HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016CV31096 - CITY OF FORT COLLINS, A COLORADO MUNICIPAL CORPORATION; AND POUDRE FIRE AUTHORITY, A COLORADO PUBLIC ENTITY V. KEITH GILMARTIN - 068 - PLAINTIFF'S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST2672516.1
DISTRICT COURT, LARIMER COUNTY, COLORADO
Larimer County Justice Center
201 La Porte Avenue
Suite 100
Fort Collins, CO 80521
970-494-3500
▲ COURT USE ONLY ▲
Plaintiffs:
CITY OF FORT COLLINS, a Colorado municipal
corporation; and POUDRE FIRE AUTHORITY, a Colorado
public entity,
v.
Defendant:
KEITH GILMARTIN, an individual.
Attorneys for Plaintiffs:
Kelley B. Duke, #35168
Benjamin J. Larson, #42540
IRELAND STAPLETON PRYOR & PASCOE, PC
717 17th
St. Suite 2800
Denver, Colorado 80202
Telephone: (303) 623-2700
Fax No.: (303) 623-2062
E-mail: kduke@irelandstapleton.com
blarson@irelandstapleton.com
Case No.: 2016CV31096
Div.: Ctrm: 3C
PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
1 Colorado Land Survey Monument
Record as prepared by Robert Alfred
Bradshaw, dated April 14, 1990
(Bates No.: PFA_000547)
2 Lease between Colorado State Board
of Agriculture for the use and benefit
of Colorado State University and
Poudre Fire Authority, dated May 10,
1990, for 30 acres on the Foothills
Campus
DATE FILED: August 10, 2017 11:53 AM
FILING ID: DDF50BF8154BB
CASE NUMBER: 2016CV31096
2
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
3 Architecture drawing and email to
Molly Davis, Deputy City Clerk,
from Ron Mills, Right-of-Way
Agent, dated January 4, 1991;
regarding West Vince Drive
(Bates Nos. PFA_000173 – 000174)
4 Deed of Easement, dated January 15,
1991, Reception No. 91018551,
between Hubert J. Gilmartin,
Florence R. Gilmartin, Keith J.
Gilmartin and the City of Fort
Collins, Colorado
(Bates Nos. PFA_000446-000453)
5 Letter to Keith Gilmartin, Evan
Gilmartin, Mr. and Mrs. Hubert
Gilmartin, from Theresa M. Tryon,
Credit Officer, Farm Credit Service;
cc: Helen Matson, regarding
Subordination and consent of
easement for the City of Fort Collins
Loan #792519-6-0, dated March 7,
1991
(Bates No. PFA_000176)
6 Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Report, dated August 21, 2010
(Bates Nos. PFA_000051 – 000053)
7 Land Plat Survey, dated November
24, 2010 (Bates No. PFA_000089)
8 Deed of Easement, dated January 15,
1991 between Hubert J. Gilmartin,
Florence R. Gilmartin, Keith J.
Gilmartin and the City of Fort
Collins, Colorado, re-recorded to
correct legal description March 15,
2011, Reception No. 20110016645
(Bates Nos. PFA_000541 – 000546)
3
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
9 Deed of Easement, dated January 15,
1991 and recorded February 11,
1991, Reception No. 91005481,
between Hubert J. Gilmartin,
Florence R. Gilmartin, Keith J.
Gilmartin and the City of Fort
Collins, Colorado
(Bates Nos. PFA_000180 – 000185)
10 Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Report, dated September 28, 2011
(Bates Nos. PFA_000054 – 000059)
11 Letter to Keith Gilmartin from Steven
C. Mason, Asst. City Attorney, City
of Fort Collins, dated October 20,
2011, regarding Poudre Fire
Authority Easement – Cease and
Desist (Bates No. PFA_000440)
12 Letter to Keith Gilmartin from
Bronwyn Scurlock, Asst. City
Attorney, Fort Collins City Attorney's
Office, regarding City Easement,
dated January 25, 2013
(Bates No. PFA_000101)
13 Email from Randy Callahan to Mike
Gress; cc: Mike Gavin, Randy
Callahan, dated May 30, 2013;
regarding Neighbor Complaint
(Bates No. PFA_000426)
14 Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Report, dated May 30, 2013
(Bates Nos. PFA_000060 – 000062)
15 Email from Randy Callahan to Randy
Callahan, dated June 27, 2013;
regarding Keith – June 27, 2013
(Bates Nos. PFA_000423)
16 Alta/ACSM Land Title Survey, dated
July 2, 2013
(Exhibit A to Plaintiffs' 26(a)(2)
Expert Disclosure)
4
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
17 Email from Chris Wolf to Randy
Callahan, dated July 5, 2013;
regarding Yesterday's Encounter with
Keith (Bates No. PFA_000421)
18 Email from Randy Callahan to
Officer Bull, Larimer Humane
Society; cc: Randy Callahan, Mike
Gress, Mike Garvin, dated July 26,
2013; regarding Poudre Fire
Authority Dog Concern, with
attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000417 – 000420)
19 Email from Chad Myers to Randy
Callahan, dated August 1, 2013, no
subject line, with attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000414 – 000415)
20 Letter to Keith Gilmartin from
Bronwyn Scurlock, Asst. City
Attorney, Fort Collins City Attorney's
Office, regarding Installation of a
Fence at PFA Training Facility, dated
August 22, 2013
(Bates No. PFA_000102)
21 Email from Mike Gress to Randy
Callahan, dated September 27, 2013;
regarding Keith
(Bates No. PFA_000411)
22 Email from Randy Callahan to Randy
Callahan, dated November 5, 2013,
regarding Keith Nov 1
(Bates No. PFA_000410)
23 Email from Mike Gress to Brad
Kobielusz; cc: Randy Callahan, dated
December 28, 2013, regarding
Training Neighbor
(Bates No. PFA_000407)
5
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
24 Email from Mike Gavin to Tom
DeMint; Mike Gress; Chris Wolf;
Brandon Garcia; Kelly Close; Randy
Callahan; Doug Lane; John Lippert;
Jim Pietrangelo; Rick Vander Velde;
Bob Poncelow; Ryan McLean, dated
February 14, 2014; regarding Update
CSU v. Gilmartin, with attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000397 – 000403)
25 Amended and Restated
Intergovernmental Agreement
Establishing the Poudre Fire
Authority, dated July 15, 2014
(Bates Nos. PFA_000001 – 000020)
26 CSU Police Department Report,
dated September 30, 2014
(Bates Nos. PFA_000063 – 000067)
27 Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Report, dated May 2, 2015
(Bates Nos. PFA_000068 – 000078)
28 Email from Spencer Rice to Randy
Callahan, dated June 4, 2015;
regarding Neighbor Keith
(Bates No. PFA_000377)
29 Larimer County Sheriff's Office
Report, dated July 1, 2015
(Bates Nos. PFA_000079 – 000085)
30 Email from Spencer Rice to Randy
Callahan, dated July 1, 2015;
regarding Photo, with attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000364 – 000374)
31 Email from Bob Poncelow to PFA
Users, dated July 1, 2015; regarding
Training Center Security
(Bates No. PFA_000363)
32 Email exchanges between Keith
Gilmartin, Tom DeMint and Carrie
Daggett, City Council, dated June 20
– July 10, 2015; regarding PFA/W
Vine Dr. Easement (Council SAR
#29995)
(Bates Nos. PFA_000132 – 000139)
6
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
33 Email exchange between Amy and
Bryan Maddox and Randy Callahan,
and Randy Callahan and Mike Gress,
dated May 19-July 21, 2015;
regarding Keith
(Bates No. PFA_000359)
34 Email exchange between Brian
Fuller, Randy Callahan, Spencer
Rice, dated August 18-19, 2015;
regarding Fuller
(Bates No. PFA_000357)
35 Email from Randy Callahan to Randy
Callahan, dated March 22, 2016;
regarding New barricade, with
attachment
(Bates Nos. PFA_000328 – 000329)
36 Email from Spencer Rice to Randy
Callahan, Mike Gress, dated February
9, 2016; regarding Keith's dogs with
attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000331 – 000349)
37 Email from Mike Gavin to Tom
DeMint; Mike Gress; Gary Nuckols;
Randy Callahan, dated May 13, 2016;
regarding Property Issue, with
attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000319 – 000327)
38 Email from Spencer Rice to Mike
Gress, Randy Callahan, dated May
31, 2016; regarding Keith, with
attachments
(Bates Nos. PFA_000311 – 000318)
39 Email exchange between Keith
Gilmartin, CCSL and Carrie Daggett,
dated May 30 – Jun 7, 2016;
regarding To Debris or not Debris,
with attached Deed of Easement
(Bates Nos. PFA_000148 – 000152)
7
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
40 Email exchange between Randy
Callahan and Tricia Booth, dated
June 16, 2016; regarding
Invoice12550 from Jordan's Tree
Moving & Maintenance, with
attached invoice #12550
(Bates Nos. PFA_000306 – 000307)
41 Letter to Keith Gilmartin from Darin
Atteberry, City Manager and Tom
DeMint, Fire Chief; cc: Carrie
Daggett, dated June 28, 2016
(Bates Nos. PFA_000169 – 000170)
42 Email exchange between Randy
Callahan and Adam Smith, dated
August 9, 2016, regarding Mr.
Gilmartin Debris Removal
(Bates Nos. PFA_000298 – 000300)
43 Intergovernmental Agreement
between Poudre Fire Authority and
the City of Fort Collins, Colorado,
dated October 12, 2016
(Bates Nos. PFA_000025 – 000050)
44 Photograph of sign erected by
Defendant on or about October 18,
2016 (Bates No. PFA_000086)
45 Email from Randy Callahan to Randy
Callahan, dated November 1, 2016,
regarding Mr. Gilmartin Parking
Complaint
(Bates No. PFA_000295)
46 Email exchange between Randy
Callahan and Christopher Robertson,
dated November 28, 2016; regarding
PFA Contract, with attached Service
Agreement for PFA Family Night
(Bates Nos. PFA_000293 – 000294)
47 Satellite Image of PFA Training
Center
(Exhibit E to Plaintiffs' Motion for
Partial Summary Judgment)
8
2672516.1
Exhibit
No.
Description Offer. Stip ADM Remarks
(Objection)
48 Photographs taken by James Snow on
April 21, 2017
(Bates Nos. PFA_000265 – 000270)
49 CSU Police Department incident
report, dated May 30, 2017
(Bates Nos. PFA_000272 – 000274)
Any and all documents, exhibits, data
compilations, intangible things
disclosed by defendant or any other
party to this lawsuit
Any document for purposes of
impeachment or rebuttal
Any exhibit necessary for
demonstrative purposes
Respectfully submitted this 10th day of August, 2017.
IRELAND STAPLETON PRYOR & PASCOE, PC
Signed original on file at the office of
Ireland Stapleton Pryor & Pascoe, PC
/s/ Kelley B. Duke
Kelley B. Duke, #35168
Benjamin J. Larson, #42540
Special Counsel for the City of Fort Collins
Attorneys for Poudre Fire Authority
9
2672516.1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this 10th
day of August, 2017, a true and correct copy of the
foregoing PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST was served via U.S. Postal Service, first
class mail, postage prepaid and addressed as follows:
Keith Gilmartin
3316 W. Vine Drive
Fort Collins, CO 80521
And served via email to:
keithgil2@gmail.com
/s/Barbara Biondolillo
Barbara Biondolillo