HomeMy WebLinkAbout1981-093-07/07/1981-MAKING FINDINGS RELATIVE TO AN ENGAGEMENT FOR THE PERFORMANCE OF THE 1981 AUDIT BY CLIFTON, GUNDERSO RESOLUTION 81-93
OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FORT COLLINS
MAKING FINDINGS RELATIVE TO AN ENGAGEMENT FOR
THE PERFORMANCE OF THE 1981 AUDIT
BY CLIFTON, GUNDERSON & COMPANY AND AUTHORIZING
THE CITY TO SOLICIT PROPOSALS FROM AUDITING FIRMS
FOR SUCH AUDIT
WHEREAS, on August 30, 1979, the City solicited information from
various auditing firms relative to a proposed three year auditing engage-
ment for performance of the 1979, 1980 and 1981 audits, and
WHEREAS, on September 27, 1979, the City selected six firms to present
a more detailed proposal for audit services and a proposal was submitted
to the City on October 12, 1979, by Clifton, Gunderson & Company which
contained a proposed fee schedule for the three year period and further
contained the following language on page 4 thereof
"In your consideration of the proposed fees, remember
that problems arise in making these estimates First,
our economy is currently faced with double-digit
inflation which must be considered a factor in such a
proposal Secondly, the City of Fort Collins is
recognized as one of the fastest growing and progres-
sive cities in the nation It is only reasonable to
assume that the audit will become larger and more
complex in the future It should also be agreed that
if at any point during our three year contract period,
changes in the structure, systems or operations of the
City occur which are so significant that the afore-
mentioned fees become unrealistic, we will maintain the
right to renegotiate the contracted fee Should the
negotiation process indicate that no agreement can be
reached , we will maintain the right to cancel the
contract We submit these statements both for our own
protection and for the protection of the City
Further, it should be noted that the renegotiation
process can and will work both ways Should the City
feel that the contract is unfair, any reasonable
changes will be considered This is especially
important when one considers that the quoted fees are
based on our concept of the scope of the audit and this
concept may well change in subsequent years " , and
WHEREAS, on November 6th, the Council adopted on final reading Ordi-
nance No 142, 1979, a copy of which is attached and incorporated herein by
reference, said ordinance appointing Clifton , Gunderson & Company to
perform the independent annual audit of the books and accounts of the City
for the years 1979, 1980 and 1981 and establishing a sum of Thirty Nine
Thousand Two Hundred and Fifty Dollars ($39,250 ) as the fee for per-
formance of the 1979 audit and further specifying that fees for the 1980
and 1981 audits should be subject to negotiation and ratification by the
City Council no later than July 1st of each year, and
WHEREAS, on October 30, 1979, Mayor Bowling, by letter to Clifton,
Gunderson & Company, requested that an engagement letter for the per-
formance of the 1979 audit be sent to the City which engagement letter was
sent to the City on November 26th and signed by the City An engagement
letter process was similarly established and used for the 1981 audit,
and
WHEREAS, on May 4, 1981 , Clifton, Gunderson & Company sent an engage-
ment letter to the City indicating its intent to continue the engagement
for a third year and setting a fee of Forty Five Thousand Six Hundred and
Twenty Five Dollars ($45,625 ) for performance of the 1981 audit, and
WHEREAS, the City, on June 16, 1981 , sent a letter to Clifton, Gunder-
son & Company advising the firm of its disagreement with the figure
presented in the proposal and inviting Clifton, Gunderson & Company to
submit a new proposal by June 30th, taking into account the revised scope
of work required for the audit, and
WHEREAS, on June 30th, the City received a letter from Clifton,
Gunderson & Company which did not submit a new proposal , and
WHEREAS, on June 30th at an adjourned meeting , the City Council
considered the engagement for the 1981 audit
NOW, THEREFORE, by and in consideration of the above premises, the
Council finds as follows
Section 1 That Clifton, Gunderson & Company, by Ordinance No 142,
1979, was appointed to perform the independent annual audit of the books
and accounts of the City for the years 1979, 1980, and 1981
Section 2 That in accordance with such ordinance, the fees for
performance of the 1980 and 1981 audits were to be subject to negotiation
and ratification by the City Council no later than July 1st of each of
those years
-2-
Section 3 That the engagement letter submitted by Clifton, Gunderson
& Company on May 4, 1981 , establishing a $45,625 00 fee is not reasonable
or acceptable as compensation for performance of the 1981 audit based upon
the scope of work that the Council reasonably believes will be necessary to
perform the 1981 audit taking into account revamped financial systems and
additional financial personnel hired since 1979
Section 4 That the City informed Clifton, Gunderson & Company
that its proposal for the 1981 audit was unacceptable and of the Council 's
rationale therefore, and further invited Clifton, Gunderson & Company to
submit a new proposal no later than June 30th
Section 5 That Clifton, Gunderson & Company has not submitted a
proposal for performance of the 1981 audit which is reasonable or accept-
able to the City Council or attempted to negotiate such a reasonable and
acceptable proposal and further that Clifton, Gunderson & Company has been
given a reasonable time within which to submit a new proposal or negotiate
a new fee and that no request for an extension of time to submit a revised
fee or to negotiate a new fee was made by Clifton, Gunderson & Company
Section 6 That in accordance with Ordinance No 142, 1979, which
requires that the fee for the 1981 audit shall be subject to negotiation
and ratification by the City Council no later than July 1 , 1981 , the
engagement of Clifton, Gunderson & Company not be continued for performance
of the 1981 audit
Section 7 That the Finance Department of the City be, and it hereby
is, authorized to begin a process of soliciting proposals from auditing
firms for performance of the 1981 annual audit
Passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Council of the City of
Fort Collins held this 7th day of July 1981
ayor
ATTEST
A��Y� 1��"
ity Clerk
-3-