HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-cv-901 - Surat v. City of Fort Collins, et al. - 177D - EXHIBIT 4
EXHIBIT 4
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 1 of
13
FINAL LIST OF PROPOSED EXHIBITS
CASE NO. 19-CV00901-WJM-NRN PLAINTIFF'S LIST_____ DEFENDANT'S LIST_____ THIRD PTY
DEFTS. LIST_____
CASE CAPTION Michaella Lynn Surat vs. Randal Klamser and City of Fort Collins
DATE: August 27, 2021
LIST PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBITS BY NUMBERS (1, 2, 3, etc.) and DEFENDANT'S BY LETTER (A, B, C, etc.)
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
A.
Police Report
B.
Excerpts from
Surat Criminal
Trial Transcript
(Surat 1815)
C.
Deposition of
Michaella Surat
D.
February 21, 2018
FCPD Defensive
Tactics Team
Memo from
Officer Al Brown
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 2 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
to Mitch Murray,
FC Surat 1702 -
1706
E. Deposition Exhibit
51 – Bodycam
video (Klamsers)
F. Plaintiff’s
Responses to
Defendant’s First
Set of Discovery
G. Expert Report of
Don Black
H. CV of Don Black
I. AJ Brown
Resume, FC
Surat 4876 - 4880
J. Al Brown CV-
Surat 643-647
K. Fort Collins
Training
Materials FC 1-
1284
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 3 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
L. Klamser Training
Report FC 1285-
1298
Fort Collins
Policies FC
1299-1337
M. Fort Collins Police
Services
Report FC 1340-
1412
N. Surat Charging
Docs FC 1649-
1665
O. Written Statement
of Michael Findlay
FC 2259-2260
P. Written Statement
of Kennedy
Brooks FC 2261-
2262
Q. Dan
Montgomery’s
Report in the
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 4 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
Criminal Matter
FC 4691-4701
R. Order to Amend
Summons and
Complaint in the
Criminal matter
FC Surat 4763-
4764
S. IA Investigation of
Incident FC Surat
5966-6011 &
6019-6059
T. Records from Dr.
Shoshanna
Sachtman FC
Surat 6106-6111
U. Records from
Kather Combs FC
Surat 6112-6130
V. CSU Records of
Plaintiff
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 5 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
W. SURAT 000852
Body Cam of
Incident on March
30, 2018
X. SURAT 000855.2
BodyCam of
Jace's Arrest
2018-03-31
Y. SURAT 000855.1
BodyCam of Cop
Taking Michaella
Home 2018-03-30
Z. SURAT 000767.6
Body Cam of
Phone Call with
Michaella (2018-
04-14)
A1. SURAT 000767.8
Body Cam of Jace
Everett's Arrest
(2018-04-14)
A2. SURAT 000767.7
Body Cam of
Interview with
Mitchell Waltz
(2018-04-14)
A3. SURAT 000744.2
Body Cam Video
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 6 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
of Interviews with
Michaella (2018-
03-30)
A4. SURAT 000905
Body Cam of the
Incident and
Contact with
Findlay (Klamser)
A5. SURAT 000904
Body Cam of
Michaella's
Interview with
EMS
A6. SURAT 000903
Body Cam of
Interview with
Bondi Bouncer
(Cody Esslinger)
A7. SURAT 000902
Body Cam of
Incident and
Contact with
Mitchell Waltz
(Second Officer)
A8. SURAT 000901
Body Cam of
Contact with
Mitchell Waltz
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 7 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
A9. SURAT 000900
Body Cam of
Contact with
Michaella's
Friends
A10. SURAT 000899
Body Cam at
Hospital
A11. SURAT 000743.2
Body Cam of
Police Driving
Michaella Home
(2018-03-30)
A12. SURAT 000743.1
Body Cam Arrest
of Jace Everett
and Transport to
Jail (2018-03-31)
A13. SURAT 000849
Body Cam of
Interview with
Witness and
Michaella from
Dec. 2017
Incident
A14. SURAT 000850.2
Roger's Body
Cam during
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 8 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
contact with
Michaella and
Witness
A15. SURAT 000847.7
Body Cam of
Interview with
Mitchell Waltz
(2018-04-14)
A16. SURAT 000702.2
Bodycam Video
A17. Michael Findlay
Statement-Surat
884 & 885
A18. Officer Mike
Hares Statement-
Surat 886
A19. Cory Esslinger
interview-Surat
886, 887 & 888
A20. Erin Mast
interview-Surat
889 & 890
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 9 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
A21. Heather Moore
Interview-Surat
891 & 892
A22. Al Brown
Interview-Surat
892, 893 & 894
A23. Garrettt Pastor
Interview-Surat
895 & 896
A24. Klamser
Interview-Surat
897 & 898
A25. Kennedy Brooks’
phone interview-
Surat 909
A26. Video of Michaella
Surat at Student
Resolution
Center- Surat
3071
A27. Telephone call
with “Miller”
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 10 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
(Marshall) Surat
3070
A28. Body-cam video
of Michaella in
police car with
EMS- Surat 3066
A29. CSU Case
Resolution Form-
Surat 3075-3076
A30. Surat Patient
Notes from
Shoshanna
Schatchman-
Surat 3147-3151
A31. Cognitive Therapy
Notes from
Katherine Combs-
Sruat 3152-3161
A32. SURAT
000767.10 Body
Cam of In-Person
Interview with
Jace Everett
(2018-04-14)
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 11 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
A33. SURAT 000767.9
Body Cam of
Phone Call with
Jace Everett
(2018-04-14)
A34. August 24, 2018
Verdict in
17M965, Surat
002887 - 2890
A35. Jury Instructions
in 17M965, FC
Surat 6131-6163
A36 Jace Everett
Criminal History,
Surat 732-738
A37. Mitchell Waltz
Criminal History,
Surat 95-96
A38. Demonstrative
exhibits and
diagrams as may
be needed by
witnesses in their
testimony (still
being prepared)
A39. Any deposition
(designated)
taken in the case
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 12 of
13
EXHIBIT
NO. /
LTR
WIT.
DESCRIPTION
AUT
H-
ENTI
CITY
STIP
OFFER
RECD
.
REF
.
RUL.
RSVD.
COMMENTS/
INFO.
A40. Any exhibit listed
by another party
A41. Any exhibit
necessary for
impeachment or
rebuttal
A42. Any deposition
exhibit
A43. Any document
produced in
discovery
A44. Any document
disclosed by any
party
NOTE: Defendants expressly reserve the right to object to the admissibility of any exhibits or evidence offered by
any party on any and all grounds provided under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the Federal Rules of
Evidence, as well as applicable Colorado state law. By listing items on this preliminary exhibit list, the
Defendants in no way admit that any of the listed items, or parts thereof, are admissible at trial.
Case 1:19-cv-00901-WJM-NRN Document 177-4 Filed 09/03/21 USDC Colorado Page 13 of
13