMY MA] PgE..CAST =CO.NCRETE W.LI CqP amy 04DI eRILR tl MSLATS 4LLP.M AU -PAW 040t BM.L.CpR. e.M me mMso RC4NWttl bef WCREge MARK MARK osa METAL suNSN.DE METAL oARNewoN]E D1aB OMiKM10NZE f4a) METAL/WNMY DEEPOEM BAft 0!-0E WTKTMA.'..T MET.IT BATE WqN BRONZE 06GI LdW0911f WOCO PANIIINO m M.11Nf OP.1NOE 6T.1W VERTWL KIOWAENT 0)@ eTUCCO OKAY 07-0I 67=0CpMICE OR.Y 0)a MMIE M REAM RVKPA@L eY 81EM W46 CEWNIRWOCAMgE OAOE 0416TW.EAM.TALO m.AmOR, 07-0E METALFASCIAOMq M ).W 0 PREPW611HED METKPWIWq ELATE O&AYMY 0601 KU.MM.M EIViEFROlIf N1tlPATV BYeIEM OM E O4d3 M10EVNT Cb0] sumI WINDOW MIOINC E HR WEMONZE �TRASN ENCLOSURE ELEVATION SCO17 PLAZA PDP FORTCOLLIM MO W •MnaE- 0atl BUILDING ELEVATIONS ON.G KU.BER` A3 04) PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION 4 E� ^NORTH WALL SECTION 3 NORTH WALL SECTION 1 /,\NORTH WALL SECTION 1 E%lE WIM iI1LiF 1L4ENU NO. FEM IMNUF. 4ALGR COWRM 0}p3 MM FNO S GINY pia? ME.TLpKRETE MEGSTLOKAETF WNE W m OMV YOl ORIGN ROMN60N MI PMN pEY! 6RILNWMRSBIJO FGNN6W MY R%LL 05.0] NQfl6 M WRN BROWF ma WTE . METU BW61VioE YM NHiN G9 woNN2E O O6A1 WMLE EP OECD( MMU OWS BROME MM MEi.LL TR%9M G%TIE WT. OMIt BRONZE 0601 E WOoo PAM@LNG BYRM OR.YNGE 6TNN VEflIIfJL AYW�ENT ".a. p]A9 tiiNLLOCOICNLE GRAY OiOa CEMEN1Td16FlBERBONo JF TIMBER BARN REVEN. PANELfiKRM WLe GEMlNl111W8FlBERBMXDLgINN:E W$HARM J%MfLXAROIE]IMBERBARN p)-0)6TANpWGBEAM METRLRooP SLATE GRI.Y p]OY METAL F1BCM WRN BRONZE 0)LB NIFFW6HEOMETkWPUBLN] My WJt ALUMNYAI BTpMFROMWWWNEY6RM mw BROWS M@ GLATIN] BRGNEE IIM 0!N 81� W1MGW p41K BRbIIE 9 RETAL SPACE VIEW SCOTT PLAZA PDP FORT LOLYH6 LWdUbG •YM MnMq' Mgtixn lXMnM.n�w NYWGIMMN\II4 nruany ��t BUILDING ELEVATIONS Gnewlxc n,CunT— A2 060! WT&iRNSNQRTE OM,, BRONZE MI OOMPO&TEW=§NkNEUW OUPNT OPRNOE$.IN VEPn A�MDNMENT WM BYUOCO 0-0 BTYOOOWPoIOE my OMY 07-05 CdMtlNn1KK16IIBEP 00ARD n RMRN 118VFAL PIJCLSYiTEM lll�ZF CAMBNNnDOBI BEPRWPD CdiI110E JAn 5PIARM 1NME."�H�NgE TIMBlR6MN M O/106 .W NETALPWF 6 OMV OM WT K Ol{B EMWBXEDNET.YL LAP FIA6MIND BIAIEDRA, 0GL1 /J.LMINIlM 8Td1EFPOM WINOLW 8V8TEN BWWE aeax ouxnn enar¢e nrrt 0!N 9LIMOWRMYI ONM MDI@ Al TOWNSQUARE CONDOS BIKE PARKING PROPOSED PEDESTRIAN ACCESS TO ELIZABETH ST. �J SCOTT PLAZA APARTMENTS LONG TERM PARKING FUTURE PEDESTRIAN ACCESS TO ELIZABETH ST. M BIKE PARKING p BENCHES BIKE PARKING Cal IA G C O N N E 7w a) U CAMBRIDGE HOUSE APARTMENTS N site plan II 9�y� I� r •w»���� � ! I I + ---- L vwN iaww >.0 IV Io-n.]lw 4 l I� nn y �tll L LANDSCAPE NOTES SCOI T P[ AZA 1 ..rR ru4 wu rcrw .mw«M.Nwr uaoa na«xwe�..e�Iwu wRN °re°xr°E Wr�afswaEnu®wNuaurzo :fmlwwi ] rorERN.moo°ElrwN.refrrN.nWo.euetE lNE waoa rWNEIHrr°^.�ialY �fawx�wnwaaa rNwm `w'raw I•f)f' .w.rrsE,un.I.4nraiErEN®,a.NEn4,.a4o•Na,wxr.l...zW.Ir.N®..w.nlwrroER,wraowM�.fa,«n'm w]aionWwe�o . r�iw ilo.:KEariwrnaaurmc°.w.]�m�u lMx'.mourfnmwina RAr.11 ReulEn Rrv�wEawr®«I.NenEa ' N:NrG•MN. rwafaumzw¢a Eiw�auE tawxxwnawlumNw.wmwE m.wmnle. rna NaEl n.u.Rw.PMlc.rox.wswEf r°E �Ea•.x �ro°n.NrW i<AIE] W..Eurxm.]ucmfa«nw rnEaf]n.rm°r�EE+lfrsrE«°v,cnc. • ENn4a®«Emwmwruue.fa«amEuunowwrtlra.r.rrweoo ra gym.«ne.4««r�l...�xfn Nnfmunlw lowfe «. fe�]n«re«ocvlwc. e ranrn Mm.ivrcnamxfrExr.uf.larrlsf RNnwlMM°«.XF]KN«E.a mg«M°E.a«•x+r 4i aeEal6➢r°W.EEawr4�® .4Y1°WY MMI/10b44 RW. uiMv4 «nNEfl rRBRMRW 4W]WN®Ef04RIMl uAWVN «fkH RY3F 1 E4H L6�e,uLLFNPR: MdIUOYMf RMlYNU6Y.]®WINMR.V]fDlCn011eP¢YR°EYBMTSSL1WIr�EtlIR�4➢rE OR.4u nWrIN4NY.EW «Nwcww]Vucrox°«iwawe]aTMww6iRM].14roN.w WIMBMIIF«.0 XE9nprlao.lW Rul iORTKf]MSCPlORMO • 4l �upc.gl MifA. W11WMlRYUL1EMAW91WM4i M110MTCYMdWWLINtlf..MM'6TfY wVNurtwf4N 6.1Ev®uN HNOhLBr l.il wNEn unm•• wu E E«IwmmW rotx.w!«.unw R#w. • urwN wcAfwElwao.*®wrN.Nwr°w.nceorJafwvrou nnef .0 lwweew N+°*wee.ac ro Eiwa.*ru wrN.Nwwue°wanw:..� •[UG.1W nTB� W.c®f.BIF4rNtlumt MfeNYI•].nn9t1°E.Uam®r°Ilfl Mw.rFA1£0.H.B.rf«ME4 r4W iau.f W1EM�. 4l>N%:ERr°E Wo®Wm. WYN rNtENa P)4'I61«VW°lM W:.x«I CCpEgf..v®fMo9l � E°- .EN[elr fa4osm91mlW\E M'ffMUf°rWntl ErllV6wmr««W. MF.rFO r1.K a W i E idl.9 BL W MAfaM6ir W 3T &aHMaf MMI° PnHle pl MRO.HI b W L M WAYMFSIOrtiEFIEE rCiLiWin Rnl°.FDFINO CpYfWC1kMK1M1. N4lE2NEPV®iLP4r9U£ . NWi4YN4FMF I61bYIMVMrlN4Y@ofMI.EMATYa.LOfN®i°.C9IN«wllfYTMv x3M 1la4lf MG6 .r.namr tla Er�moa.w°wm..mmMln «w INtrrlwaro.°s�N«.rrE.n uNlfwnruw.muca•wa Nn.N< ralw° n.Mrt«n vAn1M6A«EE.ew«fol n6lmRla°rtilwwon«a fwwe RE. «1uar+E uu frlRl 1v4C4M N11Y/ frl®rrR3f 114aEi6r®ul°xWr.f@N.CMONi«WM1�44 CrtYCRV uO]Rlfef t xFMnfWrpN«urWiIFA RIM.TWIpffgrµYlAM°RTR!]iLRWf pEdIINW EMAV.MM 4e5P IxM'la lfllbie9l�4.EK«IVaO®nKWiG fWIINEmfE Y«b0••• r HAiWru nAp .�N°IalNHIIOIrtli¢O�n it •RI9�MT1. I�.s« �°x ryENJNn 6oH�4Ya EnueE nEn.NOEDrRW I�Ei.(E6M s. Y�f•.N __ __ xAE«wrwrm maaa l.rf.r n O WOn 9lYLrRfF rrleEM!«N!E •w+mwwlEa ,]➢ nRrNc b. o. xC a •]ar�cv.ur WM].wmEn•uw m am®Iw Ran4 ®NNEI®,•EA esal®rrm 1!W°°mcwwu.w NEE«Emtl�.NONwalwe O«NYBIf1 rl6 � paMJIW erwl.N•MYMtm4 O`''��ppM"°EB � �rE®�.64�Hm?Cw FOYlI p a.Er mvcvuw oWx /`i frEa Erca !� iwEx.uwn rWwm * f1EEruoxr • wlwrt•nm x.«r. ]roroWrfml ..a �.�tlmnnatf ulE _—_„_._.._ Elslaum]aenawuEf 01•' i REue • lRlr4rravu ve WATER Sl1DGET CNART x.Wi«e MP PR]lOm 04LdbTl YgYIwI RYt P4a«A NWf ]!M Eox 1 ] verr law 1 f 1 f01LL 4tl Aq'. Ol Y.W SOME: 1"�tR'-0' N M —LANOSCAPEPLAN PflAN1NG NVM6fF A y I R� cFr' -ur H--A jm m i +FR'®IOrt�'r�rN�rnw1 �,\ �x1YF➢�i6� _ �I ' /iWd+o -:ru -.ar •.•.. I N M=LI R9 Arrr PM141mq rEYSM1 Wlr qYw: (,t (EX9 NNN lif - viw N4xi COr'BVpE /lO4MC.4E � Nrrr llWf dM61I0 V111gw P.1Y W11NLYlM rAf rA rlRf Me uYCPmF >WF MIII[0G44NW Ye0.I3/$ WN )Y •Nacmrmworrowx liR rfp Af41O [WGgA NIMI M1n/.y MrI1prM CIFHMNMViN Wi rNl! WOKKf lYtf Nbl�\Y WML/ N]NN Jlp _ 1plr_Nr111O. rme T® [fmM nerNasmr me aaunwr imlu.emacoW pE@I1Cbl Wff • IrTI T`O B.Rla1tM9 T pAI N TNH®1:b/UNf6 N�1 r9 roru nnWl Mas. uacxsw nr»s< L Rmi46141nearr, tOA4 wvYNimrr rwgLL Na' rw N.N�IDY'¢ IMOr1Wr5Sd1r #a p I�¢rdrr N'y ARIN __ -�iFArl� �MRYII®' ru6r6NY.MW) �Y�-�� iWOC4NOrMNB ��L w}®/AP1011dQF 'frEApBiNrpolNrMbinEiF.V9fAi1(I®R1HYlB.T IrW wHp�r OciRi NrRNP xmr�ve�AWNeWowaauvay.+ crwnesrorwYwoewxaowwrd ®rW�T.Tn r�rWx aa�.rrd rrYwuccr urmnE wrNacmeva..neewaw rvn a.rrx w�mr.r� n'�`reEwrrE�xv®rar zac.xar.�xa sr.rmlcen..rsNwuarmcw resosmrs SCOTT PLAZA PDP M�>Z�MMAIr[ RVG[9r4rUr�rlr M Bn�®NOY.IFY *. m6*rorpH6 - I®IppICrK 6ltrNcrFE w WrrB1lIE NtlW®srrnrrlxE ----'r¢6arNr+rtNtlEi » NINw YrppxurE - Bf61NC.W 19FNN]MNF R HErW a WefM'!1d✓4 mW�l®TV NE1 M"1pY W.1HIF➢NVd H'Q SITE N•no doec®w VAtdY ORNWIOMNBEII: Scott Plaza - 1201 Plum ll� q AusnnM usyl a..r✓rrrv. w aCpa FnhYn r r—Flw�q� a.w s(ryrwe�w� r �wYr Fww rMp�w M1fiw ��r.rrrw—wlrwrwrrn�r�—wrrr�wrnrn�rmaTrer��wrr.,�w r�r.. —n�. 1� aAb YA!(Y Ain ✓Yerrrwlr tiM1ti— �YICRY � IT.fTm4O1�N1110VMI11Mi11'IOG Y�IICMWT/JYTYM VM11111NiY W1 /Oty. of � • irtxlYtb VliVYw�v.ru�'ae fi..meco�rw�m wihMwcT m*+oa�vrncwK-sanyuxowlmw ar( Mr.Ye—n.� �tins wrw.w wsr�Ywo 4r�A{d Nlm aufWlT rrr�r�rY�r�nrww✓.Y rwwuwraw�wwrw G�wr W E N• wl�rlr�rwr wn w rry rrw wrF W rw(+r [wwY nawrwrrr�n W��n.7wr.urww�• wti.W Mwnnn� wMr�wrnlrY rr+r rrww� r rw F �.r ✓w� rrrw wr+w�wn 'war rr .� �a�r saa~ r w� r r a.(r nu wrr .nrrwa GIs r.aw�.n.r r�s rw�r�wn4w^M1rmwtirvr�F���wan Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9. 2014 Page 11 FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSION: In evaluating the request for Scott Plaza PDP #130032, staff makes the following finding of fact and conclusions: A. The PDP contains permitted uses and complies with the applicable land development standards of the Community Commercial District in Article 4, Division 4.18 of the Land Use Code. B. The PDP complies with the applicable General Development Standards of Article 3 of the Land Use Code. C. The PDP complies with the applicable procedural and administrative requirements of Article 2 of the Land Use Code. D. The vacation of Scott Avenue right-of-way is part of an acceptable and appropriate solution which will be supported by staff in a separate procedure for City Council hearing if Scott Plaza is approved. RECOMMENDATION: V J : Staff recommends approval of Scott Plaza PDP #130032 with a condition that subsequent vacation of the Scott Avenue right-of-way islapproved by City Council. ATTACHMENTS: 1 —Vicinity Map Lp 2 — Site Plan 3 — Landscape Plan 4 — Site and Architectural Renderings 5 — Shading and Visual Analysis 6 — Pedestrian Connectioni Concept Renderings 7 — Plat 8 — Photometric Plan 9 — Neighborhood Meeting Notes 10 — Zipcar Agreement .N Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 10 eight -foot wide bike lanes but no on -street parking). A new detached sidewalk is being added where none currently exists. Even though there is a significant expectation of bike, walking, and transit trips to be made by the residents, no deductions were allowed in the TIS for these alternative modes. 6. Compliance with Article Three — Parking Structure in T.O.D. Section 4.18(F) requires that projects located within the Transit -Oriented Development Overlay Zone comply with the requirements of Supplemental Regulation 3.10. Because Campus West is north of Prospect Road, the only applicable standard is the design of parking structure per Section 3.10.4. The parking structure contains ground floor parking only, with dwelling units above. This standard is intended to address access to a parking structure from public right-of- way. Ground Level Treatment. This standard requires that where parking structures face streets, retail and other uses shall be required along at least 50% of the ground level frontage. The project complies with retail commercial and office uses. Architectural Elements. This standard requires that architectural elements shall be incorporated to encourage pedestrian activity at the street -facing level. The project complies with ground floor design elements and materials as noted previously. Design of Auto Entrances. This standard requires that the auto entrance from the public right-of-way, be designed so that pedestrian and bicycle safety is not jeopardized by conflicts with vehicles entering and exiting structure. The project complies by recessing the garage exit and entry to allow space for visibility by both pedestrians and drivers. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING: The neighborhood informational meeting was held on August 22, 2013 at the Blessed John XXIII Church. The meeting was attended by nine community members. The attendees were generally curious about the development proposal and nobody expressed opposition. Please see neighborhood meeting notes attached. N9 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 9 4) Neighborhood Scale. This subsection requires buildings over 40 feet in height to be found compatible with the scale of the neighborhoods in which they are situated in terms of relative height, height to mass, length to mass, and building or structure scale to human scale. This Campus West neighborhood contains development with a variety of scales from older one-story houses to five -story buildings directly across West Plum Street. The proposed project is consistent with the scale of building envisioned under the CC zoning, and with the scale of the recent District project across the street, currently under construction. Section 3.5.1(H) Land Use Transition: This standard requires that when land uses with significantly different visual character are proposed abutting each other and where gradual transitions are not possible or not in the best interest of the community, the development plan shall, to the maximum extent feasible, achieve compatibility through the provision of buffer yards and passive open space in order to enhance the separation between uses. The proposed multi -family residential use abuts multi -family residential close to the west property line (Campus West Condominiums) but has significantly different visual character. The standard states that compatibility can be achieved by consideration of scale, form, materials, color, buffer yard and operational standards. Building articulation and color variation mitigate the scale of the proposed building. With regard to a buffer yard, the west perimeter will provide a row of trees as noted. With regard to operational characteristics, there is no spillover lighting or vehicular activity on the west side of the project. Section 3.6.3 — Street Pattern and Connectivity Standards: Staff finds that the proposed multi -functional access connection is an acceptable equivalent to street connectivity in this unique situation because a new street per se has been found infeasible due to existing development and grade changes on multiple properties adjoining this project. Section 3.6.4 — Transportation Level of Service: A Traffic Engineering Study was submitted and accepted by the City's Traffic Operations Department. Staff finds that the project adequately provides vehicular, pedestrian and bicycle facilities necessary to maintain the City's adopted standards Levels of Service. Plum Street is classified as major collector (meaning there are two 38 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 8 Section 3.5.1(G)(1)(a) — Building and Project Compatibility, Building Height Review: This Section requires consideration of the effects of buildings taller than 40 feet on the following considerations: 1) important views of the foothills and mountains from public streets and public spaces, 2) light and shadow, 3) privacy, 4) neighborhood scale. 1) Views. Staff finds no significant views along West Plum Street due to buildings and trees in existing development, which already constrains views. The applicant has provided visual analysis information (Attachment 5). 2) Light and Shadow. This standard duplicates Section 3.2.3 Solar Access, Orientation, Shading. Section 3.2.3 specifically exempts buildings in the C-C zone that exceed 40 feet in height from having to comply with shading standards. This subsection 3.5.1(G)(1)(a)2. states that "adverse impacts to adjacent public and private property include, but are not limited to, the casting of shadows on adjacent property sufficient to preclude the functional use of solar energy technology, creating glare such as reflecting sunlight or artificial lighting at night, contributing to the accumulation of snow and ice during the winter on adjacent property, and the shading of window or gardens for more than three months of the year." The applicant has provided a shadow analysis (Attachment 5). It indicates that there is morning shading of the adjacent Campus West Condominiums in spring, fall, and winter. However the adjacent property has full southern exposure and will receive sunshine starting from mid -morning throughout the day. The 5-story building will cast shadows onto West Plum Street. Staff finds that even if subsection 3.5.1 (G)(1 )(a)2. was not exempted by 3.2.3(D), that shadows cast would not have a substantial adverse impact on the distribution of natural and artificial light on adjacent public and private property for more than three months, considering the CC zoning context and the project compliance with building articulation and setback standards. 3) Privacy. Privacy is addressed previously in this report under Section 3.5.1. This subsection is redundant with that previous Section. 37 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9. 2014 Page 7 while providing a low, uniform level of lighting for safety at approximately 3 foot-candles or less across the site. Section 3.5.1 — Building and Proiect Compatibility: Standards in this Section require compatibility with the context of the surrounding area in terms of building size, massing proportions, design character and building materials. Where the established character of the relevant area is not definitively established, or is not consistent with the purposes of the Land Use Code, projects must set an enhanced standard appropriate for the area. Context. As documented in the 2001 Campus West Area Study, there is no predominant architectural character in the area. The CC zone envisions long term redevelopment with mixed -use multi -story buildings emphasizing pedestrian interest to establish an enhanced standard of quality. This recent District at Campus West project set an enhanced standard with a high level of articulation and mix of quality architectural materials, and this project is similar in quality. Building Scale, Massing, Materials, Details. The ground floor of the building along Plum Street is defined by brick, storefront windows, an arcade, and metal canopies over entrances. This one-story component brings the height and mass down to pedestrian scale. The remainder of the building includes significant modulation and detail features to create visual interest and mitigate the mass of the large building. Privacy on Adjacent Properties. A standard in this Section requires that the project minimize infringement on the privacy of adjoining uses. Staff finds that the one potential issue is along the west side of the project where the 5-story building overlooks an existing 2-1/2 story condominium building on the adjoining property. This area consists of the rear walls of both properties. Strips of perimeter landscape area are provided on both properties, and these areas have no outdoor use. The proposed project provides building wall articulation and a continuous row of trees to provide a layer of general buffering and mitigate looming effects. Staff finds the mitigation of the compatibility of the proposed project to be adequate and appropriate in the context of the CC zone district. 36 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 6 2) Scott Avenue. The project provides a highly developed urban multi -functional access drive and pedestrian/bicycle connection extending from Plum Street to the south property line, to be extended south to Elizabeth Street by any future redevelopment on property to the south. This connection occupies the existing 25' wide Scott Avenue right-of-way plus an additional 5' of width. It requires vacation of the existing Scott Avenue right-of-way because of the many special features associated with the project that are not currently permitted in City street right-of-way (e.g., permeable pavers, landscaping, benches, underground detention — features which create the multi - functionality in a narrow space). Section 3.2.2(C)(4) — Bicycle Parking Space Requirements: This standard requires at least one bicycle parking space per bedroom (194 spaces). 60% must be enclosed (116 spaces) and 40% must be outdoors (77 spaces). The proposed project provided these required spaces. Enclosed spaces include 30 spaces in the southwest corner of the garage structure and a minimum of 86 closets in interior hallways suitable for hanging bikes. 78 outdoor spaces are provided in four different locations. Section 3.2.2(K)(1) — Parking Space Requirements: The site is located within the Transit -Oriented Development Overlay District in which there were no minimum parking requirements at the time this project was submitted. The project, however, provides 95 parking spaces plus 4 motorcycle/scooter spaces. If the project were not located in the TOD District, 147 parking spaces would be required. A new parking requirement for the TOD District went into effect in September 2013, after this project was submitted, so the new requirement does not apply. But for perspective, that new standard would require 103 parking spaces, or an equivalent of alternatives, if this project had been submitted after September 13. This project does provide an alternative in the form of two Zipcars available to tenants in this project. Attachment 10 is the Zipcar Agreement with the project owners. According to Zipcar.com, a zipcar removes multiple personal vehicles from the streets — Zipcar claims the number as fifteen equivalent personal vehicles. Section 3.2.4 — Site Lighting: All lighting is down -directional with sharp glare cutoff fixtures. No foot-candles exceed one -tenth as measured 20 feet from property lines as required under this standard. Likewise maximum on -site lighting levels are well below the limit of 10 foot-candles 35 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 5 Section 4.18(E)(1)(a) — Building Orientation: This standard requires businesses to orient entrances to street sidewalks or other pedestrian areas, as opposed to internal parking lots. The proposed project meets the standard with a retail commercial entrance at the corner of Plum Street and the entry drive, and an entrance to the building office and elevator lobby facing Plum Street. Section 4.18(E)(1)(c) - Integration of the Transit Stop: Plum Street is served by Route 11, Transfort's highest performing route. Bus stops exist in the vicinity of this project; an east -bound stop is located in front of Cambridge House Apartments and a west -bound stop is currently under construction as part of the District Development on the north side of Plum Street. Section 4.18(E)(2)(d) — Building Height: This standard requires that all buildings be at least 20 feet in height and no more than five stones; the proposed five -story building complies. 5. Compliance with Article Three — General Development Standards: Staff finds that the project complies with all applicable General Development Standards, with the following comments. Section 3.2.1 — Landscaping and Tree Protection: Standards in this section require a fully developed landscape plan that addresses relationships of landscaping to the street, the building, abutting properties, and users on site. The project provides street trees, full tree stocking, and functional landscaping. A continuous row of trees is provided along the west property line as buffering of the new large building for the condo building to the west, which has no perimeter landscaping of its own. Vehicular use area perimeter landscaping is provided along the east edge of the property, in conjunction with a decorative metal fence, to screen, buffer, and define the main multi -use access connection. Section 3.2.2 — Access. Circulation and Parking: Standards in this section require safe, convenient, efficient, parking and circulation improvements that add to the attractiveness of the development. The two main issues are 1) the Plum Street sidewalk and streetscape, and 2) the disposition of Scott Avenue. 1) Plum Street. The project provides a dramatically improved new streetscape along Plum Street where no sidewalk currently exists. The streetscape includes a new detached sidewalk meeting City standards. This sidewalk has an interface with special paving associated with the project as well as providing a key functional connection. 34 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 4 3. Surrounding Zoning and Land Uses. Surrounding zoning and land uses are as follows: Direction Zone District Existing Land Uses 3 and 5-story student oriented multi - North C-C, Community Commercial family (The District) under construction South C-C, Community Commercial Multi tenant commercial building (Panhandler's Pizza) East C-C, Community Commercial 3 story student oriented multi -family (Cambridge House Apartments) West C-C, Community Commercial 3 story student oriented multi -family (Campus West Condominiums) 4. Compliance with Division 4.18, Applicable C-C Zone District Standards. Staff finds that the Scott Plaza PDP complies with the applicable standards in Division 4.18, Community Commercial District, as explained below. Section 4.18 (A) Purpose: The purpose of the Community Commercial District is as follows: "The Community Commercial District provides a combination of retail, offices, services, cultural facilities, civic uses and higher density housing. Multi -story buildings are encouraged to provide a mix of residential and nonresidential uses. Offices and dwellings are encouraged to locate above ground -floor retail and services." The proposed project is consistent with the stated purpose of the zone district as the project proposes to provide a mix of uses with higher -density residential in a multi -story building with ground -floor retail and an office. Section 4.18(13)(2)(a) - Permitted Use: The proposed use, Mixed -use dwellings, is permitted in this zone district in conjunction with Any residential use consisting in whole or in part of multi -family dwellings that contain more than 50 dwelling units, or more than 75 bedrooms. 33 Scott Plaza PDP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 3 the existing pattern of existing development, but it reflected a vision for long term redevelopment. A 2001 Campus West Community Commercial District Study explored the discrepancies of CC zoning vis-a-vis the realities of constraints on the ground, and the Scott Plaza property emerged as a key topic of the study because of the opportunity presented by Scott Avenue for a key north -south connection. A similar project called The Retreat at 1200 Plum was previously approved for the site in 2009. The existing buildings were not determined to be historically significant during the development review process for the Retreat in 2009, and that finding was confirmed for this proposed project. One of the buildings is currently vacant and boarded up. 2. Scott Avenue. Scott Avenue is a 25-foot wide fragment of unpaved street right of way extending from West Plum Street southward along the east edge of the site, terminating at the south property line. it is a result of ad hoc subdivision practices in the 1950's. This bit of right of way offers the best opportunity in the area for a needed future north -south connection between Plum street housing and Elizabeth Street commercial destinations. The project proposes to vacate this right of way but still provide a public access easement with a multi -functional connection for vehicle access that is also designed for joint pedestrian and bicycle use with bike racks, benches, and special paving using permeable pavers. This access connection in lieu of street right-of-way would resolve the long standing question of how to make progress toward a needed future connection using this segment of Scott Avenue, which is currently unpaved and too narrow for development of any standard City street. The Scott Plaza access connection can be continued to abutting property to the south in the event of future improvements or redevelopment on such property. The access easement facilitates development of the project, and is an acceptable solution for the Scott Avenue opportunity based on extensive past examination of the situation in development inquiries and the 2001 Campus West study. The vacation of the right-of-way will be considered by City Council if the Scott Plaza project is approved. 32 .S Scott Plaza POP #130032 Planning and Zoning Board Hearing January 9, 2014 Page 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This project represents significant redevelopment of single -story rental properties that have become outdated and deteriorated and do not have historical significance. The proposed land use, a Mixed -use dwelling of 5 stories, is permitted in the CC zone district. The project is consistent with development standards in the TOD Overlay District, which exempts the project from minimum parking requirements. The building design includes significant articulation and street -facing entrances to a commercial space, office, and elevator lobby. As a multifamily residential development with more than 50 units or 75 bedrooms, this project requires review by the Planning and Zoning Board. The project includes vacation of a fragment of public street right-of-way (Scott Avenue) while still maintaining a public access easement with special paving and landscaping, to be shared by vehicles, pedestrians and bicycles. This access provides for a needed connection that can be extended in the future by redevelopment on abutting property. The vacation of public street right-of-way is a separate procedure subject to approval by City Council. The staff recommendation of approval for this project includes a recommended condition that the vacation of public right-of-way be approved by City Council. C•Z�luL'd�ii�'�1 1. Background and Context of the Area. This stretch of West Plum Street adjacent to CSU is considered part of the area known as Campus West. Campus West is centered around the commercial stretch of West Elizabeth Street immediately west of the CSU Campus and is the focal activity center for the square -mile section with the highest residential density in the city. Its proximity to CSU offers access to and from campus by walking, bicycling, and transit. Plum Street is a convenient east -west travel corridor connecting a large body of student -oriented housing to CSU. Its signalized intersection with Shields Street (arterial street) allows for safe crossing for bicyclists and pedestrians into the campus. C-C zoning was placed on the Campus West area in 1997 as part of City Plan. This zoning reflects a vision for "downtown -like" pedestrian districts with a connected pattern of streets and blocks and development oriented primarily to sidewalks as opposed to parking lots. This zoning was done with the understanding that it was incongruous with 31 4 City of F6rt Collins PROJECT: Scott Plaza PDP #130032 APPLICANT: Stephanie Sigler Ripley Design Inc 401 W. Mountain Avenue Fort Collins, CO 80521 ITEM NO HEARING DATE January 9, 2013 ,- STAFF Mapes PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD OWNER: Taylor Fitzpatrick Capital, LLC 7825 E. Gelding Dr. Suite 102 Scottsdale, AZ 85260 PROJECT DESCRIPTION: This project would remove two single-family rental houses and two single -story apartment buildings built circa the 1950's, and construct a 5-story student -oriented apartment building with 4 stories of dwelling units above ground -level parking incorporated into the structure (podium parking). A small retail commercial space and a building rental office are included on the ground floor facing Plum Street. 79 dwelling units contain 194 total bedrooms in a mix of one, two, and three -bedroom units. 95 vehicle parking spaces are provided. The site comprises 1.17 acres located at the southwest corner of West Plum Street and Scott Avenue, 1/8 mile west of Shields Street and Colorado State University. Zoning is Community Commercial (CC), and the site is within the Transit -Oriented Development (TOD) Overlay Zone. The proposed land use is permitted subject to review by the Planning and Zoning Board. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of Scott Plaza PDP #130032 with a condition that subsequent vacation of the Scott Avenue right of way is approved by City Council. Planning Services 281 N College Ave - PO Box 580 - Fort Collins, CO 80522-0580 fcgov.com/developmentreview/ 970.221.6750 30