Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMemo - Mail Packet - 3/3/2020 - Memorandum From Delynn Coldiron And Elizabeth Blythe Re: Periodic Review For Various BoardsARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 2 - Affordable Housing Board The duties and functions of the Board shall be: (1) To advise the City Council on all matters pertaining to affordable housing issues of concern to the City; (2) To aid and guide the development of City-wide affordable housing programs to address currently existing and potential affordable housing issues; (3) To promote citizen participation and public education on City-wide affordable housing issues; (4) To be aware of and coordinate with the various other City boards and commissions whose actions may affect affordable housing in the community; and (5) To perform other such duties and functions and have other powers as provided by the City Council. (Ord. No. 84, 1993, 8-3-93) BYLAWS AND RULES OF PROCEDURE OF THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING BOARD CITY OF FORT COLLINS, COLORADO ARTICLE I Section 1. These bylaws and rules of procedure have been adopted by the Affordable Housing Board and approved by the City Council. Any bylaws or rules of procedure previously in effect are herewith superseded. Section 2. The official title of this Board shall be the Affordable Housing Board of the City of Fort Collins, Colorado. ARTICLE II Section 1. Regular meetings of the Board shall be held on the first Thursday of each month at 4:00 p.m. Section 2. Special meetings may be called by the Chairperson of the Board at such other times as the Chairperson or the Board may determine to be accessible, provided that written notice or notice by telephone of such meeting and of the subject matter of such meeting be given to each Board member at least twenty-four (24) hours prior to the time set for such meeting; provided further that notice of any such meeting be filed with the City Clerk twenty-four (24) hours before the time of such meeting. Any Board member may sign a waiver of notice which waiver shall then be in lieu of any other notice requirement. A Board member attending any meeting shall be deemed to have received the necessary notice of such meeting. Section 3. All meetings of the Board shall be held in a designated conference room in a City facility or after proper notice as set forth in Section 2. Section 4. All meetings shall be open to the public. The first item on the agenda shall be noted for Open Discussion and shall allow a ten-minute time slot for public input. Persons wanting to address the Board may also do so by obtaining agenda item approval by both the Secretary and the Chairperson of the Board not less than fourteen (14) days before the next regularly scheduled meeting. Guests may also address the Board at other times by Board invitation. Section 5. A quorum of the Board shall consist of 4 members, which is 50% of the total number of members of the board as specified by City Code. No official action may be taken by the Board unless a quorum is present. However, if a quorum is not present, the meeting may still be conducted for the purposes of status reporting and discussion of items. Section 6. The order of business for all meetings shall be the order as it appears in the agenda except that the Chairperson may, under special circumstances, rearrange the order of business unless otherwise directed by a majority of the Board. Section 7. Any Board member who has a personal interest in any matter before the Board shall disqualify himself or herself from any such consideration or discussion of or voting upon such matter. Any such disqualification shall be noted in the official Minutes of the meeting. ARTICLE III Officers and Duties Section 1. The Affordable Housing Board shall be comprised of seven regular members who shall serve without compensation. Section 2. At the first regular meeting in each year, a Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson shall be elected by majority vote of the Board. That meeting shall be designated as the Board's annual meeting. Section 3. The Chairperson shall preside at all meetings of the Board. In the event of the absence or disability of the Chairperson, the Vice-Chairperson shall preside. Section 4. A vacancy in the office of Chairperson shall be filled automatically by the Vice-Chairperson, and a new Vice-Chairperson shall be elected at the next regular meeting of the Board from among the regular members. A vacancy in the office of Vice-Chairperson shall be filled at the next regular meeting of the Board by election from among the regular members. The officers so elected shall serve until the next annual meeting. Section 5. The Chairperson, subject to these bylaws and rules of procedure, shall decide all points of order or procedure, unless otherwise directed by a majority of the Board in session at that time. Section 6. The Secretary of the Board shall be the Board’s staff liaison, who shall be a non-voting member of the Board. The Secretary shall keep or cause to be kept the Minutes of each Board meeting, shall conduct all official correspondence and generally supervise the clerical and technical work of the Board. ARTICLE IV Amendments These rules may be amended or modified by a majority vote of the Board, provided that such amendments be presented in writing and such action be taken thereon at a subsequent regular meeting, subject to the approval of the City Council. Amended: March 7, 2013 City of Fort Collins AFFORDABLE HOUSING BOARD 2019 Work Plan Demand for affordable housing continues to outpace supply in the City. The 2015-2019 Affordable Housing Strategic Plan establishes specific goals to increase the percentage of affordable housing units in the City. The Affordable Housing Board (AHB) will make recommendations to Council on policy and programing to guide the City’s efforts to reach the plan’s goals. The AHB will focus its efforts increasing the City’s affordable housing inventory and providing support to consumers of affordable housing to promote housing retention to the Fort Collins City Council by taking the following actions: • Promote implementation of the strategies contained in the 2015-2019 Housing Affordability Strategic Plan by advising staff and City Council and by prioritization of action items. o Strategy 4.1 – Increase the Inventory of Affordable Rental Units o Strategy 4.2 – Preserve the Long-term Affordability and Physical Condition of Exiting Stock of Housing o Strategy 4.3 – Increase Housing and Supportive Services for People with Special Needs o Strategy 4.4 – Support opportunities to obtain and sustain affordable homeownership o Strategy 4.5 – Refine development incentives and expand funding sources and partnerships • Work with staff on providing input into the development and implementation of City Plan, as it relates to housing, to ensure affordable housing options meet the needs of all Fort Collins citizens over the next 20 years. [Strategy 4.1; Strategy 4.3 Strategy 4.4; Strategy 4.5] • Continue to play a critical role in the Competitive Review process by reviewing all affordable housing proposals and meeting with the Community Development Block Grant Commission (CDBG) to discuss the specific proposals and share priority rankings with them and the City Council. [Strategy 4.1; Strategy 4.2; Strategy 4.3 Strategy 4.4; Strategy 4.5] • Actively participate in the creation of the updated Affordable Housing Strategic Plan for 2020-2024. • Continue to work with staff to review and evaluate the effectiveness of the City’s current incentives to developers to produce affordable housing units, and recommend modifications, or new incentives, or building code revisions to the City Council. [Strategy 4.1; Strategy 4.4; Strategy 4.5] • Continue to investigate incentives to preserve current available stock of affordable housing including mobile home parks, and implementation of selected rehabilitation programs identified in the Redevelopment Displacement Mitigation Strategy. [Strategy 4.2] • Assist staff in reviewing the land bank program implementation and potentially recommend changes to improve the program. [Strategy 4.5.3] • Review proposed policy, regulations, density and other issues (e.g., development fees and requirements) and provide input to the City Council on the impact of these issues on housing affordability, including recalibration of City fees to encourage development of affordable market rate and subsidized housing. [Strategy 4.1; Strategy 4.4; Strategy 4.5] • Research the potential for additional ongoing funding sources for the City’s various affordable housing funds to provide financial resources to affordable housing programs and projects. [Strategy 4.5] • Advocate for the need for housing affordability for the entire spectrum of wage earners in our community, specifically, engaging with City Council through written and oral communication and attending other public meetings to stress the important relationship between economic, environmental, and social vitality, using triple bottom line values as applied to affordable housing policy, regulation, facilitation and funding. [Strategy 4.1; Strategy 4.2; Strategy 4.3 Strategy 4.4; Strategy 4.5] • AHB members will attend City Council meetings and address Council on matters pertaining to housing. Also, have a detailed discussion with the Board’s Council liaison at least twice a year. • Monitor the community’s efforts to end homelessness. [Strategy 4.3] • Be informed by staff of all requests for certification of affordable housing projects. [Strategy 4.1] • At least quarterly, review the 2019 Work Plan to assure the AHB work is accomplished. Board members will consider liaison positions to other boards and commissions, as possible, including: o – Planning and Zoning Board o – Board of Realtors o – Economic Advisory Board o – Transportation Board o – Human Relations Commission o - Commission on Disability o - Senior Advisory Board o - CDBG Commission o – Sustainability Boards & Commissions Collaboration Pilot group as well as participate in/collaborate with other committees and workgroups convened by the City Council, staff, board members or citizens, in order to advocate and educate on issues related to affordable housing. The Affordable Housing Board (AHB) has an interest in 3 Key Strategic Outcome areas in the City - Community and Neighborhood livability, Economic Health and Transportation. During 2019, the AHB will be guided by the following City Strategic Objectives in its work: - Community and Livability’s key strategic objectives, including but not limited to: 1.1 Improve access to a broad range of quality housing that is safe accessible and affordable; 1.2 Preserve the significant historical character of the community;1.5 Preserve and enhance the City’s sense of place; 1.7 Leverage and improve collaboration with service agencies to address the prevention of homelessness, poverty issues and other high priority human service needs; 1.8 Expand organizational and community knowledge about diversity, and embrace cultural differences; 1.11 Maintain and enhance attractive neighborhoods through City services, innovative enforcement techniques and voluntary compliance with City codes and regulations; and foster positive and respectful neighbor relationships and open communication, as well as provide and support conflict resolution. - Economic Health’s key strategic objectives including but not limited to: 3.3 Support workforce development and community amenities initiatives that meet the needs of employers within the City; 3.7 Support sustainable infill and redevelopment to meet climate action strategies; and 3.8 Preserve the City’s sense of place. - Transportation’s key strategic objectives, including but not limited to: 6.2 Improve transit availability and grow ridership through extended hours, improved headways, and Sunday service in appropriate activity centers; 6.4 Improve traffic flow for all modes of transporting people, goods and information to benefit both individuals and the business community; and 6.7 Create and implement planning, engineering and financial strategies to address adequate infrastructure within the northeast area of Fort Collins. AFFORDABLE HOUSING BOARD 2018 Annual Report 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 1 The following lists the major items the Affordable Housing Board (AHB) was involved with during 2018: 1. COMPETITIVE PROCESS FOR ALLOCATING CITY FUNDS FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING • AHB worked with the Community Development Block Grant Commission in advising City Council on the funding for affordable housing projects in the spring cycle of the competitive process. • The Board reviewed 5 applications in the spring cycle and made recommendations to the CDBG Commission. 2. LAND BANK PROGRAM • The AHB advised staff and was kept appraised of all staff work and recommendations related to this program. • The Board helped staff prepare for the January Work Session and support staff recommended Code changes. • The Board was kept appraised of the Request for Proposals for the Kechter parcel and the outcome of that process. 3. THE BOARD SENT MEMORANDUMS OR EMAILS TO CITY COUNCIL REGARDING THE FOLLOWING MATTERS: • Support for the assignment of the 2018 Private Activity Bond Allocation • Supported expanding affordable housing fee waiver eligibility • Supported fee waivers being awarded to the Oakridge Crossing development • Supported using Affordable Housing Capital Fund as a direct capital assistance loan to the Mason Place permanent supportive housing development • Supported lifting an affordability restriction on the Timberline at Rigden Farms because the project built did not get any incentives and was not ownership product as described by the restrictive covenant • Expressed a desire for more information on the cost of 100% Renewables before forming a position on this topic. • Sent comments on the City Manager’s proposed budget. • Supported City infill options to improve choice and density. 4. BOARD BRIEFINGS • Affordable Housing Capital Fund • 2018 International Building Code Updates and Local Amendments • Preventing concentrated poverty • Multiple briefings on the City Plan Update project BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Commission on Disability DATE PREPARED: October 14, 2019 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Ashlynn Freestone Resigned 6. Michael Marr 2. Terry Schlicting Co-President 7. Amanda Morgan 3. Jan Barela-Smith 8. John Morris CO- President 4. Marilee Boylan 9. Sherri Reichow 5. Arianna Kilmer 10. 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: _#1 Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___Culture and Recreation ___Economic Health ___Environmental Health _#3_Safe Community _#2_Transportation The above prioritized categories are a major focus; however, Culture and recreation and economic health are also very important focus areas. Last year we gave input and worked in conjunction with the organizers of Bohemian Nights regarding the accessibility of the event and other public city events. We also developed a disability awareness training for event staff. In addition, we offered input for public recreation facilities access such as Mulberry Pool and the bike trails. Economic health is an area that needs to be addressed in the future as people with disabilities are more likely to live in poverty. The rate at which people with disabilities are employed as compared to people without disabilities represents a large gap. 30% of people with a disability in Colorado are employed compared to 71% of people without a disability. We would recommend the focus areas be chosen annually by the commission depending on the current need. 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? (1) To develop educational programs to acquaint our citizens with issues affecting individuals with disabilities; (2) To form special committees including noncomission consultants or specialists to address issues affecting the well-being of individuals with disabilities; (3) To communicate with other commissions in order to generate ideas helpful to the City Council; (4) To educate City employees about access issues affecting individuals with disabilities; (5) To recommend to the City design requirements that ensure accessibility; (6) To help the City establish conditions and practices that contribute to employing individuals with disabilities; (7) To serve as advocates among City employees, private businesses and the community on behalf of individuals with disabilities. We would add to number 5 To recommend to the city: accessible designs / code changes/ event planning and implementation that ensure accessibility. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? Please see attached work plan. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? Please see attached work plan C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)? We will be reviewing the 6 month agenda in the future to be able to offer input to upcoming topics that will relate to our goals and objectives. D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? Yes. The way in which our work plan is written is to allow flexibility. We successfully accomplish a small number of goals annually which have big impact for people with disabilities in Fort Collins. There are still many goals on our plan that need to be addressed but with a small board is difficult to accomplish all within a years time frame. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? a. Meetings generally start on time, and in a timely manner. b. Discussions are mainly focused on-topic, but periodically stray away because of difficult situations. c. Add time to the end of the agenda for planning next meeting agenda topics d. Tracking ongoing projects/processes in an Excel document e. Add sub committees/ focus groups meeting once a month with a larger board f. receive minutes and agenda a week or two prior to meeting for timely planning. g. add virtual meeting, or a teleconference system availability for each meeting for those unable to attend in person. Call in number will be listed on agendas. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? a. We would like to add a few more seats to the commission so it would be easier to break into sub committees where we could get more accomplished. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? a. We would like to see our council liaison quarterly b. Other comments: We appreciate that The City of Fort Collins has a Commission on Disability that is its own entity. The breadth and number and complexity of issues that impact people with disabilities is still immense. Combining our commission into another would be injurious. People with disabilities are a marginalized group which struggle to have their voice heard. Being combined into a larger category group like the Human Rights Commission would water down what we address and how. We recognize that the Commission on Disability has work to do on our internal processes, however, those can be addressed and overcome. We are thankful to The City of Ft Collins for the opportunity to serve on a Commission on Disability as a voice for change. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws City Manager’s Office City Hall 300 LaPorte Ave. PO Box 580 Fort Collins, CO 80522 970.221.6505 970.224.6107 - fax fcgov.com MEMORANDUM DATE: February 19, 2020 TO: Delynn Coldiron, City Clerk FROM: Carol Thomas, City Staff Liaison to the Commission on Disability CC: Kelly DiMartino, Deputy City Manager RE: 2019 Periodic Review of the Commission on Disability This memo provides a brief summary of the Commission on Disability’s (COD) 2019 Periodic Review conducted by Councilmember Ken Summers. Bottom Line: The discussion primarily focused on transportation, employment and housing matters, since they are especially sensitive issues within the COD’s Key Outcome Areas of Neighborhood Livability and Social Health, Transportation and Safe Community. Background: Councilmember Ken Summers conducted a Periodic Review for the COD on November 14, 2019 during the COD’s regular meeting. The COD submitted their completed Periodic Review Questionnaire on 10/22/19. Summary: A variety of topics were discussed with Councilmember Summers, including: • Employment: The COD would like to see the City focus efforts specifically on hiring people with disabilities. • Housing: The COD advocated for an increase in the number of accessible rental units per property, which local building codes now reflect. New units are typically not financially accessible, however; the COD would like to see more subsidized housing, especially for those who are on a fixed monthly income. • Transportation: Improvements are needed for Dial-A-Ride (DAR) service: currently, DAR only operates within the boundaries and run times of Transfort fixed route service. The COD would like to see DAR expanded to cover all of Fort Collins. DAR should provide technology used by other ride share services like Uber – which is not accessible to people with physical disabilities – like sending passengers a text 5 minutes prior to arrival instead of making folks sit outside for 30 minutes. • Recommendation: Councilmember Summers recommended that the COD address Council at least quarterly, regardless if there’s a Council agenda item related to the COD’s function. ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 9 - Commission on Disability Sec. 2-153. - Functions The Commission shall have the following functions: (1) To develop educational programs to acquaint our citizens with issues affecting individuals with disabilities; (2) To form special committees including noncommission consultants or specialists to address issues affecting the well-being of individuals with disabilities; (3) To communicate with other commissions in order to generate ideas helpful to the City Council; (4) To educate City employees about access issues affecting individuals with disabilities; (5) To recommend to the City design requirements that ensure accessibility; (6) To help the City establish conditions and practices that contribute to employing individuals with disabilities; (7) To serve as advocates among City employees, private businesses and the community on behalf of individuals with disabilities. (Ord. No. 158, 1986, § 6, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 49, 1997, 3-18-97; Ord. No. 130, 2002, § 2, 9-17-02) Commission on Disability By-laws A. NAME The name of this City of Fort Collins commission is the “Commission on Disability” as established through City Ordinance #166 on November 3, 1981, hereafter referred to as the “Commission” or the COD. B. PURPOSE The Commission will advise the City Council and the employees and residents of the City of Fort Collins on issues concerning persons with disabilities in accordance with its functions as defined in the City Code. Within the limit of its authority, the Commission will formulate, recommend, and support such programs and policies as it deems important to assure compliance with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the 1990 Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Fair Housing Act and other legislation relating to persons with disabilities. C. COMMISSION MEETINGS 1. Regular Meetings a) Regular meetings of the Commission will be held at least once a month. b) Rules on time, place, accommodation, and order must be established by motions adopted by the Commission. c) Accommodations for meetings must be made accessible to all. d) For purposes of these bylaws, “active Commission members” means all appointed Commission members except those who have asked to be excused from service on the Commission for a period of three months or more. 2. Voting / Quorum a) Only Commission members counted present at any Commission meeting may vote on any motion considered by the Commission. b) A quorum consists of the majority of the total number of members specified by the City Code to comprise the Commission. c) Motions may be adopted by a majority of a quorum of the Commission. d) Motions must not be considered without a quorum, except for a motion to recess, adjourn, or to accept subcommittee reports. 3. Special Meetings a) Special meetings may be called by any Commission member with the approval of the Commission chairperson and at least 48 hours advance notice of time and location to all active Commission members, and public notice as required by the City Code. b) The Commission may pass other motions to further restrict the time, place, nature, or business of special meetings. 4. Agenda a) All agenda items will be generated by the Commission membership with the concurrence of the Chairperson and must be submitted no less than 24 hours prior to the scheduled meeting. 2 b) The agenda will allow for an open discussion in each meeting for the general public. c) Unscheduled presentation by City departments or the public, when not on the established agenda, will be requested to limit their presentation to fifteen (15) minutes or less. The Commission will need a clear statement at the beginning as to whether their presentation is for information or whether some action is being requested of the Commission. d) The agenda may be amended by the chairperson alone or a one-thirds (1/3) vote of the quorum of a Commission meeting as necessary during the meeting. The one-thirds (1/3) vote of the quorum to amend the agenda shall override any opposing amendments made or proposed by the chairperson alone. e) A majority of the quorum of a Commission meeting may suspend all further amendments to the meeting’s agenda. 5. Record Keeping and Dissemination of Information a) The City Staff Liaison will distribute minutes and meeting agendas prepared by the Secretary/Recorder and expedite correspondence with Commission member and pertinent City offices. b) The Commission will report its activities to City Council, via a written report, at least once a year or as required by the City Code. D. MEMBERSHIP RESPONSIBILITIES 1. Display sensitivity to and awareness of the needs, desires, and aspirations of persons with physical, mental, or emotional disabilities. 2. Present any concerns or suggestions received from members of the community to the Commission for consideration at the next regular meeting. 3. Submit suggestions for agenda items to the Chairperson (or other Executive Committee member) one week prior to the scheduled Commission meeting. 4. Consult with the Chairperson and City Staff Liaison prior to making any statements or joining in any activities specifically on the behalf of the Commission. 5. Volunteer and actively participate in a minimum of one sub-committee or other project on a continuous basis. 6. Contact a member of the Executive Committee, or the City Staff Liaison, when unable to attend a Commission meeting. 7. Commission members are expected to attend all regular meeting of the Commission. Failure to comply with the City’s attendance policy for Boards and Commissions, as described in the Boards and Commissions Manual, will cause a member’s appointment to be terminated. E. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE 1. Purpose The Executive Committee leads the Commission and meets to review the progress on the goals of the Commission and makes recommendations to the Commission for how to best achieve their goals. Further, the Executive Committee ensures that the Commission remains in close contact with necessary City and City Council officials and provides reports as desired to the City Council on the business of the Commission. 2. Membership a) The Executive Committee shall consist of four (4) members: Chairperson, Vice- Chairperson, Secretary, and Historian. 3 b) Only members of the Commission are allowed to serve as members of the Executive Committee. c) Only members of the Commission that have served no less than one (1) year are eligible to serve as the Chairperson. d) A Commission member may only hold one Executive Committee position at any given time. e) The term of every Executive Committee position ends on the first regular meeting in January after the regular election of a new Executive Committee. f) The term for every Executive Committee position shall be about one (1) year, the time between on January regular Commission meeting and the next January regular Commission meeting. 3. Elections a) Nominations for the Executive Committee positions shall be held at every first regular Commission meeting in January or February. b) The regular election for the Executive Committee positions shall be held at the next regular meeting after nominations have been taken. The election must occur as the first order of business. c) To receive a position on the Executive Committee, a nominee must receive votes from a majority of the quorum present at the time of the election in the appointed meeting. d) If no nominee for a given position receives a majority of the vote from the quorum, a run- off election will be held between the two nominees that received the most votes. e) Every member of the Commission present at the election has exactly one (1) vote for each position. Members present at the election may not abstain from voting. f) In the event of a tie, the current Chairperson will appoint one of the two nominees to serve as the winner of the election. g) A motion can be made at any time during a regular Commission meeting to take nominations to replace a vacancy in the Executive Committee. Once nominations are in place, a vote for the position must be immediately taken. The rules for the regular election are followed. 4. Removal a) Any member of the Executive Committee may only be removed from office by a vote of two-thirds (2/3) of the members present at a regular meeting of the Commission. b) A motion to unseat a member of the Executive Committee may be submitted at any time during a regular meeting and must be seconded. c) Any member that forfeits their membership to the Commission is automatically removed from the Executive Committee. 5. Meetings a) The Executive Committee shall meet to discuss new potential goals for the Commission, to review the progress of the Commission in accomplishing its current goals, and to recommend the Commission’s course of action to achieve new and remaining goals. b) The Executive Committee is required to meet at least once every six (6) months. c) Meetings of the Executive Committee are called by the Chairperson. d) Notification of the time and place of any Executive Committee meeting must be given to all acting Executive Committee members seventy-two (72) hours in advance, and to the public as required by the City Code. 4 6. Leadership Succession a) Upon the absence of the Chairperson, the Vice-Chairperson assumes the duties of the Chairperson until the Chairperson is no longer absent. b) Upon the absence of the Vice-Chairperson, the Secretary assumes the duties of the Vice- Chairperson until the Vice-Chairperson is no longer absent. c) Upon the absence of the Secretary, the Historian assumes the duties of the Secretary until the Secretary is no longer absent. d) Upon the absence of the Historian, the Chairperson may appoint a temporary Historian that will serve as Historian until the Historian is no longer absent. e) The Chairperson may appoint Commission members to temporary positions to assist a member of the Executive Committee that has assumed a different position due to an absence at the request of the member. The appointee will serve until the Executive Committee member no longer assumes the extra position. f) In the absence of all Executive Committee members, the Commission may take nominations and elect a temporary Chairperson according to Sections E.3.c – E.3.f that will serve as Chairperson until a member of the Executive Committee is no longer absent. g) A member of the Executive Committee may be considered absent under three different circumstances: i) The member fails to be counted as present at the most recent regular meeting. ii) The member notifies of the inability to perform their prescribed duties to another member of the Executive Committee or the entire Commission in writing, signed, dated, and witnessed. iii) The member is removed from the Commission. h) A member of the Executive Committee may remove their absent status via two means: i) The member is counted present at the next regular meeting. ii) The member notifies another member of the Executive Committee or the entire Commission that they should be considered present and able to perform their prescribed duties in writing, signed, dated, and witnessed. i) Any conflict that arises concerning the absence of an Executive Committee member may be resolved by the majority of the Commission in the next regular meeting. 7. Responsibilities of Chairperson a) Preside at Commission meetings. b) Preside at Executive Committee meetings. c) Develop agenda items in coordination with the Executive Committee. d) Assure the Commission meetings adhere to the agenda. e) Assure the Vice-Chairperson is prepared to preside at meetings in Chairperson’s absence. f) Be available for consultation at request of Commission members, City of Fort Collins employees, City Council, and residents. g) Report to the Commission all communication received by or delivered to Chairperson. h) Maintain contact with City Liaison. i) Oversee development of report(s) to City Council j) Assist with sub-committees. 8. Responsibilities of Vice-Chairperson a) Assist with developing agenda items. b) Assist with sub-committees. c) Assist in writing reports to the City Council. 5 d) Facilitate new member orientation. 9. Responsibilities of Secretary/Recorder a) Assist with developing agenda items. b) Assist with sub-committees. c) Assist in writing reports to the City Council. d) Record and compose meeting minutes and transmit to Staff Liaison for distribution. These transmissions should be sent to the Staff Liaison by Monday before the next scheduled meeting. e) Submit final, Commission approved minutes as required by the City Clerk’s office, any of the City’s rules governing the Commission, and any other applicable city ordinances and state statutes. 10. Responsibilities of Historian a) Assist the Commission with project timeliness, meetings, and project planning. b) Collect and organize newspaper articles and other write-ups concerning the COD. c) Prepare and maintain a COD history and scrapbook. F. SUBCOMMITTEES 1. Subcommittees are formed and discharged by a motion of the Commission. 2. The rules for establishing the Chairperson of each Subcommittee are made by a motion of the Commission. 3. The Chairperson of a Subcommittee must be a current member of the Commission. 4. The Chairperson, or someone acting in-lieu of the Chairperson according to the rules of a Subcommittee as established by Section F.2, will give a report at Commission meetings according to the agenda. 5. Membership criteria and manner of placement of membership rules of each Subcommittee are established by motions of the Commission. a) It is not required to have uniform rules for all Subcommittees. b) The rules may be inclusive to non-members of the Commission. c) The rules may also establish guidelines for qualifications of non-commission consultants or specialists to serve on a Subcommittee. d) The Commission may establish both voting membership and non-voting membership for a Subcommittee. 6. The quorum requirements of each Subcommittee shall be a majority of those appointed to the Subcommittee unless the Charter, City Code, or the Commission specifies otherwise. 7. Unless otherwise established by a motion of the Commission or the By-laws, Subcommittees are automatically discharged at the first regular meeting of a new calendar year. G. BY-LAWS 1. Notice of Amendment a) Notice, either written or, upon request, a reasonable alternate accessible format, of any proposed by-laws must be provided to each member of the Commission fourteen (14) days prior to the scheduled vote thereon. 6 b) The Commission shall not vote on an amendment unless it is able to verify that each active member has received sufficient advance notice of the proposed amendment. This may be accomplished in one of three ways: i) The member is present at a meeting of the commission at least fourteen (14) days prior to a vote where the proposed amendment is presented as reflected in the minutes of that meeting. ii) The member submits a signed and dated copy of the amendment to the Commission at any time before the vote, where the date of the signature is at least fourteen (14) days prior to a vote on the amendment. This can be done via any means, facsimile, mail, etc. iii) The member affirms that they have had the proposed amendment at least fourteen (14) days prior to a vote in a Commission meeting as reflected in the minutes. c) The way that the notice of amendment was verified for each active member shall be recorded along with the vote on the amendment in the minutes. 2. Approval Approval of these by-laws or any amendments may be accomplished thereto by simple- majority vote of the entire Commission membership. 3. Review These by-laws will be reviewed by the Commission annually for possible changes to assure a properly functioning Commission. 4. Conformance. a) These by-laws shall be consistent with the Charter and Code of the City of Fort Collins, and the City’s Boards and Commissions Manual. Those documents shall control in the event of a conflict with these by-laws. b) Rules and other adopted motions that conflict with the by-laws are not valid. Revised and Updated May 13, 2010 Largest Connection to Key Strategic Outcome Areas Secondary Connection Third Largest Connection Key Strategic Outcomes COD Action Items Strategic Objectives Supported Neighborhood Livability and Social Health Provide a high quality built environment, support quality, diverse neighborhoods and foster the social health of the community Collaborate with relevant Boards, Commission, and City Departments. o Receive and respond to citizen concerns o Ensure COD representation at major events relevant to Community & Neighborhood Livability. o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o Identify needs and develop/pursue special projects. o Update service agency list. Develop a message to push out on social media. o Address affordable housing when opportunities arise. 1.1 Improve access to quality housing that is affordable to a broad range of income levels 1.3 Improve accessibility to City and community programs and services to low- and moderate-income populations 1.4 Co-create a more inclusive and equitable community that promotes unity and honors diversity 1.6 Protect and preserve the quality of life in neighborhoods Transportation Provide for safe & reliable multimodal travel to, from, and throughout the city Collaborate with relevant Boards, Commission, and City Departments. o Receive and respond to citizen concerns o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o Ensure COD representation at major events relevant to Transportation. o Identify needs and develop/pursue special projects.* o Address paratransit education and advocacy when necessary *Projects might include: o Partner with Transfort to provide Ambassador/Consultant to evaluate proposed changes. o Work toward additional ADA accessible parking in the downtown area. o Improve Regional Interconnectivity. o Provide input to NFRMPO regarding draft plan o Address winter snow removal to ensure accessibility 6.1 Improve safety for all modes of travel 6.3 Improve transit availability and grow ridership 6.7 Address parking needs Downtown, along the MAX corridor and in residential neighborhoods Safe Community Provide a safe place to live, work, learn and play Collaborate with relevant Boards, Commission, and City Departments. o Receive and respond to citizen concerns o Ensure COD representation at major events relevant to Community Safety. o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o Identify needs and develop/pursue special projects.* *Projects might include: o Develop training for law enforcement, emergency personnel, Transfort personnel for interacting with people with disabilities. o Partner with SAVA and Womans Commission re sexual assault prevention Culture & Recreation Provide diverse cultural and recreational amenities Collaborate with relevant Boards, Commission, and City Departments. o Receive and respond to citizen concerns o Ensure COD representation at major events relevant to Culture and Recreation. o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o Develop COD statement regarding the contribution/participation of people with disabilities to our City’s culture. o Identify needs and develop/pursue special projects.* o Mayor’s Awards *Projects might include: o Collaborate with City's Special Events Coordinator as an ADA advisory committee for special events o Support The City of Ft Collins recreation events and facilities to increase accessiblity. ie City Park Pool, New West Fest o o Follow up with BoNi regarding the use the the Disability Etiquette Presentation. 2.2 Improve low and moderate income citizen access to, and participation in, City programs and facilities. 2.3 Promote health and wellness within the community and provide sustainable access to nature. 2.5 Plan, design and implement improvements to the citywide trail system. 2.6 Develop a clear strategic description of the City’s role in culture and arts while leveraging partnerships with other community organizations. 2.1 Develop recreational and cultural programs with pricing and marketing strategies that drive value, attendance and cost recovery 2.2 Plan, design, implement and maintain the City’s parks and trails systems 2.3 Provide enhanced opportunities for arts and culture throughout the City Economic Health Promote a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values Collaborate with relevant Boards, Commission, and City Departments. o Receive and respond to citizen concerns o Ensure COD representation at major events relevant to Economic Health. o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o Identify needs and develop/pursue special projects.* *Projectsmight include: o Continue to highlight/recognize employers who hire people with disabilities through annual Community Recognition Awards. o Address sub-minimum wage positions and sheltered work environments 3.2 Maintain and grow diverse employment opportunities 3.3 Enhance business engagement to address existing and emerging business needs High Performing Government Deliver an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government o Actively commit to recruit and hire people with disabilities. o Increase # of people with disabilities hired within the City. o Extend invitations to monthly COD meetings to Boards, Commissions, City Departments and aligned organizations, when relevant. o October: Promote employment for people with disabilities (October is National Disability Employment Awareness Month) 7.1 Provide world-class municipal services to residents and businesses 7.2 Promote a values-driven organizational culture that maintains the public trust through ethical behavior and transparency 7.3 Broaden methods of community engagement with additional consideration to diverse backgrounds, languages and needs 7.4 Attract, retain, engage, develop and reward a diverse and competitive workforce to meet the Commission on Disability 2018 Annual Report 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 1 The Commission on Disability serves as an advisor to the City of Fort Collins City Council on issues relating to citizens with disabilities. In its role as an advocate for citizens with disabilities, the Commission on Disability: develops educational programs to acquaint citizens with issues affecting individuals with disabilities; forms special committees to review and address particular issues; works together with other Boards and Commissions and the City Council to provide recommendations to assure compliance with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the 1990 Americans with Disability Act (ADA), the Fair Housing Act and other legislation relating to persons with disabilities; and serves as ombudsman between City departments, the private business sector, and the community of citizens who have disabilities. During 2018, the Commission members were as follows: Terry Schlicting- Chairperson Marilee Boylan Michael Marr John Morris- Vice Chairperson Jan Barela-Smith Rustin Hughes Sherri Reichow- Recorder Amanda Morgan Ariana Kilmer 1. “FIVE BEHAVIORS OF A COHESIVE TEAM” TRAINING • Members of the Commission attended 3hrs of training to increase the effectiveness of the commission. 2. CITY EVENTS ALIGNMENT WITH ADA GUIDELINES • The COD created and approved special event guidelines for the City to align with ADA guidelines when planning special events. • The COD created and approved a power point training that was requested from Doug Buffington to be used to educate staff about disability etiquette and laws in preparation for New West Fest. • Atlas Security, Security Contractor for New West Fest and Bohemian Foundation, made the following changes for ADA alignment. a) The BoNi@NWF website was updated to include an Accessibility Section that provided the ability to download the Festival Accessibility Guide. b) The Mountain Ave venue ADA platform was added. c) Training from the Rocky Mtn. ADA Center was provided. d) ADA seating was added to the Oak St. venue. e) A Security Staff ADA Information and Etiquette Guide was developed f) Three ADA drop off locations we added to the festival footprint. Commission On Disability 2018 Annual Report 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 2 3. COMMISSION ON DISABILITY COMMUNITY RECOGNITION AWARDS EACH YEAR, THE CITY OF FORT COLLINS' COMMISSION ON DISABILITY HOSTS AN AWARDS EVENT, FORMERLY TITLED THE MAYOR'S AWARDS. THE PURPOSE IS TO THANK THE PEOPLE AND BUSINESSES WHO SERVE TO ENRICH THE LIVES OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES, AFFECTING CHANGE BY EMBRACING THE SPIRIT OF INCLUSION AND RESPECT. Employer of the Year Sam’s Club, Fort Collins Employee of the Year April Tauer Volunteer of the Year Justin Kerley Educator of the Year Tara Gross Service Provider of the Year Cooper Home Spirit of Fort Collins Olander School for Project-Based Learning Dorothy Lasley Memorial Award Sam Lawrence 4. CITY PARK POOL- IN PROGRESS THE CITY’S OPERATIONS SERVICES STAFF AND COD MEMBER COMPLETED A WALK-THRU OF CITY PARK POOL TO IDENTIFY ACCESSIBILITY NEEDS BEYOND ADA COMPLIANCE. OPERATIONS SERVICES HAS COMMITTED TO INSTALLING THE FOLLOWING FEATURES: • Include the word “restroom” to sign installed to indicate location of accessible restroom • Install grab bars in the women’s restroom • Designate both of the accessible bathrooms as unisex • Install a 5’ changing table in one of the restrooms 5. BUILDING PERMIT CHANGES • The City approved Ordinance #149 and implemented The COD’s recommendation within the building permit process to require accessible units with roll in showers when a builder constructs 26+ units. • Ordinance #149 requires roll-in showers to be 36”x60’’ within the accessible units with roll in showers. This dimension allows care providers to safely assist the bathing process. Commission On Disability 2018 Annual Report 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 3 ACCESSIBLE DWELLING UNITS AND SLEEPING UNITS Total number of units provided Minimum required number of accessible units without roll-in showers Minimum required number of accessible units with roll-in showers3 Total number of required accessible units 1 -25 1 0 1 26-50 2 - NOW 1 0 - NOW 1 2 51 - 75 2 - NOW 3 1 - NOW 2 4 76-100 4 - NOW 4 1 - NOW 2 5 101 -150 5 2 7 151 -200 201 -300 6 7 2 3 8 10 301 - 400 8 4 12 401 -500 9 4 13 501 -1000 2% of total 1% of total 3% of total Over1000 20, plus1 for each100, or fraction thereof, over I000 I0, plus I for each I00, or fraction thereof, over 30, plus 1 for each I00, or fraction thereof, over 1000 1000 aRequired roll-in showers shall be a minimum of 36" by 60" interior dimension. BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Community Development Block Grant Commission DATE PREPARED: 10/10/19 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Amy Dondale Chair 6. Pat Hastings 2. Serena Thomas Vice Chair 7. Joshua Johnson 3. Steve Backsen 8. Margaret Long 4. Anita Basham 9. Sara Maranowicz 5. Olga Duvall 10. 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: ___XX Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___ Culture and Recreation ___ Economic Health Environmental Health Safe Community Transportation 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? • The current Duties of the CDBG Commission align well with the Neighborhood Livability & Social Health Key Outcome area. No need to be adjusted. o Allocating funding to various human services and housing proposals clearly aligns with providing resources needed to meet outcomes. o When considering funding allocations, commission constantly works to improve and sustain high quality neighborhoods, built environment, and overall community health. o Opportunity does exist to better address supporting diversity. o Opportunity for more alignment with the vision of affordable housing on the front end, not just the funding portion. o Opportunity for the commission to be allowed some latitude (or specific direction) in setting priorities regarding which aspects of neighborhood livability and social health, in order to be more strategic about funding recommendations. • Within the current Duties/Functions, the CDBG Commission is not clear on how to fulfill the following items, given the group’s emphasis on the annual grant process, and would welcome guidance: o Advise the City Council on matters pertaining to the HUD-CDBG Program; o Assess the community development needs of low- and moderate-income individuals and families and suggest programs to meet those needs. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? • The Work Plan is largely complimentary with the Neighborhood Livability & Social Health outcome. o The Commission designs its annual work plan based on this key outcome. o The Commission has added a component to the scoring of proposals to address this. o Opportunity for improved alignment on the planning side, not just to be utilized for funding decisions. • The CDBG Commission recognizes that there are other methods to contribute towards the NL&SH outcome. Opportunities to expand the Work Plan in 2020 towards this end will be available if the Commission desires to do so. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? • The Work Plan and the City’s Strategic Plan are primarily aligned with items 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3. C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six-Month Calendar)? • The Work Plan and the Six-Month Calendar are complimentary, but only with regard to the CDBG Commission’s funding recommendation advancing to City Council for review/approval. o CDBG Commission also follows City Council updates and periodically discusses at the monthly meetings. o Council’s Agenda Planning Calendar does not seem to offer other opportunities for consultation or advisement from the Commission. D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? • Yes, the Commission works to be effective and equitable with the funds available and to continually explore methods for improvement. • Opportunity for improvement towards Work Plan Item #5, which invites the Commission to play a stakeholder role regarding issues surrounding poverty, human services, affordable housing, etc. For example, the CDBG Commission was not aware of the City's plan to build a homeless service campus. • Work Plan only focuses on the grant funding mechanism, which is only one of many duties. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? • The Commission meetings are well run, efficient, effective and respect is given to members’ time. o As time permits, it would be good to have more general discussion of human service and housing issues. o Sometimes we do go down "rat holes". o Not optimally. It is hard to know where group discussion is leading toward an outcome. Instead of agenda items, it would be more effective to be clear about what the group is to accomplish during the meeting. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? • Yes, 9 Commission members is appropriate to represent a number of diverse views on supporting community development. o May not be as social-economically diverse as ideal. o Composition of skills / expertise and a commitment to carrying out the CDBG duties (vs advancing individual interest areas) is more important than the # of people. That being said, it would be great to expand to include more members with varied expertise. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? • Interaction between the Commission and City Council is limited and not in person, however; the established protocol for communications seems to work well and is effective. o City staff is our liaison, via written communication. This seems effective enough. o A quarterly visit from the council liaison would be beneficial for all. o More would be better as long as it doesn't compromise the independence of the Commission. o Past examples include:  Issues the Commission has deemed as important and in need of Council attention, such as the critical need for additional human service funding as the city grows.  Formal letter writing to advocate for more $ for grant funding. Other comments: • This is a commission with clear work and impact. It can be fairly time consuming during the competitive process which makes it difficult to have a more inclusive membership particularly those with low incomes. • I appreciate this effort! Assessing and making changes is never easy and it can be tough to see where things are working well and where objectives are not being met. From my view, staff management of the commission has been really well done recently. Thank you! • Given that funding decisions are made in the spring, it would be much better if new/old members could be rotated on/off at the beginning of the fall (September), rather than January. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws Social Sustainability 222 Laporte Avenue PO Box 580 Fort Collins, CO 80522 970.221.6757 MEMORANDUM DATE: December 13, 2019 TO: City Clerk Delynn Coldiron THRU: Jeff Mihelich, Deputy City Manager Jacqueline Kozak-Thiel, Chief Sustainability Officer Beth Sowder, Social Sustainability Department Director FROM: Adam Molzer, City Grants and Community Partnerships Coordinator RE: CDBG Commission Periodic Review: Dialogue with Mayor Pro Tem Stephens This memo provides a brief summary of the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Commission’s meeting on the evening of December 11, 2019 with Mayor Pro Tem Kristin Stephens to discuss their Periodic Review. Bottom line: The CDBG Commission does not recommend significant changes to the duties of the Commission and believes their work is complimentary with the City’s Neighborhood Livability and Social Health (NLSH) Outcome area. The Commission is largely satisfied with the effectiveness of their meetings, group size and communications. Edits and updates to the Commission’s functions as described in the City Code are necessary. Background: A Periodic Review is conducted every four years (rotational) of the City of Fort Collins Boards and Commissions. The Outcome area for 2019 is Neighborhood Livability and Social Health. The CDBG Commission’s primary outcome is under this focus area. The CDBG Commission completed their Periodic Review questionnaire in the fall of 2019 and presented their report to the assigned Council liaison, Mayor Pro Tem Kristin Stephens, for her response on the evening of December 11, 2019. Summary: A variety of topics were discussed with Mayor Pro Tem Stephens, including: • Receptiveness of Council for the Commission to communicate their thoughts and expertise on affordable housing and human services topics, outside of their annual funding recommendation activities. • Council’s consideration of short-term appointments to Boards & Commissions to temporarily fill vacancies during the ‘Reimagining Boards & Commissions’ project. • Updates to the City’s Code language related to the CDBG Commission, and a potential name change for the Commission. This should be part of the ‘Reimagining’ efforts. • The City’s upcoming Budgeting for Outcomes process and how the Commission can advocate for budget offers of interest to them. • Council priorities that intersect with the CDBG Commission’s interests, including childcare, and whether those should be considered during the grant funding process. • Council’s advocacy to federal officials for HUD resources delivered to the Fort Collins community. Next steps: • Staff liaison to the CDBG Commission will inquire with the City Clerk’s Office about Council’s interest in short-term appointments to Boards and Commissions. • Staff liaison to the CDBG Commission will consult with the City Manager’s Office about the anticipated timing for Code language revisions to be considered. DocuSign Envelope ID: 368B50D4-53C1-4F9F-AD81-1E0C075CE196 ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 11 - Community Development Block Grant Commission The Commission shall have the following functions: Sec. 2-183. - Functions. The duties and functions of the Commission shall be: (1) To advise the City Council on matters pertaining to the Department of Housing and Urban Development's Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program; (2) To promote the CDBG Program within the City with special attention to the three (3) low- and moderate-income neighborhood strategy areas of Holy Family, Laurel School, and Buckingham, Alta Vista and Andersonville (B.A.V.A.); (3) To assess the community development needs of low- and moderate-income individuals and families and suggest programs to meet those needs; (4) To provide recommendations to the City Council concerning the expenditure o (5) f CDBG funds received from the Department of Housing and Urban Development; (6) To perform such other duties and functions and have such other powers as may be provided by ordinance of the City Council. (Ord. No. 98, 1990, § 3, 9-4-90) BY-LAWS OF THE CITY OF FORT COLLINS COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT COMMISSION ARTICLE I – NAME The official title of this Commission shall be the Community Development Block Grant Commission of the City of Fort Collins, Colorado. ARTICLE II – PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES The duties and functions of the Commission shall be: 1. To advise City Council on matters pertaining to the Department of Housing and Urban Development's Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and the Home Investment Partnerships (HOME) Programs, the City’s Affordable Housing Fund (AHF) and Human Services Program (HSP); 2. To promote affordable housing, community development, and human service activities within the city with special attention to the needs of low- and moderate income individuals and families and special needs populations; 3. To assess the affordable housing, community development, and human service needs of low- and moderate-income individuals and families and suggest programs to meet those needs; 4. To provide recommendations to City Council concerning the expenditure of CDBG and HOME funds received from the Department of Housing and Urban Development, as well as the City’s Affordable Housing Fund and Human Services Program funds; 5. To perform such other duties and functions and have such other powers as may be provided by ordinance of City Council. ARTICLE III – COMMISSION MEMBERSHIP 1. The Commission shall consist of nine (9) members appointed by City Council. Council will strive to appoint persons with knowledge and/or experience in areas relating to affordable housing, economic development and/or human services. . 2. Each member shall serve without compensation for a term of four (4) years, except that members may be appointed by City Council for a shorter term in order to achieve overlapping tenure. Appointments shall specify the term of office of each individual. All members shall be subject to removal by City Council. If a vacancy occurs on the Commission, it shall be filled by City Council for the remaining unexpired portion of the term. No member shall serve more than two (2) consecutive terms, unless a period of at least twelve (12) months has occurred. For the purposes of this provision, a "term" shall include the balance of an unexpired term served by a person appointed to fill a vacancy if such unexpired term exceeds twenty-four (24) months. ARTICLE IV – OFFICERS 1. Each year in February or March, at a regular meeting, a Chair and Vice-Chair shall be elected by majority vote of the Commission. 2. The Chair shall preside at all meetings of the Commission. In the event of the absence or disability of the Chairperson, the Vice-Chair shall preside. 3. A vacancy in the office of Chair shall be filled automatically by the Vice-Chair, and a new Vice-Chair shall be elected at the next regular meeting of the Commission from among the regular members. A vacancy in the office of Vice-Chair shall be filled at the next regular meeting of the Commission by election from among the regular members. The officers so elected shall serve until the next February or March meeting when officers are elected. 4. The Chair, subject to these bylaws and rules of procedure, shall decide all points of order or procedure, unless otherwise directed by a majority of the Commission in session at that time. 5. The Director of Social Sustainability or employee designate(s) shall act as liaison to the Commission, shall keep or cause to be kept the minutes of each Commission meeting, shall conduct all official correspondence and generally supervise the clerical and technical work of the Commission. The liaison(s) shall be a non-voting member(s) of the Commission. ARTICLE V – MEETINGS 1. Regular meetings of the Commission shall be held at least monthly, or as established by the Commission, at a time and place agreed by its members. 2. Special meetings may be called by the Chair of the Commission at such other times as the Chair or the Commission may determine to be admissible, provided that written notice or notice by telephone of such meeting and of the subject matter of such meeting be given to each Commission member at least twenty-four (24) hours prior to the time set for such meeting; provided further that notice of any such meeting be filed with the City Clerk twenty-four (24) hours before the time of such meeting. Any Commission member may sign a waiver of notice which waiver shall then be in lieu of any other notice requirement. A Commission member attending any meeting shall be deemed to receive the necessary notice of such meeting. 3. All meetings of the Commission shall be held in a designated meeting place in a City facility or after proper notice as set forth in Section 2. 4. All meetings shall be open to the public. The first item on the agenda shall be noted for Open Public Discussion and shall allow a ten-minute time slot for public input. Persons wanting to address the Commission may also do so by obtaining agenda item approval by both the Chair and the Staff Liaison of the Commission not less than fourteen (14) days before the next regularly scheduled meeting. Guests may also address the Commission at other times by Commission invitation. 5. A quorum of the Commission shall consist of a majority of the total number of members specified by City Code to comprise the Commission. No official action may be taken by the Commission unless a quorum is present. However, if a quorum is not present, the meeting may still be conducted for the purposes of status reporting and discussion of items. 6. The order of business for all meetings shall be the order as it appears in the agenda except that the Chair may, under special circumstances, rearrange the order of business unless otherwise directed by a majority of the Commission. 7. Any Commission member who has a personal interest in any matter before the Commission shall disqualify himself or herself from any such consideration or discussion of or voting upon such matter. Any such disqualification shall be noted in the official Minutes of the meeting. ARTICLE VI – AMENDMENTS TO BY-LAWS These rules may be amended or modified by a majority vote of the Commission, provided that such amendments be presented in writing and such action be taken thereon at a subsequent regular meeting, subject to the approval of the City Council. Revised and approved 10/11/2018 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT COMMISSION: 2019 WORK PLAN The Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Commission is responsible for: overseeing the Competitive Process for the funding of affordable housing and community development projects and programs; reviewing related activities; and making funding recommendations to City Council. The following items are included in the CDBG Commission’s 2019 Work Plan: 1. Competitive Funding Process: Program Development The CDBG Commission will continue to work to improve the Competitive Process for CDBG, HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME), Affordable Housing Fund (AHF), Human Services Program (HSP) and Keep Fort Collins Great (KFCG) funds. The Commission will continue to use a web-based Competitive Process application process and will make adjustments and improvements as warranted. 2. CDBG FY 2019: Program Development CDBG Program Development involves the continuation of the federally funded grant program for activities such as affordable housing, public facilities, economic development and public services. The process includes a review and update of the processes for application selection, solicitation of proposals, criteria for funding, and funding recommendations. 3. HOME FY 2019: Program Development HOME Program Development involves the continuation of the federally funded grant program for affordable housing and will include review of the processes for application selection, solicitation of proposals, criteria for funding, and funding recommendations. 4. Human Services Program, Affordable Housing Fund, and General Fund and Keep Fort Collins Great: Program Development For these City General Fund and Keep Fort Collins Great funding streams, Program Development will include review of the processes for application selection, solicitation of proposals, criteria for funding, and funding selection. 5. City’s Social Sustainability Work Program and Community Initiatives The CDBG Commission will continue to play a stakeholder role for review and input as work continues both within the City organization and in the community regarding issues surrounding poverty, human services, affordable housing, community development and social sustainability. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT COMMISSION ANNUAL REPORT: 2018 The Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Commission met a total of twelve times during 2018. Six were regular meetings and six were special Competitive Process-related meetings. One funding cycle was conducted in the spring. The Commission held six evening meetings during the spring cycle to listen to presentations by housing and human service applicants, to consult with the Affordable Housing Board and discuss the merits of the grant proposals, and to make funding recommendations to Council. A subcommittee of Commission members also met for a series of five meetings in the summer months. This group worked with staff to provide a comprehensive review and evaluation of the Competitive Grant Process. These recommendations will be folded into improvements for the grant process in 2019, allowing the grant process to be leaner and more effective, while maintaining the value and integrity of the final funding recommendation. During the regular meetings, the Commission reviewed the funding process and discussed the status of some grantees. A presentation from members of the Economic Advisory Board also provided information about a special project that would focus on the City’s Triple Bottom Line approach to project evaluation and engagement of various Boards & Commissions from the Sustainability Service Area. Discussions also occurred around the City’s Budgeting for Outcomes process and budget offers that specifically impacted the Human Services Program and the Social Sustainability Department. Commission members wrote a letter to the City Council advocating for retained funding for the HSP budget. There were also topical discussions on housing affordability, poverty, and a special presentation about issues impacting seniors in our community. The Commission provided recommendations to City Council as to the allocation of the City’s FY2018 CDBG and HOME entitlement grants, CDBG and HOME program income, AHF, HSP and KFCG funds. Funding requests were greater than available dollars so not all proposals submitted were funded. Funding Source Funding Totals CDBG $ 2,170,510 HOME $ 1,752,030 AHF $ 525,047 HSP $ 758,406 TOTAL $5,205,993 2 The projects and programs funded during 2018 were: HOUSING • DMA Plaza: Rehabilitation • Habitat for Humanity: Poudre Build • CARE Housing: UFAS • Housing Catalyst: Mason Place PUBLIC SERVICE • Alliance for Suicide Prevention: Suicide Prevention & Mental Health Education • B.A.S.E. Camp: Childcare Scholarships • Boys & Girls Clubs: Great Futures Start Here • CASA Program: Court Appointed Special Advocates • CASA Program: Harmony House Supervised Visitation Center • Catholic Charities: Senior Services • Catholic Charities: The Mission Shelter • (The) Center for Family Outreach: Scholarship Program • ChildSafe Colorado: Sexual Abuse Treatment Program • CO Health Network d/b/a Northern Colorado AIDS Project: Client Services • Crossroads Safehouse: Advocacy Program • Disabled Resource Services: Access to Independence • Elderhaus: Community Based Therapeutic Care • Faith Family Hospitality: Family Programs • Food Bank for Larimer County: Kids Café • Homeward Alliance: Murphy Center Programs • Homeward Alliance: Program Support • Larimer County Partners: One to One Mentoring • (The) Matthews House: Empowering Youth Program • (The) Matthews House: Building Employment Skills • Neighbor to Neighbor: Housing Counseling • Neighbor to Neighbor: Rent Assistance • Partnership for Age Friendly Communities: A Little Help Program • Project Self-Sufficiency: Healthy Families Program • Respite Care: Childcare Scholarships • SAVA Center: Sexual Assault Victim Services • SummitStone Health Partners: Community Behavioral Health Treatment Program • SummitStone Health Partners: Mental Health Services at the Murphy Center • Teaching Tree Early Childhood Learning Center: Childcare Scholarships • The Family Center/La Familia: Scholarship Program & Family Services • The Growing Project: Youth Gardening Education • Turning Point: Crisis Intervention Services • Voices Carry Child Advocacy Center: Family Advocacy • Volunteers of America: Home Delivered Meal Service BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Human Relations Commission (HRC) DATE PREPARED: 1/3/2020 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Julia Mackewich Chair 6. Wendy True 2. Beth Jaeger 7. Victor Smith 3. Eva Amason 8. Phil Walker 4. Cynthia Davis 5. Jean Runyon 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: ___1 Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___ Culture and Recreation Economic Health Environmental Health 2 Safe Community Transportation ___3___High Performing Government 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? Our goal is to ensure Fort Collins is a welcoming, equitable and inclusive town. As well as to ensure healthy communication and understanding of Human Relations throughout the community. The Human Relations Commission keeps a close eye on city initiatives and local or international Human Rights matters. The Government Relations Chair’s responsibilities include reviewing and staying up to date on government happenings as highlighted in Sec. 2-263 Functions section D in City Code. The HRC also works to educate community members on diversity and inclusion as outlined in Functions Section C. The Educational Outreach Chair spearheads this effort. In section E, it is stated that HRC members are to recommend actions to City Council in the areas of equal employment, equal housing, equal public accommodation and positive community relations in all fields of government. In Functions B, it is stated that HRC members are to “Cooperate with and provide leadership and support for other groups interested in promoting value and respect for diversity and positive intergroup relations”. We were under the impression this verbiage would allow us to collaborate with other boards and commissions, community groups or organizations (including schools) with likeminded interest or purpose. Upon meeting with City Counsel, Jenny Lopez Filkins told us for the City that this verbiage does not allow collaboration across groups. We would like to edit the code to allow for stated purpose. HRC members feel it is integral that we are permitted and encouraged to collaborate and include community members outside the commission in order to most effectively serve our City. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? The work plan outlines long range goals such as cultivating relationships with the community, providing educational outreach and advocating for an inclusive environment within city government and community. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? The Strategic Plan outlines a number of Neighborhood Livability and Social Health objectives that align with our mission and work plan. Some examples that are paraphrased in our work plan include: 1) Co- create a more inclusive and equitable community that promotes unity and honors diversity, 2) foster positive and respectful neighborhood relationships, and 3) collaborate with other agencies to address high- priority human service C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)? We would like to be involved with the April 14th, 2020 work session item that will include an annual update regarding homelessness in Fort Collins. This is not currently in our work plan but will be on our agenda for our January 2020 meeting. The HRC monitors the City Council’s 6-Month Planning Calendar for upcoming issues that may impact marginalized community members. D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? Our work plan has historically been a two-year work plan. This longer planning range, as opposed to a one- year cycle, provides more continuity between years and the ability to plan into the next calendar year. We have discussed changing this process so we can make our work plan more specific. Due to the fact that our work plan is a broad two-year vision, we are consistently aligning with the outlined vision of the plan. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? Meetings begin on time and are conducted in an effective manner. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? The current size of the board is appropriate. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? The HRC has been pleased with our experience with Emily Gorgol as our new Council Liaison. We would like our liaison to keep our commission in mind and actively involve us when there are human relations related matters that arise. We do try to keep up with current happenings but can miss City initiatives or are not always informed. HRC serves in an advisory capacity to City Council and would welcome an opportunity to be involved with and/or consulted on issues within the HRC’s scope of responsibilities. There is often a lack of consistent communication on a particular issue. For example, part of our 2019 work plan was to develop Principles of Community. We found out that Social Sustainability was working on this; then there was discussion about perhaps passing it to a different City department. We have requested multiple times to be involved in this project but have not heard an update on this matter. 7. Other comments: The Human Relations Commission serves an important role in creating and sustaining a community that values diversity and inclusiveness with a focus on equity-mindedness. The HRC was established by City Council to “enhance the acceptance and respect for diversity through educational programs and activities, and to embrace inclusion of individuals reflective of characteristics such as race, ethnicity, gender identity and expression, physical abilities/qualities, sex, sexual /affectional orientation, age, culture, different ideas and perspectives, familial status, immigration status, geographic background, marital status, national origin, religious and spiritual beliefs, socioeconomic status, and veteran status.” The members of this commission look forward to opportunities to lead and support the efforts. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws City Manager’s Office City Hall 300 LaPorte Ave. PO Box 580 Fort Collins, CO 80522 970.221.6505 970.224.6107 - fax fcgov.com MEMORANDUM DATE: February 19, 2020 TO: Delynn Coldiron, City Clerk FROM: Carol Thomas, City Staff Liaison to the Human Relations Commission CC: Kelly DiMartino, Deputy City Manager RE: 2019 Periodic Review of the Human Relations Commission This memo provides a brief summary of the Human Relations Commission’s (HRC) 2019 Periodic Review conducted by Councilmember Emily Gorgol. Bottom Line: The discussion primarily focused on HRC duties and creating alignment between the HRC’s bylaws and City Code. The HRC’s Key Outcome Areas are Neighborhood Livability and Social Health, Safe Community and High Performing Government. Background: Councilmember Emily Gorgol conducted a Periodic Review for the HRC on January 9, 2020 during the HRC’s regular meeting. The HRC submitted their completed Periodic Review Questionnaire on 1/06/20. Summary: A variety of topics were discussed with Councilmember Gorgol, including: • HRC Duties: The HRC keeps a close eye on City initiatives and local, national and international Human Rights matters; provides educational outreach about diversity and inclusion awareness; and, recommends actions to City Council in the areas of equal employment, housing, public accommodations, and positive community relations in all fields of government. There were no requests for assistance with filing a complaint about police officers or through Chapter 13 of the Code. • Alignment of Code and HRC Bylaws: The HRC would like to create a “student liaison” role to help them understand concerns within that demographic and dedicate a space for that perspective. This type of role is referenced in the HRC’s current bylaws but not in the Code, so they would like to explore changes to the Code that will include these types of relationships. Councilmember Gorgol advised them to wait until the Reimagining Boards and Commission initiative is completed. • Currently: The HRC would welcome any opportunity to work directly with City staff on Council initiatives pertaining to equity and inclusion. ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 17 - Human Relations Commission Sec. 2-263. - Functions. The Commission shall have the following functions: (1) To promote positive interaction among all City residents and to discourage all forms of discrimination based upon the diversified values and individual differences of such residents by: a. Developing and promoting educational programs and activities that advocate awareness and respect for diversity; b. Cooperating with and providing leadership and support for other groups interested in promoting value and respect for diversity and positive intergroup relations; c. Educating City residents about existing local, state and federal laws dealing with discrimination and diversity; d. Reviewing proposed legislation, policy changes or other governmental action at the federal, state or local level which may affect human rights in the City and making recommendations to the City Council regarding the same; and e. Recommending to the City Council such actions as may be necessary or advisable to achieve: 1. Equal employment opportunities for all persons; 2. Equal housing opportunities for all persons; 3. Equal public accommodation opportunities for all persons; and 4. Positive community relations in all fields of governmental endeavor. (2) To assist residents of the City in utilizing the complaint procedure under Chapter 13, Article II of the Code and to hear appeals from decisions of the City Manager as provided in Subsection13-23(b) of the Code; provided, however, that any members of the Commission who have rendered assistance to particular complainants shall refrain from participating in the Commission's review of any decisions of the City Manager related to such complainants. (3) To facilitate the review of citizen complaints concerning the actions of City police officers or community service officers by: a. Designating volunteers from the public or from the Commission's own membership to assist individual citizens who wish to file such complaints; b. Assisting citizens who have language barriers in the completion of complaint forms; c. Soliciting assistance from other social agencies in notifying the public about the complaint process; and d. Communicating with other similar Commissions in order to share experiences and become more sensitive to potential problems. (4) To make periodic reports to the City Council concerning the activities and recommendations of the Commission; and (5) To perform such functions as are committed to it by other ordinances or resolutions of the City. (Ord. No. 158, 1986, § 11, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 83, 1992, § 3, 7-21-92; Ord. No. 103, 1993, 9-21-93; Ord. No. 76, 1998, § 3, 8-4-98; Ord. No. 151, 2001, 10-16-01) 1 FORT COLLINS HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION BYLAWS (Revised 4/11/2013) Section I - Purpose of the Commission The Commission is assigned the following functions by City Ordinance: A. To develop and promulgate an educational program to acquaint Fort Collins residents with all local, state and federal civil rights ordinances, statutes and laws. B. To recommend to the City Council such actions as may be necessary or advisable to achieve the following: 1. Equal employment opportunity for all persons. 2. Equal housing opportunities for all persons. 3. Equal public accommodation opportunities for all persons. 4. Best possible Fort Collins government-community relations in all fields of governmental endeavor. C. To supplement the foregoing purposes by the following means: 1. Formation of special subcommittees, including non Human Relations Commission member specialists; 2. To make a continuing study of ways to support the laws concerned; 3. To solicit aid from other social agencies in educating the public; 4. To communicate with other similar commissions in order to share experiences and become more sensitive to potential problems. D. To perform such functions as are committed to it by other ordinances or resolutions. Section II – Membership and Attendance Upon application for acceptance of appointment, HRC members have demonstrated their intention and ability to attend meetings. HRC’s regularly scheduled meetings include: monthly HRC meetings; periodic meetings of the Standing Committee on which the HRC member has volunteered to serve; attendance at City Council on designated previously agreed upon dates; recommended special event meetings for attendance by all HRC members including but not limited to the annual HR Awards Breakfast, Educational Outreach public events, other occasional public meetings and HRC training and development. 2 Consistent with the Attendance Policy in the Boards and Commissions Manual Revised January 2013: either of the following shall automatically cause a member’s appointment to be terminated: Three consecutive absences from regularly scheduled HRC meetings, if prior to the meeting where the absences occurred, no written notification of any such absence has been submitted to the staff liaison, or the chair, or if the chair is the person experiencing attendance problems, then to the vice chair. Four absences from regularly scheduled HRC meetings in any calendar year, without written notification to the staff liaison or the chair or, if the chair is the person experiencing the attendance problems, then to the vice chair. In the event that a vacancy occurs by reason of this policy, the chair and/or vice chair shall work with the staff liaison consistent with current Boards and Commissions Manual policy so that the vacancy can be filled in a timely manner by Council. Section III - Offices. Tenure and Duties The commission shall elect from its membership a Chair and Vice Chair, each for a one- year term and they will be eligible for re-election. Their duties shall be those generally assigned by the nature of their offices. Interim elections may be held if any such office is vacated. Section IV - Committees Standing Committees of the Commission shall be appointed by vote of the Commission after discussion by the Commission. Each Committee shall annually elect appropriate officers from among its membership. Interim elections may be held if any such office is vacated. The following shall constitute the Standing Committees with responsibilities as described under each: Standing Committees: 1. Executive Committee: - To provide problem resolution of urgent issues brought to HRC. - To delegate issues for resolution to standing or to special committees. - To become informed about possible human relation issues within Fort Collins in order to take appropriate preventative action. - To draw up monthly meeting agenda. 3 2. Educational Outreach Committee: - To promote the commission’s vision and mission to the local community and to heighten awareness to create a better understanding of issues regarding specific cultural , ethnic, racial, gender, age, disability or diversity specific issues through the use of forums, talk shows, articles, speaker bureau or other communication venues. - To collaborate and continue to develop liaisons with other organizations to present cultural, educational activities to the Fort Collins community. 3. Media and Community Recognition Committee: - To present annual HRC awards which recognize and commend deserving individuals groups, companies or organizations for inspiring contributions and leadership on behalf of minority or disadvantaged citizens and betterment of the community. - To foster cooperative relations with local media regarding HRC's vision, mission and consequent events and activities. - To draft necessary articles or communication pieces to support the work of the HRC 4. Government Relations Committee: - To manage the Citizen Liaison Program. - To foster cooperative relations with the Citizen Review Board. - To monitor City Council agendas and attend meetings as appropriate. - To review proposed legislation , policy changes or other governmental action at the federal , state or local level which may affect human rights in the city and make recommendations regarding the same. - To research and recommend actions necessary to achieve 1) equal employment opportunity; 2) equal housing opportunities; 3) equal public accommodations opportunities and 4) the best possible Fort Collins government/community relations in all fields of governmental endeavor. 5. Other Committees as formed by the Commission: The Chair of the Commission shall establish any other committees prior to the next Commission meeting for the length of time needed to accomplish stated purposes as need shall arise in order to carry out Commission functions. Section V – Conduct of Business A. Quorum - A quorum for the official conduct of business shall consist of a majority of Commission members. B. Business shall be conducted in accordance with Robert's Rules of Order. C. Meeting Time 1. The Commission shall hold regular monthly meetings which shall be conducted on the second Thursday of each month at 5:30 p. m. in the CIC Room , 300 W. LaPorte Avenue. 4 2. Meeting times or location can be changed by a majority vote, or in case of emergency by the Chair. 3. Additional meetings as needed shall be called by the Chair. D. Time Commitment - members have agreed to a minimum time commitment of 6 hours per month (2 hours for the regular meeting and 2 hours for committees). Section VI Changes and Amendments The Bylaws may be changed and amended by motion passed by a majority of the entire Commission. Section VII- Continuing Relation of the Commission to the City Council Reports - The Commission shall provide an annual report to the City Council in January, and an annual work plan in November. It shall also provide other reports at such time as requested by the Council when deemed advisable by the Commission. Adopted by the Human Relations Commission this 11th day of April, 2013. Myles W. Crane, Chair April 11, 2013 FORT COLLINS HUMAN RELATIONS COMMISSION 2019/2020 WORK PLAN MISSION As community leaders and advisors, the Human Relations Commission collaborates, educates, and advocates for equity and inclusion in the City of Fort Collins. VISION Embracing differences and giving value to every human being. PURPOSE The Fort Collins City Council established the Human Relations Commission (HRC) in 1964 to promote acceptance, equity, inclusion and respect for diversity through educational programs and to act in an advisory capacity to the City Council. LONG RANGE GOALS Cultivate relationships with the community and media that support the mission and vision Provide educational outreach that promotes equity and inclusion Advocate for an equitable and inclusive environment in city government and community The Fort Collins Human Relations Commission will continue a broad plan for enhancing productive human relations and supporting social sustainability issues that are pertinent to the City of Fort Collins and are consistent with the City Charter. The Commission will strive to be informed about diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice issues within Fort Collins and will recommend appropriate action to City Council. HRC goals and responsibilities are divided among four standing committees for procedural reasons but are not exclusive to any one committee. THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE SHALL: • Determine meeting agendas for monthly and special HRC meetings • Maintain regular communication with the HRC’s City Council Liaison and City Council • Delegate issues for resolution to standing or special committees • Provide support to HRC standing committees as needed • Call special meetings as needed THE MEDIA/COMMUNITY RECOGNITION COMMITTEE SHALL: • Plan, coordinate and execute an annual HRC Awards event • Update and refine the HRC website content so that its message and branding are clear • Build HRC’s community and media relations by maintaining an updated contact list and building a far-reaching communications platform. • Act as a liaison to the HRC Community Advisors • Report monthly to the HRC THE EDUCATION OUTREACH COMMITTEE SHALL: • Create a better understanding of equity and inclusion through educational programs and events • Collaborate with new/existing community organizations, boards or commissions • Propose outreach collaboration opportunities as response to new or long standing community issues or topics • Recruit speakers and facilitators • Plan and deliver interactive public forums or discussion sessions • Report monthly to the HRC THE GOVERNMENT AND COMMUNITY RELATIONS COMMITTEE SHALL: • Monitor City Council activity and attend meetings as needed • Work with the HRC, City Council and all citizens to develop Principles of Community that will serve as a guide for our community • Educate citizens and recommend actions that promote positive relationships within our City • Review proposed legislation, policy changes or other governmental actions at the Federal, State or Local level which may affect human rights in Fort Collins and recommend actions as appropriate • Research and recommend actions necessary to achieve equity and inclusion • Advocate for Persons of Color to join City Boards, Commissions and Government • Align HRC’s priority objectives with local and state priorities as appropriate • Report monthly to HRC BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Landmark Preservation Commission DATE PREPARED: October 9, 2019 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Meg Dunn Chair 6. Kevin Murray 2. Kristin Gensmer Vice Chair 7. Anne Nelson 3. Alexandra Wallace Vice Chair 8. Anna Simpkins 4. Michael Bello 9. Mollie Bredehoft 5. Katie Dorn 10. 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: ___1 Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___ Culture and Recreation ___2 Economic Health ___3 Environmental Health Safe Community Transportation _______High Performing Government 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? The duties in the City Code align well with and directly support the Key Outcome Areas of Neighborhood Livability & Social Health, Economic Health, Environmental Health, and High Performing Government.  The LPC helps to protect and promote the historic resources that enrich our community. These resources are essential to creating a sense of place for Fort Collins residents (and visitors) and adding value to their daily lives through tangible and cultural experiences.  By providing professional determinations of a resource’s significance and integrity, the commission helps evaluate properties to identify which resources warrant preservation. These determinations help council to make decisions that will benefit not only individual properties and owners, but will bolster local history, economy, and education.  Economic vitality is promoted through financial incentive programs, ensuring quality, energy‐efficient housing and providing owners with additional disposable income.  Environmental stewardship is enhanced, and greenhouse gases and energy use are reduced by adaptively retaining, retrofitting, and reusing historic buildings.  The LPC further supports the Design Assistance Program and Landmark Rehabilitation Loan program, funding programs for owners of locally designated homes to fix / maintain their homes. It makes it possible for owners to stay in their homes.  And, through Friends of Preservation awards and other outreach efforts, the LPC encourages the community to ‘see’ and appreciate their shared culture. Specifically, the Commission’s duties are:  The Commission is the Final decision‐maker on: o Requests for alterations to properties designated on the National Register, Colorado State Register, and as Fort Collins Landmarks o Determinations of eligibility for Fort Collins Landmark designation o Allocation of Landmark Rehabilitation Loan funds  The Commission makes recommendations to: o Council, on Fort Collins Landmark designations; o The Colorado State Review Board, on nominations to the National and State Register o Decision Makers, on compatibility of developments adjacent to historic properties  The Commission advises Council and staff on: o The identification and significance of historic resources, threats to their preservation, and methods for their protection; o Policies, incentives and regulations for historic preservation. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)? D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? E. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? The Work Plan is developed to directly support the City’s Strategic Plan in the Key Outcome Areas of Neighborhood Livability and Social Health, Economic Health, Environmental Health, and High Performing Government. The LPC’s on‐going duties and goals further align the Commission’s strategic objectives with those of City Council: Supports Neighborhood Livability and Social Health by:  Enhancing the community’s sense of place by protecting historic character through landmark designation; and through design review and development review, helping to ensure compatible alterations and new development;  Celebrating historic resources through a wide variety of community recognition and appreciation opportunities, such as the Friends of Preservation Awards; tours, signage and brochures; and partnerships with community history organizations;  Supporting Housing Affordability goals by retaining and rehabilitating historic building stock, promoting more affordable options in housing;  Developing a community‐wide survey plan and identifying priorities for historic survey. Supports Economic Health by:  Allocating Landmark Rehabilitation Loans and promoting Design Assistance Program, State Tax Credits, State Historic Fund grants, and other financial incentives to eligible properties;  Supporting Housing Attainability and Affordability through revisions to the Rehabilitation Loan Program and the Design Assistance Program to address financial equity issues, and better assist low and moderate‐income citizens with cost‐effective repairs and improvements to their homes.  Ensuring a smooth, integrated Development Review process by providing early comments to developers and staff on Land Use Code projects; and by providing decision makers with recommendations on development near historic properties  Promoting and subsidizing the use of Fort Collins’ specialized skills and tradespeople to keep more financial resources in the community.  Assist staff in the performance of two State Historic Fund grant‐funded projects: the survey of 50 properties in Old Town Fort Collins between Mulberry Street and Laporte Avenue; and the comprehensive Historic Structure Assessment of Fort Collins Water Treatment Plant No. 1 at Gateway Park. Supports Environmental Health by:  Incentivizing sustainable building practices and energy conservation measures in older homes through historic preservation review processes;  Promote sustainability, retention of embodied energy, and waste‐steam reduction by encouraging the reuse of existing buildings and materials  Facilitating safe, cost‐effective building rehabilitation and energy retrofitting and resource sustainability through 0%‐interest loans, free professional advice, and the City’s Design Assistance Program;  Promoting the Historic Preservation Division’s Costs Calculator, an on‐line tool that enables area contractors and residents to understand the cost, longevity and energy trade‐offs in material choices. Supports High Performing Government by:  Overseeing the implementation of the new historic preservation codes and processes and continuing to identify improvements, recommending appropriate code revisions as needed;  Providing the best service to Council and the residents of Fort Collins by identifying and implementing innovative solutions and best practices through partnerships, continuing education, and professional trainings;  Building capacity, increasing productivity, and facilitating the career training and growth of young professionals by working with CSU students in Historic Preservation, Archeology, Construction Management, Heritage Tourism and other related fields of study; Furthering Council’s and the City’s goals and objectives through the performance of the Commission’s duties. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? Board meetings are conducted in an effective manner. Discussions may outwardly appear lengthy at times, but the complex topics discussed warrant a thorough, methodical, and code‐driven approach. It was noted that discussions could be more organized and stay on topic, rather than bounce back and forth as they sometimes do. City staff and board members work together to ensure that time management is respected. Meetings consistently begin on time, which is appreciated by applicants and residents. The consistent structure of requesting questions / info at the work session, and the actual discussion in the meeting is effective and consistent. This has resulted in meetings are far more productive, and the decisions far more supported and defensible. One item of improvement identified by Commission members is motions. While staff provides sample language both for and against in the packet (which was noted as extremely beneficial), members are hesitant to make motions, and bog down when required to craft motions that deviate from the language provided by staff. At the upcoming retreat Commission members will spend time with the Attorney’s Office talking about how to structure motions, when to disagree or have discussions / friendly amendments etc. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? The LPC has nine members. Commission members agree that the current size is of the board is appropriate. Having a board of this size allows members to recuse themselves without negatively effecting the quorum. Fewer members would make it more difficult to ensure a quorum and increases the potential for project delays. Another strength of having a larger board is the increased diversity of members backgrounds and experience. One Commission member recommended that a set number of board positions be reserved for historic architects. Commission members comments on recent suggestions by some to reduce terms for board members. While the quick turn‐over could increase community involvement, board members noted the lengthy and steep learning curve for quasi‐judicial boards. Members expressed concern that reducing terms would lead to a loss of understanding of the code and good decision‐making through turnover. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? Commission members acknowledged the tremendous workload and amount of information that Council must deal with in an average packet and appreciated Council’s desire to do more. The Commission first identified ways that it could promote communication with Council, including adding a summary section to each meeting minutes; and providing an onboarding packet to new Council members on historic preservation in Fort Collins. Members noted that they feel like the City Council doesn’t really have a clear sense of what the LPC does. One member commented that, in sitting in on work sessions and regular meetings of Council, they can tell from some of the comments that are made that Council doesn’t fully understand the LPC’s role or grasp the entire reason why the LPC exists. The LPC’s council liaison typically attends the Commission’s annual retreat. Having time for discussion and to get to know the council liaison better is greatly appreciated. Attendance at the retreat was viewed as making the council member seem more approachable and more interested in better understanding the commission’s work. The Commission would appreciate opportunities for additional communication with Council. It would be helpful to receive direct feedback regarding recommendations (whether positive or negative). Council members are also encouraged to attend the LPC work sessions or regular meetings. 7. Other comments:  Every year our city council liaison has joined us for at least a short time at our annual retreat. This has always been a great time of talking and is probably the most positive, successful example of communication between city council and the LPC that I can think of.  How can we help council more? What do you need from us? What’s the best way to deliver this?  Thank you for funding the City‐wide survey person. Please continue this funding in the upcoming budgets. There has been a noticeable reduction in controversy since the city hired this position.  Professional survey is the foundation of everything we do as a commission.  Our services and regulatory responsibilities in the twenty‐first century are increasingly dependent on technology and effective data and records management. Capturing historic property data, analyzing it, and sharing it with the public are CLG priorities, but require adequate staff resources. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 19 - Landmark Preservation Commission Sec. 2-278. - Functions. (a) The Commission shall perform all duties relating to preservation of historic landmarks as set out in Chapter 14 of this Code, including the designation of sites, structures, objects or districts as landmarks and the review and approval or rejection of plans for the construction, alteration, demolition or relocation of any such site, structure, object or district. Decisions of the Commission are final unless appealed to the City Council. (b) The Commission shall also perform the following additional functions: (1) To promote awareness and understanding of, and appreciation for, the value of historic resource preservation in contributing to the quality of life in the City and actively encourage property owners to voluntarily designate their properties as historic landmarks; (2) To advise the City Council and City staff with regard to the identification and evaluation of historic resources within the Growth Management Area and provide information regarding the significance of the resources, the nature and degree of threat to their preservation and methods for their protection; (3) To advise the City Council and City staff with regard to appropriate policies, incentives and regulations for encouraging and/or requiring preservation and rehabilitation of historic resources; (4) To coordinate with the various other City boards, commissions and City staff members whose actions may affect the preservation of historic resources in the community; (5) To establish a committee of its members to provide advice and, if required under § 2.10.2(H) of the Land Use Code, written recommendations to the owners of eligible historic properties, and of properties located near eligible historic properties, regarding historically appropriate design and site planning for additions, alterations and new construction in the City; provided, however, that any members of such committee who provide such advice or recommendations to property owners under this provision shall refrain from participating in any subsequent decisions of the Commission related to such properties; (6) To provide advice and written recommendations to the appropriate decision maker and/or administrative body regarding plans for properties containing or adjacent to sites, structures, objects or districts that: (a) have been determined to be individually eligible for local landmark designation or for individual listing in the State or National Registers of Historic Places; (b) are officially designated as a local or state landmark or are listed on the National Register of Historic Places; or (c) are located within an officially designated historic district or area; and (7) To perform such other duties and functions as may be provided by the City Council by ordinance or resolution. (c) In order to better perform the foregoing functions and to coordinate the activities of the Poudre Landmark Foundation or such other privately funded nonprofit corporations as the Commission may approve that are organized for the primary purpose of furthering the preservation of the community's historic resources. (Ord. No. 158, 1986, § 12, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 78, 1988, § 3, 6-7-88; Ord. No. 66, 1995, 6-20-95; Ord. No. 24, 2005, § 3, 3-1-05; Ord. No. 002, 2011 § 2, 2-1-11; Ord. No. 058, 2014 , 4-15-14) BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS IN PROCESS preliminary RESPONSE PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Senior Advisory Board DATE PREPARED: October 9, 2019 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Myles Crane Chair 6. Janet Sanders 2. Jason Brabson 7. Sarah Schilz Vice Chair 3. Suzanne King 8. Gregory Wells 4. David Kovach 9. Vacant 5. Nancy Luttropp 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: ___XX Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___ Culture and Recreation ___ Economic Health Environmental Health Safe Community Transportation 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? The current duties of SAB are fully aligned with City Code and all eight functions specified Under Section 3. We recommend no duties be added or deleted. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? The SAB Work Plan is fully aligned with the City’s Key Outcome areas for Neighborhood Livability and Social Health, Transportation and Housing. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? The SAB Work Plan is prepared after comprehensive review of the City’s Strategic Plan and it is fully aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan in each of the three Key Outcome areas specified in 3 A above. C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)? Prior to preparing the SAB Work Plan, Board members review the latest APC for relevant Issues in the three specific outcome areas as well as any other relevant topics pertaining to the Senior population as identified in the Six Month Calendar. We ensure that these matters are appropriately addressed in the SAB Work Plan. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? Yes, the Senor Advisory Board effectively accomplishes its annual work plan. Please refer to the 2018 Annual Report. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? Board meetings are consistently conducted in an effective manner, Discussions are focused around A published agenda and an SAB Activities Calendar updated for the current month. We have no recommendations at this time to improve Board meetings. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? The current size of 9 seems to be appropriate, with a current actual membership of 8. As with all boards, recruiting and keeping engaged members is at times challenging. Our current 8 members are all in good standing and quite engaged. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? Communications are balanced effectively in those instances when the board presents information to Council or when Council requests feedback from the board. The board would value more interaction with its Council Liaison and Council. B&C’s in general are interested in building the best possible relationship with Council and would welcome clearer expectations about what Council wants from each B&C – including the format and basis on which B&C’s can maintain accountability with Council. At its meetings, this board gathers information about the senior community. The board invites Council’s input on any specific matters that Council would like the board to address or track with appropriate creation of timelines, ownership and closure on the issues. 7. Other comments: As Fort Collins continues its vibrant growth demonstrating why it was the recipient of the Malcolm Baldridge national quality award in 2017, it is a key consideration for Council to acknowledge its expanding older adult population and their economic and other important contributions to our city’s current well‐being and future success. it is critical for Council that the voices of older adults are heard, respected and considered especially in areas of Neighborhood Livability and Social Health, Transportation, and Safe Community including affordable housing and overall community health all of which are key issues for Council’s focus. The board has and plans to continue representing the interests of older adults in Fort Collins through its monthly meetings, conversations, alignment and support of other service agencies and organizations in Larimer County. The board is comprised of a dynamic group of men and women with diverse backgrounds who dedicate their time and energy to learn about and place senior issues on the table for City Council’s consideration. The board is committed to continue serving Council in this manner. As Council is in process of reimagining the organization of B&C’s, if such restructure were to involve more periodic meetings with Council such as at joint evening sessions with other B&C’s convened to discuss Super Board issues, it is this board’s opinion that such a restructure would likely result in reduced time and attention regularly focusing on the specific needs, challenges and concerns of our growing senior demographic. We request Council to be cognizant of this concern. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws City of Fort Collins Senior Advisory Board Minutes Wednesday November 13, 2019 11:30 a.m. Fort Collins Senior Center 1200 Raintree Drive Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Mission: The Senior Advisory Board shall serve in an advisory capacity y to the Fort Collins City Council on programs and policies that help aging citizens live full and interesting lives and continue to contribute, participate, and share in the life of the community. NOTE: light lunch will be served I. Call to Order 11:32am II. Guest introductions: Deanna O’Connell III. Administrative Items a. Attendance: Excused: Jason Brabson, Greg Wells In Attendance: Nancy Luttropp, Jan Rossi, Suzanne King, Sarah Schilz, David Kovach, Myles Crane. Staff Katie Stieber b. Approval of Minutes: David Kovach moved; Sarah Schilz seconded. Approved unanimously c. Correspondence d. SAB September Activities Update: e. SAB 2019 Annual Calendar Update: Speakers rescheduled to later date f. Public Participation: none g. SAB Member Autobiography – David Kovach IV. Today’s Speaker Councilmember Ken Summers: history of his careers and public involvement. Focus on affordable housing and transportation boards. V. Ongoing initiatives a. City Council Periodic Review Discussion with Councilmember Ken Summers Ideas from members: more communication between boards and council, transportation discussion, speak out at public comment portion of Council meetings, Skype comments from public in home to Council live? Discussion by members to continue to fill empty board positions, to continue to have a full board. Agreed by Councilmember Summers. Discussion around the importance of this specific board in representing seniors and their needs. Supported by Councilmember Summers and ideas on reaching out to seniors. b. Intergenerational Conversations Debrief: every other month, Fort Collins and Loveland well attended, learned from each other VI. Updates a. Transportation: City & PAFC - Jason b. Affordable Housing Board & PAFC– Nancy & Sarah c. Other PAFC: H&W & Culture of Aging: Volunteers of America work with United Way looking into grant; mental health self-directed volunteer team d. Larimer County Office on Aging Annual Report VII. New Business a. “Oh Boomer!” - discussion, handout b. 2020 Speakers send ideas to Myles and Sarah for next year; one meeting will be at Loveland Housing Society facility, c. 2019 SAB Annual Report Planning due soon. Myles and Sarah to create draft. d. Officers for 2020 e. December meeting out to lunch, where, FoCo Café provide cater meal, TBD UPCOMING EVENTS and OTHER ANNOUNCEMENTS ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 30 - Senior Advisory Board Sec. 2-398. - Functions. The Board shall have the following functions: (1) To serve as a supporting agency for all senior citizen services and activities in the City; (2) To publicize and support present senior citizen services and activities in the community; (3) To investigate and make recommendations regarding new senior citizen services and activities; (4) To encourage new senior citizen programs as need is indicated and, when appropriate, to participate in the planning and development of such programs if asked to do so; (5) To encourage and support widespread opportunities for more meaningful and useful participation of senior citizens in community activities and programs; (6) To establish and maintain communication with local, state and national groups and government agencies concerning senior citizens; (7) To advocate policies and practices within the community that respect and consider the needs and interests of senior citizens; (8) To work to dispel stereotypes about aging through education and awareness activities. (Ord. No. 158, 1986, § 22, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 104, 1996, 8-20-96; Ord. No. 199, 2004, 1-4-05) Fort Collins Senior Advisory Board 2019 Work Plan Summary Statement: Consistent with our Mission and the City of Fort Collins’ Strategic Budgeting for Outcomes, the Senior Advisory Board will serve in an advisory capacity to the Fort Collins City Council on programs and policies that help older residents live full and interesting lives and continue to contribute, participate, and share in the life of the community. [Suggested changes in orange] Summary Statement: Consistent with our Mission and the City of Fort Collins’ Strategic Budgeting for Outcomes, the Senior Advisory Board serves as advisors to the Fort Collins City Council on programs and policies that help older residents live full and interesting lives continuing to contribute and participate in our vibrant community. Primary Functions of the Senior Advisory Board: Engaging with other organizations and/or relevant organizations pursuing similar goals by attending meetings and keeping the board apprised of their activities. Larimer County Office on Aging Advisory Council (LCOA) Partnership for Age Friendly Communities (PAFC) Transportation and Housing (staff and boards Communicating information describing the Senior population and its value and benefits to the community. Communicating information describing our ever-changing senior population - as different generations re-invent what it’s like to be a senior – and highlighting the value and benefits of our seniors to the community. Keeping current on critical issues so that we can inform council and community members of programs and activities occurring which are of benefit to seniors. [change to put the word ‘informing’ first] Informing city council and community members of programs, activities and issues that involve seniors or benefit our senior population. Participating in events within the community (Senior Law Day, Elder Care Resource Day and Bridging the Gap) Participating in special events important to seniors throughout the year within the community. Senior Law Day Elder Care Resource Day Bridging the Gap Work Areas for 2019 Prioritization 1. Neighborhood Livability and Social Health a. Education: We will learn and engage in discussion to help the council towards solutions for the senior community’s housing needs by attending the Affordable Housing Board’s and the Partnership for Age Friends Community’s Housing Priority Group’s meetings. We will also remain open and receptive to the general voice of seniors in the community and their thoughts and opinions on local housing needs. We will actively seek out speakers from various industries, non- profits, health and lifestyle advocates and others to give us a broad perspective in this and other areas regarding Seniors. b. Advocacy: We will work on ways to educate all members of the housing needs of seniors. We will share with council our consideration regarding improvement to senior housing options on a timely basis. c. Outreach: We will share with other boards what we know and have learned regarding the housing needs of seniors. 2. Transportation a. Education: We will learn and engage in discussion to help the council towards solutions for the senior community’s transportation needs by attending the Transportation Board’s meetings. We will also remain open and receptive to the general voice of seniors in the community and their thoughts and opinions on local transportation needs. b. Advocacy: We will share our concerns and thoughts with the Transportation Board and City Council on ways the city can improve transportation for seniors and ways the city has made great strides in providing seniors with reliable transportation. c. Outreach: We will compile and disseminate what we have learned about the senior community’s transportation needs and we will share that with the Transportation Board and City Council. 3. Safety a. Education: We will learn and engage in discussion to help the council towards solutions for key safety issues Fort Collins seniors encounter. We will remain an open and receptive group where the community can voice their concerns and encourage citizen attendance of our meetings. b. Advocacy: We will voice any safety concerns we have with City Council and we will suggest areas of improvement and the potential pros and cons of our suggestions based on our research and knowledge. c. Outreach: We will share potential safety issues with the community and, when necessary, we will request that the City make major safety issues known to our senior population. [proposed new section below] Timely Information to Assist with Council’s Strategic Budgeting for Outcomes Focus Senior Board Members will provide information more frequently to City Council regarding upcoming agenda items for council meetings as per council request and our observance of important items approaching deliberations that may involve our senior population. For example: any new city broadband changes, decisions on adding new requirements to older dwellings that might affect seniors and more. We have implemented a bi-annual review of our activities for Council due to new changes happening in this area of our population. It’s important that seniors are considered in decisions regarding our community. The ‘norms’ for this older generation are changing (as family dynamics change) and retirement years last longer. We recognize the important elements of our work and will inform the council so that the City of Fort Collins remains a healthy, vibrant community with active members from our entire population. City of Fort Collins Senior Advisory Board 2018 Annual Report January 9, 2019 City of Fort Collins Senior Center 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 1 The Senior Advisory Board assumed responsibility for involvement in a network of senior agencies and organizations to remain aware of issues, needs and occurrences that are relevant to our work for city council. Our primary focus was to educate our community about the aging process, to inform and be informed, to advocate for a good quality of life and to encourage networking among the various groups that deal with senior issues. In 2018 the Senior Advisory Board achieved its goals per our 2018 Work Plan as indicated in the items and bulleted notes below. 1. EDUCATION • 16 leaders from our community informed the Board on the following senior issues: o Housing Considerations o Mental Health o Physical Health o City Utilities and Resources o Social Engagement o Safety Concerns o Mobility Concerns • Also, a former city mayor gave us her views on board effectiveness • Provided continuous learning to raise awareness about senior issues which we shared with the community 2. OUTREACH • Participated in a network of community agencies and organizations including the following: o Larimer County Office on Aging o Partnership for Age-Friendly Communities in Larimer County  Affordable Housing Priority Group  Health and Wellness Group  PAFC Steering Committee o Senior Center Council Meetings o Senior Transportation Coalition o City of Fort Collins Affordable Housing o City of Fort Collins Transportation Board o Transfort, Bustang, RTD Coordinated Transportation Educational Initiative o Senior Day at the Capital o Senior Law Day Senior Advisory Board 2018 Annual Report 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 2 o Elder Care Resource Day o Professionals for Seniors o Elder Care Network o Bridging the Gap o Various City Board and Commission Meetings and Programs 3. ADVOCACY • Provided Council with a semiannual progress report • Emailed various communications to Council throughout the year • Represented the Senior Advisory Board in various city-sponsored activities BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Women’s Commission DATE PREPARED: 10/16/19 LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Hannah Little Chair 6. Alyssa de la Torre 2. Shana Ryken Vice Chair 7. Kori Wilford Secretary 3. Lexie Kuznick 8. Erma Woodfin 4. Nadine Nehme 9. Vacant 5. Melanie Potyondy 10. 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: 1 Neighborhood Livability & Social Health Culture and Recreation 3 Economic Health Environmental Health 2 Safe Community Transportation 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted? Women’s Commission Duties The Commission is created for the purpose of enhancing the status of and opportunities for all women in the City. We have currently identified some key areas to be women’s health, safety, and economic stability. The Commission shall have the ability to: (1) Document issues of importance to the status of women in the City; (2) Conduct educational programs in the Fort Collins community to increase public awareness and sensitivity to the needs and capabilities of all women; (3) Cooperate with other organizations and individuals interested in issues affecting women in the Fort Collins area; (4) Review proposed legislation, policy changes or other governmental action at the federal, state or a. local level that would enhance or otherwise affect the status of women in the City and make b. recommendations to the City Council regarding the same. (5) Recommend to the City Council the adoption of local legislation or policies that would enhance the status of women in the City. We don’t have any duties to add. Neighborhood Livability and Social Health ‐ provide a high quality built environment, support quality, diverse neighborhoods and foster the social health of citizens. Our duties include providing educational programing, collaborating with other agencies, and documenting issues of importance on the status of women as it relates to 1.1 Improve access to quality housing that is affordable to a broad range of income levels 1.2 Collaborate with other agencies to address poverty issues and other identified high‐priority human service needs, and to make homelessness rare, short lived and non‐recurring 1.3 Improve accessibility to City and community programs and services to low‐ and moderate‐income populations 1.4 Co‐create a more inclusive and equitable community that promotes unity and honors diversity 1.5 Foster positive and respectful neighbor relationships and open communication Safe Community ‐ provide a safe place to live, work, learn and play Documents important issues (proclamations) Educational programs Reviewed and weighed in on policy changes 5.1 Improve community involvement, education and regional partnerships to increase the level of public trust and keep the community safe Economic Health ‐ promote a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values 3.2 Maintain and grow diverse employment opportunities Homelessness and Housing Panel, Health, Transportation Safety, Mental Health Proclamations ‐ see the 2019 proclamation schedule Coordinating with other commissions and boards Reviewing council documents: sexual harassment, BFO Cracking the Codes ‐ partnership with HRC, educational program around inclusion WomenGive Luncheon ‐ networking with local philanthropy Women’s Foundation Luncheon Affordability Index ‐ educational program ‐ self‐sufficiency standard Speaking on behalf of Commission Joint Boards and Commissions Breakfast Intergenerational Conversations Marcile N. Wood Award Council Communications Committee and regularly attend CEDAW ‐ promoting equity 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above? a. The women’s commission uses our annual planning meeting in Feb to plan ahead for the year as such, see current work plan. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan? a. The women’s commission uses our annual planning meeting in Feb to plan ahead for the year as such, see current work plan. Specifically we look for the top three places of alignment in both plans. C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)? a. This is something we would like to prioritize more in the future. We have members attend and/or watch each city council meeting so that we have a read on current info and can keep an eye out for best opportunities to inform city council. D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan? a. Yes. We also discuss the previous year’s work plan in our annual retreat so that we can assess goals and success. 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings? Mostly yes. Here are some areas we believe we can improve and grow in: Focus time on advising and recommending policies to City Council. Decline presentations that are not most relevant to our work plan and focus areas. Create a standing agenda item to determine topics to advise City Council on. Develop a “memo” to send updates to City Council that gets sent along . 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make? If all vacancies can be filled, the size is ok. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications? We are ever attempting to facilitate effective communication. We believe a more effective way to enforce this would be to set‐up a monthly correspondence or standing check‐in with council liaison. 7. Other comments: The re‐imagining of boards and commissions was a flop. Positions were offered and then put on hold. There was not good communication. Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 35 - Women's Commission Sec. 2-443. - Functions. The Commission is created for the purpose of enhancing the status of and opportunities for all women in the City. The Commission shall have the ability to: (1) Document issues of importance to the status of women in the City; (2) Conduct educational programs in the Fort Collins community to increase public awareness and sensitivity to the needs and capabilities of all women; (3) Cooperate with other organizations and individuals interested in issues affecting women in the Fort Collins area; (4) Review proposed legislation, policy changes or other governmental action at the federal, state or local level that would enhance or otherwise affect the status of women in the City and make recommendations to the City Council regarding the same. (5) Recommend to the City Council the adoption of local legislation or policies that would enhance the status of women in the City. (6) (Ord. No 158, 1986, § 7, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 001, 2011, 1-18-11) Fort Collins Women's Commission Bylaws Revised March 2017 Article I - Commission Title The name of this Commission shall be the Fort Collins Women's Commission. The Commission shall seek: Article II - Purpose • To develop and foster relationships with members of the Fort Collins Community which results in the exchange of ideas. • To further the legal, social, political, economic and educational opportunity and advancement of all women. • To identify and promote the elimination of discrimination against women on the basis of sex, race, age, religion, sexual orientation, disability, national origin or marital status. • To encourage the promotion of equal participation of all women in the community regarding decisions which affect their well-being. Article III - Objectives The objectives of the Commission shall be generally as outlined herein: • To identify and document issues of importance to the well-being of women in Fort Collins. • To review legislation policy changes and other actions that may affect women in the community. • To promote or conduct educational programs in the Fort Collins community to increase public awareness and sensitivity to the needs and capabilities of all women. • To partner with other organizations and individuals interested in issues affecting women in the Fort Collins area. Article IV - Board Composition The Board shall consist of nine (9) members appointed by the Fort Collins City Council. The Larimer County Commissioners and Colorado State University officials may each appoint one non-voting ex-officio liaison who shall function as a resource person for the Committee. Permanent members shall serve for four (4) years or until their successors are appointed. The initial appointments shall be staggered so that members have overlapping tenure. Article V - Attendance Commission member’s appointments will automatically be terminated if either of the following Sections apply: Section 1: Two (2) unexcused absences from regularly scheduled meetings of the Commission in any calendar year not approved by the Commission. (note: The first absence is considered a warning.) Section 2: Four (4) excused and/or unexcused absences from regularly scheduled meetings of the Commission in a calendar year. Note: An excused absence is a call/contact to the Chairperson before the meeting in which the member will be absent. Article VI - Officers The Commission shall elect from its membership a chairperson, a vice chairperson and a secretary, each for a one (1) year term and eligible for re-election. See Article VI. Article VII - Nominating Committee Article VIII - Election of Officers Elections of Officers shall take place at the February meeting. Article IX - Duties of Officers Section 1: The chair shall be responsible for: being the spokesperson to the City Council and to the community at large; agenda development; chairing regular official meetings; appointing task force members as needed; reviewing minutes on a quarterly basis for attention to timelines and task accomplishments; and along with the staff liaison, monitoring the commission's budget. The chair shall also sign all official commission communications except wherein individual members' signatures are deemed appropriate by the Commission. The chair can delegate any responsibility to other officers or members. Section 2: The vice chair shall be responsible for: assisting the chair in agenda development as necessary; acting as liaison to City Council; developing and providing reports to the Commission on Council activities; acting in the role of chair in the chair's absence; providing orientation to newly appointed members; monitoring committees and task forces; handling all incoming and outgoing official correspondence ( ); and assisting the chair in the quarterly review of minutes. Section 3: The corresponding secretary will be responsible for: recording and working with the staff liaison to distribute meeting minutes (in case of absence the vice chair will take minutes); preparing resolutions for commission consideration monitoring Council’s 6 month planning calendar; and tracking Commission’s Action Items as part of the minutes document. ) Article X - Committees / Task Forces Committees / Task Forces shall be established as needed for specific tasks. Committees / Task Forces shall be dissolved upon completion of the assigned tasks. Task Forces shall be responsible for: reporting to the Commission anddeveloping reports and recommendations for the Commission that reflect consensus and minority positions of task force members. The Commission shall support or deny support for recommended actions of the task force. (Refer to procedural guide on functioning of Task Forces.) In the absence of designated officers of the Commission and in the existence of a quorum, the Commission has the right and privilege of delegating responsibility for action in dealing with discrete specific tasks. Article XI - Meetings Section 1: Meetings shall be held on the third Wednesday of each month or as established by the Commission. Committees shall meet once a month prior to the regularly scheduled Commission meetings. Section 2: Special meetings may be called by the chairperson, provided notice is given to all members at least 24 hours in advance. Section 3: All meetings of the Commission at which formal action is taking place shall be open to the public. Article XII - Conduct of Business Section 1: A quorum shall consist of a majority of seated Commission members. No official action may be taken unless a quorum is present. Section 2: Decision making shall be by consensus whenever possible. If 2/3 of the voting members present agree to suspend consensus, decision making shall be by majority of the vote. Article XIII - Amendments to the Bylaws Amendments to these bylaws may be proposed by any member at any regularly scheduled Commission meeting. Proposed amendments shall be voted upon at the next regularly scheduled Commission meeting. Amendments must be approved by a majority of the voting members of the Board. J -) /) Women’s Commission 2019 Work Plan and Meeting Schedule 2019 WORK PLAN Page 1 For the year 2019, the Fort Collins Women’s Commission will continue to focus its efforts on three key areas affecting women in Fort Collins: Safety, Health, and Poverty. The Commission is focused on becoming a stronger voice to the City Council and the community on behalf of the women of Fort Collins. 1. MEETING SCHEDULE 2. GOALS • Continue to align the work plan and monthly agendas with the city of Fort Collins’ seven key strategic outcomes. • Review and capitalize on the research available from existing sources to provide a picture of the status of women in the community, foster dialogue and create the forums and synergies necessary for problem solving. • Collaborate and network with local organizations and law enforcement to highlight issues such as domestic violence, sexual assault, homelessness, gender discrimination and poverty. • Bring to the attention of city council and identify and utilize key events/media outlets in the community where the materials and messages of the women’s commission can be effectively communicated and leveraged. • Continue to develop and leverage relationships with other city of Fort Collins’ boards and commissions around issues that impact the key focus areas of the women’s commission, i.e. attend super meetings and collaboration meetings. • Continue to develop and leverage relationships in the community, i.e. presentation of the Marcile N. Wood Award in conjunction with other community recognition events. • Focus and align women’s commission activities and work with the key outcome of community & neighborhood livability, especially as related to the women’s commission periodic review in 2019. Jan 16 Apr 17 Jul 17 Oct 23 Feb 20 May 15 Aug 21 Nov 20 Mar 20 Jun 19 Sep 18 Dec 18 Women’s Commission 2019 Work Plan and Meeting Schedule 2019 WORK PLAN Page 2 • Spearhead and collaborate with other community and organizational entities to craft a recommendation to city council for the adoption of a CEDAW resolution. • Continue to vet the names of Fort Collins women for the city street naming project. 3. WORK PLAN GOAL 1: Continue to align the work plan and monthly agendas with the city of Fort Collins’ seven key strategic outcomes, with the key outcome of community & neighborhood livability, especially as related to the women’s commission periodic review in 2019. o Track the Council’s policy agenda and, in the Commission’s advisory role, provide information and appropriate comments to the City Council on issues of information gathered by the commission. o Monitor City Council 6-month planning calendar GOAL 2: Review and capitalize on the research available from existing sources to provide a picture of the status of women in the community, foster dialogue and create the forums and synergies necessary for problem solving. o Identify and reach out to community experts and resources to inform the work of the Women’s Commission GOAL 3: Bring to the attention of city council and identify and utilize key events/media outlets in the community where the materials and messages of the women’s commission can be effectively communicated and leveraged. o Attend and present material at City Council meetings GOAL 4: Continue to develop and leverage relationships within the community and with other city of Fort Collins’ boards and commissions around issues that impact the key focus areas of the women’s commission, • Attend super meetings and collaboration meetings. Presentation of the Marcile N. Wood Award in conjunction with other community recognition events • Maintain an inclusive process to vet the names of Fort Collins women for the city street naming project. Collaborate and network with local organizations and law enforcement to highlight issues such as domestic violence, sexual assault, homelessness, gender discrimination and poverty. GOAL 5: Spearhead and collaborate with other community and organizational entities to craft a recommendation to city council for the adoption of a CEDAW resolution. Women’s Commission 2018 Annual Report Summary statement The City of Fort Collins Women’s Commission promotes decisions and actions that address the needs and positively impact women in our community. We do this by listening to the voice of women, advising city council, promoting community events, and educating ourselves and others about safety, health, and poverty as they relate to the City of Fort Collins Key Strategic Outcome of Community and Neighborhood Livability. During 2018, the Fort Collins Women’s Commission continued to focus its efforts on three key areas affecting women in Fort Collins: Safety, Health, and Poverty. The Commission focused on becoming a stronger voice to the City Council and the community on behalf of the women of Fort Collins. 1. ITEM 1 - Continue to align the Work Plan and monthly agendas with the City of Fort Collins seven Key Strategic Outcomes. ● Women’s commission members attend and/or watch each City Council meeting and report back at the monthly meeting ● Members elect to participate in public comment on behalf on the Women’s Commission as is relevant 2. ITEM 2 - Review and capitalize on the research available from existing sources to provide a picture of the status of women in the community, foster dialogue and create the forums and synergies necessary for problem solving. ● Provided feedback on BFO that reflect the priorities and the well-being of women in the communities ● A staff person from the Colorado Health Network spoke with the Commission about the opioid epidemic and how it uniquely impacts the lives of women ● Organized and hosted Homelessness Panel ● Member attended the Colorado Women’s Small Business Conference in November ● Members attended and hosted a table at the WomenGive Luncheon in Loveland ● Members attended and invited other community members to attend the Women’s Foundation of Colorado Luncheon in Denver on October 10 3. ITEM 3 - Collaborate and network with local organizations and law enforcement to highlight issues such as domestic violence, sexual assault, homelessness, gender discrimination and poverty. ● Sponsored refreshments ($200) for a “Community Conversation focused on empowering women: tackling exploitation, assault, and other issues” put on by a young teenager in Fort Collins 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 1 BOARD NAME 2018 Annual Report ● The Commission submitted and hosted proclamations preceding City Council meetings on the following: Domestic Violence Awareness Month, Women’s History Month, Gun Violence Awareness Month, Sexual Assault Awareness Month, Hunger and Homelessness Week, and Recovery Awareness. 4. ITEM 4 - Bring to the attention of City Council and identify and utilize key events/media outlets in the community where the materials and messages of the Women’s Commission can be effectively communicated and leveraged. ● City Councilwoman Kristin Stephens invited to attend Women’s Foundation of Colorado Luncheon ● City Councilwoman Stephens attended the presentation of the Marcile N. Wood Award breakfast for the SAVA Center. Staff was able to provide an overview of their work and have a meaningful conversation with Councilwoman Stephens about sexual assault in Fort Collins ● Attended a meeting and spread word on the Fort Collins Chapter of Zonta “Legends” Project 5. ITEM 5 - Continue to develop and leverage relationships with other City of Fort Collins’ Boards and Commissions around issues that impact the key focus areas of the Women’s commission, i.e. attend super meetings and collaboration meetings. ● Hosted and coordinated a Boards and Commission Networking/Collaboration Breakfast May 8 ● Initiated a joint presentation of annual awards with Human Relations Commission on December 4 ● Coordinated Youth Advisory Board members attending a monthly meeting and presentation by Moms against Gun Violence and a Fort Collins Police officer representative on gun control 6. ITEM 6 - Continue to develop and leverage relationships in the community, i.e. presentation of the Marcile N. Wood Award in conjunction with other community recognition events. ● SAVA Center awarded 2017 Marcile N. Wood award during breakfast presentation in 2018. Councilwoman Stephens attended and presented the award to SAVA. ● Araceli Newman and other nominees awarded in joint award ceremony with Human Relations Commission 7. ITEM 7 - Focus and align Women’s Commission activities and work with the Key Outcome of Community & Neighborhood Livability, especially as related to the Women’s Commission Periodic Review in 2019. ● Homelessness panel with Holly LeMasurier, Director of Homeward 2020; Marla Cleary, 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 2 BOARD NAME 2018 Annual Report Housing First Initiative Director at Murphy Center; Annette Zacharias, Director of Faith, Family, Hospitality; and Lisa Dunworth, Behavioral Health Clinician at Summit Stone. ● Conversation with Councilwoman Stephens during her attendance at monthly meeting 8. ITEM 8 -Spearhead and collaborate with other community and organizational entities to craft a recommendation to City Council for the adoption of a CEDAW resolution. ● Worked with City Council liaison to develop a recommendation memo. The next step is to present that to other boards and commissions for feedback and present to City Council in 2019. 9. ITEM 9 - Design an inclusive process to vet the names of Fort Collins women for the City Street Naming Project. ● Worked with Zonta Project, Fort Collins Museum of Natural Discovery and other community sources to gather and sort names to be collected and stored on the Women's Commission Drive as a name archive resource for the City of Fort Collins ● Name were collected into a spreadsheet in May ● CBS News Denver showcased the work the Fort Collins Women’s Commission has done in partnership with others in Fort Collins on this project. The story aired April 6, 2018 ONGOING ANNUAL COMMISSION ACTIVITIES ● Attend and present material at City Council meetings ● Organize collaboration meetings with other Boards and Commissions ● Participate in and/or arrange community events that highlight issues pertinent to women in Fort Collins ● Create collaborative relationships with individuals and entities who address the community’s issues of poverty, health, and safety ● Identify and reach out to community experts and resources to inform the work of the Women’s Commission ● Professional development and training for Women’s Commission members ● Quarterly evaluations of progress ● Participate in city budget discussions as appropriate ● Produce materials related to annual goals which will be available in both electronic and paper form ● Monitor City Council 6-month planning calendar 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 3 BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS PERIODIC REVIEW QUESTIONNAIRE BOARD/ COMMISSION NAME: Zoning Board of Appeals DATE PREPARED: LIST OF MEMBERS: 1. Ralph Shields Chair 6. Ian Shuff 2. Shelly LaMastra Vice Chair 7. Butch Stockover 3. Robert Long 8. 4. John McCoy 9. 5. Taylor Meyer 10. 1. Please indicate the Key Outcome Areas this Board/Commission is aligned with, using (1) for the primary connection, (2) for second largest connection, and (3) for third connection: ___XX Neighborhood Livability & Social Health ___ Culture and Recreation (all boardmembers chose this one area) ___ Economic Health Environmental Health Safe Community Transportation _______Transportation 2. How do the current duties of the board, as defined by City Code, align with the Key Outcome Areas identified above? What duties would you suggest be added and/or deleted?  Being new to this Board, I do not have much experience at this point to provide an evaluation of the duties. That being said, the duties seemed to be aligned wit the Key Outcome Areas.  Hearing variance requests to allow property owners flexibility outside of defined Land Use Code standards, in attempt to improve the built environment. None.  The duties of the board align very well to the above Key Outcome Area in that many of the variances impact the overall livability and perception of a well ordered urban context. At this time the duties seem to be well covered and I see no further duty changes being required.  Managing land uses and potential reasonable exceptions for valid issues and unique situations is a foundational piece of maintaining neighborhood livability and social health!  Deciding and authorizing appeal requests allows property owners to deviate from the strict interpretation of the Land Use Code while maintaining a reasonable response to the intent of the code. I wouldn’t suggest any duties be added or deleted.  They align as they should. 3. Regarding the board’s annual Work Plan: A. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Key Outcome(s) identified above?  These appear to be aligned.  The work plan is aligned with neighborhood livability.  The purpose of the LUC is to ensure a safe livable and consistent urban context, variations to this should meet the intent or be nominal and/or inconsequential in nature. The Work Plan could be more specific in what types of variances can be heard.  Perfectly.  Deciding and authorizing appeal requests allows property owners to deviate from the strict interpretation of the Land Use Code while maintaining a reasonable response to the intent of the code. A monthly meeting to accomplish this is an appropriate recurrence for this task.  It provides a consistent structure for managing land uses and potential reasonable exceptions for valid issues and unique situations that citizens can rely on. B. How is the Work Plan aligned with the City’s Strategic Plan?  These appear to be aligned.  The work plan is aligned with the City's strategic plan.  It is too vague in nature to answer how it aligns with the Strategic plan.  No issues.  Deciding and authorizing appeal requests provides the opportunity to review how each case affects the cities intent to provide a high quality built environment and support quality, diverse neighborhoods.  It provides a consistent structure for managing land uses and potential reasonable exceptions or valid issues and unique situations that citizens can rely on. C. How is the Work Plan aligned with the Agenda Planning Calendar (Six Month Calendar)?  These appear to be aligned.  I am not clear on this  No issues.  I’m not sure how the work plan aligns with the Agenda Planning Calendar; the ZBA meetings do not show on the 6 month calendar.  Our primary focus is a less than 6 month period, and generally address 30‐60 day cycles; and can be lied upon to be consistent in 6 months! D. Does the board effectively accomplish its annual Work Plan?  I believe that is has.  Yes.  Yes.  Yes, it does!  Yes.  Yes, very much so 4. Are board meetings conducted in an effective manner (do the meetings start on time? Are discussions focused around the agenda topic, etc.)? What could be done to improve board meetings?  From my brief experience, it appears meeting are conducted effectively.  Yes.  More focus need to be code issue at hand, if the request meets a justification for a variance and then debate over that. Too much emphasis is on personal opinion.  Meetings start on time and stay on topic.  The board meetings are conducted in an effective manner. The meetings start on time and the discussions are focused around the agenda topic. An improvement that could be made to save the board’s time would be to introduce a section in the Land Use Code that addresses unique setback requirements for corner lots. Many of our discussions revolve around requests to vary from the setback requirements of corner lots and often the reaction is the same and that is that corner lots should be allowed less constraining setbacks.  Meetings are consistently on time, and if there are concerns about time constraints due to a heavy workload, board members work collaboratively to serve the public in an effective manner. 5. Is the current size of the board appropriate? If not, what suggestions would you make?  The current board size seems adequate.  Yes.  Yes.  It is appropriate.  Yes.  Yes, there is an adequate number of members so that in a “worse case scenario” with one or several members out for a meeting and other potentially recusing themselves we still have a quorum. The number and diversity of our board feels like it can thoroughly explore and discuss an agenda item without becoming cumbersome. 6. Please describe the effectiveness of the communications between the board and Council. What could be done to improve these communications?  I’m not aware of communication between the board and Council and would assume it would only exist if the Council liaison to the P&Z Board were present at board meeting.  Not applicable in my time on the board.  There is none. Anything would improve it.  Very little communication is required from the requests we have received.  Meeting minutes from the ZBA meetings are recorded for the Council to review. This seems effective and appropriate.  There tends to be limited communication between the board and council, however our structure and bylaws provide a good framework to do our jobs and limited board input is required. 7. Other comments:  The board members are excellent, very thoughtful, reasoned and determined to do a good job! Attachments: a. City Code description of duties b. Current Work Plan c. Current Annual Report d. Current Bylaws 281 North College Avenue P.O. Box 580 Fort Collins, CO 80522.0580 970.221.6376 970.224.6134 - fax Planning, Development & Transportation MEMORANDUM DATE: January 9, 2020 TO: Delynn Coldiron, City Clerk FROM: Noah Beals, Senior City Planner-Zoning RE: November 14, 2019 Periodic Review – Zoning Board of Appeals ____________________________________________________________________ At the November 14 meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA), Councilmember Cunniff attended to participate in the periodic review of the board. Board members present at the periodic review were Chair Ralph Shields, Vice Chair Shelley LaMastra, John McCoy, Taylor Meyer, Ian Schuff and Butch Stockover. Summary of the discussion: During the meeting Councilmember Cunniff facilitated a discussion related to concerns, questions and comments from Zoning Board of Appeals members: • A desire was expressed for more involvement during Land Use Code Changes. It was suggested that the ZBA offer a recommendation to Planning and Zoning Board and City Council for proposed Land Use Code changes. City staff will follow up on this item and include ZBA in future outreach. Additionally, the ZBA could suggest possible changes that relate to standards or variances that are frequently heard by the ZBA. • The board requested additional training for quasi-judicial boards and their roles in the City development review process. Concern was expressed about training of ZBA and Planning and Zoning Board members related to their area of influence and decision parameters. It was suggested that the criteria under which boards review proposals be defined and shared to ensure decisions are clear, consistent and fair. • The importance of diversity on the board was expressed. Board recruitment should ensure a balance of professionals in development and residents with other expertise. • The board requested that staff reports include more information about the general purpose of code standards to ensure they have a complete understand -2- the intent behind code requirements and to provide greater context and background. • ZBA members were encouraged to review City Council’s 6-month calendar. If there are Council items of interest to the ZBA, then they can provide input as appropriate. ARTICLE III. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Division 37 - Zoning Board of Appeals Sec. 2-453. - Functions. The Board shall have the following powers and duties: (1) To hear and decide appeals from and review any order, requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative official charged with enforcement of the regulations established by the Land Use Code or, if applicable, Articles I through IV of the Transitional Land Use Regulations in accordance with the provisions of Division 2.10 of the Land Use Code. (2) To authorize upon appeal in specific cases, and in accordance with the provisions of Division 2.9 of the Land Use Code, variances from the terms of Articles 3 and 4 of the Land Use Code or, if applicable, Chapter 29, Articles I through IV of the Transitional Land Use Regulations. (Ord. No. 158, 1986, § 25, 11-4-86; Ord. No. 154, 1987, § 13, 10-20-87; Ord. No. 29, 1992, 3-3- 92; Ord. No. 51, 1997, § 7, 3-18-97; Ord. No. 113, 1997, § 2, 8-5-97) ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 2019 WORK PLAN The Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) will meet on the second Thursday of every month, providing that there are discussion items appearing on the regular monthly agenda. The Board may also meet as needed in order to convene special meetings. The primary purpose of the meetings will be to hear and decide appeals of certain administrative decisions made by City staff and to authorize variances from the requirements of the Land Use Code. It is estimated that the Board will consider approximately 45 variance requests in 2019. The Board will review proposed Land Use Code revisions that may be necessary as the City continues refinement of the Code through the annual code update ordinance and will also explore updating the By-Laws for the Zoning Board of Appeals. No other special projects or issues are anticipated at this time. Zoning Board of Appeals 2018 Annual Report December 26, 2018 281 N. College Ave 2018 ANNUAL REPORT Page 1 BACKGROUND: The Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) consists of seven members. Meetings were held the second Thursday of every month in the Council Chambers at City Hall. The Board may also meet as needed in order to convene special meetings. The Boardmembers who served in 2018 were: Daphne Bear, Robert Long, Cody Snowdon, Ralph Shields, Heidi Shuff, Butch Stockover, and Karen Szelei-Jackson. The annual election of officers resulted in Heidi Shuff being elected as chairperson and Ralph Shields as vice-chairperson. City Council liaison to the Board during 2018 was Ken Summers. Staff support was provided by Noah Beals, Marcha Hill, Kacee Scheidenhelm, and Christopher Van Hall. 2018 YEAR IN REVIEW: Forty-seven (47) applications for variances to the Land Use Code were submitted to the ZBA in 2018. In comparison, the number of applications for variances was thirty-eight (38) in 2017; forty-one (41) in 2016; fifty-one (51) in 2015; thirty-five (35) in 2014; twenty-seven (27) in 2013; twenty-six (26) in 2012; and seventeen (17) in 2011. Thirty (32) of the variance requests were approved; four (4) were denied; eight (8) were approved with specific conditions; two (2) were withdrawn before the meeting; and one (1) was tabled and has not been heard at this time. needs of the community now and in the future 7.5 Foster a culture of safety and well-being across the City organization 7.6 Leverage data, technology, metrics and benchmarks to guide decisions, improve results, and enhance service delivery 7.9 Proactively influence policy and legislative development at all levels General • Review COD Bylaws annually • Develop Annual Work Plan • Host Community Recognition Awards • Plan recognition for outgoing COD members o Develop education for landlords regardingmaking reasonable accommodation to ensure safety for vulnerable populations. o Explore current emergency preparedness systems and make appropriate suggestions for improvement. List Resources on FCGOV website? o Maintain involvement with special events staff: develop an education plan for event staff, security and volunteers regarding visitors with disabilities o Meet with New Police Chief 5.1 Improve community involvement, education and regional partnerships to increase the level of public trust and keep the community safe 5.2 Meet the expected level of core and specialized police services as the community grows 5.3 Partner with Poudre Fire Authority to provide high-quality fire prevention, community risk reduction and emergency response services 5.4 Improve emergency management and preparedness COD 2019 Work Plan Rev. 5/09/2019