Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOUNCIL - AGENDA ITEM - 02/25/2014 - LINCOLN CORRIDOR PLAN UPDATEDATE: STAFF: February 25, 2014 Amy Lewin, Transportation Planner Pete Wray, Senior City Planner WORK SESSION ITEM City Council SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION Lincoln Corridor Plan Update. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this item is to update City Council on the status of the Lincoln Corridor Plan. Staff invites feedback and direction on the proposed Preferred Alternative design, transit phasing, neighborhood projects, and next steps in the planning process. GENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED 1. What feedback or questions does Council have on the proposed Preferred Alternative design? 2. What comments and direction does Council have regarding the proposed transit phasing or neighborhood projects? BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION The Lincoln Corridor Plan is a 12-month planning project to develop a long-term multi-modal roadway design for Lincoln Avenue from Jefferson Street to Lemay Avenue and to identify related improvement projects in the study area. The planning effort is focused on developing: • A community-driven corridor vision for Lincoln Avenue • A preferred multi-modal roadway design • Recommendations for implementing infrastructure projects in the surrounding neighborhoods • Preliminary project costs • Project funding options and phasing • Implementation strategies and actions Previous planning efforts, such as the Mountain Vista Subarea Plan (1999), the Northside Neighborhoods Plan (2005), and the Pedestrian Plan (2011) noted existing infrastructure deficiencies in the Lincoln area. Subsequently, the Lincoln Corridor was identified in City Plan (2011) as an important “catalyst area” with the potential for desirable social, economic, and environmental benefits that combines public and private sector initiatives. The Lincoln Corridor Plan was included in the 2013/14 budget and work program and Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) as a priority project. As both a transportation corridor plan and a strategic implementation plan, this effort is well positioned to address emerging issues in the corridor and surrounding neighborhoods, including opportunities for addressing numerous existing infrastructure deficiencies, enhancing Lincoln as a gateway and connection to Downtown and East Mulberry, and improving safety and mobility within this corridor. The Lincoln Corridor Plan represents an overall community-supported vision for the Lincoln corridor and a clear roadmap for strategies to implement that vision. The Plan not only provides a preferred street design for Lincoln Avenue (between Jefferson Street and Lemay Avenue), but also addresses a broader context, making recommendations for related infrastructure projects in the surrounding area that further advance implementation of existing neighborhood and transportation plans. The Plan will include implementation strategies, an action plan, potential phasing/timeframes, and potential funding sources. February 25, 2014 Page 2 The project was initiated in March 2013 and is led by a team of FC Moves and Planning staff, with support from a multi-departmental Technical Advisory Committee and consultants. The Plan will be presented to City Council for consideration of adoption in April 2014. The Plan is divided into three phases: Phase 1 - Vision (April - July 2013) * Complete Phase 2 - Corridor Design Alternatives (August - October 2013) * Complete Phase 3 - Preferred Alternative/Implementation Planning (November 2013 - April 2014) * In Progress The Phase 1 project efforts were documented in a memo provided to Council dated August 27, 2013 (Attachment 1) and included documentation and analysis of existing and future conditions, summary of the project’s robust community engagement, and development of a corridor vision. During the transition from Phase 1 to Phase 2 the project team developed an initial Triple Bottom Line (TBL) Analysis and Summary of this early brainstorming effort. This TBL analysis helped guide the development of alternatives, community engagement, and the development of evaluation criteria. More recently, the TBL Analysis and Summary were updated to reflect the Preferred Alternative and Implementation approaches (Attachment 2). Recent Community Engagement Community engagement since the last work session in October included the third Stakeholder Group meeting, as well as many one-on-one and small group meetings with businesses and residents in the corridor. The project team also visited with Boards and Commissions. The project posted an online survey January 17-31 (approximately 170 respondents), and hosted a Public Open House January 23 (69 attendees); a summary of the survey and Open House is in Attachment 3. While the initial Preferred Alternative generally received support from the public, key stakeholders recently identified a few remaining concerns to address, including: • Need for existing driveway accesses • Need to accommodate truck movements • Concern about potential congestion • Strong desire by some residents to maintain driveway access from front of residences In response, Staff refined the Preferred Alternative to accommodate the needs of existing businesses and residents, and to provide a flexible framework that responds to future potential development. An example of this flexibility is illustrated in the Preferred Alternative that accommodates existing business driveway access for current operations, while identifying future options for driveway consolidation upon redevelopment. Input from business owners and residents, with corresponding responses from staff are summarized in Attachment 4. Alternatives Analysis/Evaluation (Phase 2) In Phase 2, the project team developed and shared three draft corridor design alternatives with the public based on the Vision defined in Phase 1. The vision statement is as follows: The new Lincoln will be recognized as a Great Street1: an active and vibrant destination that celebrates our history and is a model for sustainability. These three alternatives were evaluated with a variety of factors, including performance criteria, level of community support, cost, and triple bottom line considerations. The performance criteria were based on a set of five objectives. These objectives emerged from the project goals and vision statement. For each of the objectives, key criteria were developed that support each objective: Objective #1 - Improve Multi-Modal Mobility Objective #2 - Improve Safety Objective #3 - Create Active Street Environment 1 As defined by Allan B. Jacobs in Great Streets (1995) February 25, 2014 Page 3 Objective #4 - Enhance Appearance Objective #5 - Incorporate Sustainable Street Design Practices These five objectives are organized into an alternatives evaluation table, which also includes considerations of cost as well as community support (Attachment 5). The evaluation table includes a "Base Alternative", which includes both the existing condition (which does not meet street standards) and the 2-lane minor arterial street standards. These provide a baseline by which the alternatives could be compared. Because the available right-of-way and adjacent land uses vary, the corridor was divided into three segments for the alternatives: • West Segment - Jefferson Street/Riverside Avenue through 1st Street (including the Lincoln Bridge) • Central Segment - 1st Street through 3rd Street (fronting the Buckingham neighborhood) • East Segment - 3rd Street through Lemay Avenue See Attachment 1 for a map of the segments. The three corridor design alternatives from Phase 2 incorporated various approaches to median widths and breaks, on-street parking, and bicycle and pedestrian facilities. These alternatives were presented and discussed at the October 22, 2013 Council Work Session (summarized in Attachment 6). Preferred Alternative (Phase 3) Based on the alternatives evaluation results described above, including costs and community support, the project team developed a draft Preferred Alternative by combining and refining the components of the alternatives for the West, Central, and East segments of the corridor that best supported the corridor vision. Key elements of the Preferred Alternative include: • Two travel lanes • Buffered bike lanes • Wide sidewalks (generally 10’ on north side, 8’ on south side) • Special pavement materials to enhance aesthetics and improve safety at driveways and intersections • Transit stops and shelters • On-street parking in select locations • Generous landscaped median • Streetscape amenities such as gathering areas, furniture, lighting, and art in public places • New Lincoln bridge design with an enhanced connection to the Poudre River • Low Impact Development (LID) applications to improve stormwater drainage and water quality • Reduction in speed limit to 30 mph (existing is 35 mph) The project team continued to meet with property and business owners and neighbors along the corridor to get feedback on the draft plan as the design evolved. A key part of this review included coordination of existing and future driveway access and potential right-of-way adjustments along the corridor. The Preferred Plan describes a phased approach for access and right-of-way changes to ensure existing conditions can work and also accommodate future redevelopment. The Preferred Alternative provides a solid framework for the future of the roadway with the flexibility to adapt as the corridor evolves. The Preferred Alternative plans and cross-sections are provided in Attachment 7. The project team identified a menu of streetscape amenities to include in the preferred design to support the desired vision of an active and attractive street environment. Several of these amenities, including gathering areas, special pedestrian crossing treatments, and locations for art, are shown in the Preferred Plan. Examples of additional amenities, such as street lighting design, furniture, and entry monuments are shown in Attachment 8. February 25, 2014 Page 4 Transit Since the October Work Session, the study team further assessed the various transit phasing options, including continuing the existing service on Lincoln (routes 5 and 14), enhancing existing service, adding a modified Downtown Circulator route (“Lincoln Shuttle”), adding the Lincoln Shuttle with a custom vehicle (e.g., rubber-tired trolley or innovative bus vehicle), and finally expanding to the full Downtown Circulator as described in the Transfort Strategic Operating Plan. A phased approach to service improvements is recommended, in concert with the increased development and demand expected in the corridor. For more details see Attachment 9. Other Neighborhood Projects In addition to the development of a design for Lincoln Avenue, another key component of the Lincoln Corridor Plan is to identify appropriate neighborhood infrastructure improvements and other projects that can be implemented in the area separate from the street reconstruction project. These are smaller projects that address longstanding existing deficiencies and enhance neighborhood livability. Some of these projects were already identified in previous plans (e.g., Northside Neighborhoods Plan, Pedestrian Plan), and some projects are new ideas that have arisen during this public process. The list of potential neighborhood projects was refined to best align with the corridor vision and objectives and meet realistic expectations for implementation. Examples of neighborhood infrastructure improvements and other projects are shown in Attachment 10 and include: • New and interim sidewalks (e.g., 3rd Street, east side of Lemay) • Enhanced pedestrian crossings (e.g., Lemay) • Transit stop improvements (e.g., Vine Drive just west of Lemay) • Neighborhood gateways • Signage/wayfinding plan for the breweries to reduce brewery traffic through the neighborhood These neighborhood improvements are important in addressing longstanding deficiencies in the area and could be implemented independently of the Lincoln Avenue improvements. The Lincoln Corridor Plan takes into account the planned realignment and improvements to Lemay Avenue and Vine Drive, as well as the related grade-separated crossings, as defined in the Master Street Plan. Several of the projects identified in the Lincoln Corridor Plan will help inform the plans for Vine and Lemay as that design progresses in the future. Next Steps in the Planning Process The next steps are to complete Phase 3-Preferred Alternative/Implementation Planning and finalize the plan document that summarizes the entire project and that will be presented to Council in April. Remaining Phase 3 items include addressing project costs, benefits, and phasing; potential funding options; and final implementation strategies and actions. Community engagement will continue throughout the process. Project Costs, Project Benefits, and Funding Options The preliminary estimated cost for reconstructing Lincoln is approximately $19 million (with $5 million of the total associated with the new Lincoln Bridge). The cost will be updated when the Preferred Alternative is finalized, and a detailed cost breakdown and potential phasing options will be included in the final plan. The benefits of supporting funding and implementation of the Lincoln project are significant. This project is identified in City Plan as an important catalyst project for the area and is included as a prioritized action item in the City’s Capital Improvement Plan. The new Lincoln Corridor will be an attractive and active street environment that is a source of community pride. Specifically, the Lincoln Corridor design will: • Address existing infrastructure deficiencies • Support economic activity • Encourage new development and redevelopment February 25, 2014 Page 5 • Enhance the existing historic neighborhood • Provide an attractive gateway to the Downtown and East Mulberry corridors • Improve and enhance safety and mobility • Incorporate best practices in sustainability A sample of potential funding options includes: • Dedicated sales tax (next round of Building on Basics) • Downtown Development Authority • Street Oversizing Fund • Keep Fort Collins Great (KFCG) • General Fund • State and federal grants The Lincoln Corridor Plan process has also provided an opportunity to advance other neighborhood-related improvements in the area. Securing funding for these smaller projects could be addressed in the near-term (e.g., in the 2015/16 budget process) and is important to address safety, connectivity, and to celebrate the historic and cultural qualities for the existing neighborhoods. Implementing these projects will also advance the work done in previous plans and address longstanding concerns within the neighborhoods. The project team is continuing to finalize the list of neighborhood projects, associated costs, and potential funding options available. Preliminary Implementation Strategies The project deliverables include preliminary design for Lincoln Avenue, as well as a prioritized list of suggested projects to enhance the surrounding neighborhoods. The Lincoln Corridor Plan will include a plan for implementation that lays out strategies and specific actions to take to implement the identified projects. A key step to implementation will be to secure funding for Lincoln Avenue design and construction and for the neighborhood improvement projects, as full funding for these projects has not yet been identified. Preliminary implementation strategies include: Lincoln Avenue 1. Secure funding 2. Finalize potential phasing 3. Prepare final design/construction plans and obtain approvals 4. Acquire right-of-way 5. Conduct construction operations to minimize impacts to businesses and residents Neighborhood Improvements 6. Secure funding 7. Implement phased transit enhancements/improvements (see Attachment 9) 8. Implement neighborhood-related infrastructure improvements (see Attachment 10) 9. Implement other programs and projects in area The project team is currently identifying specific actions associated with each strategy; these will be refined over the next few weeks and incorporated into the Lincoln Corridor Plan. Community Engagement Key community engagement milestones during the rest of the project include: February 2014 • Transportation and Planning Projects Open House (February 20) • City Council Work Session (February 25) March 2014 February 25, 2014 Page 6 • Stakeholder Group Meeting #4 (March 5) • Boards and Commissions Review and Recommendations April 2014 • Council consideration of adoption of Plan (April 1) ATTACHMENTS 1. Study Area Map (PDF) 2. TBL Summary Analysis (PDF) 3. Online Survey and Open House Summary (PDF) 4. Staff Responses to Public Input (PDF) 5. Alternatives Evaluation Table (PDF) 6. Work Session Summary, October 22, 2013 (PDF) 7. Preferred Alternative (PDF) 8. Streetscape Amenities (PDF) 9. Proposed Transit Phasing (PDF) 10. Neighborhood Projects Table (PDF) 11. PowerPoint Presentation (PDF) Lemay College Mulberry Vine Minor Roads Major Roads Streams Cache la Poudre River ¯ Buckingham Neighborhood Woodward Alta Vista Neighborhood Andersonville, Via Lopez, and San Cristo Neighborhoods Vine West Central East Lincoln Corridor Study Area Mulberry Area of Influence Lemay Linden Buckingham Jefferson/ Riverside N Po ud re River a n d T r a i l College ATTACHMENT 1 1 T t L o a I I I This summar to the propos Lincoln Corr observations action items I. Genera A. T B. M 1 2 C. C D. D ot op to E. L to F. M ou G. T II. Conclu A. T B. F w C. C ha D. R te III. Potenti A. A im 1 2 B. In ry reflects ke sed Preferred ridor Plan st and conclus for the Linc al Observatio The TBL analy Many consider . Crossing c . Crossing o City Plan iden During the TB ther columns pportunity to o property val Limitations hig o better under Much discussi Form Completed January 8, 2014 This form is based on research by the City of Olympia and Evergreen State College Triple Bottom Line Analysis Project or Decision: Lincoln Corridor Plan – Stage in Planning Process: Phase 3 - Preferred Plan Evaluated by: Lincoln Corridor Project Team and Social Economic TBL Team Environmental STRENGTHS:  Implements City Plan components  Is consistent with recent Master Street Plan downsizing of Lincoln from 4-lane to 2-lane arterial – Supported by neighborhoods  Neighborhood cohesiveness - amenities celebrate historic qualities of existing neighborhoods  Public engagement, increased understanding of neighborhood values, may lead to rebuilding trust  Increased street activity and connectivity – active streetscape  Safe environment, walkable community - "eyes on the street"  Driveway access for businesses was designed to both support existing and future needs and potentially improve safety  Maintains residential driveway access and provides resident amenities (e.g., on-street parking, landscape buffer)  Beautifying gateways - enhanced gateway to Downtown and to East Mulberry Corridor  New design supports reducing speed limit, which could improve overall safety  Plans for more frequent transit connection to Mason Corridor MAX and Downtown  Transit options may discourage cut-through traffic in Buckingham Neighborhood street network  New opportunity for corridor identity through streetscape amenities  Strong integration of art in public places, which will enhance cultural & aesthetic value of adjacent neighborhoods and businesses  Opportunities for people to connect to nature and observe / learn about natural systems in adjacent Poudre corridor and pocket areas  Proposes implementation of neighborhood projects that address longstanding concerns STRENGTHS:  Implements City Plan components  Affected neighbors may have increased property values  Reduced risk of flooding with improvements  Increased street activity and connectivity  Safe environment, walkable community  Flexibility incorporated into design that supports new development and redevelopment opportunities while supporting existing businesses  More attractive street and gateways – enhances economic potential for Downtown and East Mulberry areas  May enhance ridership potential on Mason Corridor/MAX and transit overall  Ties into Woodward enhancements associated with proposed development components  New opportunity for universal design (infrastructure) Form Completed January 8, 2014 This form is based on research by the City of Olympia and Evergreen State College Triple Bottom Line Analysis Project or Decision: Lincoln Corridor Plan – Stage in Planning Process: Phase 3 - Preferred Plan Evaluated by: Lincoln Corridor Project Team and Social Economic TBL Team Environmental LIMITATIONS:  Potential continued impacts to Buckingham neighborhood relating to cut-through traffic  Increased activity within the neighborhood may lead to perceived lack of safety, e.g., from increased transient traffic  Lack of access to businesses because of street improvements  Money spent on street project should not preclude funding for neighborhoods related projects  Traffic concerns/impacts on Buckingham Neighborhood during construction  Proposed reduction in speed limits could frustrate drivers used to higher speeds in corridor LIMITATIONS  Impacts to businesses in the area and close to Old Town due to construction  Some locations have less convenient access to businesses because of street improvements (e.g., due to medians restricting turn movements)  Green street features and street amenities increase project costs  Investment made here takes away from another area – priority of public dollars  Operations and Maintenance for streets and parks department, may increase level of effort and cost based on preferred design LIMITATIONS:  Construction often generates dust, carbon emissions, and consumes substantive fossil fuel resources  Increased activity due to construction can discourage wildlife travel and establishment in the area OPPORTUNITIES:  Recent public engagement has created a strong dialogue with the neighborhood and public – new best practice  Will be the first “New Great Street” project – if successful, may create similar street opportunities across FC  Neighborhood cohesiveness - opportunity to improve neighborhood collaboration  Increase aesthetics, more beautiful street  Improved health benefits created by encouraging more cycling and walking  Can offer new destination opportunities, i.e. brewery district, cultural/historical district, landmark building showcases  Could develop new partnerships and collaborations with breweries and future breweries  Could become a catalyst project for Northside Neighborhoods  May enhance community pride  Attractive streets tend to attract high quality developments and higher paying employment  New transportation vehicles may be prototyped within the district near Woodward Form Completed January 8, 2014 This form is based on research by the City of Olympia and Evergreen State College Triple Bottom Line Analysis Project or Decision: Lincoln Corridor Plan – Stage in Planning Process: Phase 3 - Preferred Plan Evaluated by: Lincoln Corridor Project Team and Social Economic TBL Team Environmental improve flood protection and overall community resilience  New education and awareness programs and signage could minimize impacts of cut-through traffic in neighborhood THREATS:  Increased traffic volumes impacting existing neighborhoods  If outreach efforts do not succeed, could lose neighborhood engagement and trust  Potential gentrification of neighborhoods by new development/redevelopment – potential impact on property values/taxes  Vine and Lemay intersection creates a transportation bottleneck near the new corridor – interim transportation solutions may be necessary  Creating “gateway” to downtown may increase use, changing integrity and feel of residential neighborhood  Right-of-way (ROW) negotiation sensitivity by businesses  Without funding for implementation of neighborhood projects, neighborhood trust could be impacted THREATS:  Floodplain - property damage, high potential  If vision does not drive funding opportunities, then what?  Vine and Lemay intersection creates a transportation bottleneck near the new corridor – interim transportation solutions may be necessary along Lemay Ave  ROW acquisition in select locations is part of achieving project vision but at the same time, impacts should be minimized  Potential gentrification of neighborhoods by new development/redevelopment – potential impact on property values/taxes  Could detract from other commercial corridors in the community by focusing on this area THREATS:  Increased activity due to construction can discourage wildlife travel and establishment in the area  Future flooding in area NOTES: Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 1 Lincoln Corridor Plan - Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan January 17-31, 2014 Approximately 170 Respondents Introduction The draft Lincoln Corridor Plan has been developed over the past 10 months with opportunities for public input throughout. It provides a vision for the Lincoln Corridor as well as strategies to implement the vision. The Plan includes a proposed street design for Lincoln Avenue (between Jefferson Street/Riverside Avenue and Lemay Avenue) and also makes recommendations for related projects in the surrounding area. The purpose of this survey is to get additional public input regarding the proposed street design, transit options, and possible neighborhood projects. This input will be used to finalize the draft plan before the City Council reviews the plan in March. This survey should take 10-15 minutes; thanks in advance for your input. ATTACHMENT 3 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 2 Study Area Map 1. Do you live in the Lincoln Corridor (shown on the map above)? Value Count Percent Yes 17 9.8% No 157 90.2% Statistics Total Responses 174 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 3 2. Do you own a business or work in the Lincoln Corridor (shown on the map above)? Value Count Percent Yes 23 13.3% No 150 86.7% Statistics Total Responses 173 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 4 Preferred Alternative – Introduction The project team has prepared a draft Preferred Alternative design for Lincoln Avenue, based on an evaluation of the three earlier alternatives, including costs and community support. This proposed draft reflects a combination and refinement of components of the previous alternatives for the West, Central, and East segments of the corridor that best support the corridor vision. 3. The key elements of the Preferred Alternative are listed below. Please select the top 3 elements that are most important to you. 27.0% 11.0% 11.0% 16.0% 35.0% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Buffered bike lanes Wide sidewalks Streetscape amenities New Lincoln bridge All Others Value Count Percent Two travel lanes 30 6.0% Buffered bike lanes 134 26.9% Wide sidewalks (generally 10’ on north side, 8’ on south side) 56 11.2% Special pavement materials to enhance aesthetics and improve safety at driveways and intersections 25 5.0% Transit stops and shelters 26 5.2% On-street parking in select locations 17 3.4% Generous landscaped median 29 5.8% Streetscape amenities such as gathering areas, furniture, lighting, and art in public places 53 10.6% New Lincoln bridge design with an enhanced connection to the Poudre River 81 16.3% Low Impact Development (LID) applications to improve stormwater drainage and water quality 24 4.8% Reduction in speed limit to 30 mph (existing is 35 mph) 23 4.6% Statistics Total Responses 171 Average Responses per Person 2.9 1 100% Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 5 4. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 ,,,, 1 As long as we don't forget anything to help the handicap. 1 Don't do share the road bike lanes. Make them separate. 1 Greetings, who is paying for all this? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I don't think two travel lanes will be enough to accommodate traffic efficiently. 1 I like it very much. 1 I want to be able to ride my bike home from ODells safely when I am shithoused. 1 Important to plan for needed turn lanes throughout corridor 1 Make it more bike friendly! dont waste money on aesthetics... 1 Nice to see simple signs pointing towards the breweries as they are a top tourist draw 1 Reducing the speed limit and enforcement of it will make much more beautiful our street thanks. 1 Since I just moved here (with my bike) I am anxious to have safe areas to ride on! 1 The vision here should be to accommodate ever increasing traffic, both bike and car. 1 Would actually like to see four travel lanes - or at least a turn lane to encourage mobility. 1 need to be pleasing to the eye. smooth flow of traffic. biker and ped safety. 1 peace on earth 1 please make it easier for bikes to cross Lincoln Bridge with traffic. 1 use roundabouts at intersections 1 Definitely need to separate traffic from bike traffic (commonly associated with Odell/New Belgium/FC Brewery/ Funkwerks). Improving the aesthetics of this corridor will significantly help with the tourism industry- it is essentially Brewery Row for many visitors. 1 the speed limit should be reduced to 24 mph and the car lanes should be narrowed to slow traffic and improve safety for bikes. The city should work to get a developer to build interesting housing on top of the giant parking lot for newer lab office. parking lots should not be a part of Lincoln Ave. And there should be more housing 2 to 5 stories high 1 Safe crossings and bike travel are very important on a street that has so much truck traffic. I don't mind diverting truck access/traffic off Lincoln where possible. A trail that connects Odell's to New Belgium and avoids the neighborhood is also very important. 1 Not having curbs in the middle of the street and narrow turn ways making travel in a pickup impassable. Eliminating trees in the center of these curbs wasting precious water that is needed for Agriculture in LC and in the future the roots will be cracking pavement. This city has the worst parking and most costly and wasteful beautification I have ever seen. Go to Albuquerque and see how drought plants and rock can be used. Go to Cheyenne and see how the parking lots can have slanted parking and wide enough drives to accomodate two pickup. This City doesn't want country people to come to town, it is painful to see the waste of our Ag water. 1 I don't live in the corridor but my business and home are very close. I do ride my bike through the corridor from home to work. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 6 Count Response 1 Actually, all of these elements with the exception of the Special Pavement Materials are worthy for inclusion. 1 Glad the focus is not just on cars but also bikes/pedestrians/transit Is a trolley being considered? 1 Absolutely not to the median. There are too many businesses and neighborhood streets to turn into that a median would be an inconvenience and visibility hazard. Wider bike lanes, especially on west part are definitely needed. 1 Stakeholders who operate businesses in the area are expecting that traffic volumes expected over the long term will be accommodated by the design. Overcommitment of the available right of way to amenities will make it more functional as a park than as a key arterial serving those business, which it is. 1 I don't live or work in this area, although I do travel here often for work and leisure. I would greatly like to see the bike paths improved and make it more rider friendly. 1 Why does this town insist on doing large projects like this (and Timberline between Drake and Prospect and Prospect by the ponds) and pave the driving surface in asphalt just to mill it and overlay it 5 to 7 years later? Do it right and concrete that shit so it lasts 20 years without major maintenance! Concrete and asphalt are roughly the same price with today's oil prices; this isn't the 70s, people! 1 Lincoln will play a big role in the future of Fort Collins with the Woodward facility and the breweries. It should be a welcoming street for visitors, residents, and staff at the companies located along/near Lincoln. 1 Our town has always been bike-friendly. Of late, we have started to see some disturbing events involving collisions with motor vehicles and bicycles. In my opinion, any plan for the Lincoln corridor that takes into account increased isolation and safety of bicyclists will be welcome. 1 Although the idea of a landscaped median sounds nice, it takes up real estate that will be badly needed for traffic management. With all of the Woodward traffic coming we need at least 2 lanes each direction to support the traffic. 1 In its current state, the bridge is very unsafe for bicyclists. Bridge improvements should include safer passage for cyclists between old town and the breweries. 1 the Lemay-Lincoln stoplight is way too favorable for Lemay traffic causing the Lincoln traffic to back up unreasonably during higher traffic times - very frustrating to be on Lincoln at times 1 There should be a roundabout (traffic circle ) at Lemay and Lincoln. I thought we were concerned about air quality and reducing exhaust emissions. 1 if I could list 4 important elements, 2 travel lanes would make the list (as long as a bike lane were included) 1 Focus on encouraging foot and bicycle traffic. And mass transit access. Safety first with an effort to provide aesthetic connections to the natural features (river, green areas, parks, etc) as an alternative to cars, noise and pollution. 1 All are important to make it work. A generous landscape median is least important to me and should only be wide enough to provide an adequate pedestrian refuge at crosswalks. Do not want turf grass unless it is in an area that people are going to walk on - waste of water and energy for mowing, as well as fertilizers that may pollute water. 1 While I like the idea of a landscaped median, I am concerned about the lack of left turn lanes to access businesses. I also think there is too much right of way dedicated to shoulder landscaping 1 I attended the open house last week and was surprised at the extravagance of the proposed project! I like the landscaping and grass on the sidewalk sides of the road but feel strongly that the median should be much more accommodating for cars making left turns when heading east. It is my understanding that Colorado Rules of the Road do not permit cars to drive over into bike lanes/shoulder to go around cars Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 7 Count Response 1 Is there any way to save the trees on the south side - save a strip of landscape? Median would not have to be continuous, it could be smaller islands to allow some left turns. Sidewalks would not have to be more than 7'. 1 We'll need at least two travel lanes. Traffic isn't superb here, and there will be a large increase in traffic Woodward will bring with employees and trucks... A median would be pretty, and I am for making things look better around here, but not being able to turn left out of our parking lot for me (and for delivery trucks) is a deal-breaker. The Lincoln bridge is dangerous for cyclists in its current form, and occasionally over-imbibed bikers from the breweries can get too close to cars. 1 The connection to Link Lane on the east end of the east section is screaming out to become a roundabout! Please incorporate roundabouts in more intersection uprgade projects! 1 The amount of car traffic on this stretch will increase dramatically when Woodward is finished. We need to accommodate that with parking, adequate entrances and exits from the businesses and safe bike lanes. If we need to take away the width of medians or sidewalk width to accomplish this, that should be one of the priorities. Updating the bridge will contribute to this train of thought as well. 1 We live in the midtown area (Drake & Shields) and enjoy riding our bikes downtown frequently during nice weather. The enhanced Lincoln area would add another biking destination to our route and offer safer travel to the breweries in the area. 1 LEMAY AVE BETWEEN LINCOLN AND JUST NORTH OF VINE IS A MILLION TIMES WORSE THAN LINCOLN. THOSE POOR PEOPLE HAVE TRAFFIC JAMS IN FRONT OF THEIR HOMES ALL DAY LONG AND THE TRAINS MAKE IS EVEN WORSE!!!! 1 It all sounds great. I think you should retain street parking for the residents along the street. Good bicycle access is a must. 1 Although I don't personally live in the neighborhood, I've been attending almost all of the meetings about this project and it would be of interest to be sure that there is safe access to Lincoln Avenue for the residents of the Buckingham / Andersonville / Via Lopez neighborhoods. 1 All elements mentioned above sound ideal. Protecting and celebrating the Poudre River is important at this location in the city. Public safety is also important given the nature of the businesses along the road. 1 As someone who bikes on this road often, I would LOVE to see the Lincoln bridge widened. It is terrifying to ride right now. 1 I think it would be cool if south side of Lincoln could be closed for pedestrian walkway Sunday mornings Apr- Oct 1 Why are you trying to change the name of Lincoln Street to "Lincoln Avenue"? Smacks of gentrification. You have already ruined this area for residential and commercial purposes by allowing Woodward to occupy many acres of prime real estate in the area. More of the same --- mismanagement and poor planning by the FC City govt. What is going to happen to Team Petroleum? 1 The largest demographic in our city is 50+. Any bike considerations should include use of e-bikes to accomodate this population who bike-commutes to work, play, etc. 1 Improvement of the Lemay/Vine intersection in the study area is highest priority as I travel this area daily and see very dangerous driving habits and traffic patterns increasing at this intersection. 1 Move traffic through this area. Don't get so cute on design that you turn this into a choke point 1 If Lincoln is to remain a two lane road, please add a central left turn lane to allow traffic flow to continue Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 8 Preferred Alternative – West Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 9 5. How satisfied are you with the Preferred Alternative design for this segment? Value Count Percent Very satisfied 97 55.8% Somewhat satisfied 48 27.6% Neutral 12 6.9% Somewhat dissatisfied 10 5.8% Very dissatisfied 5 2.9% Not sure 2 1.2% Statistics Total Responses 174 Very satisfied 55.8% Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 10 6. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 1 lane we with a median is ridiculous. 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 Asphalt driving lanes SUCK and will start to pothole and crack within a few years of service. 1 Bikes for days 1 DO SOMETHING ABOUT LEMAY FROM LINCOLN TO NORTH OF VINE!!! 1 Get rid of the landscaped center medium and replace it with a turn lane 1 Greetings, who is paying for all this? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I am very happy to see these ideas. Lincoln Ave. is a prime bicycle commuting route. 1 I like the buffered bike lanes - they will help with cyclist safety 1 I like the wide bike lane next to the sidewalk. Walkers on the bike paths are dangerous. 1 I would like the bicycle buffer to be more substantial than just different colored concrete. 1 Incorporate roundabouts at intersections. 1 LOVE the separate paths for walkers and cyclists! 1 Landscape zone is under-utilized 1 That looks safer for my drunken bike ride. 1 The 3' bicycle buffer should include a physical separation of some kind (e.g. curb). 1 This is a great design but I feel the bike lanes should be protected by more than just a buffer. 1 This is exactly what I had in mind! Don't skimp on the trees! 1 Uncertain about access to Poudre trail for eastbound cyclists - hoping for safe/pleasant access. 1 We need turn lanes and ideally more lanes to support traffic. 1 Wow! 1 insufficient attention paid to meeting traffic support needs for employers on Lincoln 1 more traffic lanes or street parking? 1 vehicle lanes are too wide 1 Please make sure the intersection at Willow is well marked for bikes and peds. Will the trees in the landscaping at Willow intersection make it hard for traffice to see pedestrians coming off the sidewalk onto crosswalk? 1 I don't understand how there can be enough width to accommodate all of these lanes and landscaping 1 I'm concerned that with the construction of the Woodward complex two lanes will not be enough to accommodate the increase in traffic. I'm sure you have thought of this already, but I just wanted to mention it. 1 The railroad crossing on willow street is extremely hazardous to northbound bicyclists especially when wet. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 11 Count Response 1 What will the City do in terms of landscaping and materials so this doesn't end up looking like "Anywhere, USA"? 1 Does this plan take into account the additional traffic around the POUDRE River and on the trail if a water park is developed? I've heard conversation about a kayaking course (like Confluence Park in Denver) near the Engine Lab. This area could be a major entry point for peds and bikes. 1 Was expanding the road to 4 lanes from Riverside/Jefferson ever discussed? It might help ease congestion from the buses and extra traffic expected with the improvements. 1 I would prefer for this to be 4 lanes of traffic. With added population, the traffic is going to get worse. 1 I'd prefer the bike lanes be separated from the traffic. With all the truck traffic on this street I still think it's dangerous for cyclists. Otherwise looks good. Could move center median to sides to buffer bike lanes. 1 I especially like the improvements at the intersection with Willow and the potential bridge replacement. 1 Colored concrete buffer is awesome. I also like the entry mindset, monument, bridge, etc Is there signage? Median and cross walks are very nice as well. 1 Love the bike lane with buffer (PLEASE bring this to more streets!), median, and enhanced landscape zones. 1 Looks like a nice wide multi-use corridor How tall is the concrete buffer between the bike line and travel lane? Is the median similar size to Mountain Ave? Could the median be converted to a trolley track? 1 I am curious about the benefit of the large median between the cars? Also, I cannot see how it indicates improved access to the Poudre Trl from Lincoln? 1 I think we need to use the center median area for another lane for traffic, parking and/or turning lanes. Since there is one lane going each way, traffic will back up during the busy commuting hours with the increased volume of traffic. 1 While I love the bridge enhancements, I think too much shoulder ROW is given up to landscape zones. Designs must recognize this is an industrial use area too, trucks and cars will always be part of the equation. 1 Would like the buffer between travel and bike lanes to be even more pronounced, such as a raised buffer (NOT with a curb); or, constructed of a material that would read differently to a driver, if a car drifted into the area. Thank you for making it a different color. 1 Just to confirm, the bridge over the river needs to be expanded. It is barely pedestrian friendly and a true danger for bicyclists. 1 don't understand the need for the median between the two vehicle lanes. A small buffer between bike lane/street is nice. 1 I think the landscaped median is far too elaborate and large. I think that space could be used elsewhere. 1 Even though the buffers are a good solution, I would consider it safer for cyclists if bike lanes were not on the road but actually directly next to the pedestrian sidewalk. There would be a wider gap between car traffic and bikes. As per the above image, the bike lane could be moved right next to the pedestrian path as an extra path and the landscape green stretch could be between the bike lane and the road for car traffic. 1 i love green space as much as anyone, but this seems excessive. Between medians and "landscape zones" there is now almost 60' of vegetation, wider than the existing street! 1 I really like to see some unique landscaping in this area. Try some new plants in designs, maybe lean towards natives, or make a pollinator garden. The plants can be marked and help the public understand the Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 12 Count Response 1 Will there be adequate crossings for pedistrian traffic from north side to south side of street? Looks like a lot of zones to cross to me. However, the landscape zones are very important to me as well as the medians. You know how people like to j-walk! 1 Eliminate the curbs and the trees and make the lanes double so you can drive a pickup in them. Stop wasting water!!!!! This is absolutely BS! It will be congested and impassable! 1 Concerned that access points to business won't be guaranteed. Need to protect those businesses. And what happens when a big truck pulls in? Does all traffic stop? Need turn lanes versus boulevards. 1 Awesome job on buffered bike lane design. This is one of the more scary roads I bike on regularly. Seems like there are more trucks on this road because of all the auto-shops, junkyards, etc on this side of town. 1 The bike lane should be paved, not concrete. It isn't specified in the design, but concrete becomes very bumpy. 1 The buffered bike lanes are a real plus. They need to be of a durable material that will not throw debris into the bike lane (should be paved or concrete). 1 Why are you trying to change the name of Lincoln Street to "Lincoln Avenue"? Smacks of gentrification. You have already ruined this area for residential and commercial purposes by allowing Woodward to occupy many acres of prime real estate in the area. More of the same --- mismanagement and poor planning by the FC City govt. What is going to happen to Team Petroleum? 1 What will this mean for residences on Lincoln? Will the widening of this street take away from their homes/businesses? 1 Absolutely need turn lanes at Lincoln and Riverside. With increased car traffic in the area you should not be removing ways to leave the area. Also need something for the train crossing near Riverside. When the train is switching tracks here it can block Lincoln, Linden, and Willow, essentially blocking the entire end of town for 20 minutes or more. Traffic piles up, just like at Lemay and Riverside. I'd love something for vehicles to bypass the tracks, but how about a pedestrian overpass to start? 1 I Like the bike and ped aspects. I would leave enough space in the central median to get two more car lanes if required in the future. 1 Near 1st street and just before entering the west side of the bridge, you have crossing areas. First, will there be flashing lights for pedestrian crossing, stop signs, or stop lights at either of those crossing areas? Second, I see that there is not an easily accessible way to get from the southside (driving/riding directional east) bike lane along the bridge onto the Poudre River trails. Is there going to access on the southside to the trail or some type of crossing area to turn left into the trail entrance to go north? 1 Traffic at Ranch-Way store would be difficult for peds, too many customers using retail store and parking in front of mill. Colored pavement idea is stupid, it doesn't last very long. 1 Do you need all the landscape zones. Thinking of water resources and maintenance costs to the city. Perhaps using art or other lower maintenance options. 1 I'm not sure that there is a current need or possible future need for the sidewalk on the South side. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 13 Preferred Alternative – Central Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 14 7. How satisfied are you with the Preferred Alternative design for this segment? Value Count Percent Very satisfied 78 45.4% Somewhat satisfied 56 32.6% Neutral 19 11.1% Somewhat dissatisfied 10 5.8% Very dissatisfied 6 3.5% Not sure 3 1.7% Statistics Total Responses 172 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 15 8. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 ASK THE PEOPLE ON LEMAY WHAT THEY WOULD LIKE 1 Again stop with the waste, eliminate the curbs and trees that take precious water! 1 As long as left turns are allowed on all of these intersections. 1 Bike lane placed between travel lane and parking lane is a safety concern 1 Don't like the parking 1 Eliminate the parking and utilize smaller driveways, 24' wide maximum. 1 Greetings, How Do the people in the area feel about all this? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I don't like the parking lane on the street. 1 I would like to see pedestrians with a landscape buffer between them and the street. 1 Incorporate roundabouts at intersections. 1 Looks good and very future focused 1 Multiple lanes of traffic would be preferred, but the parking is nice. 1 Need more lanes for traffic. 1 Need turn lane 1 Same problem with just one lane. This street should be designed to carry traffic. 1 See previous comment about curb in bike buffer. 1 Thank you for adding parking. I think this should be extended through the whole design. 1 This Pete guy is pretty awesome. 1 What does "ROW" mean? 1 Worried that bike lane is sandwiched between parked cars and traffic 1 go planners! 1 insufficient attention paid to meeting traffic support needs for employers on Lincoln 1 more road surface, less median to allow room for a turning lane. 1 multiple travel lanes or street parking? 1 same comment 1 sidewalks should be included not 'potential' 1 there is no buffer between the parked vehicles and the bicycle lane. 1 Is a one foot door zone buffer enough space? Doors typically open more than one foot, and if two bikes are riding side-by-side, there is potential for a conflict. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 16 Count Response 1 Please make sure that residents of the area have adequate access to their homes and vehicle parking. The lower speed limit is a good idea. This will be busy area and subject to increased vehicle traffic despite the proposals. 1 The same comment applies as to the previous section in which idea the bike path would be more integrated into the pedestrian stripe and further away from car traffic. In addition, the afore-mentioned idea would protect cyclist from opening car doors. 1 The following comments are my key feedback for this survey. In November 2012, I was in a bike-car accident at the intersection of Lincoln and 3rd. I was riding my bike west-bound on Lincoln, and the driver was on 3rd trying to enter east-bound traffic on Lincoln. When the driver saw a gap in east-bound traffic she accelerated from the stop-sign on 3rd and ran into me as I was riding by. My feeling is that this happened, as least in part because she was in a hurry. Nevertheless, my sense is that unless the speed limit in reduces substantially, the added "visual clutter" of this plan may lead to increased car-bicycle interactions. I would encourage planners to incorporate design elements that would reduce bike-car interactions. 1 Cannot tell from this if sidewalks continue to north from Lincoln, into the neighborhoods. It would be great if these neighborhoods received sidewalks, curbs, street lights, etc. Basically if they were more finished. 1 there should be green median separation between the bikes and cars. maybe get rid of green median between cars and vehicle lanes width to slow traffic. Also, someone should build a cool 4 story lofts above the giant eye sore In Situ parking lots while keeping most of the parking spaces. 1 New sidewals on 1st and 2nd St.? No one uses the sidewals in the neighborhood because existing sidewals are so narrow. Everyone walks in the streets. 1 We strive to be "green" yet you insist on paving with asphalt which causes many more pollutants to be exhausted into the air than its concrete counterpart. 1 I am in support of the of the potential new sidewalk on the East side of 3rd Street, as this would be a way to help divert some of the traffic around the neighborhood, if it could include a bike trail like the rest of the bike paths in Fort Collins. A walking history with the use of video and paver stones with the names of the families who were original residents of the Buckingham neighborhood would be a wonderful addition. Examples of how this is used can be found with projects that have been implemented in conjunction with the Poudre Heritage Alliance, as these neighborhoods reside within the Natural Heritage Area. A sculpture suggestion for placement in the median or in the neighborhood: Children with giant marbles to signify the "Marble Wars" that use to take place in the Buckingham neighborhood alleys. Please see Cheryl Glanz for more information on this. 1 I was really pleased with the Entry/Neighborhood Monuments, appreicate that it had Tres Colonias and a sugar beet to represent the history of the beet workers. Please don't change that. 1 do not like parking along Lincoln Ave, will slow traffic & be more dangerous for bikes. Would prefer a second travel lane 1 Please make sure that residents have adequate car parking along these streets. In addition to ped and bicycle safety we need to respect their needs to have access to their cars for work, school, errands, etc. it would be inappropriate for all the parking to be used by people who are just visiting the neighborhood rather than permanent residents. 1 I'm concerned about visibility of bikers and pedestrians through the tree-lined median, and afraid the median might actually increase traffic speeds rather than slowing people down. Special design and safety treatments at crossings will be very important. 1 Can you make vehicle parallel parking nearest to driving lane so as to not require drivers to cross bike lane Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 17 Count Response growth projections? I don't know. 1 Concerned about gentrification of the neighborhood - if they like the new landscaping and buffer - great. If there are any concerns, it needs to be changed. 1 I would love to see Buckingham park more accessible to children with a variety of (special) needs… northern FC is lacking 1 Very satisfied with most aspects, but not happy about on street parking because I don't see the need for additional parking in this area. However, if the need is real, the design looks good. 1 The parking on the right side of the bike lane seems like it's asking for trouble (i.e., accidents with doors, parked cars pulling out in front of bicyclists, bicyclists having to swerve into traffic, etc.). Placing a protected bike lane to the far right would protect the cyclists even more. People that park in the cars and need to cross over the bike lane could do so at their own discretion or at marked crosswalks. 1 I like the crosswalks! Could you consider putting the parking on the outside and the bike lane next to the curb? Also I worry a bit about now left turn lane for cyclist turning left into Odells. 1 Why are you trying to change the name of Lincoln Street to "Lincoln Avenue"? Smacks of gentrification. You have already ruined this area for residential and commercial purposes by allowing Woodward to occupy many acres of prime real estate in the area. More of the same --- mismanagement and poor planning by the FC City govt. What is going to happen to Team Petroleum? 1 As a resident of Buckingham, I find the the longitudinal parking parallel to Lincoln confusing for cyclists, pedestrians, and motorists. People regularly park facing both directions and pull out into traffic or U-turn into opposite traffic. The parking also blocks the view of oncoming pedestrians and cyclists (many of whom ride on the "wrong" side of the road because they do not feel safe on the opposite (non-residential) side of the street. I think this arrangement yields more possible opportunities for people, bikes, and cars to collide. That said, with a proper sidewalk and bike lane on the non-residential side of the street, perhaps more people will feel safe traveling the "right" way on Lincoln. Also- with the addition of a median, cars may park facing the flow of traffic on the residential side, which would encourage them to move into the flow of traffic from their homes. 1 Is anything being done to acquire commercial and old industrial properties in the floodplain? This should be a priority to preserve and restore a functional floodplain and protect the river from pollution when it floods. I think this should take priority over the street improvements at the current time. 1 Bikes are still riding in "door" area where cars can open their doors and hit cyclists. I'd prefer the bike lanes be separated from the traffic and praking. With all the truck traffic on this street I still think it's dangerous for cyclists. Otherwise looks good. Could move center median to sides to buffer bike lanes. 1 Same bike lane comment. The bike lane needs to be paved, not exposed concrete. Concrete becomes very bumpy. 1 Seems like a lot of intersections and business access along with on-street parking in this area. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 18 Preferred Alternative – East A Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 19 9. How satisfied are you with the Preferred Alternative design for this segment? Value Count Percent Very satisfied 76 44.2% Somewhat satisfied 57 33.1% Neutral 18 10.5% Somewhat dissatisfied 12 7.0% Very dissatisfied 7 4.1% Not sure 2 1.2% Statistics Total Responses 172 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 20 10. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 1 foot of room is not enough space to prevent cyclists from being hit by car doors opening 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 Add turn lane 1 Again, same comment! This is insanity! 1 Biking on sidewalks should be reserved for children under 16 years of age. 1 Don't like bike lane between car lanes. 1 Don't like the parking 1 Greetings, who is paying for all this? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I don't like the on street parking. 1 I like the food truck and pedestrian gathering areas. 1 I think I see pockets of street parking which I like becasue it may help civilize traffic. 1 Looks great love the extra food truck and event space, as well as space for art. 1 Love the idea of the permeable concrete parking lane, however the asphalt driving lane sucks! 1 Medians are completely unecessary, and may hinder visibility of on coming traffic. 1 Need more lanes for traffic. 1 Not sure additional parking is worth the safety of the bike lane being compromised. 1 Not sure why there are bikes on the sdewalk? 1 Ok, I think I see the turn lane now into Odell's. 1 The bike lane should be to the far right and should be protected. 1 The median cut is mandatory at ODell Brewing Company. 1 Would be a curb or other physical separation in the bike buffer. 1 You really are going to need four lanes! 1 insufficient attention paid to meeting traffic support needs for employers on Lincoln 1 need more road surface, less median, to allow for a turn lane. 1 odells and hot dogs 1 ped/biker safety near brewery entrances. 1 same comment as before. 1 see previous comment 1 Why is the cross section showing bikes and peds sharing the 10-foot sidewalk? It appears that there's a bike lane on that side of the street. Mixing peds and cyclists on a sidewalk can be dicey and uncomfortable for both groups. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 21 Count Response 1 Don't want to see the future sidewalk on third street to be used for the route to go from one brewery to another. We need to make sure the neighborhood has its privacy. Would like to see the breweries create a route through their properties. I thought the main entrance for Woodward was to be off Lemay. 1 Are the buffered bike lanes still there? There's no left turn lanes for 3rd street or hydro construction entrance. Is there a crossing for Woodward employees to get to the food trucks? 1 Looks nice but same issues as before. I'd prefer the bike lanes be separated from the traffic and side street parking. With all the truck traffic on this street I still think it's dangerous for cyclists. Otherwise looks good. Could move center median to sides to buffer bike lanes. 1 Have you ever been to a city with traffic? I suggest a trip to Austin to study traffic. This looks like an entrance street into a small housing Development. 1 Same concern as central-bike lane is surrounded by parked cars and traffic. Good chance for bikes to get "doored" 1 Very Suburban. No distinction between neighborhood area and commercial area. Why enhance parking spots that will be covered with cars. Enhanced walkways and sidewalks and crossings are good. 1 Turn lanes? Seems like something for Woodward entry, Odell entry. Need to plan for increased traffic. 1 I like the idea of the potential food truck parking being located to the East of the Buckingham neighborhood to minimize disruptions for residents. 1 I'm not sure about the future bus stop between Odell's driveway and the neighborhood. There is already a lot of traffic in this area. It is already difficult to get out of the driveway at 300 E Lincoln with the traffic entering and exiting the parking lot in addition to the pedestrians and bikes. 1 Map does not show on-street parking, but picture does. I don't see the need for on-street parking in this area. If the map is right (no on-street parking), I am very satisfied with the design for this segment. 1 I would much prefer to see a dedicated turn lane or acceleration lanes (or both) in this segment. It is often difficult to enter Odell brewing from the west without holding up traffic in order to make the left into their lot, and also frequently difficult to exit into traffic from there (particularly if continuing eastbound on bicycle). I do like the idea of the dedicated food truck area, although if Odell were to ever move locations, this space may become uncecessary. 1 seperate cars and bikes with green median. maybe get rid of green median between cars lanes and definitely narrow car travel lanes to slow traffic thereby extending old town 1 Parking looks good, I still think we need to make the median narrower to accommodate car traffic lanes. 1 I wish the bike lane could have been adjacent to the sidewalk, to separate the car & truck parking from the bike lane and potential bike & driver issues. However, I don't know the negatives/downside of such a design. (The separated bike lanes I saw in Amsterdam seemed to work great.) I do appreciate the differently colored buffer and white corner paint in the parking lane. (Not sure drivers will be able to see the white paint though.) I feel like cyclists were given serious consideration in this design which is greatly appreciated. I also feel the planners really tried to accommodate everyone equally. 1 bike lane between travel lane and parking lane is a saety concern. Don't show biker riding illegally on sidewalk. 1 Same concerns about reduction of vehicle access to businesses on the north side of Lincoln if driving from the downtown core. 1 I don't like the on-street parking, as it opens cyclists up to being doored by the parked cars. Otherwise I like Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 22 Count Response Woodword will be and already is significant. The bike lane needs to be paved, not concrete. Not specified in the design, but concrete becomes very bumpy. 1 I like it, but again I'm worried about safety at intersection and effect of the median on potentially increasing traffic speeds. 1 Not psyched on the street parking of this segment. I would add bike staples instead. You can fit ten times the parking for bikes than cars resulting in more customers for the businesses. It is already hard to find bike parking on this section of Lincoln. Cars parked next to bike lanes result in people get "doored". Also, why promote parking in front of the breweries, where people are just going to drink and drive... 1 Make vehicle parking nearest to vehicle driving lane, so that vehicles do not have to cross bike lane to park. 1 Why are you trying to change the name of Lincoln Street to "Lincoln Avenue"? Smacks of gentrification. You have already ruined this area for residential and commercial purposes by allowing Woodward to occupy many acres of prime real estate in the area. More of the same --- mismanagement and poor planning by the FC City govt. What is going to happen to Team Petroleum? 1 Same comment as in previous segment, especially with regard to opening car doors into the bike path. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 23 Preferred Alternative – East B Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 24 11. How satisfied are you with the Preferred Alternative design for this segment? Value Count Percent Very satisfied 70 40.5% Somewhat satisfied 63 36.4% Neutral 15 8.7% Somewhat dissatisfied 14 8.1% Very dissatisfied 8 4.6% Not sure 3 1.7% Statistics Total Responses 173 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 25 12. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 1 foot of buffer space is not enough to prevent cyclists from being hit by car doors opening 1 A median that varies between 6ft and 22ft? Seems like a lot of variance 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 Add turn lane 1 Again, like the car parking, what if the bus stops could be outside the bike lane? 1 Don't like parking, don't see need for it. 1 FIX LEMAY AND VINE FIRST 1 Getting in and out of The Back Porch is always tricky. 1 Greetings, who is paying for all this? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I do like the permeable pavement! 1 I don't like the on street parking. 1 It would be nice to see a turn into the Backporch from east bound Lincoln. 1 More traffic lanes, less median. 1 Need double lanes to handle traffic 1 Need more lanes for traffic 1 Parallel parking will effect the flow of the bike lane. 1 Same comment as for East A 1 Thanks for providing a cut in the median for Fort Collins Brewery. 1 This section didn't come up on the screen. 1 Too brewery signage?? 1 Turn lanes? 1 Would be a curb or other physical separation in the bike buffer. 1 again with the on street parking 1 insufficient attention paid to meeting traffic support needs for employers on Lincoln 1 more road surface, less median, add turn lane 1 narrow car travel lanes to slow traffic at least to 24 mph 1 same comment 1 see previous street paring comment 1 trees are always good Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 26 Count Response 1 The travel lane in front of Fort Collins Brewery is odd. It curves rather than being straight. This does not feel inviting. Again, no distinction between commercial area and neighborhood. 1 It would be nice to have the sidewalks and bike lanes constructed in a manner where they are not rigidly parallel to the street and this segment is probably the best place to do it. Have a pathway that meanders or curves around sculpture or landscape features would be preferable to marrying the sidewalk/bike lane to the road. Also Lemay and Riverside is a very busy intersection and poses challenges for peds and bikes. The cycling experience on Lemay is very different from what is proposed for Lincoln. How will traffic be calmed once people turn off Lemay to go west on Lincoln? 1 I hope there will be signage for cyclists & pedestrians to understand cyclists can ride on this section of the sidewalk. Need a Bike Share station here? Need a charging station for electric cars? Just asking. I did like the City "trolley" (bus) idea for tourists and other folks heading in and out of Old Town and the breweries. (It can be added later, too.) 1 Bike lane should not be crossed by any vehicle traffic in order for vehicles to park. please put vehicle parking nearest vehicle driving lane. 1 Have you ever tried to turn on to Lincoln from Lemay? It's a nightmare with one lane of oncoming traffic due to the curve in the road, and now you're adding another oncoming lane. Additionally, you're going to have many people who turn left onto Lincoln and then U-turn at that first intersection to get to Lambspun/Backporch Cafe, even with the earlier turn lane on Lemay. Also, remember how it's a nightmare to turn with just on oncoming lane lane? 1 Likely needs 2 lanes each direction. A lot of traffic in the area. More traffic when Woodward opens. Bike labne needs to be paved, not concrete. Not specified in design, but concrete becomes very bumpy. 1 Pay close attention to Lemay street… as much introduction to the new Licoln corridor would be great 1 Again, I don't see the need for on-street parking and prefer not to have that. But I can't tell if it is part of the design based on the map. 1 Once again, lose the medians. Extra money for upkeep, worsened visibility, especially for bikers. The lanes and sidewalks are great, though. 1 I don't like the on-street parking, as it opens cyclists up to being doored by the parked cars. Otherwise I like it. 1 There has to be a traffic circle at Lemay in order to keep vehicles moving. We do not need more red li8ghts and idling tailpipes. Aren't you concerned about air quality? 1 When my tires get popped again due to the milling of the asphalt, I'm sending you dipshits the bill. 1 How do you access the Ace Auto Collision and Stor-Mor sites if you are driving east on Lincoln from the downtown? These are currently vehicle intensive businesses/properties that could be adversely impacted. Give up some of the landscape ROW to provide left turn access. 1 I am very concerned about bike safety between Lemay and Lincoln- needs to be very clear area for bikes to turn into Lincoln from Lemay 1 The trick here will be accessing Lambspun while heading west on Lincoln from Lemay, There will be lots of U turns somewhere... 1 Why are you trying to change the name of Lincoln Street to "Lincoln Avenue"? Smacks of gentrification. You have already ruined this area for residential and commercial purposes by allowing Woodward to occupy many acres of prime real estate in the area. More of the same --- mismanagement and poor planning by the FC City govt. What is going to happen to Team Petroleum? Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 27 Count Response 1 what is the entrance point for the cafe and retail on the corner of Lemay and Lincoln? It's hard to turn there now! 1 Appears that Lambspun/Backporch lose their north access point, I do not agree with removing that. Also would like to see consideration of relocated Lemay Ave to realign for new intersection at Lemay/Vine. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 28 Transit – Lincoln Shuttle Lincoln Avenue is currently served by two Transfort routes, Route 5 and 14, that both operate at 60 minute frequencies. The transit service on Lincoln is proposed to be incrementally improved to support development in the area and observed ridership demand. One of the potential improvements includes adding a new “Lincoln Shuttle” route that connects Downtown with the Lincoln Corridor, as shown in blue on the map below. With the addition of the Lincoln Shuttle, Route 14 would move to Riverside Avenue. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 29 13. Rate how important the Lincoln Shuttle service is to you. Value Count Percent Very Important 23 13.3% Fairly Important 40 23.1% Neutral 40 23.1% SlightyImportant 26 15.0% Not Important 44 25.4% Statistics Total Responses 173 Not important 25.4% Very satisfied 55.8% Slightly Important 15% Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 30 14. Rate how important the use of a custom vehicle (e.g., rubber-tired trolley or innovative vehicle) for the Lincoln Shuttle service is to you. Value Count Percent Very Important 21 12.1% Fairly Important 36 20.7% Neutral 37 21.3% Slightly Important 30 17.2% Not Important 50 28.7% Statistics Total Responses 174 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 31 15. Please share any other comments Count Response 1 A custom vechile could be very cool yet also unneeded. The idea of it for tourism is spot on. 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 Add a turn lane 1 Any type of train will slow down car traffic an then people will star honking the horns. 1 Don't think I would ever use the shuttle as I live close enough to bike those areas. 1 FIX LEMAY AND VINE! 1 Greetings, are the fares being subsidized? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I am in that area very seldom. 1 I am just making a comment to make sure this is working - Lori 1 I generally ride a bike or walk in between those areas. 1 I like the idea of 15 minute frequencies on the Lincoln Shuttle. 1 I like the idea of something fun and unusual! 1 I think it would get used and may prevent drunk driving 1 Interesting idea 1 Lunchtime shuttles to old town would be fantastic. 1 Whatever vehicle is used, it should accommodate bikes in some way. 1 While I bike or drive, the shuttle offers a neat option. 1 Who will fund the shuttle? Nice idea but I am a bit concerned about inebriated passengers. 1 bikes will be used, no need for custom vehicle 1 who would use the shuttle beside out of towners wanting to go to breweries? 1 would like to see transport from mtn/shields to lincoln/lemay 1 Shuttle could include going around to Buckingham street to add New Belgium campus. What a great way to move visitors and locals - and reduce parking problems and traffic. I see less of a need to move it around Wally-World (walmart). 1 I often travel this route on my bicycle. However, I strongly support public transit. The current bus stops are less than inviting. 1 Your Lincoln shuttle will not work with the train situation..unless you build an overpass at Lincoln and Riverside! 1 I think this is much needed and vital to the project, since you want those Woodward workers to eat downtown, and this will help connect the breweries with downtown and MAX. 1 This kind of local circulator route is a great idea. Assuming frequency would be adjusted for time/day and based on ridership. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 32 Count Response 1 I love this idea. Being a business owner in Old Town, this will be key in bringing people to shop, eat, and meet during or after work. I also can see the neighborhoods utilizing this shuttle to get to Walmart and that particular shopping area for work and to shop. If a convention center is ever built, this will be a great service for people attending events. I think this could help shuttle people during DBA events as well. 1 The custom vehicle for the Lincoln Shuttle would be a great opportunity for Fort Collins to show off some new alternative energy technology, such as biofuels, electric, etc... powered vehicle 1 I recently started using the bus service, but mostly to go to work in the south of FC. I have not learned my way north yet. 1 Innovative vehicle would be nice, but not if it costs significantly more than a current transfort bus. 1 Not sure that this route is the best for people visiting breweries. Would prefer that it goes north on Linden to new Belgium, and down 1st Street to Lincoln, and then eventually connect to the destinations further east in the Airport Industrial area, where incubator breweries are. No significant destinations on east end loop, besides Walmart and the apartments, which is already served by Route 5. The neighbors will probably not like a bus in front of their houses, but it could reduce the number of drunken bicyclists if the bus had a trailer to put a lot of bikes on. 1 This isn't a town that wants more public transit. People either drive their car or ride a bike and I don't see that changing with the MAX or any other public transit systems. 1 I really like the idea of the trolley. It is certainly symbolic of FC history and has a higher probability of use by tourists if it doesn't look like the Transfort buses. 1 I don't see using the Shuttle myself; however, I think a shuttle for commuters and tourists (e.g., Woodward Governor and brewery tours) should be considered. I think the connection to Max is critical. I would especially love to see people leave their cars behind if they will be drinking, and heading into Old Town to have dinner. As for the look of the shuttle, I could see the Shuttle being pretty festive. I think people, at least the tourists, would be much more inclined to take the shuttle if it looked very different from a City bus. 1 I ride a bicycle and have no need for a shuttle in this town. But I like the idea of a "trolley or innovative vehicle" and would enjoy the spectacle of it. 1 This service should be looked at with public/private sector operations. A transfort service seems too expensive. 1 I like the idea. I live near the DTC and would definitely use it to get out to Walmart. With the new MAX this would be a great addition for getting to the breweries. I would suggest you talk with New Belgium to see if the bus might run up linden circle the Buckingham neighborhood. 1 We most likely wouldn't use it on a regular basis but might serve as a destination to bring guests from out of town or family who live elsewhere. 1 If a shuttle is used, something special to separate it and add signifigance to it would be desired. Otherwise it is just another bus route, which serves a purpose, but would not be overly exciting. A trolley or innovative vehicle would be the preferred option. 1 If you were to do it, it would need to be something special. I don't see myself using it much, but maybe I underestimate how important it would be for visitors. 1 Frequency is more important than route or vehicle. I imagine that 15 min is the most people would be willing to wait for a bus. 1 this is a great idea, allowing people to quickly connect to Lincoln Triangle from Max etc. It would be neat to Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 33 Count Response 1 Consider expanding the Lincoln Shuttle to Funkwerks and Timberline Rd. Other than that, minimizing emissions with an alternate vehicle is a great idea. 1 Everything this bus would access is bikable or evey walkable. It seems like consideration should be given for this proposed shuttle to loop onto Linden St. providing a stop for NBB. That would provide more rider-ship than other locations in my experience. 1 extend the trolly line on mountain ave and put tracks on lincoln. Buy back the old Fort Collins trolley being stored in Colorado Springs museum and re-use the north-south tracks in old town 1 I like the idea of the Lincoln shuttle. It would be nice to have something like a trolley or something similar to keep the Old Town feel, but it's not necessary. Maybe more longer-term goal to add. 1 who are the anticipated users of this additional shuttle? How is it beneficial to the city and the public? 1 The buses and truck traffic are going to destroy those asphalt driving lanes and also decrease their fuel mileage. 1 I love the idea of a trolley to connect these two areas. This map needs street names on it, I'm having a hard time knowing where exactly these routes are. 1 I believe that this would be a wonderful option for this part of Fort Collins that would connect the trolley history from the current West side of Fort Collins to the East side, if this is something that can be budgeted for the City. Since we can't bring back the actually trolley system that used to exist, it would be a fun implement for tourism and brings visitors or residents between the breweries in this part of Fort Collins to Old Town. An audio/video history could be included with this vehicle. 1 I think a trolley would help so there would not be so much foot traffic. I don't like the round barrel that has 6 people while one person is driving while everyone is drinking. 1 Old Town Fort Collins has charm, and it would be wonderful to see improvements and additions preserve the charm of the town. Having a trolly or innovative vehicle (not an unattractive bus) that connects down town to the Lincoln Corridor would be a VERY welcome addition. Please consider having a bike rack on the Lincoln Shuttle. 1 So basically the shuttle goes from Old Town to... Wal-Mart? And those apartments on Lincoln and Lemay? What broad spectrum of the community is that serving? Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 34 Neighborhood Projects The Lincoln Corridor Plan also identifies related neighborhood projects within the plan area (see blue boundary on map below). These are smaller projects that address longstanding existing deficiencies and enhance neighborhood livability that can be implemented in the area separate from the street reconstruction project. Some of these projects were already identified in previous plans (e.g., Northside Neighborhoods Plan, Pedestrian Plan), and some projects are new ideas that have arisen during this public process. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 35 16. Please select your top 3 projects from the list 17.0% 12.0% 25.0% 18.0% 13.0% 15.0% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Additional street lighting Interim sidewalks lighting New sidewalk connections New pedestrian crossing Transit stop improvements All Others Value Count Percent Neighborhood gateway/interpretive signage or monuments (Tres Colonias) 38 8.4% Additional street lighting (Lemay Ave) 75 16.7% Interim sidewalks lighting (Lemay Ave) 52 11.6% New sidewalk connections (Lemay, 1st Street, and 3rd Street) 112 24.9% New Pedestrian crossing on Lemay adjacent to the Andersonville neighborhood (push-button signal) 82 18.2% Transit stop improvements 58 12.9% Education program, signage to minimize cut-through traffic in Buckingham neighborhood 33 7.3% Statistics Total Responses 156 Average Responses per Person 2.9 100% Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 36 17. Please share any other comments; are there any additional projects that should be on the list? Count Response 1 A transit route dedicated to Lemay all the way south past Trilby. 1 A two-lane street is not enough to handle traffic. 1 Add a turn lane. This is an industrial area 1 FIX LEMAY AND VINE!!! SIDE WALKS WON'T HELP, FIX THE TRAFFICE JAM PROBLEM 1 I dont care about any of these. 1 Let the neighborhood's priorities and safety take precedence. 1 Traffic circle at Lemay. 1 Trail connecting Odell to New Belgium that avoids the neighborhood 1 With the traffic of course Buckingham will get "hit"!! Two lanes?? really?? 1 none 1 Anyway we can sell this as an improvement to these neighborhoods for long time residences will be a benefit. They are a vocal, active group and will not be happy unless we can show them we care about their neighborhood improvements being part of the projects that are funded. 1 I don't see anything very important there. Especially unsure about the idea of cut-through traffic. It's not really cut-through, it's just natural movement. Seems like the beer destinations create less than other neighborhood streets like Cherry, Mountain, others. 1 It is my hope that with this development that the privacy of Buckingham is secure, that has not been the case, it is very frustrating to not have our peace and quiet. I have great concern with this development if a plan is not in place the impact on Buckingham will be huge. We need to make sure that folks are not cutting through the neighborhood. I also have concern about the noise that with more people coming to the breweries what the impact will be for Buckingham residents. 1 Greetings, will the neighborhoods listed experience a property tax increase? Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I have to say I am amazed and pleased that the City of Fort Collins is considering re-routing Lemay in deference to the health and safety of the neighborhoods in question. If additional lighting happens, it would be so nice if they were similar to the ones used on Linden and the North College area, which are terrific. 1 I am totally in favor of interpretive signage and monuments for the Buckingham and Andersonville neighborhoods. However, as I have personal family history with these neighborhoods since inception in 1903, I am vehemently against the inaccurate use of the "Tres Colonias" slogan, as these neighborhoods were NOT Hispanic, they were built for and BY the Germans from Russia who were the first workers for the Great Western Sugar Company. Please do the homework on this and get the accurate history from Dr. Rock and colleagues of the International Center for German Russian Studies at CSU and Adam Thomas from the 2004 report (accessible on the City of Fort Collins website under "SugarBeet Neighborhoods"). Additionally, I am the Public Relations board member for the Northern Colorado Chapter of the American Historical Society of Germans from Russia and a fourth generation member of families of this ethnic group AND both neighborhoods, who have resided in Fort Collins for 110 years. Thank you - Cheryl Glanz cherg.811@gmail.com or 970-237-9750. 1 street light should fit with old town and shine down not up into the sky. Re-use the old trolley track in old town and bring back more trolley track 1 The intersection of Vine and Lemay needs left hand turn lanes (NB and SB Lemay turning left onto WB and EB VIne, respectively). Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 37 Count Response 1 Redesign of Lemay/Vine intersection should be a priority for the city in this study area. Between the dangerous driving behaviors, the narrow streets next to houses, and the development north and east of this intersection, this intersection should be prioritized for redesign and construction. 1 I think all these streets in Buckingham need wider sidewalks. And I don't want to discourage people from cutting through Buckingham. It is a a neighborhood and some of us welcome visitors. And some of us would still like the Tour de Fat to Start at New Belgium - where it belongs. 1 If there's a push-button signal crossing, it needs to be a red light. Current crossings with flashing yellow are more scary than no light at all, provide only false security, and are ignored by a significant portion of motorists. 1 I have seen people with disabilities having a difficult time with transit stops in this area. I have seen wheelchairs in the street traveling to the bus stops because sidewalks were not accessible. 1 Pedestrian activated signal at 1st on Lincoln. Brewery trail connection through Odell property that abuts Buckingham from New Belgium. Attractive screen wall east of 3rd Street to buffer the neighborhood from views of port-a-potties, and noise that eminates from stereos and loud people/vehicles, as well as amplified music for special events. Neighborhood should not be part of Tres Colonias because the Germans and Russians were equally significant as the Hispanics in the Sugar Beet Factory neighborhoods. Should drop this terminology, use actual neighborhood names only, or combine German and Spanish words to create a new name (Drei Colonias, or Tres Kolonien) 1 Additional street lighting wouldn't be needed if the roads were paved in concrete. The white concrete reflects the light making it brighter with less lights while the black asphalt absorbs light requiring more artificial lighting to be needed. 1 Alternative bike and pedestrian paths around Buckingham would be nice. What will is the plan for the bridge over the Poudre? 1 I hope that you are doing a lot of community engagement within these neighborhoods to determine what their needs are. They are the people that have to live with these "improvements" on a day to day basis. I know that there are several "hard to reach" populations in the area - but I think that is a great opportunity for the City to make connections and let these neighborhoods know that they have a voice in our community. 1 Tres Colonias isn't shown/labeled on the map. Left hand turn lanes on Lemay at Vine and Buckhorn would trump all of these projects. 1 While I realize that the nearly constant traffic problems that residents of the Andersonville neighborhood face on a daily basis seem to take back seat to the City of Fort Collins, I have concerns that with the construction and opening of Woodward these problems are only going to increase. I spend countless mornings on my bike or in my vehicle waiting to cross Lemay Ave, these crossings are usually quite unsafe. While looking over the proposed changes to Lincoln Avenue, I can't help but feel a little forgotten and ignored. I wonder, often, if our neighborhood had a higher median income if our traffic woes would be ignored. I write this comment to encourage you to take a look at potential ideas and alternatives to ease this burden for myself and my neighbors. 1 None of these features should be put in place at the expense of the City. The kinds of things the neighborhood is asking for are normally provided during development. Just because their neighborhood precedes those standards should not mean the City has to pay for them now. Property owners pay for those improvements. Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 38 18. Please share any other comments you have about the Lincoln Corridor Plan Count Response 1 Add a turn lane 1 As a Woodward employee, I really appreciate the study and plan. 1 Bike lane across the poudre is most important to any plans that may be implemented!!! 1 Check out the new book "Bikenomics" by Elly Blue for some good ideas! 1 Excellent job planners, really bringing everyone together and accommodating the whole community. 1 Greetings, thank you for the survey. Happy trails, DWGustafson 1 I am looking forward to the improvements. Thank you for allowing community feedback. 1 I hope the budget for the Plan does not detract from other needed area improvements. 1 I think it is a good idea to improve the bike lanes. The extra items I feel neutral about. 1 It looks like a good plan. I'm excited about the improved transit and bike facilities. 1 It's great to see the plans. Thanks for soliciting feedback. 1 Looks great - can be a real showplace for the city. Please be sure to make it bike friendly. 1 Looks great! Excited to see how it turns out! 1 Love the idea of custom vechile need brewery signs. 1 Love where it's going! Can't wait till it's done! Thanks! 1 Nice work! 1 Really excited about the outcome of this study! 1 Start over! 1 Think about it!!!! 1 This is much needed and appreciated! 1 This looks like a nice improvement to our city. 1 This plan should be redone to reflect priorities expressed by landowner stakeholders on Lincoln. 1 Very nice job on the survey! 1 Very pleased and hoping the plan will be adhered to. 1 great job planners! It looks fantastic! 1 nn 1 so far, looks very good. Great job! 1 traffic circle instead of stop lights. 1 Again, I think it would be innovative if traffic on the south side of street could be closed off one weekend morning a week in the summer. Businesses and residents could still come and go on north side of street. It would be a street fair type environment-lots of cities around the world doing this. It would be COOL! Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 39 Count Response 1 As a landscape architecture student at CSU who is studying urban design and development, I am pleased to see Fort Collins taking the steps to produce these designs to enhance the connectivity of our community. 1 Mobility along this corridor is key. It is industrial and should get a face lift - but should also keep a focus on moving large trucks, safely, through this corridor. 1 I'm really disappointed that none of the plans look like they adequately address the increased auto traffic flow. Please listen to those of us that have to live with your decisions. 1 None if this will be good as long as visitors to the area are harassed by some residents in the Buckingham neighborhood. Also, something needs to be done about the aggressive homeless population in the area. 1 Very well done, and seems like a good compromise between the earlier alternatives and diversity of stakeholders. 1 Looks good. Keep those bike lanes coming, and make sure left hand turn lanes exist to keep those cars from driving in the bike lanes. 1 The plan that I saw at the Open House looked extremely expensive. I like trees and sidewalks and bike paths but reasonable cost versus extravagence are important to me 1 It looks like a well-thought out plan that addresses all modes of transportation while improving the south edge of the Buckingham neighborhood. 1 I appreciate the workshops, presentations, surveys and well thought-out work and design. The hard part will be waiting for all this to happen! 1 Am curious about the timing and milestones. What is timing for plan presentation and acceptance? When will the buildout commence? It seems like the Udall natural area is just an empty barren field. Or am I missing something? Is this habitat for specifc critters? Is this space being leveraged for some purpose we are unaware of? Some of the commercial establishments near the river (oil and gas, cement plant, etc) are eyesores while InSitu has taken a more environmentally friendly approach. Not sure how you can encourage these other businesses to improve their facades and environs to integrate more seamlessly into these new designs. Good luck! Thanks for this opportunity to provide input. 1 This plan is very disappointing. I think it's great that the city wants to improve the aesthetics of the Lincoln Corridor and that will be much appreciated but I work in the Lincoln Corridor now and it's already a challenge getting to downtown for lunch. It can take 2-3 cycles to turn left from Mountain onto College. Walking is great but only when the weather isn't too hot or cold and when I have extra time - you can't walk, get lunch, and get back in less than an hour. If you add the traffic from Woodward I'm afraid it will be too much of a hassle and it will no longer be practical to go downtown for lunch. 1 QUIT PAVING NEW AND RECONSTRUCTED ROADS IN ASPHALT, YOU ARE COSTING US TAX PAYERS MORE MONEY IN THE LONG RUN THAN YOU ARE SAVING INITIALLY! 1 I am excited for this project and hope the funding falls into place with the hopeful renewal for BOB II. Extending Old Town down to the river and along the Lincoln corridor really enhances all of Old Town. 1 The additional bicycle/pedestrian amenities, bridge enhancement plans and addition of landscaping are great. However, landscape ROW designs for shoulders are too wide. Design seems ignore that auto/truck traffic will always be a reality on East Lincoln given the commercial zoning. The vision is for another West Mountain Avenue feel but this stretch of Lincoln is mixed use and not all residential. Celebrate the commercial businesses along with the residential on Lincoln Avenue. Provide more left turn access or drivers will be pulling U-turns to access 1 Online Survey #3 Preferred Plan Summary 40 Count Response sustainability to the next level in our city. 1 I am very concerned about single lanes of auto traffic; when a police traffic stop occurs, traffic will back up for a long ways and a long time. Transit bus pull-over lanes are nice, but I forgot to check for those. Overall a very beautiful and well conceived plan. 1 I think the Power trail should be extended off of the Poudre river trail up Lamay and then across Buckingham and pop out on Linden at Vine. Once across Vine it can run up to the power station where it can connect with other future bicycle trails (shown as already planned). 1 IT LOOKS VERY NICE AND I'M SURE LOTS OF PEOPLE WILL APPRECIATE IT. BUT LEMAY FROM LINCOLN TO NORTH OF VINE IS HORRIBLE, THEN A TRAIN COMES AND MAKES IT WORSE. FIX THAT FIRST!!! 1 I didn't see any public restrooms. It would be nice to have 2 to3 public restrooms in the area. Good or bad idea I would like to know why not. Just a thought. 1 Currently, Lincoln Ave is very dangerous. I ride my bike and the trail is closed so Lincoln Ave is the alternative, and it's very dangerous. Cars travel too fat and too close to the alternative lane. 1 The main concern I have is how this development is going to affect the Buckingham neighborhood. With more traffic and noise, will long time residents move somewhere else. Will this development put pressure on folks living on Lincoln that there home and yard will have to look a certain way? 1 I think this needs to be integrated as fully as possible with acquisition and protection of open space in the Poudre floodplain in this area, especially for old industrial and commercial properties adjacent to the river. The most consideration should be given to how it will impact and benefit the neighborhoods. The businesses seem to be doing fine without the corridor development so I don't want o subsidize them with tax $ 1 I believe strongly that this area has long been neglected over the years by the City of Fort Collins and I would love it if the planners would consider a meeting with both the remaining families (most are still here) who founded these neighborhoods, who NEVER get included in any of these discussions for input, opinions and historical reference. I have faith that this city will not let us down again in history with forced oppression that existed in the past history of Fort Collins, and remember that this is a multi-cultural history that has drawn crowds of hundreds for me at the Fort Collins Senior Center and at the International Convention for the American Historical Society of Germans from Russia this past July. Thank you for your time and consideration of my comments. - Cheryl Glanz 1 The plan seems to be well thought out and very pretty. My biggest concern is cost. All of the questions were about how to make it better and what "ideally" one might want. It appears to be a lot of money to spend for a mile of road. If asking most people what they want in a car they might describe a Ferrari... yet most people don't buy a Ferrari. Asking about what is worth the cost or some value questions might be more beneficial. Yes I think many of the things on this survey but if it increases the cost or delays other projects because of funding to this I may not want them in that situation. Thanks - 1 Aesthetics are great, but we need to focus on functionality over form to start with. There seems to be a desire to cut down on automobile usage, which is nice, but consider that there are businesses with traffic needs here, there are people who work in this area who are not going to bike to work all the time. This plan seems to really neglect the main issues of this neighborhood in an attempt to make it pretty. 1 To assist the current & future heavy truck traffic & in minimizing traffic through the Buckingham neighborhood, Lincoln needs to be widened to 2 lanes in each direction. 1 Might consider a bike path from New Belgium Brewery to Lincoln Ave. along 1st Street; many people use that route to get to Lincoln Ave. with the intention of traveling to Odell and Fort Collins Breweries. E T i s p I i n S C Lincoln Ja Event Over The project t nformation streetscape a potential fun n addition, i ncluding tra neighborhoo Summary o Citizen Appr  Looki fabulo  Looki  Alway  Large  Exper  Plenty  Great  Loves likes t  Happy and V the sa  Beaut  Likes  Likes  Appea  Like t  Likes  Likes  Likes  Likes  Excite Corridor P anuary 23, rview team provid on the Prefe amenities, b nding option nformation nsit phasing od infrastruc of Public C roval: ng forward to ous idea. ng forward to Lincoln Corridor Plan – Summary of January 23, 2014 Open House Page 2 of 3 Preferred Alternative Design & Implementation February 10, 2014  Likes the focus on pedestrians and number of sidewalks.  Likes sidewalk barriers, medians, and introduction to park.  Nice visual display.  Likes buffers between bike and car lanes.  Likes fenced private yards.  Overall looks great – big improvement while protecting the neighborhood.  Likes that Lincoln will remain a 1‐lane road in each direction – should keep traffic relatively slow and awake.  Likes bike buffer strip. More room for sharing with pedestrians.  Presentations, information, and solicitation of feedback have been good and helpful. Suggestions for Improvement:  Would like to narrow the median near the Lincoln/1st Street intersection to allow for a left turn lane eastbound Lincoln onto northbound 1st Street.  Would like to see 15 mph signs, speed bumps, and signs that read “through traffic discouraged” on 1st, 2nd, and 3rd Streets.  Would like a parking garage on the current mission site (near Jefferson/Linden).  Wanted to know if the City will be paving the north/south alleys between Lincoln and Logan or just the east/west alley that runs parallel to Lincoln?  Wondering about the widening of the sidewalks on 1st, 2nd, and 3rd Streets?  It would be nice to have Q&A “zones” by expert and labelled to facilitate finding them by role.  Bike lanes should not be put into the door zone. Park an SUV, open the door, and draw the bike lane outside of that range.  The north side entrance to 1101 E. Lincoln does not look like it is drawn as a regular entrance. If there is an expectation to close this entrance, that would be a major problem.  Would love to see a trolley plan instead of rubber tire shuttle.  Would like to see more local history incorporated.  Not enough diversity re: Germans, Russians, Hispanics  Traffic is not addressed well – there are still issues for residents in Buckingham.  Get local (diversity) involved so they will support the plan.  Need to have Vine/Lemay rerouted before Lincoln project or the Lincoln project will fail.  Very concerned about semi’s unloading vehicles on the street and deliveries in and out.  Would like improvement in the 2‐directional center turn lane in central the central segment or alley access alternative.  Would like more area on the bridge for an overlook.  Would prefer not to have signage regarding cut‐through traffic.  Lighting could be improved.  Questions the on‐street parking in front of the commercial businesses – considers the street parking a danger that doesn’t seem to be needed in the east segment. Lincoln Corridor Plan – Summary of January 23, 2014 Open House Page 3 of 3 Preferred Alternative Design & Implementation February 10, 2014  What about closing down the south side of the street to traffic every Sunday morning to turn it into a pedestrian mall (bikes and skates ok) during the summer?  Wonders what will become of the ditch along the north side of the road?  Consider a roundabout at Lincoln and Lemay.  Interested in a pedestrian connection and master transportation plan between the brewery district, sugar beet district, and energy district.  Would like to see the issue of cyclists turning west onto Willow from Lincoln addressed – this is currently a 90 degree angle and a turn is difficult. Cyclists heading onto Lincoln (on NW side) need to be able to exit the Poudre Trail safely.  Concerned about encouraging people to drive to breweries and drink, as well as being “doored”.  Concerned that traffic flow will suffer because too much attention is being paid to design and landscaping. LINCOLN INPUT RESPONSE Last Updated: 02/19/14 1 BACKGROUND COMMUNITY‐DEFINED VISION: The new Lincoln will be recognized as a Great Street: an active and vibrant destination that celebrates our history and is a model for sustainability. PROJECT APPROACH: ‐ Green boulevard, two lane arterial (consistent with Streetscape Standards and Master Street Plan) ‐ Safe, convenient facilities for all users ‐ Amenities that support gateway and celebrate history of area/neighborhood ‐ Look for opportunities to close/consolidate driveways to reduce conflict points ‐ Balance needs of existing businesses with future potential redevelopment 1. Lincoln Preferred Alternative Plan What We Heard from Businesses City’s Response Need for existing driveway accesses  Maintained driveways to support needs of existing businesses; could change upon redevelopment  Provided median breaks and left‐turn lanes at select locations Need to accommodate truck movements  Sized driveways, turn lanes to support truck movements Desire to preserve rail trolley option  City Council did not support including the rail trolley in the plan  Preferred Alternative design does not include design for a future rail trolley; however, we are looking at updating the design to provide a wider median in the East segment where there is adequate right‐of‐way (ROW) to make a trolley easier to implement, should it be supported in the future Concern about potential congestion  Preferred Alternative design is for a two‐lane arterial, per the Master Street Plan  Forecasts for daily traffic fall within general capacity guidelines for a two‐lane arterial  Lincoln Avenue intersection operations were analyzed, and all operated at acceptable LOS  Turn lanes are included at: o Willow (EB LT) o Woodward West/Odell West (WB & EB LT) o Woodward East (EB RT, WB LT) o Fort Collins Brewery (EB LT) ATTACHMENT 4 LINCOLN INPUT RESPONSE Last Updated: 02/19/14 2 What We Heard from Businesses City’s Response  As other properties redevelop, a site‐specific TIS will be conducted that will address appropriate additional mitigation (e.g., turn lanes), if needed  Medians generally designed to support U‐turns (of passenger cars)  Median breaks east of 3rd Street generally wide enough to provide refuge for turning passenger cars such that through traffic should be able to generally flow with minimal disruption Sensitivity to potential right‐of‐way (ROW) acquisition  Any ROW acquisition would follow the City’s prescribed process with appraisals and compensation  Some ROW would be acquired under existing ownership; other acquisition would only occur upon redevelopment Desire for unique eclectic design  Design includes current streetscape standards as a base level, plus a variety of unique streetscape amenities specifically designed for Lincoln, such as art/sculpture, historical markers, pavers that offer opportunities for customization (e.g., sugar beets, etc.)  The design changes along the corridor based on expected level of activity and adjacent land uses  Preferred Alternative reflects a general framework and Preliminary Design level of detail. The Final Design will incorporate more detail with the overall streetscape design, including unique urban design amenities. What We Heard from Residents City’s Response Have project outreach events in neighborhoods (recommended Streets facility specifically)  Except for one set of workshops, all events have been held at locations on Lincoln Avenue or at Streets Strong desire by some residents to maintain driveway access from front of residences  Driveway access maintained with additional parking in driveways and on‐street  Potential improvements to rear alley may provide additional access to residents fronting Lincoln Existing sidewalk too close to front doors  Preferred Alternative maximizes distance between sidewalk and front doors, offering generous landscaped buffer Protect the neighborhood  No ROW acquisition proposed on Lincoln in front of Buckingham Celebrate history of area  Art/sculpture, historical markers, and pavers all offer opportunities for customization (e.g., sugar beets, etc.) LINCOLN INPUT RESPONSE Last Updated: 02/19/14 3 2. Neighborhood Projects What We Heard from Residents City’s Response Have project outreach events in neighborhoods (recommended Streets facility specifically)  Except for one set of workshops, all events have been held at locations on Lincoln Avenue or at Streets Protect the neighborhood  Proposing projects that reduce impacts of traffic on neighborhood (e.g., routing of brewery traffic, etc.)  No change to existing RL zoning for neighborhood Celebrate history of area  Art/sculpture, historical markers, pavers all offer opportunities for customization (e.g., sugar beets, etc.) Need sidewalk connections to complete gaps in network  Plan identifies list of neighborhood related infrastructure improvements including interim and new sidewalks to provide enhanced connectivity to destinations in the area Residents in Andersonville neighborhood have difficulty exiting onto Lemay due to traffic – requested new traffic signal at existing Lemay/Buckingham intersection  High costs for interim signal and infrastructure at existing intersection; equipment not transferable to new intersection at realigned Lemay  Traffic volumes do not warrant a new signal at the existing intersection  Future traffic volumes may trigger need for new signal at the realigned Lemay/Buckingham intersection  If Lemay realignment is constructed, traffic in neighborhoods will be significantly reduced Need for street lighting on east side of Lemay between Buckingham and Lincoln  Street lighting currently exists along west side of Lemay  Installing new street lighting on east side would require curb and gutter, which do not currently exist along alignment  Need for safe pedestrian crossing on Lemay  Interim pedestrian signal project proposed near Streets facility to help cross street to park  If Lemay realignment is constructed, traffic in neighborhoods will be significantly reduced, and this would likely be removed 01.15.14 Lincoln Corridor Alternatives Evaluation Table LINCOLN CORRIDOR PLAN DRAFT 4 October 29, 2013 Objective #1 Improve Multi-Modal Mobility Objective #2 Improve Safety Alternative Accommodates Traffic Flow Pedestrian Comfort and Convenience Commuter Bicyclist Comfort and Convenience Leisure Bicyclist Comfort and Convenience Motorist Access and Convenience Commercial Truck Access and Convenience Transit Access and Convenience Provides Safe Crossings at Intersections and Entrance Drives Provides a Buffer Between Vehicular Traffic and Bicyclists Reduces Driveway Access Conflict Points Base Alternative Existing Condition (Includes Woodward Interim Improvements) Fair Poor Fair Poor Good Good Fair Poor Poor Poor Minor Arterial Standard Good Fair Fair Poor Good Good Good Fair Fair NA West Broad Boulevard West Fair Fair Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Poor Modest Median West Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Fair Skinny Street West Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Central Broad Boulevard Central 01.15.14 Lincoln Corridor Alternatives Evaluation Table LINCOLN CORRIDOR PLAN DRAFT October 29, 2013 5 Objective #3 Create Active Street Environment Objective #4 Enhance Appearance Objective #5: Incorporate Sustainable Street Design Practices Community Cost Promotes Traffic Calming Provides Convenient On Street Parking Anticipates Future Redevelopment Potential for Pedestrian Gathering Areas Provides Adequate Landscape Enhancements Potential for Streetscape Amenity Enhancements Transit Oriented Potential for Bioswales & Stormwater Infiltration Potential for Pervious Pavement Community Support Capital Cost Lifecycle Costs Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Fair Poor Poor NA NA NA Poor Poor Poor Poor Fair Fair Good Fair Poor NA NA NA Fair Poor Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Good Fair Good Fair Poor Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Good Fair Poor Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Good Fair Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Poor Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Good Fair Fair Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Poor Fair NA NA Good Good Good NA NA NA Good Fair Fair Fair NA NA Good Good Good NA NA NA Good Fair Fair Good NA NA Good Good Good NA NA NA Good Fair Fair ATTACHMENT 6 October 22, 2013 Council Work Session Summary Page 2 Lincoln Corridor Plan update October 24, 2013 Discussion Summary (continued):  Pedestrian-oriented design and safety are important factors to include in corridor alternatives, including options for traffic calming along corridor  Street alternatives reflect opportunities and constraints – will be a challenge to identify preferred solution  The rail trolley transit option #5 has a significantly higher cost than the other options and is unlikely to be implemented  Downtown circulator with the custom vehicle option appears to be well supported; proposed loop route could be enhanced to further improve service in area  Rubber-tired transit vehicle that reflects innovation and a unique design would benefit Downtown and Lincoln area  Extent of community outreach to-date is great Follow-up Items:  Add second work session prior to hearing (note: tentatively scheduled for January 28, 2014)  Screen out rail trolley transit option from further consideration  To assist with evaluating design alternatives to identify the Preferred Alternative, include more details on capital and operations & maintenance costs for street improvements  Assess how enhanced transit option costs would compare to cost of existing service  Include assessment of potential transit ridership in analysis of expanded service Staff appreciates the opportunity to discuss the Lincoln Corridor Plan with the City Council and received valuable feedback and direction for the project. For more information regarding the project, please visit: http://www.fcgov.com/lincoln. 02.13.14 1 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - West Segment POTENTIAL ACCESS CHANGE WHEN PROPERTY REDEVELOPS LEGEND PROPERTY BOUNDARY/ROW LONG TERM ROW ACQUISITION NEAR TERM ROW ACQUISITION LANDSCAPE (XERIC, TURF AND TREES, OR BIOSWALE) SPECIAL PAVEMENT * PEDESTRIAN SCULPTURAL LIGHTING ELEMENT ATTACHMENT 7 02.13.14 2 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - West Cross Section 02.13.14 3 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - Central Segment ON STREET PARKING SUMMARY TOTAL APPROXIMATE EXISTING: 18 APPROXIMATE PROPOSED: 14 PROPOSED DRIVEWAY PARKING WITHIN ROW: 8 TOTAL APPROXIMATE PROPOSED: 22 POTENTIAL ACCESS CHANGE WHEN PROPERTY REDEVELOPS LEGEND PROPERTY BOUNDARY/ROW LONG TERM ROW ACQUISITION NEAR TERM ROW ACQUISITION LANDSCAPE (XERIC, TURF AND TREES, OR BIOSWALE) SPECIAL PAVEMENT * PEDESTRIAN SCULPTURAL LIGHTING ELEMENT 02.13.14 4 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - Central Cross Section 02.13.14 5 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - East Segment A POTENTIAL ACCESS CHANGE WHEN PROPERTY REDEVELOPS LEGEND PROPERTY BOUNDARY/ROW LONG TERM ROW ACQUISITION NEAR TERM ROW ACQUISITION LANDSCAPE (XERIC, TURF AND TREES, OR BIOSWALE) SPECIAL PAVEMENT * PEDESTRIAN SCULPTURAL LIGHTING ELEMENT 02.13.14 6 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - East Segment B POTENTIAL ACCESS CHANGE WHEN PROPERTY REDEVELOPS LEGEND PROPERTY BOUNDARY/ROW LONG TERM ROW ACQUISITION NEAR TERM ROW ACQUISITION LANDSCAPE (XERIC, TURF AND TREES, OR BIOSWALE) SPECIAL PAVEMENT * PEDESTRIAN SCULPTURAL LIGHTING ELEMENT 02.13.14 7 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - East Cross Section 02.13.14 8 Lincoln Corridor Preferred Alternative - Lincoln Bridge ROW Median - Special Pavement Overlook Overlook Planters Benches Walk Poudre River Trail On Street Bike Lane Walk Walk On Street Bike Lane Pavers Pavers Walk Plan Elevation Poudre River Trail Overlook 02.13.14 1 Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Materials Palette Sandstone Veneer Wood Rusted Metal Finishes Textured Plantings Crushed Stone Concrete Pavers ATTACHMENT 8 02.13.14 2 Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Entry/Neighborhood Monuments Sugar Beet Art or Similar. Backlit to Create Lantern Effect Stone Veneer Rusted Metal Finish 02.13.14 3 Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Typical Pedestrian Gathering Area 02.13.14 4 Bench Trash Receptacle Stone Seat Wall Pavers Pedestrian Lighting Bike Rack Art Plaque Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Pedestrian Gathering Area Amenities 02.13.14 5 Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Special Event Space/Food Trucks Permeable Pavements in Parking Areas Food Trucks in Front of Breweries Tables and Chairs Crushed Stone Pedestrian Area 02.13.14 6 Lincoln Corridor Streetscape Amenities - Special Pavements Special Pavement Bike Lane Buffer Special Pavement at Crosswalk Edge Provides Safe Crossings for Pedestrians Special Pavement Marks Business Entry Concrete Crosswalk Asphalt Drive Concrete Bike Lane DRAFT 01 Propose The Tran Buckingh TSOP. Th  P a  P  P T L  P This phas needed t densities Maps for Near‐/Mi Phase 1 Maintain E Phase 2 Increase Ex Phase 3 – Phase 2 an Phase 3 – Phase 2 an * Ridersh Lemay Av 1/15/14 ed Transit sfort Strateg ham Street. he three pro Phase 1 – Ma and MAX. Phase 2 – En Phase 3 – Op This option w Lincoln Aven Phase 3 – Op sed impleme to support tr s and conseq r the route a d‐Term Trans Existing Route F xisting Route F – Option A nd Lincoln Shut – Option B nd Lincoln Shut ip projections venues; full co Phasing gic Operatin Implementa oposed phase aintain the e nhance the fr ption A – Exp would realig DRAFT 01 Proposed Phase 1 Maintain E Phase 2 Increase Ex Phase 3 – A: Phase 2 B: Phase 2 1/15/14 d Transit Phas Existing Route F xisting Route F – Option A/B and Lincoln Sh and Lincoln Sh sing – Route A Frequencies Frequencies (same routin huttle Route us huttle Route us Alignments (N ng) sing a Standard sing a Custom Near‐/Mid‐Te d Vehicle; Vehicle Term) 2 DRAFT 01 Proposed Phase 4 Replace Lin 1/15/14 d Transit Phas ncoln Shuttle w sing – Route A with Downtow Alignments (L n Shuttle Long‐Term) 3 *Does no DRAFT 10 Prelimina # 1 M ‐ ‐ ‐ 2 En ‐ ‐ 3 Do St ‐ 4 Do Ru ‐ 5 Li ‐ ot include co 0/16/13 ary Transit O Maintain Exist Route 5 – 6 Route 14 – 30 minute connecting nhance Exist Increase fre routes that 15 minute connecting owntown Ci tandard Bus Shuttle – 1 connecting owntown Ci ubber‐Tired Shuttle – 1 connecting ncoln Avenu One‐mile r Lemay) – 1 ost of potent Options – th Description ting Service 60 min. frequ – 60 min. freq (combined) s g to MAX ting Service equencies on t currently se (combined) s Page 2 of 2 DRAFT 10/16/13 Potential Transit Routing – based on Transfort Strategic Operating Plan # 1 B 2 E ( 3 L N 4 L A 5 L a 6 A B 7 A 8 B 9 B ( 10 B 1 11 L A Source of 2005 ‐ No 2011 ‐ Pe 2013 ‐ Lin Location/ Brewery Destinat East Vine Drive – (north side, Alta V Lemay Avenue – Neighborhood an Lemay Avenue – Apts. and Walma Lemay Avenue – and Lincoln Aven Alta Vista, Anders Buckingham Neig Andersonville Ne Buckingham Neig Buckingham Neig (west side); 3rd St Buckingham Neig 1st Street and 3rd Lemay Avenue – Avenue (both sid f Project: orthside Neighborh destrian Plan (PP) ncoln Corridor Plan /Neighborhood tions near Lemay Ave Vista area) between Anders nd Streets Facility between Buffalo rt (east side) Buckingham Stre ue (east side) sonville, and ghborhoods 2/25/2014 1 1 City Council Work Session February 25, 2014 2 General Direction Sought And Specific Questions To Be Answered 1. What feedback or questions does Council have on the proposed Preferred Alternative design? 2. What comments or direction does Council have regarding the proposed transit phasing or neighborhood projects? ATTACHMENT 11 2/25/2014 2 3 Why is the Lincoln Corridor Plan a priority? • Longstanding existing infrastructure deficiencies • City Plan “Catalyst Project” • Funded in 2013/14 work program • Address emerging issues in area 4 Lincoln Corridor Study Area 2/25/2014 3 5 Process/Schedule Phase 1 Vision • Mar – Jul 2013 Phase 2 Alternatives • Aug – Oct 2013 Phase 3 Preferred Plan • Nov 2013 – Apr 2014 We Are Here Community Engagement 6 Corridor Vision The new Lincoln will be recognized as a Great Street: an active and vibrant destination that celebrates our history and is a model for sustainability. 2/25/2014 4 7 Community Engagement – What We Did • Key component throughout project • 2 large public workshops (June, September) • Multiple open houses • 3 online surveys • Regular Boards/Commissions updates • 2 Council Work Sessions • Formal Stakeholder Group meetings • Multiple small group/individual meetings 8 Community Engagement – What We Heard Key Issues – Addressed: • Need for existing driveway access • Need to accommodate truck movements • Need for neighborhood infrastructure improvements in area • Improved level of service for all modes of travel Key Issues – Continued Discussion: • Preserve rail trolley option • Concern about potential congestion • Vine/Lemay impacts 2/25/2014 5 9 Preferred Alternative – East Cross-Section 2 travel lanes Buffered bike lanes Wide sidewalks On-street parking Reduced speed limit 10 Preferred Alternative – East Segment A 2/25/2014 6 11 Lincoln Bridge Conceptual Design 12 Streetscape Amenities 2/25/2014 7 13 Streetscape Amenities 14 Proposed Transit Phasing Phase 1: Existing Service Phase 2: Increase Service Ph. 3: Add Lincoln Shuttle • Option A: Standard Vehicle • Option B: Custom Vehicle Ph. 4: Add Downtown Circulator Increasing Level of Investment Near-/Mid-Term Long-Term 2/25/2014 8 15 Transit – Phase 1 30 minute combined headway 16 Transit – Phase 2 15 minute combined headway 2/25/2014 9 17 Transit – Phase 3 <15 minute combined headway New Lincoln Shuttle route 18 Neighborhood Project Examples • New sidewalk connections • Interim sidewalks • New pedestrian crossing • Transit stop improvements • Education program, signage to reduce impacts of cut- through traffic • Neighborhood gateway/interpretive signage or monuments 2/25/2014 10 19 Neighborhood Projects Map ~$1 million for all projects 20 Lincoln Avenue – Project Costs Estimated Total Cost: $19M (preliminary) • Roadway and sidewalks • Bridge • Landscaping • Streetscape amenities • Transit stops • Design and construction engineering • ROW and construction easements 2/25/2014 11 21 Project Benefits Social: • Attractive, active, and safe street environment Economic: • Catalyst project for area Environmental: • Stormwater/water quality management, reduces reliance on single-occupant vehicle 22 Funding Options • Budget Process (BFO) • General Fund • Keep Fort Collins Great (KFCG) • Dedicated sales tax – Building On Basics (BOB) • Existing/Future • Downtown Development Authority • Street Oversizing Fund • State and federal grants 2/25/2014 12 23 Next Steps Project Website: fcgov.com/lincoln Feb / March 2014 • Finalize Plan document • Stakeholder Group Meeting #4 (Mar 5) • Final Public Review of Plan • Boards/Commission Recommendations April 2014 • City Council Adoption Hearing (Apr 1) 24 General Direction Sought And Specific Questions To Be Answered 1. What feedback or questions does Council have on the proposed Preferred Alternative design? 2. What comments or direction does Council have regarding the proposed transit phasing or neighborhood projects? 2/25/2014 13 25 For More Information Visit: www.fcgov.com/lincoln ighborhood ghborhood ghborhood – 1st S treet (east side) ghborhood – betw Street near Linco Vine Drive to Lin es) hoods Plan (NNP) (LCP) DR Wayfind breweri Neighbo nue Transit s bus stop onville y Push‐bu Run New sid eet Interim A) along B) along Avenue project) New gat Monum New ne park are Signage traffic Street New sid ween oln Alley im and pav neighbo coln Perman concurr estimat Timing of P Short‐Term Mid‐Term ( Long‐Term RAFT Neighborh Febr Project De ding to provide ro ies that do not cu orhood stop improvemen p to add new she utton pedestrian dewalk asphalt sidewalk g east side of exis g dedicated ROW (10th Street to fu ) teway/interpretiv ment for neighbor ighborhood park ea at Streets Faci e to reduce impac dewalks mprovements incl ving of alley to pr ors nent sidewalks, cu rent with realigne e includes ROW Projects: m (1‐2 years) (3‐5 years) (5+ years) hood Improvem ruary 12, 2014 escription outes between ut through Buckin nt: upgrade exist elter and pad signal, crosswalk k; two options: sting Lemay Aven W of realigned Lem uture residential ve signage, or en rhoods k elements to exis lity cts from cut‐throu uding ROW acqu ovide better acce urb and gutter; ed Lemay Avenue ment Projects Sourc ngham LCP ting PP k LCP PP nue may PP LCP ntrance NNP LCP sting NNP LCP ugh LCP PP LCP isition ess for NNP PP e; PP LCP rce Projec P Sho P Sho P Sho P Sho P P Sho P P Short/ P P Short/ P Short/ P P Short/ P P Short/ P P Lon ct Phasing ort‐term ort‐term ort‐term ort‐term ort‐term /Mid‐term /Mid‐term /Mid‐term /Mid‐term /Mid‐term ng‐term Cost Estimate $1,000 $10,000 $80,000 $10,000‐15,000 A) $60,000 B) $40,000 $90,000 $150,000 $1,000 $150,000‐300,00 $140,000 $200,000‐400,00 1 0 00 00 ATTACHMENT 10 g to MAX rculator Serv 0 minute freq g to MAX rculator Serv Custom Veh 0 minute freq g to MAX ue Trolley (R ail route (Ma 0 minute freq ial right‐of‐w hese will be r ency uency service n existing rve Lincoln service vice Using quency vice Using hicle quency ail) thews to quency way acquisit refined and Likely ‐ Trans popu ‐ Gree ‐ Trans popu ‐ Gree ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Trans popu ‐ Gree ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Trans popu ‐ Gree ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Touri ‐ Trans popu ‐ Gree ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Area ‐ Touri tion or new m incorporate User Group sit dependen ulations n Riders sit dependen ulations n Riders Residents Employees sit dependen ulations n Riders Residents Employees Visitors sit dependen ulations n Riders Residents Employees Visitors ists sit dependen ulations n Riders Residents Employees Visitors ists maintenance ed into the L ps Ca Ongoi Cost t N $4 t $80 $9 t $80 $1, t $1,5 $1, t $23,0 $1, e facility Lincoln Corri apital / ing Annual Estimate None / 450,000 00,000 / 900,000 00,000 / 200,000 500,000 / 200,000 000,000* / 200,000 idor Preferre  Continuan  Unlikely t  Upgraded  Increases  Benefits e and Lema  Additiona  Upgraded  Convenie Corridor  Unknown  Additiona  Upgraded  Convenie Corridor  Unknown  Upgraded  Tourist at  New spec  Potential  Dependin be neede  Potential  Convenie Corridor  Unknown  Tourist at  New spec  Higher m  Potential  Infrastruc . Likely . Upgra . Need . Crossi . Bridge . New t ed Alternati Cons nce of existing o meet future d bus stops convenience, extend beyond ay) al vehicles and d bus stops nt trips betwe n ridership pote al vehicles and d bus stops nt trips betwe n ridership pote d bus stops ttraction cialty vehicles for higher mai ng on vehicle ty d, e.g., electric for innovative nt trips betwe n ridership pote ttraction cialty rail vehic aintenance and need for right‐ cture Upgrades removal of ex aded stops for maintenan ngs of existing e widening ove track installatio ve siderations funding levels demand on Lin thus expandin the Lincoln Co operating cost en downtown ential operational co en downtown ential intenance and ype additional c charging facil technologies en downtown ential les d operational c ‐of‐way‐acquis s isting median p ce facility on r g railroad track er Poudre River on s ncoln ng ridership bas orridor (Mulbe ts and Lincoln osts and Lincoln operational co infrastructure ities and Lincoln costs sition parking rail line s r se erry osts may Vehicle T Type LINCOLN CORRIDOR TRANSIT OPTIONS PRESENTED AT OCTOBER 22, 2013 WORK SESSION nue yields a c ption B – Thi entation is s ransit service quently phas alignments fo sit Phases Frequencies Frequencies ttle using a Sta ttle using a Cus s are based o orridor infill/r g Plan (TSOP ation of this es for near‐/ existing Rout requencies o pand upon P n Route 14 o combined fr s option is t upported by e at or below sing service i or near‐/mid andard Vehicle stom Vehicle n residential redevelopmen P) (2009) pro long‐term v /mid‐term im tes 5 and 14 of Route 5 a Phase 2, add onto Jefferso requency of he same as y recommen w 15 minute improvemen d‐ and long‐t Linc and employm nt is not inclu oposes a bi‐ vision is reco mplementat 4 at 60 minut nd 14 to 30 ing a modifi on/Riverside less than 15 Phase 3 Opt ndations of t e frequencie nts in concer term phases coln Corridor Downt 30 Mi 15 Mi <15 M <15 Mi ment density uded in these directional c ommended t tion include te frequenci minutes eac ed Circulato e Avenue an 5 minutes. T tion A, excep he Transit C s. As this ar rt with incre s are provide r Frequency t town nute nute inute nutes projections f e projections. circulator ro to be phased the followin ies, but coor ch, creating or Route (“Li nd keep 30 m This option u pt a customi Capacity and rea does not eased develo ed on subseq to P (78,000 (86,000 for the year 2 ute at 10 mi d in concert ng: rdinate the o a combined ncoln Shuttl minute bi‐dir utilizes stand zed vehicle Quality of S t currently, n opment and quent pages Projected Rid (annual 193,00 277,00 355,00 0 generated fr 363,00 0 generated fr 017. This inc inute freque with the cor operating tim 15 minute b e”) that pro ectional serv dard Transfo would be us ervice Manu nor is planne demand exp s. Near‐/Mid ership* ) 0 0 0 om Circulator) 0 om Circulator) orporates the encies, conne rridor buildin mes to creat bi‐directiona vides a 15 m vice by Rout rt vehicles to ed to opera ual, Third Ed ed to have su pected in the ‐Term trans Cost 1) Capital 2) O & M 1) $0 2) $450,00 1) $800,00 2) $900,00 1) $1.6 M 2) $2.1 M 1) $2.3 M 2) $2.1 M e Woodward ecting the Li ng out and c te a 30 minu al connection minute bi‐dir te 5 on Linco o operate th te the Linco ition (2013) uch densities e corridor. it phases are 00 00 00 site full build incoln Corrid reating dem te bi‐directi n between t ectional con oln Avenue. T he proposed ln Shuttle se , which state s with dwell e summarize d out and anti dor to Down mand for the onal connec he Lincoln C nnection bet The combin Lincoln Shu ervice. es that corri ing units alo ed below. Project P (O& icipated resid ntown Fort C high freque ction betwee Corridor and tween the Li nation of the uttle. idor densitie one, staff rec ted Annual Co Passenger &M/Ridership) $2.33 $3.25 $5.91 $5.79 dential develo Collins and M ency circulat en the Linco d Downtown incoln Corrid e Lincoln Shu es of 15 dwe commends a ost/ P Ex 20 - - - - - - opment on th MAX via Lem tor service p oln Corridor a and MAX. dor and Dow uttle and Rou elling units (d also conside roposed Imp xisting Servic 017/18 When combi employment When ridersh suggesting ex When fundin When combi employment When ridersh suggesting ex When fundin he northeast c may Avenue a roposed in t and Downto wntown and ute 5 service du)/acre are ring employ lementation e ned 15 du an t per acre is re hip meets ind xpansion of s ng is identified ned 15 du an t per acre is re hip meets ind xpansion of s ng is identified corner of Linc and he wn MAX. e on ment Timeframe d/or eached dicators ervice d d/or eached dicators ervice d coln and 1 ATTACHMENT 9 Fair Good Good Good Poor Fair Good Good Good Good Modest Median Central Good Fair Good Good Fair Poor Good Fair Good Fair Skinny Street Central Fair Poor Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Poor East Broad Boulevard East Fair Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Fair Modest Median East Fair Good Poor Good Fair Poor Good Good Fair Fair Skinny Street East Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Poor Bridge Bridge Option 1 - Broad Boulevard Good Fair Good Good Good Fair NA Good Good NA Bridge Option 2 - Modest Median Good Fair Good Good Good Fair NA Good Good NA Bridge Option 3 - Skinny Street Good Good Good Good Good Fair NA Good Good NA LINCOLN CORRIDOR PLAN - DESIGN ALTERNATIVES EVALUATION Evaluation Criteria Ratings: Poor Fair Good DRAFT ATTACHMENT 5 ys well‐organ pictures are rts available f y of chairs an t snacks and w s the new brid the improved y that the tra Vine intersect afety of the n tiful plan. the change to the wide bike ars that earlie he bridge and the circulator the median s bridge impro increased fre ed to have Tra Plan – "Linc , 2014 Ope ed project m erred Altern bridge conce ns. was availab g options, Lo cture improv Comments o having more o alley improv ized. handy. or Q&A are h d tables for r water. dge because i d crossing of t nsit phasing t ion haven’t b eighborhood o parking for e lanes and go er citizen sugg d glad the rou r custom bus separation in vements, nei equency of ro ansfort on Go coln Prefer en House – materials at a ative for Lin ept, benefits le on related ow Impact De vements and (69 citizen e frequent bu vements and helpful. reviewing doc t is currently the train track ties into MAX been forgotte kids. the single fam ood flow of th gestions have undabout fail in Old Town. west and eas ighborhood m utes, custom oogle. rred Altern – Summary a public ope coln, includi of the proje d neighborh evelopment d other proje ns in atten us service – th sidewalks in cument plus n a death trap ks and the int X. Also likes t n. These roa mily homes o he design. e been well‐in ed. . st segments a monuments, a vehicle ideas native and y of Public en house Jan ing the over ect, estimate ood implem t (LID) compo ects identifie dance) hinks Lincoln/ Buckingham. note‐taking. for pedestria tersection by the fact that i ds need to be on the north s ncorporated i and extra prop and bike lane s, and downto d Impleme c Commen nuary 23, 201 rall design fra ed project co mentation str onents, and ed within the /Downtown s . ans and bicyc Ranchway Fe mpacts of ex e improved e side. into plans. posed bus sto e. own shuttle. ntation" ts 14 with amework, ost and rategies, e study area shuttle is a lists and also eeds. isting Lemay specially for ops. a. The only thing I can say is that it is wonderful to read about these improvements! Fort Collins was always known to me as a Bicycle/Pedestrian friendly town and all of these ideas are great! 1 It is exciting to hear of the proposed improvements. The Lincoln Corridor is currently quite an eyesore and dangerous to cycle on. 1 Very pleased with the direction this area is going. Please, protected bike lanes must be included in all new designs for the city. This is an absolute need to get more women and families out riding their bikes and take use some sort of innovative vehicle 1 "The transit service on Lincoln is proposed to be incrementally improved to support development in the area and observed ridership demand." Bass ackwards. Nobdy will take the bus if the frequency is 60 minutes. Transit is one of few topics on which the maxim "Build it and they will come" is valid. Please spare us more of your fancy schmancy --- just put in lots of bus service. 1 Same issues as in other areas of Lincoln. I'd prefer the bike lanes be separated from the traffic. With all the truck traffic on this street I still think it's dangerous for cyclists. Otherwise looks good. Could move center median to sides to buffer bike lanes. it. 1 I DRIVE FROM WILLOX SOUTH ON LEMAY TO LINCOLN WEST TO RIVERSIDE EVERYDAY TO WORK AND BACK. IT IS HORRIBLE, THEN THE TRAIN COMES!!! 1 This section might need to be wider (two lanes each direction). Traffic from Lemay to the breweries and while entering or exiting parking area? 1 You will most certainly need an overpass at Lincoln and Riverside as well as at Lemay and Riverside and Vine and Lemay as the traffic is horrible now with the volume and is even worse when trains are present!! This is a disaster waiting to happen!! Woodward should have been built nearer to I-25! 1 Is there space for more traffic lanes if required in the future. Should this be a concern based on demographic importance of native Rocky Mountain plants. PS Please NO MORE Karl Forester grass!!!!!!!! That's so early 2000...:) 1 Widened/new bridge over river is crucial in this segment to allow and encourange pedestrian and bicycle traffic in a safe manner. uninterrupted when a vehicle needs to turn.. waiting to make a turn. I'd like to see a much narrower median and add in a turn lane wherever appropriate in both directions. I would like to see the speed reduced to 25 mph because safely of pedestrians and cyclists will be even more crucial in years to come. If lower speed limit reduces the amount of traffic taking this route so much the better.  As corridor plan is implemented, increased opportunities to OPPORTUNITIES:  Will be the first “New Great Street” project – if successful, may create similar street opportunities across FC  Could develop new partnerships and collaborations with breweries and future breweries  Could help develop new funding collaborations – sales tax, DDA expansion, new business attraction  Utilizing local and sustainable materials reduces embedded energy and life cycle costs  Could become a catalyst project for Northside Neighborhoods  Attractive streets tend to attract high quality developments and higher paying employment  New transportation vehicles may be prototyped within the district  As corridor plan is implemented, increased opportunities to improve flood protection and overall community resilience  The strategic nature of this planning document will allow for quick implementation of some elements, which will allow benefits to be realized more quickly  Adding flexibility to zoning/land use could facilitate new development and redevelopment and encourage mixed-use projects that support an active pedestrian oriented street environment along the corridor OPPORTUNITIES:  The project has the opportunity to collaborate with other, significant efforts in the Poudre River – synergies with this project and the other, environmentally-focused efforts will contribute to the City’s overall triple bottom line  Utilizing local and sustainable materials reduces embedded energy and life cycle costs  Improved health benefits and air quality created by encouraging more cycling and walking  Appropriate night lighting and street lighting can minimize impacts on area wildlife  Appropriate landscaping can mitigate heat island effect  New transit vehicles may be prototyped and used in area  As corridor plan is implemented, increased opportunities to improve flood protection and overall community resilience  Incorporation of new Low Impact Development (LID) facilities within corridor  Strong integration of art in public places, which will enhance cultural & aesthetic value of adjacent neighborhoods and businesses  Potential for enhanced/expanded transit service in area  Improves access to the industrial uses and employment destinations STRENGTHS:  Implements City Plan components  Is consistent with recent Master Street Plan downsizing of Lincoln from 4-lane to 2-lane arterial – Reduced air quality impacts  Street design will incorporate sustainability practices such as “Green Street” and Low Impact Development (LID) improvements (enhanced water quality measures)  LID treatment could improve habitat value of adjacent Poudre River corridor  Increased urban tree canopy potential from landscaping improvements  Reduce greenhouse emissions  Beautifying gateways - enhanced gateway to downtown and to East Mulberry Corridor  Reduced speed limit could reduce fossil fuel consumption  Can tie into Woodward enhancements along the Poudre River Corridor  Appropriate landscaping can mitigate heat island effect  Opportunities for people to connect to nature and observe / learn about natural systems in adjacent Poudre corridor and pocket areas  Preserves environmental features in corridor utcome. The environme sions Offered This project ha lexibility inco while supportin Creating a grea as many socia Right-of-way a erm and with ial Key Indic As indicated d mportant to th . The projec effort thus . The team w term impac nclude this pr Trip ey informati d Alternative taff and cons sions are hig oln Corridor ons from TBL ysis was well rations crosse columns indic of rows indica tifies the plan L analysis, th – the social a celebrate the lues. ghlight the sh rstand the long on around the ental consider d: as incorporate orporated into ng existing bu at street that i al, economic, acquisition in future redeve cators Sugges uring the TBL he planning ou ct managers h far. will need to e cts of implem ocess in a com Lincoln ple Bottom Ja ion extracted e design for sultant proje ghlighted, inc r Plan. L Analysis: l balanced wi ed into many c cates excellen ates potential nning corridor he social stren aspects of a st neighborhoo hort-term (dur g-term conseq e process of th rations could/ ed strong pub o design that s usinesses. incorporates b and environm n selected loca elopment; the sted: L analysis bra utcome. have excelled engage in a m menting this p mmunication - 1 - n Corrido Line Analy nuary 8, 20 d from the Tr Lincoln Ave ect team thro cluding reco ith ample stre columns and nt depth of dis for conflictin r as a Catalys ngths, limitati treet/corridor ods, provide a ring construct quences of th he plan’s dev /should be str lic engageme supports new best practices mental benefi ations is key t process shou ainstorming, t at engaging t ore direct dia lan. plan & publi or Plan ysis – Summ 014 riple Bottom enue. The T ough a series ommendation engths and lim rows. scussion and d ng values. st Area; this p ions, opportun cannot be un additional con tion) impacts his effort. velopment bei rengthened in ent throughou w developmen s (e.g., LID, en its but at a hig to fulfilling th uld continue to the process o the neighborh alogue with th ic engagemen mary m Line (TBL TBL analysis s of brainstor ns on key in mitations iden debate. plan implemen nities and thre nderstated in t nnectivity, and to neighbors ing equally im n additional an ut the process. nt and redevel nhanced ame gher cost than he full corrido o be treated w f developing hoods and bus he public abou nt plan. L) Analysis a s was develo rming sessio ndicators and ntified. nts City Plan eats far outwe this process, i d address con and residents mportant to th nalysis. . opment oppo enities and tra n typical road or vision both with sensitivit this plan is eq sinesses throu ut the short-te as it relates oped by the ons. General d suggested . eighed the including the ncerns related s and a need he overall ortunities ansit service) dway projects h in the near- ty. qually ughout the erm and long- l d . - ATTACHMENT 2