The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutCOUNCIL - AGENDA ITEM - 01/15/2019 - RESOLUTION 2019-014 MAKING AN APPOINTMENT TO FILLAgenda Item 20 Item # 20 Page 1 AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY January 15, 2019 City Council STAFF Delynn Coldiron, City Clerk Carrie M. Daggett, Legal SUBJECT Resolution 2019-014 Making an Appointment to Fill a Vacancy for Councilmember for District 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this item is for Council to make an appointment to fill the vacant District 1 Council seat. Councilmember Bob Overbeck tendered his resignation from the Council effective January 1, 2019, as a result of his recent election to the office of Larimer County Assessor. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends adoption of the Resolution. BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION Council interviewed eight applicants at its work session on January 2, 2019. The applicants interviewed included: • Nathaniel Budd • Danielle Buttke • E. John Clarke • Richard Cress • Jerry Gavaldon • Susan Gutowsky • Jessica Hazlett • Joseph Somodi, III The applications for all applicants are attached (Attachments 1-9). A summary of the interviews is also attached (Attachment 10). Additionally, the video of the interviews can be found at: https://fortcollinstv.viebit.com/player.php?hash=N1Oz6JgupgHs starting at 00:46:49. On December 18, Council adopted Resolution 2018-129 (Attachment 11), establishing the process for selection and appointment. Formal notice of the interview date of January 2, 2019 was not provided, although some of the applicants had been in contact with the City Clerk and were informed of the scheduled interviews. Two applicants were not informed due to a staff oversight; one of the two applicants did attend and participate in interviews on January 2, 2019; one did not (Christopher Staten). This was discussed by Council leadership, and there has been no support indicated for changing from the interview process Council approved in order to conduct an additional interview. Among the related considerations are: 20 Packet Pg. 427 Agenda Item 20 Item # 20 Page 2 • Council’s December 18 Resolution adopting the process that would be used to fill the vacancy included the date Council would be doing interviews; • The District 1 Vacancy webpage included an information memo and timeline that both included the date Council would be doing interviews; • Mr. Staten may choose to provide comments to Council at the January 15, 2019 meeting; and • Mr. Staten can run for the District 1 seat as part of the April 2019 election. Despite not receiving an interview, Mr. Staten did submit an application and Council may still wish to consider his application as part of the January 15, 2019 process. Public comment is being collected through the following methods: • Feedback Form on the City’s website • Emails to Council • Facebook and Nextdoor • Written letters Responses received using the Feedback Form on the City’s website through January 9, 2019 are attached (Attachment 12). Feedback received by email through January 9, 2019 is also attached (Attachment 13). No written feedback has been received. Feedback received after January 9, 2019 will be provided in read- before packets on January 15, 2019. The public will also have a chance to provide feedback as part of public participation at the January 15, 2019 meeting. The Mayor has indicated that he will ask Council to use a series of motions to focus the selection process, and then will ask for a motion to adopt the Resolution. The Resolution contains a blank for Council to insert the appointee’s name. If no applicant receives a majority vote, Council may wish to postpone the item to a later date for further consideration. If an appointment is made, the oath of office will be administered to the new appointee at an adjourned meeting on January 22, 2019. ATTACHMENTS 1. Application for Nathaniel Budd (PDF) 2. Application for Danielle Buttke (PDF) 3. Application for E John Clarke (PDF) 4. Application for Richard Cress (PDF) 5. Application for Jerry Gavaldon (PDF) 6. Application for Susan Gutowsky (PDF) 7. Application for Jessica Hazlett (PDF) 8. Application for Joseph Somodi (PDF) 9. Application for Christopher Staten (PDF) 10. Interview Summary (PDF) 11. Resolution 2018-129 (PDF) 12. Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (PDF) 13. Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (PDF) 14. PowerPoint Presentation (PDF) 20 Packet Pg. 428 .k,:.SCity of olli!!_S APPLICATION FOR COUNCILMEMBER - DISTRICT 1 APPLICATION DEADLINE: 5:00 p.m. on December 26, 2018 (late applications will not be accepted/considered) RECEIVED City Clerk's Office 1, d- -a" -;l-0 ,a 1 PLEASE TYPE OR USE BLACK INK. ATTACHMENTS TO APPL/CATION MUST BE LIMITED TO TWO PAGES. INCOMPLETE APPL/CATIONS WILL NOT BE CONSIDERED FOR APPOINTMENT. Return completed application: In person: City Clerk's Office 300 LaPorte Avenue Mail: City Clerk's Office PO Box 580 Email: cityclerk@fcgov.com Fort Collins, CO 80522 Ellglblllty Requirements: United States citizen Registered voter in the city for one year immediately prior to appointment At least 21 years of age A resident of Council District 1 Never convicted of a felony If you have questions or need more information, contact the City Clerk's Office at 970 .221.6515 NAME: Nathaniel Budd RESIDENCE ADDRESS: 817 Smith St. ----------------------- HOME PHONE: ____ N_la ___ _ WORK PHONE: __ 9_7_ 0_-4_9_ 1-5 _ _7 11 _ __ EMAIL: nathaniel.budd@gmail.com ARE YOU 21 YEARS OF AGE OR OLDER? Yes iz:J No D HAVE YOU BEEN A REGISTERED VOTER IN FORT COLLINS FOR AT LEAST A YEAR? DO YOU RESIDE IN DISTRICT 1? Yes jg] No D HAVE YOU EVER BEEN CONVICTED OF A FELONY? Yes D No � CURRENT OCCUPATION/EMPLOYER: Development Officer· Colorado State University RECENT AND/OR RELEVANT WORK EXPERIENCE (PLEASE INCLUDE DATES): Colorado State University· Development Officer [Fort Collins, CO) Jan. '16 - Present MOBILE: __ 7_ 1_9·_ 2 _13_-_81_8_ 2 __ Yes IZJ No D Wyco Power and Water 1nc. - Business Development Advisor [Fort Collins, CO] Dec. '09 - Present GanneWColoradoan Media Group· Key Account Executive [Fort Collins, CO] July '13 - Jan 1'6 COMMUNITY ACTIVITIESNOLUNTEER EXPERIENCE (PLEASE INCLUDE DATES): Neighbor to Neighbor - Vice President of the Board [Fort Collins, CO] 2016 - Present Friends of the Gardens on Spring Creek - President of the Board [Fort Collins, CO] 2015- Present Coloradoan - Editorial Board [Fort Collins, CO] 2015 Homelessness Prevention Initiative - Development Chair [Fort Collins, CO) 2015 UniverCity Connections- Scoping Committee Member [Fort Collins, CO] 2014 ATTACHMENT 1 20.1 Packet Pg. 429 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.1 Packet Pg. 430 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.1 Packet Pg. 431 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.1 Packet Pg. 432 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.1 Packet Pg. 433 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.1 Packet Pg. 434 Attachment: Application for Nathaniel Budd (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 20.2 2 Packet Pg. 435 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.2 Packet Pg. 436 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.2 Packet Pg. 437 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.2 Packet Pg. 438 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.2 Packet Pg. 439 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.2 Packet Pg. 440 Attachment: Application for Danielle Buttke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 3 20.3 Packet Pg. 441 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 442 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 443 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 444 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 445 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 446 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.3 Packet Pg. 447 Attachment: Application for E John Clarke (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 4 20.4 Packet Pg. 448 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.4 Packet Pg. 449 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.4 Packet Pg. 450 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.4 Packet Pg. 451 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.4 Packet Pg. 452 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.4 Packet Pg. 453 Attachment: Application for Richard Cress (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 20.5 5 Packet Pg. 454 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 455 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 456 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 457 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 458 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 459 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.5 Packet Pg. 460 Attachment: Application for Jerry Gavaldon (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 20.6 6 Packet Pg. 461 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 462 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 463 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 464 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 465 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 466 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 467 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.6 Packet Pg. 468 Attachment: Application for Susan Gutowsky (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 7 20.7 Packet Pg. 469 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 470 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 471 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 472 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 473 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 474 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.7 Packet Pg. 475 Attachment: Application for Jessica Hazlett (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 8 20.8 Packet Pg. 476 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 477 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 478 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 479 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 480 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 481 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 482 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.8 Packet Pg. 483 Attachment: Application for Joseph Somodi (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 20.9 9 Packet Pg. 484 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.9 Packet Pg. 485 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.9 Packet Pg. 486 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.9 Packet Pg. 487 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.9 Packet Pg. 488 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.9 Packet Pg. 489 Attachment: Application for Christopher Staten (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Summary of District 1 Vacancy Interviews E. John Clarke Mr. Clarke stated he was previously appointed to Council and served as a County Commissioner and he would be able to move forward with his existing experience in the interim prior to the election. He stated he has no intention to run for the Council seat in April. Mr. Clarke discussed his 48 years in Fort Collins and the unique development opportunities in District 1. He stated he intends to blend with the existing Council for the next few months which will allow the April election to proceed with a level playing field. Jerry Gavaldon Mr. Gavaldon discussed his history as a native of Fort Collins and stated his knowledge of the community and City politics will enable him to hit the ground running. He stated District 1 has growth, constraints, and infrastructure opportunities and stated his experience as an HOA president has shown his ability to collaborate with others. Mr. Gavaldon stated he would hold frequent listening sessions as a Council member and would always make his phone number and email available. Councilmember Summers asked Mr. Gavaldon about Council's impact on economic development. Mr. Gavaldon replied economic development is the key driver in the community and it should be balanced with other priorities. He stated Council is the leader in creating a strong economic policy. Councilmember Martinez asked Mr. Gavaldon what he feels are the most important budget items for the City and about his opinion on the Keep Fort Collins Great ballot initiative. Mr. Gavaldon replied he has supported Keep Fort Collins Great; however, he will question whether the proper priorities exist. Councilmember Stephens asked Mr. Gavaldon how he would deal with an unsatisfied citizen. Mr. Gavaldon replied he would communicate and listen to the citizen and reach out to staff to enlist their assistance. Danielle Buttke Ms. Buttke stated she has lived in Fort Collins for 7 years and has a strong commitment to community service. She stated serving through government is one of the most unique opportunities to have long- lasting and significant impacts on policies that will shape the future. Because she is on active duty, she is occasionally deployed and therefore cannot run for the office long-term. Ms. Buttke discussed the impact of climate change on more frequent and severe storms, which therefore affects our daily lives. She discussed the ways in which local government can affect change and detailed how her education and background can assist her in serving and evaluating data. She discussed her family's history in agriculture and noted the importance of addressing the balance between that history in the community and growth. ATTACHMENT 10 20.10 Packet Pg. 490 Attachment: Interview Summary (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Summary of District 1 Vacancy Interviews January 2, 2019 Page 2 Councilmember Summers asked Ms. Buttke to describe the role of economic development in the City. Ms. Buttke replied the triple bottom line is mutually dependent and innovation has allowed Fort Collins to become the economic leader of the area. Innovation is needed to address environmental and social sustainability and those two aspects cannot be addressed without economic sustainability. Councilmember Martinez asked Ms. Buttke to discuss affordable housing. Ms. Buttke replied she is very interested in some of the options outlined by City Plan and stated the City has done a good job to ensure low-income housing is integrated throughout the community. She suggested examining other communities which have used innovative approaches such as additional dwelling units or tiny house communities. She also discussed the importance of addressing more alternate forms of transportation. Councilmember Martinez asked how Council should go about providing affordable housing options. Ms. Buttke replied building codes and zoning are ways to not necessarily pay for affordable housing, but to incentivize housing that can address the needs. Councilmember Stephens asked Ms. Buttke to address some of the unique issues affecting District 1. Ms. Buttke replied the challenging differences of opinion as to how yet-to-be-developed parcels should be used, meeting transportation and social service needs, and natural resource issues all face the area. Susan Gutowsky Ms. Gutowsky stated she and her family have lived in the same house in Fort Collins for nearly 40 years, and while growth is inevitable, it can be managed. She stated District 1 is unique and she views this opportunity as a way to continue her service. She discussed the similarities between her service on the School Board and Council. She stated her skill set in areas such as diplomacy, collaboration, consensus building, dealing with people, and having realistic expectations of time commitments will allow her to dig in and begin Council work. Ms. Gutowsky stated she would plan to run for the Council seat in April and as she has previously run two successful campaigns, she is aware of what that takes. She stated partnerships and sharing resources are essential and she has huge respect for the assistance of staff. Councilmember Summers asked Ms. Gutowsky to describe the role of economic development in the City. Ms. Gutowsky replied the emphasis on vocational education is going to feed the City's workforce. She also noted an excellent school system attracts home buyers thereby positively impacting economic development. Councilmember Stephens asked Ms. Gutowsky to describe the unique challenges of District 1. Ms. Gutowsky replied the diversity of the district, traffic and congestion, and ensuring good development are unique aspects of District 1. Councilmember Martinez asked Ms. Gutowsky to address affordable living in Fort Collins. Ms. Gutowsky replied City leaders have done an excellent job at being visionary; however, Fort Collins is not affordable. She discussed the importance of sustainability and commended the City's efforts to provide broadband service. 20.10 Packet Pg. 491 Attachment: Interview Summary (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Summary of District 1 Vacancy Interviews January 2, 2019 Page 3 Jessica Hazlett Ms. Hazlett stated she is a recent graduate of the City Works 101 class and stated the small businesses in the Old Town area of District 1 are vital to the community. She discussed forming a group called the Volunteer Fight Club noting the importance of social media and public engagement. Councilmember Summers asked Ms. Hazlett to describe the role of economic development in the City. Ms. Hazlett replied partnerships with the Chamber of Commerce and the Small Business Development Center would be critical as would ensuring small businesses continue to thrive. Councilmember Stephens asked Ms. Hazlett to describe some of the unique challenges facing District 1. Ms. Hazlett replied homelessness and mental health issues are unique issues facing Old Town. Nathaniel Budd Mr. Budd stated he is extremely passionate about Fort Collins since he attended college at CSU. He discussed his experience as Vice President of the Neighbor-to-Neighbor organization which deals with homelessness and as President of the Gardens on Spring Creek Board. He stated it is important to ensure individuals with the largest future in the community have a strong voice. Mr. Budd stated his previous experience in running for Council has allowed him to begin engaging with the public and stated it is important for Council to engage in a robust dialogue to foster the right types of questions to be answered. He stated staff members are truly experts and he would hope to leverage his access to them to help answer important community questions. Councilmember Summers asked Mr. Budd to describe the role of economic development in the City. Mr. Budd replied economic development will need to play a critical role in Fort Collins' future. He discussed the importance of utilizing regional advantages in providing job opportunities. Councilmember Martinez asked Mr. Budd to address homelessness and multi-cultural issues in District 1. Mr. Budd replied the City has done a good job in utilizing the Land Bank and incentivizing affordable housing stock. He noted housing affordability is not a transient issue and stated long-term community residents are beginning to feel squeezed out of the City. Councilmember Stephens asked Mr. Budd to describe unique challenges facing District 1. Mr. Budd replied the Vine and Lemay intersection, mix of utility services, annexation of the Mulberry corridor, transportation issues, and identifying areas of opportunity for higher density development are unique issues of District 1. Joseph Somodi III Mr. Somodi stated the people of the community have motivated him to want to serve in a more meaningful way, including residents who are experiencing homelessness, seeking affordable child care and housing, and who are working to overcome mental health issues. He stated accurate representation means knowing the challenges of the community and discussed his 20 years of diverse small business 20.10 Packet Pg. 492 Attachment: Interview Summary (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Summary of District 1 Vacancy Interviews January 2, 2019 Page 4 experience. He stated he has strong negotiation skills, is passionate about crafting responsible budgets, is hungry to expand knowledge and make decisions that will lead to a healthy and thriving community. Mr. Somodi stated he has already declared his intent to run for the Council seat in April and has already begun public engagement. He stated he is on the Board of the Family Center, La Familia, is working with Imagine Zero, a suicide prevention organization, and remains connected with the Human Relations Commission since he left his position in 2017. Councilmember Summers asked Mr. Somodi to describe the role of economic development in the City. Mr. Somodi replied Council needs to make some bold decisions and noted there is clearly a gap in the community needs. He stated high-density zoning needs to be further researched as it can help with affordable housing, decrease stress on transportation, is environmentally friendly, and helps small businesses thrive. He discussed the importance of ensuring small businesses continue to thrive and ensuring Fort Collins is desirable for long-term careers. Councilmember Stephens asked Mr. Somodi to address unique issues with District 1. Mr. Somodi replied growth is a great opportunity and discussed the way the new whitewater park was developed to ensure environmental and economic success. Councilmember Martinez asked how Mr. Somodi views the planned Police training facility and how he feels about making Police Services a higher budget priority. Mr. Somodi replied the Keep Fort Collins Great tax does allow for a great deal of necessary police programming; however, it is necessary to compensate for the City's growth. He stated the new Police training facility makes the area more attractive to new talent. He stated he has no negative feelings about the Police force; however, he is concerned about ensuring the size of the force and facilities are adequate for the population. Richard Cress Mr. Cress stated the timing is correct for him to take on this position as he has recently retired and moved full-time to Fort Collins. He discussed his history of owning a small business and interacting with others. Councilmember Summers asked Mr. Cress to describe the role of economic development in the City. Mr. Cress replied Fort Collins is in a great place economically and has grown quite intelligently. He suggested District 1 may eventually be too large for one Council representative. Councilmember Stephens asked Mr. Cress to describe unique issues facing District 1. Mr. Cress replied controlled growth is a main issue but commended the work of the City thus far. Councilmember Martinez asked Mr. Cress to describe ways to improve relationships with CSU, Poudre School District, and Larimer County. Mr. Cress replied the City seems to have a good relationship with the County and CSU and it is important to keep those relationships viable. 20.10 Packet Pg. 493 Attachment: Interview Summary (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ATTACHMENT 11 20.11 Packet Pg. 494 Attachment: Resolution 2018-129 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.11 Packet Pg. 495 Attachment: Resolution 2018-129 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 20.11 Packet Pg. 496 Attachment: Resolution 2018-129 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) DISTRICT 1 COUNCIL VACANCY APPLICANT FEEDBACK FORM USED ON THE WEBSITE 1. Please describe the characteristics/attributes you want in an appointed City Councilmember: 2. The following nine candidates have applied for the position: E. John Clarke Jerry Gavaldon Danielle Buttke Susan Gutowsky Jessica Hazlett Nathaniel Budd Joseph Somodi III Christopher Staten Richard Cress Please provide your thoughts about their strengths and/or perceived limitations: 3. Do you live in Fort Collins? 4. How long have you lived here? 5. Are you a resident of District 1? (If unsure, find your current district.) 6. Do you work in or own a business in Fort Collins? ATTACHMENT 12 20.12 Packet Pg. 497 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Report for District 1 Council Vacancy Applicant Feedback Completion Rate: 100% Complete 75 Totals: 75 Response Counts ResponseID Response 2 A person who is willing to listen to and sometimes act on the concerns of Fort Collins folks. Also important to have a holistic big picture view as regards decisions and their effects on the constituents. 3 Intelligent, thoughtful, transparent 5 One who has a commitment to represent District 1 residents, not just react to the special interest folks who speak at the City Council meetings. One who sees the need to look at long term strategies re: growth management and the protection of the health, safety and welfare of the community. Desired characteristics: Honesty, integrity and desire to serve the community, not personal political interests. One who has the ability to be objective, is pragmatic, compassionate and intelligent. One who says what they mean and means what they say. No "flip flopping". One who follows through on commitments. 6 The characteristics I would like to see in the new councilmember include: rationality, supportive, positive, constructive, accepting of all community members, open-minded, ability to compromise, thoughtful, collaborative, appreciative, fiscally responsible, and constructively critical to name a few. I think it's important for any elected official to be willing to speak for the people they represent even when their personal views may not align exactly. 10 A City Councilmember should have a balanced perspective and willingness to communicate with all citizens about thoughts and concerns. Our city is a beautiful place that can and should be both held in high esteem but also embrace progress and change. Councilmembers should straddle and balance between our strong past and potential future. 1. Please describe the characteristics/attributes you want in an appointed City Councilmember: 1 20.12 Packet Pg. 498 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 11 Proven experience in public service. 12 Diversity such as age, gender, socioeconomic status, race/ethnicity. Time and desire to read/learn/educate oneself on topics they are going to be voting on. Ability to use common sense on issues. Recognizing the value of consulting city legal counsel early in the process. Ability to identify own biases and consciously move beyond them when dealing with and voting on an issue. Also awareness of own values and methodologies for considering and voting on an issue - we need diversity in this area as well. Less politics/bias and more analysis and consideration of data. 13 I think a patient, well educated person should be selected because they will be the incumbent for the April elections. 14 I want someone who will be open minded and clear on their perspective. Someone who will be committed to the enormous amount of research and understanding needed in order to the job right. Someone who will stand up for what they believe in and let people know that perspective but also be flexible and willing to compromise. Someone who is out talking to the constituency so their perspective is represented in the council members voice in the chambers 15 I want someone who is future focused. With a passion for the citizens of Fort Collins as well as for the city itself. I think someone that is well spoken, currently engaged in our community, and has the willingness to serve the people of Fort Collins now and into the future. 17 Passion 19 Engages with the community. Responds to community concerns. Represents constituents concerns on City Council, not the loudest voices or biggest money interests. 20 - A strong personal connection to and deep understanding of our city's culture, including the fine arts, bike commuting, outdoor recreation, and hospitality/tourism. - A progressive moral compass, helping usher Fort Collins into a top city for inclusion and equal rights. - Above all else, an unwavering sense of duty to act in the best interest of all residents and encourage frequent public feedback. 21 It is essential that this vacancy be filled by someone who reflects the preferences of District 1 voters (as expressed in their election of Bob Overbeck) rather than your own perspectives and wishes. This means that the council member you select should be someone who will consider environmental sustainability and neighborhood quality of life, who is responsive to constituent concerns, progressive and open-minded. For the good of the entire city, it is also important that this vacancy be filled by someone who is articulate, knowledgeable, and intelligent. This seat will be re-filled in April by an elected Council member. I appreciate the perspective that the replacement you select will have an incumbent's advantage and therefore I like the idea of selecting a temporary council member who is not planning to run for the seat in April. For these reasons, Danielle Buttke is unquestionably the most qualified and appropriate replacement for the District 1 Council seat. ResponseID Response 2 20.12 Packet Pg. 499 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 23 I think Jerry Gavaldon would be an asset because of his growing up in Fort Collins knowing the city and its needs and the people he would be very loyal honest discrete fair.I would like to see him accepted in to the council. Thank you Rex Anderson long time resident And small business owner in Fort Collins 24 Honesty,integrity and dedication to the citizens. 26 - Broad understanding of issues for the city and region. - Good listener - Articulate - Knowledgeable on many topics that will impact the city and region. - Solid commitment to consider common good. 27 Dedication with the public's interest in mind. Someone related... 28 Compassion! 29 a 30 Honesty Ability to listen well to the community Personable Thoughtful Knows the community 31 Thoughtful, hard working, thorough, good listening skills. 32 Honest, sincere, intelligent, caring, hard working, innovative. 33 Empathy, follow through, honesty, integrity, persistence, and a kind heart. 34 Joe Somodi is a very honest man. He can be counted on to step in and help whoever is in need. Joe is a good listener who will take the time to analyze an issue before forming an opinion. Once Joe sets his mind he is very methodical in garnering his energy to accomplish the task at hand. Joe gets along easily with people of different backgrounds. He has no bones to pick and would be an unbiased voice as a member of the council. 35 A compassionate open-minded listener who is connected to the community and dedicated to creative problem solving. 36 Fiscal responsibility (ability to balance a budget and plan for the future), maturity of character, sensitivity to the diverse needs of a Rocky Mountain community, communication and negation skills. 37 The characteristics that I want in an appointed city council member are strong work ethic, willingness to learn, and someone who is always listening to the needs of the community. 38 Ability to collaborate--proven ability to make good decisions in a diverse group. Commitment to Fort Collins. Pay attention to generational transition. 39 HONESTY AND ABILITY TO GOVERN! ResponseID Response 3 20.12 Packet Pg. 500 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 40 Someone who is concerned, and advocates for all constituents - diverse populations, migrants, children, the elderly, etc. 41 Integrity, curiosity, dedication to Fort Collins, commitment to diversity 42 Someone who is open-minded. Someone who is thoughtful and listens more than speaks. Someone who has consciously chosen to live and work in Fort Collins. 43 A person who has a long history with our city and a record of service on boards. 44 1. Will be prepared and engaged during Council meetings. 2. Will use data, facts, and logic to make decisions. 3, Will be respectful of other Council members, City Staff, attendees, media, and all community members. 4. Is passionate about public service; is not there for a personal agenda.5. Is a person of strong character; has integrity. 6. Brings additional/different perspectives to round out Council (i.e. not just more of the same) 45 Comprehension of details. Ability to see two sides of an issue. Problem-soling practicality. Love for Fort Collins. 46 Quick study; hits the ground running; experience dealing with problem solving and consensus building. 48 Someone who is caring and who listens to the people with careful consideration. 49 Open, honest, kind, compassionate, dedicated, authentic. 50 Open, honest, transparent, understanding, flexible. 52 Open to new ideas but committed to preserving the historic character of Old Town, interested in environmental and social issues with an eye to improving conditions, not wedded to unending growth and development, and caring for the homeless, underprivileged and minority populations. 53 Strategic, Inclusive, Wise, Dogged, Pragmatic, Motivated by community 54 Sincere, Honest, Knowledgeable, Relateable, Experienced 55 Honest, hard working, dedicated, trustworthy, knowledgeable, cares about the city and it's people. 56 Strong fiscal management. Ability to think outside the box. Appreciation of diversity. Diverse social base. Passionate about Fort Collins. Community pride. 57 Strong fiscal management. Ability to think outside the box. Appreciation of diversity. Diverse social base. Passionate about Fort Collins. Community pride. ResponseID Response 4 20.12 Packet Pg. 501 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 58 I think it's important to have a forward-thinking City Council. Fort Collins has benefited greatly from it's progressive decision making over the last 20 or so years and I want to see that continue. I also think it's important to have people on the City Council that will work to achieve the Fort Collins Climate Action Plan. Finally, I believe a focus of the City Council should be to promote economic and cultural diversity in Fort Collins. 59 I'd like to express my support for Joe Somodi despite the fact I do not live in Fort Collins. However I have known Joe for almost a decade and I believe his unique lens on life would enhance any community and its governing council. He is constantly a steady force when forces around seem to be chaotic - as it often does in today's highly polarized and opinionated society. He listens - deeply - to all sides and can clearly see the real issues at hand. He allows people to feel heard and thus appreciated and valued. While I don't know the specifics around the community of Fort Collins, I do know his strength of character and reliability would serve any community. 60 Knowledge of issues, hard work, fairness, honesty. 61 I want someone trust worthily, financially responsible, who loves Colorado and Fort Collins. 62 Balanced, moderate, non-partisan, representative of middle majority, long- term/visionary thinker, not persuaded by short-sided loud voices/activists 63 Someone who has not been on council before. Someone who lives in the North-East Mountain Vista area. We are fed up with council people who don't have a clue North- East side of town is inside Fort Collins city limits. 65 Fair, unbiased. Minimal predisposition before hearing the facts. Business minded. Young adult (need balance on Council). 66 Listens to all sides, wise, experienced in working with others and on boards, has lived in their distrlct for a number of years, articulate, willing to talk to constituents and listen to their concerns about an issue. 67 Someone who knows our city's issues. Someone who cares deeply about Fort Collins. Progressive outlook and mindset. Collaborative. 68 Someone who is accessible. Someone who will meet with me or my neighbors on issues we may face in District 1. Someone who can work successfully with all kinds of people. Someone who cares as I do for District 1, Old Town 69 Team player *Honest *Fair *Respectful *Looks at different viewpoints *Familiarity of the community he/she is representing 70 See below. ResponseID Response 5 20.12 Packet Pg. 502 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 71 Listens with an open mind, Inclusive, Creative, Dedicated, Stellar Communicator, Caring and Kind, Passionate, Of high personal and professional Integrity, Humble, Knowledge and Curiosity (specifically about our city and communities) 72 *Ability to communicate with citizens with differing opinions. Avoid personal agendas for the sake of a more inclusive viewpoint. *Ability to listen and ask questions to clarify another's concerns, ie staff or citizens. *Ability to view situations from a higher level and stay out of the weeds, let staff do their jobs. *Willing to respond to emails. 73 integrity, intelligent, clear communication, compassion for all citizens 74 Honest, diligent, detail oriented, represent the people not just what the city wants to do and how to pass it legally. 75 Knowledgeable, hard working, dedicated, experienced, community oriented, a leader. ResponseID Response ResponseID Response 2 Sorry don't have the time for 9 sets of pros and cons. I thought Susan Gutowsky looked like the strongest candidate in terms of experience and ability to consider all facets of issues before making a decision. 3 All that interviewed come with different strengths but to best fill Bob Overbeck's seat, Danielle Buttke fits the bill. She seems to be the most closely aligned with Councilman Overbeck's views and leadership style, which is what the voters chose in 2017. The rest of the candidates if they so choose can run in April to win District 1's favors. 5 Nathaniel Budd already won over 43% of the District 1 voters in a previous election against the incumbent, Bob Overbeck. I would respectfully encourage you to give this young man the opportunity to serve the remainder of Bob's term. He reached out to most of my neighbors, unlike any of the other applicants. We do not want Mr. Somodi or another who has only lived here for four years representing District 1. Nor do I want Mr. Clarke who did not respond directly to questions last night and appears to rest on his laurels. As for the other applicants, several come to the table with special interests or narrow experience. I am certain one applicant cares about education, but we need a representative with broader experiences, not just years serving on a particular board. Your decision should not be based on who gets along with you or knows you. It should be based on who will best represent the varied interests of this large district. At least Mr. Budd can connect with the younger folks in this city and perhaps encourage them to be more involved and get out and vote. 2. The following nine candidates have applied for the position: E. John Clarke Jerry Gavaldon Danielle Buttke Susan Gutowsky Jessica Hazlett Nathaniel Budd Joseph Somodi III Christopher Staten Richard Cress Please provide your thoughts about their strengths and/or perceived limitations: 6 20.12 Packet Pg. 503 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 6 Based on my personal interactions with Jerry Gavaldon, he does not possess the qualities or characteristics that are needed to perform successfully as a City Councilmember. As a service provider in this community I have witnessed and endured the "Wrath of Jerry". He has let me know that I'm worthless on many occassions because he didn't approve of how I addressed him. The title "Sir", is generally found to be professional and respectful, but apparently Mr. Gavaldon does not agree. While he visits our business on a monthly basis, I may personally provide service to him 1-2 times per year and he expects me to remember exactly what he wants and how to specifically address him. His behavior is completely unreasonable and disrespectful. 7 I think Nathaniel Budd ran a very strong campaign to represent District One (my district) in 2017. He made a sincere effort to connect with voters, and he has reasonable, measured policy positions and vision for Fort Collins. He will bring a diverse perspective to Council and I believe will represent District One well. In the 2017 election I thought that Bob Overbeck was disinterested in his own re-election and did not try to court my vote; I strongly believe he only won re-election due to name recognition. I'm also interested in John Clarke's proposal to serve in the interim so that the April election will be an even playing field among all candidates. If Mr. Budd is not appointed, then I support Mr. Clarke's appointment specifically due to his commitment not to run for the permanent seat in April. 10 Only Nate Budd has a name that is familiar to me and was someone who I could recognize as a caring and interested citizen. I know Nate ran in a recent election for District 1 and it seemed to be a fairly tight race with Bob Overbeck. Nate made sure to engage with citizens throughout his election efforts and seemed to really care about District 1. Bob had popular support at the time, but it seems natural that Nate could step in with his absence. 11 I value experience in public service and the community, as this appointee will not have a lot of time for "training wheels" in order to effectively serve during their time on the council. While some are involved in community projects, I can only find one who is currently a public servant: Susan Gutowsky. I believe that is her greatest strength in this case. 12 I would be fine giving most of these candidates the opportunity. Personally I have whittled the list down to: Danielle Buttke, Susan Gutowsky and Nathaniel Budd (in no particular order) based on the characteristics/attributes I listed above. Thank you for your service and consideration. 13 Nate Budd was a very good canidate and was supported by the realtor community previously. He would be a good candidate for proper growth and sound business decisions. 14 Diversity is important to me. I like Nate Budd- he is young, African American and I also think his priorities and interests around affordability are inline with what our community needs. ResponseID Response 7 20.12 Packet Pg. 504 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 15 For most of the candidates, I feel they are passionate for the City of Fort Collins, well spoken, and have an understanding of the role of City Council. I feel Nate Budd stood out as a leader from the rest with his direct and knowledgeable response to the questions. He knows the interworking of the city and what it is currently facing. 17 Jessica Hazlett has my vote. It would be great to have some new, fresh ideas on the council 19 I appreciate John Clarke's offer to sit on City Council to "level the playing field" for the candidates who plan to run for the seat in April. This may help the candidates running for the seat but works against the voters of District 1. Having candidates on the Council for a few months gives voters the chance to see how the candidate interacts with constituents and the other City Council members. Appointing Council Members who do not plan to run for the seat in April is inefficient. Voters need all the information possible to make their selection for City Council. Please consider not appointing John Clarke, Danielle Buttke and any other applicant who stated they do not plan to run for the seat. Susan Gutowsky has the a great deal of community and education experience. She has run for office and services on the PSD Board. She is accustomed to interacting with the public. 20 I believe Jessica Hazlett has her finger on the pulse of this city. She is young, civil-service minded, a musician, and supporter of the arts. Her limited experience is a positive, in my opinion, and I expect her learning curve will be short. I am very excited to have her represent our district and city. ResponseID Response 8 20.12 Packet Pg. 505 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 21 John Clarke has written numerous op-eds in the local paper and while he managed to say very little in his interview, he clearly does not exhibit the philosophy or policy perspectives that Overbeck was elected to bring to council and therefore would not be an appropriate choice. Jerry Gavaldon also does not exhibit the philosophy and policy perspectives of District 1 voters and he was not able to express himself articulately. He intends to run for the seat in April. He would not be an appropriate choice. Danielle Buttke was able to clearly and eloquently express a perspective and policy agenda that is similar to that of Bob Overbeck. Her science background would be indispensable. She has stated she will not run for the seat in April. She is the best choice for this seat. Susan Gutowsky would also be a good second choice. Her philosophy and policy perspectives would appear to align with that of the district and she has experience in an elected office. Since she intends to run in April she would not be the best choice. Jessica Hazlett did not express perspectives on the issues of neighborhood quality of life and environmental quality that would seem to align with District 1. Her prior comments to council on homelessness do not align with the concerns of many in the neighborhood. These perspectives and her intention to run in April make her a poor choice. Nathaniel Budd was rejected by the voters of District 1 and has espoused positions that are not aligned with the District or the best long-term interests of city residents. He intends to run in April and would be a poor choice as an appointed council member. Joseph Somodi expressed an unfounded belief that density is the answer to housing affordability. This perspective is at odds with neighborhood continuity and livability. He stated that he has already begun to campaign for the April election, he should not be selected. Christopher Staten was not interviewed (an apparent no-show?) but his application materials state that he wants to "manage the city's brand" to attract business opportunities. This city does not need to attract more people. Growth is our most pressing problem. His intention to run is unknown, but his policy perspective is not aligned with District 1, he would not be a good choice. Richard Cress seemed to just see this as "something to do…" His opening statement and responses to questions were almost flippant. He did not express any relevant interest in any of the many issues facing the city. He would not be an appropriate selection. 22 I am a candidate in the April 2 election for the District 1 council seat. I did not participate in the interim app't process because my voter registration was in Park County until last March because I was an elected official serving 10 years on a metropolitan district. Given two qualified candidates who are willing to serve only for the interim 2.5 months, I think the residents would be best served it you select one of these two. This would allow the District 1 election to be an even playing field with no advantage to any one person, and no disadvantage to the others. It is reasonable to assume that your selection will signal a judgement that one person is the "best" and others less so. Lets the voters make this judgement in light of two qualified candidates with no aspirations of entering the April election. glenn haas 23 Jerry Gavaldon grew up here and knows the town and has worked real estate to understand it squirrel Jerry Gavaldon grew up here and knows the town and has worked real estate to understand it growth. ResponseID Response 9 20.12 Packet Pg. 506 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 24 Jerry Gavaldon has the best work ethic, he is a long time resident and is always willing to help Fort Collins residents. He doesn't hesitate to get involved with city projects and looks for what's best for the residents and city government. Jerry is very trustworthy and is well known in the community. 26 After watching the interviews, I decided that Danielle Butke would be excellent as the interim. She is savvy and will not be a candidate. If she is not selected, I would select either Susan Gutowsky or Nate Budd. Both bring experiences well-related to governing and, while they have particular areas of interest and expertise, they view the whole exceedingly well. I've known and worked with both on various projects and would feel comfortable their decision-making processes. Both have the highest integrity. Nate brings the connection with CSU and community non-profits. Susan brings a PSD perspective as teacher and board member. John Clarke has served the community well, but I'd like a fresh perspective. The others should be thanked for stepping up, but each seemed to have a particular focus. I prefer those who have broader perspectives. I should note that we live in the GMA, are retired, and for many years had a business housed in Fort Collins. Fort Collins provided us the best life we could have imagined. 27 Jessica Hazlett would be an amazing person to fill the role. She is not only passionate about anything she puts heart heart into, she also keeps her word and follows through. 28 Jessica Hazlett, brings with her compassion, intellect and an unwavering drive and work ethic. She is an accomplished cellist, song writer and a creative force that would be a great addition to FOCO, City Council. 29 a 30 Please select Joe Somodi. He is a thoughtful man who is a superb listener and is able to take action. He works well with a team even those he disagrees with. 31 I fully support Joe Somodi as the candidate that would be the best fit for District 1 and Ft Collins. I have worked with Joe on the Human Relations Commission, on FOCO Speaks Out and other community projects. Joe is organized, respectful, responsive and willing to work hard to find effective solutions that will be the best for everyone. Joe is a pleasure to work with and cares deeply about the Ft. Collins Community. Please choose Joe Somodi as the next District 1 representative. 32 Joseph Somodi is the clear leader of the group of candidates. He is smart, thoughtful, a good listener and can assimilate information quickly. More importantly, he makes decisions that just make sense. Joe is the clear choice. 33 Joe is my first pick. Aligns with all of the valuable characteristics I would expect in a person for this position. 34 I know Joe Somodi III best and I believe that his objectivity would help him be a great councilman ResponseID Response 10 20.12 Packet Pg. 507 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 35 I have known Joe Somodi for five years as an artist, a life coach, and a friend, and he has consistently demonstrated that he is committed to the betterment of individuals as well communities both large and small. He is a deep listener with exceptional compassion, never backs down from a challenge, is a creative problem solver, and a lover of life and humanity from all walks. I believe he is the right voice for right now. His 20 Years of Small Business Experience make him the best choice, and I know him to be thorough and pragmatic in his decision making. Ever since Joe moved to Fort Collins, he has been deeply connected and dedicated to the diverse and rich fabric of the community. 36 Joseph Somodi III is the absolute personification of the traits I mentioned above. I came to know Joe through his spouse who has been a dear friend of mine for almost 40 years. Joe accepted me as a client when I hired him to help me train/prepare mentally and physically for a 500-mile European hike in 2016. I was so impressed by his professionalism and the highly effective, practical plan he developed for me. Joe is an intelligent, kind, and strong leader who has quickly come to understand the joys and the challenges of Front Range living. I remember when Joe and his family chose Fort Collins as their home. It was a thoughtful and deliberate choice, based not only on what the city could provide to them, but also for the energy and commitment he and his family were excited to bring to Fort Collins. Although new to Colorado, Joe is adaptable, considerate, and no-nonsense. He'll bring fresh ideas and an understanding of urban and suburban living to the Council. His natural charm will make him well-suited to represent values of a diverse Fort Collins community. I highly recommend him to you for District 1 City Councilmember. 37 I'm Tyler Goodspeed and I've lived in Fort Collins for 7 years now. I'm a CSU Alumni and I'm a CPA in town at Plante Moran. I have known Joe now for 2 years. He's a neighbor and a good friend. Joe always asks amazing questions, is an excellent listener, does his research, and welcomes all points of views! Please choose Joseph Somodi! He's the right choice for right now! 38 I think you should select either Susan Gutowski or Nate Budd--I think generational change is important to a city with our demographics, which would shade to Nate. 39 Susan Gutowsky would be an exceptional person for the FC City Council! I am excited for she would be excellent in this spot. Susan Gutowsky will be an excellent fit for our City Council. I am supporting her and hope she will be successful!!! 40 I would recommend Susan Gutowsky - she gave an incredible speech last October in the Town Square about the educational issues/needs of all age groups - something which is very important for pre-school through college. 41 I support Joe Somodi. He seems dedicated and caring and committed to listening to the citizens of Fort Collins. 42 I support Joe Somodi because of his commitment to sustainability and inclusivity. 43 Susan Gutowsky meets my criteria for a qualified candidate. She has served well on the PSD Board where she has shown herself to be dedicated and thoughtful. ResponseID Response 11 20.12 Packet Pg. 508 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 44 The candidates most appealing are Danielle Buttke and Nathaniel Budd. Both were prepared, well-spoken, and would bring valuable experience and perspectives to Council.The other candidates fell into one of the following categories: 1. More of the same, 2. Not serious or prepared, 3. Did not present tangible evidence of qualifications or value they would bring, 4. Did not seem to have a handle on the type of issues constituents in District 1 care about, and/or 5. Did not seem to understand the range and type of constituents in District 1. 45 Susan Gutowsky is my neighbor in District 1. I have known her for several years and know that she is intelligent, enthusiastic, practical, well-read, a gardener and very kind. As a former teacher she has many many skills, since teachers can do almost anything. She will be a fine Councilmember. After all, she's been a fine school board member. 46 I actually watched the meeting but do not recall names. Believe the PhD vet would be a fresh look and offer bright solutions even though she would not be running in April. The woman on the school board could be a formidable candidate. Several of the others may be good; however, let's find someone who knows, understands and will be in the community on behalf of economic engagement. I encourage you to think outside the box. 48 I think Joseph Somodi lll would be an incredible voice for the community 49 I think Joe Somodi would be a wonderful addition to the city council. 50 Joseph Somodi- brilliant, empathetic, motivated, loving, listens, understanding to the economically diverse populations 52 John Clarke is a known conservative with very fixed opinions. Susan Gutowsky is well informed, capable and suitable for the position. I do not know enough about the others to comment. 53 I would like to endorse Susan Gutowsky. I think she has a wonderful handle on the community and is fair and strategic when considering community issues. Additionally, I think it would be lovely to have more than one woman serving on our council. 54 Susan Gutowsky has been a long time friend and City advocate. She is very out-going truthful and everything she does and says is well planned and thought out. She cares about our city and has the best intentions to make our City great is everyway possible. She should be the next Council member for District 1 55 Joe Somodi is my choice as he fulfills all my expectations of a City Councilmember. He is familiar with the city, small business minded, thoughtful, he values other's opinions, knowledgeable and able to work with people of all backgrounds. I think he is exactly what our city needs. ResponseID Response 12 20.12 Packet Pg. 509 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 56 Joe Somodi III embodies the qualities that will make a good council member. He has a strong position on downtown density in order to foster strong economic security. He is compassionate but pragmatic about homelessness. He is a strong arts advocate. He represents the LGBTQ community. He is a strong fiscal manager with a passion for budgeting. In short, he is the ideal city council member. 57 Joe Somodi III embodies the qualities that will make a good council member. He has a strong position on downtown density in order to foster strong economic security. He is compassionate but pragmatic about homelessness. He is a strong arts advocate. He represents the LGBTQ community. He is a strong fiscal manager with a passion for budgeting. In short, he is the ideal city council member. 58 I am unfamiliar with most of the candidates but I have gotten to know Joe Somodi over the last couple of years and I fully support his bid for this position. Joe is a warm and caring person first and foremost. He has a great compassion for inclusion and diversity. He is open minded and accepting of views different from his own, which seem to be unfortunately rare attributes these days. 59 I also know Joe cares DEEPLY for his community. This has been evident to me in our conversations since he and his partner have moved there. He LOVES Fort Collins and I know is deeply committed to seeing it realize its fullest potential as a vibrant, thriving, inclusive and diverse community. 60 I have known Jerry Gavaldon almost 20 years as a resident of the Stonehenge community in Fort Collins. For many of those years Jerry served on committees for the Home Owners Association and was later a long-serving President of the Stonehenge HOA. He is an idea man, and thoroughly researches options to select the best result. He does his homework. He follows through with an issue until it is resolved. As president of the HOA, he is in charge of notifying hundreds of residents of issues in a timely manner, and presides over the annual HOA meetings thoroughly yet concisely. In my experience he has been fair and responsible. I believe his thoroughness and hard work would be an asset to the Fort Collins city council. His ability to hear and understand multiple viewpoints speaks to his ability to contribute to the council. 61 I believe Joseph Somodi would make a great council member because of his integrity, commitment to Fort Collins, progressive believes, and financial responsibility. 62 Nate Budd is a fantastic candidate! John Clarke would be good too, but perpetuates the "old retired white guy syndrome." Many of the other candidates are underqualified and/or are too radical/ideological 63 Have not been able to watch the interviews on comcast, I would pick Richard Cress because it looks like he lives in the North-East Richards Lake area, and we have never had anyone support us. ResponseID Response 13 20.12 Packet Pg. 510 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 65 I will only give feedback on those I know. Nate Budd - balanced candidate, was an excellent choice when he ran 2 years ago. Very thoughtful on decisions. John Clarke - great experience, but has he been out of the loop for too long? Jerry Gavaldon - activist, very narrow view of the City. Doesn't seem too smart, either. Susan Gutowski - could be a good choice, but not too sure on her experience with city politics. Don't know the rest, which, since I do keep an eye on city politics, says they are not involved, which is not a good thing. I want someone knowledgeable of council's duties & past experiences. 66 I would highly recommend Sue Gutowsky as I have known her for a long time as a friend, neighbor, fellow educator, PSD School Board member, and one who is active in political events. I have always respected her as a person and as someone I can trust to be fair to others, listens to diverse viewpoints, has plenty of energy for the task, has shown her expertise serving on the School Board, and one who could easily step into the position without a steep learning curve. Sue easily fills all the attributes I listed above. I do not perceive any limitations choosing Sue as a Council member. 67 Joe Somodi would be a great fit for this position. He is caring and compassionate and has a passion for helping and for our city. He has a progressive outlook and is very forward thinking. He has fantastic networking skills. 68 I live in District 1, Old Town Fort Collins. I recommend Susan Gutowsky for the District 1 vacancy seat for City Council. I have known Susan for 8 years and when she was on School Board. I can't think of a better person to fill this vacancy than Susan Gutowsky. While on PSD school board Susan has always been available and can answer any questions about PSD in a fast and professional and friendly manner. She is very dedicated to ensuring the voice of the people is heard. Susan is the person we need in District 1 City Council. State Senator Joann Ginal 69 I believe Jerry Gavaldon, has all of the qualities listed above. He grew up in Fort Collins and has a lot of historical knowledge. Mr. Gavaldon is well known and respected in the Fort Collins community. In addition, Mr. Gavaldon is honest and fair, and I believe he would make an excellent Council person. In my opinion, he possesses the qualifications necessary in representing the people as well as the City of Fort Collins. ResponseID Response 14 20.12 Packet Pg. 511 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 70 IN SUPPORT OF JOSEPH SOMODI III Dear Distinguished Members of the Fort Collins City Council, Happy New Year, and I hope this note finds you well. This is Dr. Patrick Rishe (www.patrickrishe.com), and I'm a Professor of Economics and the Director of the Sports Business Program at Washington University in St. Louis...a Top 20 university nationally. I also write for Forbes, have run a sports consulting practice since 2000, and am the recent author of a book on leadership and strategy in the sports industry...which leans heavily on insights from 50 of America's leading sports business executives. I recently learned that my friend of nearly 25 years, Joe Somodi, is running for the vacated seat in District 1. Mr. Somodi and I became acquainted in college at Binghamton University in NYS in 1994, and have stayed in touch thereafter. As such, I'm uniquely qualified to lend this group my insights of Mr. Somodi's qualities and characteristics which would make him ideally suited to join your group. If I learned anything from my book project in my research on leadership when speaking with the high-profile executives I had the pleasure of meeting, it was the importance for leaders to (1) be good listeners, (2) be well-informed, and (3) be "bridge-builders". Without question, Mr. Somodi possesses each of these attributes in large quantities. He's an excellent listener and communicator, he enjoys consuming information and being educated on issues important to the community, and he genuinely cares about people. Apart from these necessary attributes, he is - as you saw from his interview several days ago - articulate, good natured, and carries a sense of diversity and youthful exuberance that would serve as an energetically positive "shot-in-the-arm" to both the council's make-up and the community as a whole. While Mr. Somodi is a relative newcomer to the community, it's my sense that his reason for running for District 1 stems from his deep affection for the Fort Collins community, and a sense of empowerment he's felt from several community members encouraging him to run for this vacated seat. This latter fact alone speaks volume of how he would be received by the community at large. I'm excited for your community, as it appears to be a wonderful place to live/work/play. But I'd be even more excited if Mr. Somodi were to obtain a seat at your distinguished table. Because he brings to that table both the passion, the intelligence, the thoughtfulness, and the humility I suspect you would want in a colleague. I plan on sharing these same sentiments in the online application form, but I wanted to take the extra time/effort to reach out to you personally via email to express my thoughts regarding Mr. Somodi's qualifications. Thank you for your time and consideration. Patrick Dr. Patrick Rishe 314.540.4017 www.patrickrishe.com Director, Sports Business Program, Washington University in St. Louis Founder/CEO, Sportsimpacts Sports Business Contributor, FORBES.com 71 Joseph Somodi III has demonstrated his passion, creativity, drive to improve our city and our communities since becoming a Fort Collin resident. His desire to create a more inclusive and outspoken Fort Collins has already been witnessed through the impactful projects and events he created for this community. He's ability to listen to others and ask poignant questions sets him a part as a leader and a friend. I believe Joseph Somodi would be an incredible choice to help lead this city. 72 I strongly support Nate Budd because he has an understanding of the underemployment in our community and he is interested in attainable housing solutions. Nate is young, energetic, well read and comes without a political agenda. It is time for a fresh face in city leadership with a candidate that I perceive to be well grounded and respectful of others. ResponseID Response 15 20.12 Packet Pg. 512 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 73 Joseph Somodi is the only candidate I'm familiar with. I think he would make an excellent council member as he embodies all the qualities listed above. 75 I've worked with Joe Somodi on La Familia's annual fundraiser this past spring and I've seen Joe's hard work, willingness to go the extra mile and dedication to a cause firsthand. Joe gets things done. On top of everything else he did to make the event a success he also created a gorgeous video presentation that La Familia can use in future fundraising. Joe's involvement made a tremendously positive impact on the success of this event. I believe Joe's leadership, small business experience, pragmatism and hard work make Joe an ideal candidate for City Council. ResponseID Response 3. Do you live in Fort Collins? 85% 85%Yes Yes 15% 15%No No Value Percent Responses Yes 84.8% 56 No 15.2% 10 Totals: 66 4. How long have you lived here? 16 20.12 Packet Pg. 513 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) ResponseID Response 2 11.5 years 3 30 years 5 15 years 6 18 years 7 17 years 9 7 years 11 5 years 12 16 years 13 13.5 years 14 8 years 15 28 years 17 10 years 19 5 years 20 5 years 22 43 years 23 45yrs And my parents are natives of Fort Collins 24 50 yrs I was born and raised here. 27 9.5 years 28 1964-1970 and for the last 5 years. 29 3 30 50 years 31 45 years 32 21 years 37 7 years 17 20.12 Packet Pg. 514 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 38 39 years 39 almost 24 years 40 15 years 41 20 years 42 6 years, but does it matter? 43 49 years 44 10 years 45 9 years 46 4 years; moving here from another part of CO 49 22 years 50 14 years 52 nearly all of my life; I am a native 54 16 years 55 24 years 58 12 years 60 20 years 61 14 Months 62 22 years 63 native 65 20 years 66 48 years 67 30 years 68 30 yrs 69 28 years ResponseID Response 18 20.12 Packet Pg. 515 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 71 15 Years 72 33 years 73 6 years 74 34 years 75 8 years ResponseID Response 5. Are you a resident of District 1? (If unsure, find your current district.) 51% 51%Yes Yes 49% 49%No No Value Percent Responses Yes 50.9% 28 No 49.1% 27 Totals: 55 6. Do you work in or own a business in Fort Collins? 19 20.12 Packet Pg. 516 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) 68% 68%Yes Yes 32% 32%No No Value Percent Responses Yes 68.2% 45 No 31.8% 21 Totals: 66 20 20.12 Packet Pg. 517 Attachment: Website Feedback Form Responses Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: wsee252@aol.com To: City Leaders Cc: wsee252@aol.com Subject: Letter of Support for Susan Gutowsky Date: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 4:43:04 PM To Whom it may concern: I am writing to you as someone who has personally worked beside Susan Gutowsky. I am a fan of her dedication to any requested task and her willingness to serve others. Susan has been an active Board Member for Project Smile since the origination of our organization, several of those years while she was still working on the school board. She is an able and dependable leader and gave great support to the mission and activities surrounding our work at Project Smile. Our Board Members are asked to help out in many different ways and at many different functions. She was comfortable working with kids and their parents as well as sponsors and donors to our cause. We counted on her to volunteer at our dental/vision screenings, helping putting together the "goodie bags" of dental supplies for the school kids and working to organize and participate in our fundraiser events. She could always be counted on to come to meetings prepared to contribute with well thought out questions and helpful suggestions for improving our efforts. In my opinion, the people of the City of Fort Collins would be well served by Susan on the City Council, just as the children of Poudre School District have been well served through her dedication to Project Smile! Sincerely, Bill See Chairman, Project Smile Corporation EMAILS RECEIVED - ATTACHMENT13 20.13 Packet Pg. 518 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Christophe Febvre To: City Leaders Subject: Letter in support of Susan Gutowsky Date: Tuesday, January 8, 2019 10:45:33 AM Esteemed colleagues and Members of City Council, It is with mixed feelings that I write you a letter of support for Susan Gutowsky as she seeks to fill the vacated Fort Collins City Council District 1 seat. Should the PSD Board of Education lose Susan for the remainder of her term, we will find ourselves in a pinch to replace her thoughtful leadership, her meaningful experience, and her eloquent demeanor. However, I would ultimately feel quite good should she be given the opportunity to continue her life-long commitment to serving our community. Susan is deeply caring, passionate, and willing to advocate and lead. I recently nominated Susan for a McGuffey Award through the Colorado Association of School Boards (CASB) which she did receive. As part of what I wrote for the nomination, and which was read out loud in front of the entire Regional Conference, I stated, “In those seven years on the PSD Board, Susan has modeled a dignified eloquence at all the right times, a thoughtful but determined attitude that has helped drive improvements across the District, a passion for networking and creating community connections to the school district, and a willingness to step forward and take on board leadership.” I think these comments capture Susan’s role on our elected school board. I fully expect Susan will bring these attributes to the Fort Collins City Council in a way that will contribute to collaborative engagement, provide positive bearing and thoughtful words in the course of discussions, and add to the overall decision making process. Over the course of Susan’s terms on the PSD School Board, she has been central to some important changes to the system. An example of this was when she championed the idea of adding “Connections” as one of the District’s four major themes within it’s stated Ends. This deceptively simple end has turned out to be truly novel and innovative and is changing the way the District works to educate students in ways that are proving to be quite impactful. This is the type of work I will expect the Fort Collins City Council to benefit from with Susan Gutowsky’s membership. Please feel free to write to me or call me should any of you want to further explore my knowledge of Susan’s work on the PSD School Board. Respectfully and with kind regards, Christophe Christophe Febvre (President, PSD School Board) CEO DGCD, Inc. (970) 292-5880 (970) 227-0282 – Cell www.DGCDinc.com 20.13 Packet Pg. 519 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Francisco Romero To: City Leaders Subject: City Council member Date: Friday, January 4, 2019 1:49:06 PM I very strongly support Jessica Hazlitt in her bid to fill Mr. Overbeck’s seat on the Council. Jessica possesses strong organizational skills, intellect, and a passion for advocating for others. She has been tireless in expanding her knowledge about City functions and has been instrumental in organizing people to become more involved as citizens. She will bring a fresh perspective to the Council’s work. Francisco Romero Colonel, ARNG J.D., SHRM-CP Sent from my iPhone 20.13 Packet Pg. 520 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Rogers, Gary To: City Leaders Subject: Susan Gutowsky Date: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 10:53:13 AM To the Members of City Council, I am writing in support of Susan Gutowsky’s interest in filling the vacant position for District 1 on the City Council. I believe Susan has the interest and abilities to significantly contribute to the work of the City Council. I met Susan approximately 3 years ago when we both participated in a day-long strategic planning session for the Poudre School District and the Poudre School District Foundation. It was apparent early on that she has a sincere interest in making our community better. Her comments throughout that day struck me as involved, engaged, and intently looking for better ways for the Foundation and School District to work together. In April of 2018, I was hired as the Executive Director of the Poudre School District Foundation and have since worked more directly with Susan in her various roles with our organization. Susan is an ex-officio member of the Foundation’s Board, the Chairperson of the Excellence In Education Awards event hosted by the Foundation to provide recognition for outstanding educators, and a member of the Board of Education. Our Foundation is in the middle of re-envisioning our “big why” and we have navigated countless conversations related to “the way we have always done” v. “what should we do now”. These conversations aren’t usually easy for board members and some become entrenched in one way or the other, while other members may hide and wait to see how the conversation turns out. Not Susan. On many occasions I have witnessed her politely sharing her opinion as to why we used to do things a certain way and then share why things in the “new way” may make sense. She has the vision to be able to blend the good from the past with the potential for the future. I truly value the leadership ability to value the past, envision the future, and then invite others to see potential. She has this ability in spades. Because of our work together, we have had several discussions around creating opportunities for those that could use a hand up (not a handout). I believe her to be truly entrenched in her desire to utilize her efforts and abilities to help others succeed. Another trait of hers that I admire. Susan is friendly (even in disagreement), passionate about our community, gracious to others, and committed to making a difference in our community through her involvement. I imagine her interests, abilities, and skills would be a welcome addition to the City Council. Her abilities to communicate and collaborate may prove even more valuable to this City Council, given that the remainder of the term is only a few short months. Sincerely, Gary Rogers 20.13 Packet Pg. 521 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Executive Director Poudre School District Foundation 970.490.3248 office 970.619.0794 mobile psdfoundation.org 20.13 Packet Pg. 522 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Jeannie Craft To: City Leaders Subject: Susan Gutowsky Date: Monday, January 7, 2019 4:25:33 PM To Whom It May Concern, I strongly believe that Susan Gutowsky is the best candidate to fill the City Council seat for District 1, left vacant by Bob Overbeck. She was instrumental in the work needed to get the non-profit Project Smile started in Poudre School District (PSD). She was one of Project Smile's original board members and volunteered at the dental/vision screenings, putting together the "goodie bags," and organizing our annual fundraising luncheon. I also have had the opportunity to work on the Excellence in Education celebrations for outstanding PSD teachers with Susan. She put together three amazing award celebrations for Excellence in Education. She has an eye for detail. I believe that Susan's service is her passion. She has worked tirelessly with many community members for the benefit of our local children. She really cares. Jeannie Craft Operations Coordinator Project Smile 1100 Gregory Road Fort Collins, CO 80524 970-215-1189 20.13 Packet Pg. 523 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Kimberly Baker Medina To: City Leaders Subject: Nomination of Susan Gutowsky Date: Monday, January 7, 2019 4:15:00 PM Honorable Mayor and Members of City Council I am writing in support of the nomination of Susan Gutowsky for City Council. I first met Susan when she was running for the School Board and she reached out to me in an effort to gain information about the needs of Hispanic and Immigrant children in our community. I grew up in Fort Collins, attended PSD schools, worked at the Family Center for 4 years as a parent educator for Spanish speaking parents and have worked as an Immigration Attorney in Fort Collins for the past 16 years. I am a volunteer in PSD schools and with several community organizations. I am a parent, property and business owner, and my immediate and extended family live in Fort Collins. I was encouraged when Susan reached out to me at the beginning of her tenure with PSD and she did not disappoint me during her time on the Board. Susan has a deep knowledge of the Fort Collins community and a heartfelt desire to serve that community. She takes the time to educate herself and seeks the input of constituents and stakeholders in the issues that come before her. As our city grows and we see an influx of newcomers, it is important that someone speak for the members of our community with a less powerful voice, and I believe that Susan is that person. I know that you share a desire to see the benefits of living in this beautiful city extend to all of our residents and having Susan on the Board will help you to ensure that we all thrive as our city continues to grow and change, and that no members of our community are left behind. I also believe that it is important that the membership of the Board reflect the residents of our city, and I believe that Susan, as a Hispanic woman who grew up in our town, would provide a needed presence on the Board. In addition, her long experience with PSD would help the city continue to forge strong alliances with our schools, educators and families. I have observed in Susan as she works with parents, students, staff and teachers in PSD and have been greatly impressed with her work. I would be delighted to see that work continue in support of our city. Please let me know if you have any questions or need any additional information about Susan. Sincerely, Kimberly B. Medina -- Kimberly Baker Medina 308 Cherry Street Fort Collins, CO 80521 Office: 970-388-3332 Cell: 970-308-1184 Fax: 970-232-9455 20.13 Packet Pg. 524 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Services limited to immigration law. Licensed to practice in Federal and California courts Virus-free. www.avast.com 20.13 Packet Pg. 525 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Mark Keller To: City Leaders Cc: "susan.gutowsky@gmail.com" Subject: FW: sue gutowsky letter of recommendation Date: Wednesday, January 9, 2019 3:24:36 PM Dear City Council, I have been fortunate to have known Susan Gutowsky as a friend and client for over thirty years. Her twenty six years as a public school teacher followed by eight years as a director on the Poudre School District Board of Education put her at the top of the class. I was a special educator for over twenty years, proud father of two PSD graduates and a realtor in Fort Collins for the last 15 years. Over time, I have watched Susan display a wonderful stewardship of the challenges between financial obligation and community vision. She is the type of person you can bet on to keep her cool in a stressful situation as her sense of humor always takes over. Service is Susan’s passion and I am confident she will work tirelessly to ensure our city remains clean, safe and prosperous. Most importantly, she is fair-minded, thoughtful and has a huge heart. I highly recommend Susan Gutowsky for City Council. Please feel free to contact me at anytime, 970-219-5570. Sincerely, Mark Keller Mark Keller RE/MAX Advanced, Inc. 1018 Centre Ave. Fort Collins, CO 80526 Cell: (970)219-5570 20.13 Packet Pg. 526 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) From: Mary Hasl To: City Leaders Cc: Darin Atteberry Subject: Susan Gutowsky Date: Tuesday, January 8, 2019 4:34:58 PM Dear Fort Collins City Leaders, It is with great enthusiasm that I take a moment to share my thoughts with you about Susan Gutowsky as you consider her application to serve on the Fort Collins City Council. I have had the honor of knowing Susan for many years as an educator and as a school board member and her impressive service compels me to connect with you on her behalf. No doubt you receive numerous emails singing the praises of what makes each candidate the best choice and I am sure they are all accurate. Fort Collins is an exceptional place to live filled with many visionary and thoughtful leaders. Let me tell you what makes Susan different. Susan has the most pure agenda you could ever desire from someone serving in public office; she only wants to make Fort Collins a better place for people to thrive and to enjoy a great quality of life that is accessible to all. Susan does not seek office to fight for her own isolated priorities, she seeks office so she can listen and represent the priorities of the community. Susan is not motivated by power, she is motivated by purpose. Susan's 8 years on the Poudre School District School Board are proof positive that she is a thoughtful listener, fair in her decision making, tenacious in her dedication, and steadfastly committed to the greater good. We are living in uncertain and decisive times. Unfortunately, people have become cynical about the integrity of leaders and are reluctant to believe that their voice truly matters even in Fort Collins where we have wonderful representation. In Susan Gutowsky you will have a council member who will open doors and who will help to enhance the communities faith and trust in government. Susan's presence on city council will provide inspiration to her fellow council members and hope to her community. The Fort Collins community will know that their voice matters. I am so glad that Susan with her vast talents, impressive knowledge, and compassionate heart knocked on your door. Please welcome her in as a member of City Council. 20.13 Packet Pg. 527 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Thank you so much for your time. Mary Hasl Fort Collins Community Member~35 years 20.13 Packet Pg. 528 Attachment: Emails Received Through January 9, 2019 (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) January 15, 2019 District 1 Vacancy Interviews Delynn Coldiron, City Clerk ATTACHMENT 14 20.14 Packet Pg. 529 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) District 1 Vacancy Interviews December 18, 2018 – Approved process that would be used to fill vacancy December 12, 2018 – Advertising began December 26, 2018 – Deadline to submit applications • Received 10 applications January 2, 2019 – Interviews • 8 Candidates 2 20.14 Packet Pg. 530 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) District 1 Vacancy Interviews Qualifications: • United States Citizen • At least 21 years of age • Resident of District 1 • Registered voter for at least one year • No felony convictions 3 20.14 Packet Pg. 531 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) District 1 Vacancy Interviews Candidates Interviewed: 1. Nathaniel Budd 2. Danielle Buttke 3. E. John Clarke 4. Richard Cress 5. Jerry Gavaldon 6. Susan Gutowsky 7. Jessica Hazlett 8. Joseph Somodi III 4 Candidate Not Interviewed: 1. Christopher Staten 20.14 Packet Pg. 532 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) Candidate Feedback January 3, 2019 – Request for Feedback • Feedback Form on City’s Website • Emails to Council • Facebook, Nextdoor • Written letters January 9, 2019 – provided with Council agenda materials. January 15, 2019 – provided in read-before packets. 5 20.14 Packet Pg. 533 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) District 1 Vacancy Interviews Tonight’s Process: • Public Comment • Motions and votes • Resolution Next Steps: • Possible postponement if no applicant receives a majority vote. • Oath of office given on January 22 • Onboarding 6 20.14 Packet Pg. 534 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) District 1 Applicants 1. Nathaniel Budd 2. Danielle Buttke 3. E. John Clarke 4. Richard Cress 5. Jerry Gavaldon 6. Susan Gutowsky 7. Jessica Hazlett 8. Joseph Somodi, III 9. Christopher Staten 7 20.14 Packet Pg. 535 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (7552 : District 1 Councilmember Appointment) -1- RESOLUTION 2019-014 OF THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FORT COLLINS MAKING AN APPOINTMENT TO FILL A VACANCY FOR COUNCILMEMBER FOR DISTRICT 1 ON THE FORT COLLINS COUNCIL WHEREAS, a vacancy for Council District 1 was created by the resignation of Councilmember Bob Overbeck effective January 1, 2019; and WHEREAS, the Charter of the City of Fort Collins provides that the City Council shall fill such vacancy by appointment within forty-five days, and that the appointed Councilmember shall serve until the next regular election, when District 1 voters will elect a Council representative for a four-year term; and WHEREAS, the Council has carefully considered a number of applications received from qualified District 1 residents to fill such vacancy and has interviewed such applicants; and WHEREAS, the City Council desires to appoint _____________ to fill said vacancy on the Fort Collins City Council to serve until the District 1 voters elect a representative at the April 2, 2019, regular municipal election, and the elected individual has taken office. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FORT COLLINS that _______ is hereby appointed to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of Councilmember Bob Overbeck and to serve as District 1 Councilmember on the Fort Collins City Council until an elected representative for District 1 has taken office following the April 2, 2019, regular municipal election. Passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Council of the City of Fort Collins this 15th day of January, A.D. 2019. __________________________________ Mayor ATTEST: _____________________________ City Clerk Packet Pg. 536