Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOUNCIL - AGENDA ITEM - 04/10/2012 - CITY COUNCIL REVIEW OF DRAFT RESULT MAPS AND REQUEDATE: April 10, 2012 STAFF: Darin Atteberry, Mike Beckstead, Lawrence Pollack Pre-taped staff presentation: none WORK SESSION ITEM FORT COLLINS CITY COUNCIL SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION City Council Review of Draft Result Maps and Request for Results Documents as Prepared by the 2012 Result Teams for the 2013-14 Budget. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Council will review the draft Result Maps and Request for Results documents for the 2013-14 Budgeting for Outcomes (BFO) process for the following seven Outcomes: 1. Economic Health 2. Environmental Health 3. Transportation 4. Culture and Recreation 5. Community and Neighborhood Livability. 6. High Performing Government 7. Safe Community The purpose of the work session is to hear brief presentations from each of the seven Result Teams and provide feedback to the teams regarding the draft Result Maps and Request for Results (RFRs). The RFRs will be used by staff to determine to which Outcome their proposed services and programs (Offers) should be submitted. The Result Teams will then use the RFRs to help develop their ranking of Offers and which ones they recommend be included in the City Manager’s Recommended 2013-14 Budget. GENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED 1. Is Council in agreement with the overall strategy and direction of the Result Teams? 2. Does Council have any suggested changes to the proposed Result Maps and Request for Results which have been developed by the Result Teams? BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION In 2005, the City implemented Budgeting for Outcomes (BFO), a process that is based on collaboration, transparency, and delivering the services that matter most to the public. BFO is based on the premise that there is a “price of government,” a percentage of personal income the public is willing to pay for the services and programs provided by their government through taxes, fees, and charges. While traditional budget models are built around covering costs, BFO shifts the focus from April 10, 2012 Page 2 paying for costs to buying results within available revenue streams. BFO can be described as a series of basic steps: • Determine how much revenue will be available • Determine what results matter most to citizens • Decide how much to spend to achieve each result • Decide how to best deliver the results that citizens expect. In short, BFO puts citizens and their priorities first. It emphasizes accountability, efficiency, and innovation. The City of Fort Collins will continue this commitment to BFO for the 2013-14 budget and we have continued to make improvements to the BFO process based on previous budgeting cycles and feedback that we solicit. As in the previous budgeting cycles using BFO, the following is a summary of how City staff will be involved in the process: • Result Teams comprised of staff and citizens will develop Result Maps and RFRs that document purchasing strategies for the Outcomes adopted by City Council. • Departments/Divisions (“Sellers”) will build and submit their budget Offers (budget requests for services and programs to be “offered”) based upon the purchasing strategies identified in the RFRs, and identify funding sources that will allow delivery of their proposed Offers. • Result Teams will review Seller’s Offers and rank them based on their ability to deliver the desired results. This recommended ranking of Offers will be submitted to the Budget Lead Team. • The Budget Lead Team reviews the work of the Result Team and develops the City Manager’s Recommended Budget. Following staff’s work on the budget, Council will work during September and October to transform the City Manager’s Recommended Budget into its own adopted budget for 2013-14. Council’s deliberation process will include several work sessions, as well as public hearings to invite participation of the community, Boards and Commissions. 2013-14 OUTCOMES At the February 11, 2012 Council Workshop, Council provided direction that the following seven Outcomes be used for the 2013-14 budget: • Economic Health Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values • Environmental Health Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. April 10, 2012 Page 3 • Community and Neighborhood Livability Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods • Safe Community Fort Collins is a safe place to live, work, learn, and play. • Culture and Recreation Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities • High Performing Government Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative City government. • Transportation Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. REQUESTS FOR RESULTS The Result Maps and the Request for Results (RFRs) are the “bridge” between the City's strategic plans and the services/programs offered to achieve those plans (Results). The Result Maps graphically depict how the Outcome/Result can be achieved The RFRs are a narrative of the map and will guide Sellers in the preparation of their Offers. Much like a purchasing Request for Proposal (RFP) for services, an RFR outlines what kind of Offers the team thinks will produce the desired Outcome/Result. The RFRs consist of: • A statement of the Outcome/Result • Identification of indicators and performance measures that will tell us if we have achieved the desired Outcome/Result • Purchasing Strategies that are intended to guide Sellers in preparing the types of Offers the Result Team wants. Council will be asked to review the draft Result Maps and Request for Results and provide feedback or suggestions for changes prior to the Results Teams formally issuing their RFRs to Sellers. ATTACHMENTS 1. 2012 Results Team Member List 2. Requests for Results (RFRs) and Result Maps 3. Powerpoint presentation 2012 Results Teams for the 2013-14 Budget Updated 19 March 2012 Economic Health Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Ginny Sawyer Comm Dev & Neighborhood PPT Services Continuing Budget Liaison Jessica Ping-Small Finance Financial Services New Communications Jill Mueggenberg Recreation Comm & Ops Services Continuing - new team & role Josh Birks Economic Development Sustainability Services Continuing - new team Bill Whirty Parks Comm & Ops Services New Dean Cunningham Patrol Police Services New Timothy Wilder Advance Planning PPT Services New Citizen McCabe Callahan New Environmental Health Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Lucinda Smith Environmental Sustainability Sustainability Services Continuing - new role Budget Liaison Barb Brock Natural Areas Comm & Ops Services Continuing Communications Lori Greening Human Resources Emp & Comm Services New Craig Hibbard Water Reclamation & Biosolids Utility Services Continuing - new team Bob Adams Recreation Comm & Ops Services New Kevin Cronin Patrol Police Services New Lance Smith Utilities Finance and Budget Utility Services New Citizen K-Lynn Cameron New Community and Neighborhood Livability Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Matt Zoccali Regulation & Govt Affairs Utility Services Continuing - new team & role Budget Liaison Janice Saeger Recreation Comm & Ops Services New Communications Susan Herlihy Cultural Services Comm & Ops Services Continuing - new role Kurt Clow Patrol Police Services Continuing Tim Buchanan Parks Comm & Ops Services Continuing Patty Netherton Municipal Court ELJ Services New Polly Lauridsen Comm Dev & Neighborhood PPT Services New Citizen Kristin Kirkpatrick New Safe Community Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Ann Turnquist City Manager's Office ELJ Services Continuing - new team & role Budget Liaison Tricia Muraguri Office of the Chief Police Services Continuing Communications Cathy Blakeman Human Resources Emp & Comm Services Continuing - new team Susie Gordon Environmental Services Sustainability Services Continuing - new team Mike Trombley Police Services Police Services Continuing - new team Ron Simms Poudre Fire Authority Poudre Fire Authority New Daylan Figgs Natural Areas Comm & Ops Services New Citizen Gary Thomas New Josh Jones City Manager's Office ELJ Services Temporary role Culture and Recreation Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Beth Sowder Comm Dev & Neighborhood PPT Services Continuing - new team & role Budget Liaison Dawna Gorkowski Parks Comm & Ops Services Continuing Communications Rita Davis Police Services Police Services Continuing - new team & role Wayne Sterler Utilities Services Utility Services Continuing Craig Foreman Park Planning Comm & Ops Services Continuing Steve Lukowski Parks Comm & Ops Services Continuing Marc Virata Engineering PPT Services Continuing - new team Citizen Carol Ann Hixon New High Performing Government Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Carol Webb Utility Reg & Govt Affairs Utility Services Continuing - new team & role Budget Liaison Jolene Buxman Finance Financial Services New Communications Carol Workman Police Information Services Police Services New Tracy Ochsner Operation Services Comm & Ops Services Continuing - new team Clint Andrews MIS Comm & Ops Services New Ginger Purvis L&P Operations Service Utility Services New 1 • Balance talent/workforce • Encourage retail mix/opportunities • Recruit unique businesses • Support target industry clusters • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Balance talent/workforce • Encourage retail mix/opportunities • Recruit unique businesses • Support target industry clusters • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Strengthen business retention & expansion • Foster transparency • Ensure retail sales diversity • Maintain effective/efficient City processes • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Strengthen business retention & expansion • Foster transparency • Ensure retail sales diversity • Maintain effective/efficient City processes • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote incubation & recruitment • Foster intellectual property • Minimize barriers to business • Support access to capital • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote Economic Health Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Ginny Sawyer, Community Development & Neighborhood Services Budget Liaison: Jessica Ping-Small, Finance Communications: Jill Mueggenberg, Recreation Members: Josh Birks, Economic Development Bill Whirty, Parks Dean Cunningham, Patrol Timothy Wilder, Advance Planning McCabe Callahan, Citizen Participant Result Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values. Introduction/Summary of Results Map The 2012 Results Team had in-depth discussions regarding what promotes and reflects a healthy economy. Based on these conversations, the current Results Map and accompanying Request for Results (RFR) have been simplified in comparison to past years. The Results Map articulates the Team’s goal to identify foundational elements while allowing for creativity, innovation, and continuance of effective strategies and programs. The Team has also worked to align aspects of the Map and RFR to both Plan Fort Collins and the Draft Economic Strategic Plan. Ideally, the high level alignment concepts will remain while allowing future budgeting cycles the flexibility to focus on specific needs, trends, and relevant measures. The map contains four primary factors focusing on diversity, resiliency, opportunity, and place. An emphasis was placed on the importance of utilizing collaboration and partnerships as a way of doing business by including “collaboration and partnerships” as a causal factor under each Primary Factor. Six indicators and their measurements are also contained in the RFR along with nine purchasing strategies to guide sellers in creating their offers. Indicators Indicator 1: Measure job growth in targeted industry clusters. Measure:  Track the total number of jobs in the five industry clusters. Target: Increase by 2.5 % annually. This measure captures local job growth and provides comparison data to national numbers. By focusing on the industry clusters we can also gauge the effect of City support in these areas. Growth in new and emerging industries also helps to diversify our economy. Indicator 2: Maximize retail sales efficiency. Measures:  Track regional and local sales. Target: Ensure current sales ratios are maintained.  Track locally earned income spent outside of Fort Collins. Target: Keep this sales leakage at or below the current level of 17%. Sales tax is a significant source of revenue for services. By tracking sales both regionally and locally the City can gauge the economic health of the community and can identify and mitigate where sales leakage is happening; thereby maximizing sales efficiency and ensuring that we continue to be a net importer. Indicator 3: Support efforts to match the local workforce to job needs in the community. Measure:  Narrow the gap of the resident education level versus the local job educational requirements. Target: Decrease the gap by 2-3% every 10 years. As a community it is important to try to balance the job skills needed with the skills of the available workforce. By tracking and minimizing the gap between these two measures we can support both employee and employer needs in the community. Indicator 4: Receive recognition as a quality of place community. Measure:  Track Citizen Survey response to the question rating overall economic health. Target: Maintain a “Very Good” or “Good” response rate of 40% or better on the “Overall economic health of Fort Collins” citizen survey question. These national and local recognitions speak to both the perceptions and realities within our community and beyond. By continuing to maintain high citizen survey results related to economic health we can ensure that City’s efforts are on track. The 40% target is based on 2012 results. Indicator 5: Enhance the innovation ecosystem. Measures:  Foster local intellectual property. Target: Maintain 1 patent per 1,000 residents (U.S. Patent Office).  Monitor the number and dollar value of capital investments in private companies within the incubation ecosystem. Target: Increase the dollar value of these capital investments to $20 million by 2014 (Rocky Mountain Innosphere and CSU companies.) Fort Collins as a community values innovation and entrepreneurism. These measures help us to ensure that we are cultivating the intellectual property and leveraging the necessary assets to perpetuate and enhance this culture and community value. In 2011, the Rocky Mountain Innosphere assisted private companies within the incubation program with raising $10.0 million in capital investments. Indicator 6: Expand and strengthen existing business. Measure:  Track jobs retained and/or created through City assistance to companies within the growth management area. Target: Increase the number of jobs created or retained by 5% annually within the City boundary. Maintaining and increasing local jobs benefits the economic health of our community. By measuring and tracking jobs within businesses which the City has provided direct assistance we can determine the impact of these services. Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. Enhance opportunities for both businesses and the local workforce. Primary Factors: Create Diversity and Provide Opportunity 2. Support the innovative and entrepreneurial spirit of Fort Collins. Primary Factors: Create Diversity and Provide Opportunity 3. Focus on fostering a diverse mix of employment and retail opportunities. Primary Factors: Ensure Resiliency and Create Diversity 4. Build upon the Quality of Place that exists in Fort Collins. Primary Factors: Preserve Place 5. Revitalize and strengthen business centers. Primary Factors: Preserve Place and Provide Opportunity 6. Provide a safe and enjoyable experience in shopping, dining, and retail centers. Primary Factors: Preserve Place and Ensure Resiliency 7. Demonstrate collaborations and leverage City resources for the benefit of the community. Primary Factors: Create Diversity, Ensure Resiliency, Provide Opportunity and Preserve Place 8. Ensure timely and thorough policy plan implementation, creation, and updating. Primary Factors: Ensure Resiliency and Preserve Place 9. Provide transparent, predictable and efficient processes for citizens and businesses interacting with the City. Primary Factors: Ensure Resiliency Rationale for RFR and Primary and Secondary Factors It is the team’s expectation that offers should align with relevant Council approved plans with emphasis on Plan Fort Collins and the Draft Economic Strategic Plan. The process for defining primary factors, secondary/causal factors and indicators involved taking a broad view of the characteristics and specific elements that make-up and encourage a healthy, sustainable economy. The Team will accept a wide variety of offers that meet the needs of the business community, the local workforce, and the residents of the community as a whole. 1 • Water treatment* • Pollution Prevention* • Wastewater treatment* • Stormwater treatment* • Watershed & floodplain management* • Water supply and conservation* • Climatic conditions & adaptation* • Water treatment* • Pollution Prevention* • Wastewater treatment* • Stormwater treatment* • Watershed & floodplain management* • Water supply and conservation* • Climatic conditions & adaptation* Primary Factors Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources Secondary/Casual Factors Excellent Air Quality Excellent Air Quality Exemplary Land Conservation & Stewardship Exemplary Land Conservation & Stewardship • Open lands* • Land use* • Built environment (green buildings)* • Healthy & bio-diverse habitat • Community buffers • Access & engagement* • Scenic views • Natural heritage • Open lands* • Land use* • Built environment (green buildings)* • Healthy & bio-diverse habitat • Community buffers • Access & engagement* • Scenic views • Natural heritage • Waste generation, recycling & diversion* • Greenhouse gas emissions* Environmental Health Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Lucinda Smith, Environmental Services Budget Liaison: Barb Brock, Natural Areas Communication Liaison: Lori Greening, Human Resources Members: Craig Hibbard, Utilities Water Reclamation Bob Adams, Recreation Kevin Cronin, Patrol Lance Smith, Utilities Finance and Budget K-Lynn Cameron, Citizen Participant Result Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. Introduction/Summary of Results Map The Team believes that exceptional stewardship of water resources and air quality, and exemplary land conservation/stewardship are the fundamental building blocks of a healthy and sustainable environment. The three Result Map primary factors focus on stewardship of natural resources and are critical contributors to the Outcome defined by City Council. They contribute not only to improved environmental quality but also public health and an attractive, well-planned community. Our Result Map identifies numerous contributing factors which impact the three primary factors. Interactions between factors are also important. For example, there are direct linkages between air pollution and water quality (e.g. acid rain) and between land conservation and water quality (impervious pavement carries pollutants). Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources Excellent water resources (including drinking water and surface water) are an essential aspect of environmental health. Good water quality is important in fulfilling the role of the Utilities in providing life- essential services and infrastructure to advance the health, safety and prosperity of our community. According to the Center for Disease Control, “Environmental conditions greatly influence the relation between water and human health.” In Fort Collins, water resources and water quality are highly regulated by the State and Federal government, therefore performance is extensively measured. Historically, water resources have been important to the City. For example, City Council passed Resolutions such as Recognizing the Need to Protect Water Quality, the Water Supply and Demand Management Policy, Drinking Water Quality Policy, and Approving the Watershed Approach to Stormwater Management. City Council policies also address sustainable water supply, storm water quality management, and conservation in City Plan. Wise use of water resources is important to the environmental health of Fort Collins, especially if our conserved water is put to uses that benefit the environment and Fort Collins community. Excellent Air Quality High quality air is critical to the health of the environment, the health of our citizens, and to citizens’ quality of life. City air quality programs play an important role in achieving the City Council’s over-arching air quality goal to “continually improve air quality”. Local programs (i.e. ozone education and incentives, idling reduction, radon, wood smoke, Healthy Homes) complement and fill gaps left by federal, state, and county efforts. The federal health standard for ground level ozone was exceeded on eight days in the Fort Collins Growth Management Area in 2011. Reducing high ozone is especially important because the 2011 Fort Collins Air Quality Survey finds that 26% of Fort Collins households have a member suffering from a chronic respiratory ailment, and ozone is a respiratory irritant. Fort Collins has long been committed to reducing community greenhouse gas emissions as a means of achieving long-term environmental and economic health as well as mitigating our impact on global warming gasses. Energy use is a big part of our environmental footprint. Efforts to meet the objectives of the Fort Collins Climate Action Plan and the Fort Collins Energy Policy will create better air quality and improve public health, along with providing numerous other benefits. The reduction of waste benefits the air, water and land. Fort Collins has a goal to divert at least 50% of waste annually from landfills using a hierarchy of waste management approaches and has reached a landfill diversion rate of 43% in 2010. By finding additional, more effective ways to “repurpose” or recycle the community’s discards, Fort Collins helps preserve natural resources (timber, minerals, energy, water) and reduces greenhouse gas emissions associated with manufacturing new products from virgin materials. Exemplary Land Conservation and Stewardship Fort Collins is a leader in land conservation and stewardship. Citizens of Fort Collins supported tax initiatives on five separate occasions to support natural area and open space activities with the earliest passing in 1973 and the latest, “Open Space, Yes!” passing in 2002. The Natural Areas program manages 43 sites and over 34,000 acres. In addition, the City has conserved 5,548 acres through conservation easements. Natural areas are experiencing ever-increasing use and enjoyment, and they are at risk of being “loved to death” without careful stewardship. It is well recognized that land conservation and stewardship strongly contribute to environmental health. Open lands help retain and filter water, control stormwater run-off, and provide habitat and corridors for wildlife and plants. Healthy vegetation also acts as a carbon sink, thus reducing the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. Open lands can help maintain a compact urban form, a key factor in maintaining air and water resources, as well as the ecological integrity of natural resources. Indicators Indicator 1: The degree to which water quality (including drinking water and surface water) is maintained and improved. Measures:  Sustain 100% compliance for key established state and federal regulations and standards (Goal = achieve 100% compliance annually)  Benchmarked performance of at least four different performance measures for water treatment and waste water treatment, based on self-assessment and peer review. (e.g., WWA/Qualserve, Global Reporting Initiative)  Number of technical water quality complaints per thousand customers (Goal = 5 per 1000 or less)  Footage of high risk water and wastewater pipe replaced or rehabilitated/year (Goal = at least 2 miles of high risk pipe replaced/yr) Indicator 2: The degree to which water supply and treated water is conserved. Measure:  Gallons treated water used per capita per day (Goal = 140 gal/person/day by 2020) Indicator 3: The degree to which our outdoor and indoor air quality is improved. Measures:  Number of days in each Air Quality Index (AQI) category (Goal = 100% “Good” days for all pollutants measured [8 hour ozone, PM2.5, PM10 and carbon monoxide] for all days measured, which would ensure compliance with federal air quality standards)  A reduction in greenhouse gas emissions that puts the City on track to meet the City policy objectives in the Climate Action Plan (3% reduction by 2012, 20% reduction by 2020 and 80% reduction by 2050, below 2005 baseline) and internal City sustainability goals to reduce emissions 20% below 2005 levels by 2020  Reduce priority air pollutant emissions (including ozone-forming pollution, fine particles, indoor air pollutants) by 2% /year over prior year through City programs Indicator 4: The degree to which we conserve, steward and enhance habitat and ecosystem health. Measures:  Percent of Natural Areas acres currently in native vegetation (Goal = obtain native plant composition of 75%)  Continue acquisition of lands that meet the conservation criteria set forth in Open Space, Yes!, the Land Conservation and Stewardship Master Plan, and Plan Fort Collins Indicator 5: The degree to which solid waste is reduced and diverted from landfills Measures:  Decrease community waste to landfills 5%/year  Increase community waste diversion rate (Goal = 50% diversion or better/year)  Increase per capita recycling and composting volumes by 5% annually Indicator 6: The degree to which community energy (electricity and natural gas) consumption is reduced and remaining energy is renewable Measures:  Annual electricity savings from efficiency and conservation programs (Goal = Achieve program savings at least 1.5% of community annual electric use, based on 3 year average)  Percent renewable energy towards compliance with State Renewable Energy Standards (Goal = achieve State RES for municipal utilities; 6% by 2015, 10% by 2020)  Increase the percent of renewable energy from voluntary subscriptions Indicator 7: Citizens’ perception of the quality of the environment Measure:  Improvement in the results of the bi-annual citizen survey as compared to the prior survey results These indicators and measures were chosen to reflect both high level indications of the quality of the environment and ways to measure operational progress that contributes to environmental improvement. Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. We are seeking offers that:  Demonstrate leadership  Support existing City Council plans and policies relative to the environment  Promote collaboration across organizational boundaries (departments, cities, counties, non-profits, etc.)  Address multiple Outcomes  Enhance operational excellence and the culture of innovation in the area of environmental practices  Leverage outside funding and resources  Implement Best Management Practices and reduce life cycle costs and negative environmental impacts 2. Maintain and improve water quality including offers that:  Provide clean and reliable drinking water  Provide safe and effective wastewater treatment that protects the watershed 3. Align water quantity with water storage and conservation policies, including offers that:  Lower residential and business water consumption  Provide alternative water systems to decrease amount of treated water needed 4. Contribute to long-term improvement and maintenance of air quality, including offers that:  Reduce ground level ozone-forming emissions  Reduce emissions from vehicles and heavy equipment  Reduce particulates and improve visibility  Improve indoor air quality 5. Result in a reduction of greenhouse gas (carbon) emissions, including offers that:  Assist businesses and residents to reduce greenhouse gas emissions  Reduce carbon footprint of existing and new buildings and other infrastructure  Move towards net zero carbon emissions from energy, waste, and transportation, etc.  Promote green building practices 6. Conserve and restore habitat and promote biological health and diversity, including offers that:  Improve and maintain open lands with minimal adverse environmental impact,  Identify, conserve and enhance lands that attain adopted policy objectives, that provide multiple benefits, and that provide natural connective areas of public and private lands  Support habitat enhancements to stormwater detention areas  Increase native, xeric and adaptive vegetation  Provide ecological restoration of streams and the Poudre River 7. Reduce waste and resource consumption, including offers that:  Improve source reduction, re-use, recycling, and lower per capita discards including removing barriers and increasing choices  Focus on largest waste sector categories (organics, construction and demolition debris, and paper) and ‘hard to recycle’ materials  Provide outreach that increases public knowledge, awareness of and involvement in waste reduction and recycling programs  Promote responsible procurement, product stewardship and environmental design  Recognize the waste stream as a energy and economic resource  Reduce toxics going into the landfill or the natural environment 8. Increase energy conservation, efficiency and renewable energy, including offers that:  Provide technical and behavioral solutions  Encourage the installation of new renewable energy sources including 3rd party agreements and leveraging capital  Address peak demand  Reduce household, commercial and industrial energy use 9. Increase the community’s resiliency and preparedness for changes in climate, weather, and resources availability, including offers that:  Identify and address community risks and vulnerability from changing climate and weather patterns We are seeking offers that promote, protect, and enhance a healthy and sustainable environment. Special consideration will be given to offers that express a proactive approach that contributes to the environmental health, safety and prosperity of our community. Projects with the flexibility to scale up or down and that continue to produce results may stand a better chance of being funded. Offers should take into account the organizational priorities of operational excellence and enhancing the culture of innovation and should support Council plans and policies, including those listed in the Appendix. Relevant Plans and Policies for Environmental Health Results Team Offers Action Plan for Sustainability (2004) Air Quality Plan (2011) Bobcat Ridge Natural Area Management Plan (2005) Cache la Poudre River Natural Areas Management Plan (2002) Carbon Monoxide Maintenance Plan (2003, revised 2010) City Plan (2011) Climate Action Plan (2008) Climate Wise Program (2000) Drainage Basin Master Plan (2004) Drinking Water Quality Policy (2003) Energy Policy (2009) Foothills Natural Areas Management Plan (2007) Fossil Creek Natural Areas Management Plan (2005) Land Conservation and Stewardship Master Plan (2004) Natural Areas Easement Policy (2001) Natural Areas General Management Guidelines (2001) Natural Areas Vegetation Management Guidelines (2007) Natural Areas Wildlife Management Guidelines (2007) Roadmap for Coordinated and Enhanced Green Building Services (2007) Soapstone Prairie Natural Area Management Plan (2007) Strategic Plan for 50% Waste Diversion (2006) Water Conservation Plan (2009) Water Supply and Demand Management Policy (2003) Resolution 95-14: Approving the water shed approach to stormwater management Resolution 92-14: Framework for Environmental Action Resolution 2000-128: “Recognizing the Need to Protect Water Quality” Natural Areas Ballot Issues 1992 – Choices 95 – City ¼ Cent Sales Tax 1995 – Larimer County Help Preserve Open Space (HPOS) Sales Tax 1996-2003 1997 – Building Community Choices (BCC) – City ¼ Cent Sales Tax with a portion going to Natural Areas 1999 – Larimer County Help Preserve Open Space (HPOS) Sales Tax 2004-2018 2002 – Open Space Yes! – City ¼ Cent Sales Tax for Natural Areas 1 Secondary/Causal Factors • Capacity Improvements • Traffic light timing • Parking • Signs & directions • Routes & zones • Capacity Improvements • Traffic light timing • Parking • Signs & directions • Routes & zones • Maintenance • Capital improvements • Design standards • System connectivity • Safety and efficiency improvements • Technology infrastructure • Maintenance • Capital improvements • Design standards • System connectivity • Safety and efficiency improvements • Technology infrastructure • Planning • Funding sources • Demand forecasting • Partnerships & collaboration • Planning • Funding sources • Demand forecasting • Partnerships & collaboration • Mass/para transit Transportation Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Ken Mannon Budget Liaison: Delynn Coldiron Communications: Kim Newcomer Members: Jon Haukaas Darren Moritz Joe Olson Rick Reider, Citizen Participant Lisa Voytko Result Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. Introduction/Summary of Results Map We want offers that support the City’s transportation system including quality infrastructure, smooth traffic flow, and multiple travel options contributing to a strong economy, healthy environment, and vibrant community. The system needs to facilitate safe and reliable multi-modal travel in order to provide the services that individuals and the business community expect. Quality transportation planning, programs, and projects strengthen our local economy and demonstrate the City’s commitment to environmental stewardship by supporting the efficient movement of people and goods. First and foremost, existing infrastructure must be adequately maintained to protect the City’s historical investment in transportation. Historically, Fort Collins residents have identified transportation as a high priority and have consistently asked for more effort toward transportation. This priority was further underscored by the passage of the Keep Fort Collins Great tax initiative, which allocates 50% of the new tax revenue to street maintenance and other transportation efforts. Citizens expect the City to provide better and additional transportation services. The City will have many opportunities, as well as challenges, related to transportation that are associated with new projects. The Mason Corridor Project, the City’s largest transportation capital project to date, is just one example. Other potential projects include: - The potential on-campus Colorado State University Football Stadium - Major changes in employment centers (e.g., Colorado State University Engines and Energy Conversion Lab expansion) Offers should address the need for flexibility and responsiveness to adjust to changing circumstances. Indicators Indicator 1: Traffic Flow Measure:  Time traveled on selected routes Goal: Motor vehicles will travel at an average of three minutes per mile or better. The average time it takes a motor vehicle to travel on selected primary arterial streets during “peak” travel times will be measured. Indicator 2: Roadway System Maintenance Measure:  Roadway conditions Goal: Average pavement conditions will be Level of Service B (index rating of 70-85 on 100-point scale). Roadway conditions measure efforts and effectiveness of roadway maintenance, which contribute to the safety and reliability of travel. Roadway conditions will be measured by the average pavement conditions of Fort Collins roads. Conditions are measured using pavement management software to determine the pavement condition index (PCI) of the roadway network. PCI is a standard measurement tool in the industry. Indicator 3: Safety Measure:  Number of crashes per vehicle miles traveled and number of fatal injury crashes per vehicle miles traveled Goal: Maintain or decrease crashes and fatal injury crashes per vehicle miles traveled. The overall safety of the transportation system will be measured and evaluated by tracking two different categories of crashes: all crashes and those that result in a fatal injury. Vehicle miles traveled is determined using the Highway Performance Measuring System utilized by the Colorado Department of Transportation. Crash data is obtained from Police Service crash reports. Indicator 4: Transit Mobility Measure:  Transit rides per capita Goal: 28.7 rides per capita (based on ridership projections from full implementation of the Transit Strategic Plan) To evaluate viability of travel by transit, change in transit rides per capita (with a focus on riders by choice) per calendar year will be measured. Indicator 5: Use of Alternative Modes Measure:  Mode of travel used for trips Goal: Increase trips made by bicycle, transit, and walking by 20% (currently at 17.6%) The North Front Range Metropolitan Planning Organization Household Survey provides data related to the mode of travel individuals use for trips. The survey is administered every five years in conjunction with the Regional Transportation Plan update. Specifically, the percent of trips made by bicycle and the percent of trips made by walking will be used to evaluate use of alternative modes. Indicator 6: Citizen Satisfaction Measure:  Community Survey Goal: Attain or surpass Front Range and national benchmarks. There are several qualitative parameters that are implied in the desire for reliability of travel, which will be measured through opinion polls. Statistically valid surveys have been conducted in recent years; these allow us to benchmark new survey information against perceptions citizens have expressed about the reliability of mobility and other transportation concerns. Specifically, citizen satisfaction will be measured by the following questions on the Citizen Survey:  Street Maintenance  Ease of travel via public transportation  Traffic congestion Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. Innovation Demonstrate innovation and a specific increase in efficiency. We welcome creative, innovative, money- saving ideas (including enhancement offers) that address increases in efficiency. Innovative offers should be well thought-out, well researched, and should support operational excellence and continuous improvement. Examples include:  Service “pairing” that leverages and/or combines functions across and within the organization.  Efforts to “de-silo” departments and result areas to capitalize on limited resources (e.g., two departments cooperate and communicate to provide a service at a reduced cost, to eliminate duplication, improve service, and create efficiency).  Partnerships (internal and communitywide) that create value.  Eliminating duplicative services.  Changing the way we operate to be more nimble and responsive to citizen needs and concerns.  Focusing on providing high quality customer service and “value-added” initiatives.  Moving away from “the way we’ve always done it” when appropriate. 2. Traffic Flow Improve the traffic flow in Fort Collins for all modes of transporting people, goods, and information (not just vehicles) to benefit both individuals and the business community. Key indicators of success will include the ability of a proposal to optimize travel time and the predictability of traffic flow by addressing features including, but not limited to:  Safe and reliable multi-modal movement  Intersection and roadway improvements  Traffic light timing and signs  Traffic congestion  Parking  Awareness of routes and zones (e.g., construction, school, or loading zones)  Public information 3. Quality Infrastructure Provide safe, well functioning, high quality streets, bikeways, sidewalks, trails, etc., or that improve other critical infrastructure. The types of topic areas to be addressed include, but are not limited to:  Maintenance (e.g., potholes, snow removal, pavement management, sidewalk improvements, bridges)  Capital projects (e.g., roadway improvements)  Design standards (sustainability, ongoing maintenance needs, aesthetics, etc.)  System connectivity  Safety/efficiency improvements  Communication infrastructure  Environmental impacts  Americans with Disabilities Act requirements 4. Planning Provide good, long-term transportation planning, to enhance citizens’ mobility and therefore help local and regional transportation networks operate at a high level of efficiency. We are also seeking offers that implement Council-adopted strategic plans such as the Transportation Master Plan, the Transit Strategic Plan and others. Areas of consideration include, but are not limited to:  Planning  Funding sources (new, leveraged, grants)  Demand forecasting  Partnerships and collaboration (relationships, organizations, intergovernmental agreements) with agencies such as the North Front Range Metropolitan Planning Organization, Colorado Department of Transportation, Poudre School District, Colorado State University, Front Range Community College, and others.  Citizen input  Linkage between commuter trails and bike lanes  Sustainability 5. Travel Modes Limit the rate of increase in or reduce the amount of motor vehicle traffic, and enhance alternative travel modes for Fort Collins citizens. Citizens should be able to choose from a variety of viable travel options. Examples include:  Mass transit and para-transit  Bus rapid transit (Mason Corridor)  Bicycling  Walking  Carpooling  Car sharing  Online/telecommuting  Wheelchair and disability access  Awareness programs 6. Maintenance and Operation Address long-term maintenance and operations costs. Offers should demonstrate fiscal responsibility by ensuring cost efficiencies, cost sharing, and other innovative approaches. Sellers need to provide information about all long-term maintenance and support costs with each proposed project. 7. Sustainability Address sustainability and consider social (both individual and business needs), financial (cost effectiveness) and environmental impacts. Proposals should integrate sustainability into construction techniques, design features, business operations, etc. Specifically, offers should support Council-adopted sustainability goals as identified in City Plan, the Transportation Master Plan, the Climate Action Plan, Air Quality Action Plan, and other pertinent plans and policies. 8. Awareness Include elements of customer service, education, and/or public involvement that enhance citizens’ ability to travel safely and reliably. When applicable, offers should also include efforts to raise awareness about individual transportation choices and the impact on the environment. 9. Safety Include consideration of safety as a core value. Sources, Reports and Related Major Plans  2010 Citizen Survey  2010 Community Scorecard  Air Quality Plan  Annual survey of peer cities’ accident rates  City Plan and related plans  Climate Action Plan  Interviews with City Transportation Staff  Mason Corridor Plan  Parks and Recreation Policy Plan (trail connectivity)  Police Benchmark Survey (accident statistics)  Transit Strategic Plan  Transportation Master Plan  Traffic Taskforce (internal team addressing traffic congestion) 1 • Offer high quality and diverse culture and recreation programs and opportunities • Support arts, culture, and recreation educational programming • Develop arts, culture, and recreation partnerships • Promote visibility of arts, culture, and recreation opportunities • Offer high quality and diverse culture and recreation programs and opportunities • Support arts, culture, and recreation educational programming • Develop arts, culture, and recreation partnerships • Promote visibility of arts, culture, and recreation opportunities • Provide well-maintained, attractive, functional, and safe facilities, lands, parks, and recreational trails • Demonstrate environ- mental sustainability • Utilize effective and innovative partnerships • Adapt to change in community needs and interests • Support an interconnected and regional and local system of parks, trails and open lands. • Provide well-maintained, attractive, functional, and safe facilities, lands, parks, and recreational trails • Demonstrate environ- mental sustainability • Utilize effective and innovative partnerships • Adapt to change in community needs and interests • Support an interconnected and regional and local system of parks, trails and Culture and Recreation Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Beth Sowder, Community Development & Neighborhood Services Budget Liaison: Dawna Gorkowski, Parks Communications Liaison: Rita Davis, Police Services Members: Craig Foreman, Park Planning Marc Virata, Engineering Steve Lukowski, Parks Wayne Sterler, Utility Services Carol Ann Hixon, Citizen Participant Result Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities Introduction/Summary of Results Map The 2012 Result Team reviewed the past Request for Results (RFR) and made changes based on priorities and adopted plans, placing greater emphasis on operational excellence, customer service, and innovation. The Results Map reflects the goal to provide quality cultural and recreational opportunities and highlights the desire for sustainable practices, high-level customer service, and quality facilities for the community. The map contains four primary factors and associated secondary/causal factors focusing on customer service; convenient and affordable access/opportunities; quality facilities and lands; and quality programming. The RFR also contains four indicators and associated measurements along with eleven purchasing strategies to guide sellers in creating offers. Cultural and recreational opportunities anchor Fort Collins’ quality of life. Residents consistently rate these services high on the 2010 Citizen Survey, and 94% of respondents believe the City should put the same or more emphasis in this area. Strong support was also demonstrated by the passage of the Keep Fort Collins Great initiative. The team utilized Plan Fort Collins as the community’s strategic plan for the future of Fort Collins. Goals from Plan Fort Collins include providing a wide variety of high-quality recreational services and opportunities, creating an interconnected regional and local trail system, promoting community, and focusing on enhanced ecologically sound and green practices. Recreational facilities and lands are essential assets to enhance the quality of life and connect people to place, self, and others. The principles in Plan Fort Collins that are important to consider include: CPR-1: The City will promote, encourage and stimulate the growth of cultural development and participation, recognizing that artistic and cultural opportunities are essential to a vital and creative community. CPR-2: The City will employ arts and culture as an economic driver and promote Downtown as a world-class cultural center and destination. CPR-3: The City will recognize that cultural education and participation are vital to stimulating a creative community, encouraging personal development, and promoting social well being. CPR-4: The City will maintain and provide a variety of high quality recreational opportunities to the community through an interconnected and diverse network of parks, trails, recreation facilities, public spaces, and natural areas. CPR-5: The City will adapt parks and recreation facilities to meet the range of needs of a changing community. Indicators Indicator 1: Deliver exceptional customer service in cultural and recreational programs that is responsive to customer and community needs and expectations. Measures:  Demonstrate continuous improvement of the “Good” or “Very Good” responses on the “Culture, Parks, and Recreation” section of the Citizen Survey (which also supports the “Listening to Citizens” section of the Citizen Survey consistent with the City’s Strategic Priorities). No specific target was established because survey results varied significantly by survey question.  Demonstrate continuous improvement in response time to inquiries in Access Fort Collins. In 2011 Culture, Parks, and Recreation’s average response time was 3.35 days. The target response time for Culture, Parks, and Recreation is the City’s average 2011 response time of 3 days. Indicator 2: Maintain and provide a variety of high quality recreational facilities and lands. Measures:  Demonstrate continuous improvement of the “Good” or “Very Good” responses on the “Culture, Parks, and Recreation” section of the Citizen Survey (which also supports the “Listening to Citizens” section of the Citizen Survey consistent with the City’s Strategic Priorities). No specific target was established because survey results varied significantly by survey question.  Demonstrate continuous improvement in response time to inquiries in Access Fort Collins. In 2011 Culture, Parks, and Recreation’s average response time was 3.35 days. The target response time for Culture, Parks, and Recreation is the City’s average 2011 response time of 3 days. Indicator 3: Participation in and utilization of cultural and recreational programs and facilities. Measures:  Improve the “Good” and “Very Good” ratings in the availability and diversity of recreational opportunities and arts and cultural activities sections in the Citizen Survey. No specific target was established because survey results varied significantly by survey question.  Measure the usage of cultural and recreational programs and facilities and set targets.  Measure the percentage of capacity in programs and facilities and set targets.  Measure cultural and recreational economic benefits and set targets. Indicator 4: Provide sustainable programs and facilities by utilizing public and private support (i.e. partnerships, volunteers, grants and sponsorships). Measures:  Measure volunteer hours as a means of offsetting costs and set targets.  Increase non-general fund support to improve self-sufficiency by facility.  Measure requests for discounted or waived fees and set targets.  Measure the number of types of programs offered (specifics yet to be determined by Futures Committee). Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. Maximize efficiencies in the management of expenses and revenues through all available means, such as internal/external partnerships, grants, sponsorships, volunteers, etc. 2. Serve diverse customer needs, abilities, and interests throughout the community. 3. Provide programs and facilities that contribute to the economic health of Fort Collins through culture and recreation. 4. Provide programs and facilities that contribute to the social health of Fort Collins through culture and recreation. 5. Provide programs and facilities that contribute to the environmental health of Fort Collins through culture and recreation. 6. Demonstrate programming that is diverse, innovative, and improves customer satisfaction. 7. Demonstrate operational excellence, customer service, and innovation. 8. Enhance the community through public art and promote visibility of the arts and culture. 9. Encourage partnerships between educational, cultural, and business institutions to improve opportunities for learning and expanding the creative industries employment base in the City. 10. Support an interconnected regional and local system of parks, recreational trails, and open lands, and promote community interaction. 11. Fulfill City mandates and programs which the City has a unique ability to provide. Sources & Reports  2010 Fort Collins Citizen Survey  2010 Community Scorecard  Notes from 2012 City Council retreat Related Major Plans  City Plan Fort Collins  City of Fort Collins Strategic Priorities  The Cultural Plan  The Parks and Recreation Policy Plan  The Natural Areas Strategic Plan  The Land Conservation and Stewardship Master Plan 1 • Quality Design/Building Standards • Sustainable/ Attainable Housing • Integrate a Variety of Housing Types, Densities and Locations • Ownership Opportunities • Quality Design/Building Standards • Sustainable/ Attainable Housing • Integrate a Variety of Housing Types, Densities and Locations • Ownership Opportunities Primary Factors Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing Attractive Neighborhoods Attractive Neighborhoods Good Neighbor Relationships Good Neighbor Relationships Community Functionality and Attractive Design Community Functionality and Attractive Design Secondary/Casual Factors Community and Neighborhood Livability • Attractive Public Places • Clean and Maintained • Code Compliance • Graffiti-free • Historic Preservation Community and Neighborhood Livability Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Matt Zoccali, Regulatory and Government Affairs Budget Liaison: Janice Saeger, Recreation Communications: Susan Herlihy, Cultural Services Members: Kurt Clow, Police Tim Buchanan, Forestry Patty Netherton, Municipal Court Polly Lauridsen, Neighborhood Services Kristin Kirkpatrick, Citizen Participant Result Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods. Introduction/Summary of Results Map Community is defined as a cohesive, integrated whole, made up of a sum of individual neighborhoods and developments, commercial and employment activity centers, streets, parks, and public works, which fosters positive interactions among people. The four primary factors of Community and Neighborhood Livability (CNL) are Adequate and Diverse Supply of Attainable and Quality Housing, Attractive Neighborhoods, Good Neighbor Relationships, and Community Functionality and Attractive Design. These factors are supported by feedback from City Council, citizen input, discussion with subject matter experts, City Plan Fort Collins, and the 2010 Community Scorecard. The principals of CNL address Fort Collins at two levels: first, at a city-wide level, and second, at a specific level for each of the type of neighborhoods identified in the City Structure Map (City Plan Fort Collins). The overall vision for the built environment results in four basic kinds of components: Neighborhoods, Districts, Edges, and Corridors. Additional priorities that define CNL include occupancy ordinances, noise levels, multi-modal connections, conservation of natural habitats and protection of view corridors, homeowner and neighborhood relations, and historic preservation. Indicators Indicator 1: How effectively the City reduces barriers to quality affordable housing while investing its human services dollars. We will continue to reduce these barriers to affordable housing with outreach, innovative programs and policies while monitoring how effectively the affordable housing dollars are leveraged. Measures:  Number of Homebuyers Assistance loan recipients;  Dollars allocated to align with the City’s Affordable Housing Strategic Plan;  Number of low and moderate income citizens who are served in key areas of service gaps with available dollars For residents the City offers: Homebuyer Assistance (HBA) and distributes Federal dollars which fund over two dozen non-profit agencies providing wide range of needs from credit counseling, homelessness, low interest loans, and meals. By a Council Ordinance, the City allocates a minimum of $133,000 per year into the Affordable Housing Program. This is combined with Federal monies (i.e. Community Development Block Grant, HOME Investment Partnership Program, etc.) to roughly total over $4M and dispersed throughout the community. By tracking how well dollars allocated line up with the Affordable Housing Strategic Plan, and the number of low and moderate income citizens are served with human services dollars, the City can demonstrate effectiveness in reducing barriers to quality affordable housing, while addressing other key areas of need. Indicator 2: Residents like their neighborhood. We support building community through neighborhood events, education and attractive and well-planned neighborhoods. Measures:  Number of Graffiti cases reported and number of sites cleaned;  Neighborhood rating at least equal to or greater than regional and national average;  Improve 2010 Community Scorecard response to at least 80% “Good” or “Very Good”;  Maintain 2010 Community Scorecard response trend in “Good” or “Very Good” ratings relating to availability of affordable and quality housing According to the 2010 Community Scorecard, respondents who rated their neighborhoods as “Good” or “Very Good” places to live has declined from 85% in 2006, to 78% in 2010. When compared to the regional and national averages, the City of Fort Collins compares similarly; a World Class City strives to exceed regional and national averages. During the same period, the percent of respondents who answered “Good” or Very Good” to the Availability of Affordable Quality Housing, increased from below 20% in 2006 to above 40% in 2010. All offers should address the trends; continuing the positive improvements made in areas of availability of quality housing and reversing the downward trend in seeing neighborhoods as a great place to live. Indicator 3: Residents are good neighbors. We support on-going enforcement of nuisance programs and development of positive neighbor relationships. Measures:  Number of noise complaints and noise violations;  Maintain trend in City performed code compliance abatements;  Maintain/Improve 2010 Community Scorecard 40% level for respondents knowing at least 1-5 of their neighbors The City works with community members in an effort to promote and encourage voluntary code compliances. Punitive measures are rarely enforced. This cooperative effort has resulted in a decreased number of City-issued citations or abatements. (e.g. The City hires a contractor to correct the violation and charges the property owner for the work). Indicator 4: A functional and attractive community enhances quality of life. We support a community with a look, feel and function that promotes human well-being and satisfaction. Measures:  Maintain level of good and very good rating at or above 90% of overall satisfaction as a place to live;  Maintain level of good and very good ratings at or above 85% of overall quality of life found in the community. The 2010 Community Scorecard results indicated a strong satisfaction of the quality of life and services found in the community. When compared to the regional and national averages, the City of Fort Collins compares similarly or higher; a World-Class City strives to exceed regional and national averages. Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. Encourage and foster good neighbor relationships with events and education opportunities for Homeowners Associations and other neighborhood groups. Encourage open neighborhood communication and formation of neighborhood groups through inclusivity, respect, and volunteerism. Bolster customer service by creating tools to strengthen relationships, pride, enhance information sharing and educate; in particular green practices, covenants and city policies. (Good Neighbor Relationships) 2. Encourage innovative enforcement efforts and voluntary compliance with City codes and increase outreach regarding the occupancy ordinance and industrial or residential noise levels including trains, motorcycles, vehicles, barking dogs, parties, etc. (Attractive Neighborhoods & Good Neighbor Relationships) 3. Enhance and maintain the attractiveness of neighborhoods, especially with trees and other sustainable methods. (Attractive Neighborhoods & Good Neighbor Relationships) 4. Preserve the character of neighborhoods; address historic preservation, infill development compatibility, green building incentives, redevelopment, and new development indicated in City Plan. (Attractive Neighborhoods & Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing) 5. Provide, enhance and maintain attractive public spaces like rights of ways, streetscapes and gateways. Provide public education on issues like graffiti and Bark Beetles. (Attractive Neighborhoods and Community Functionality and Attractive Design). 6. Encourage collaboration with Front Range Community College, Colorado State University, Associated Students of CSU and FRCC, faculties, employees, non-traditional families and all other appropriate entities. (Good Neighbor Relationships) 7. Provide innovative solutions on housing choices and stability as well as homelessness; collaborate with initiatives like Pathways Past Poverty, Bridges Out of Poverty and Homeward 2020. (Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing) 8. Implement strategic support for key identified human services categories of need for low to moderate income households in our community, such as: meeting safety needs, increasing self- sufficiency or independence, or strategies which stabilize households or systemically decrease poverty. (Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing) 9. Encourage partnerships with private entities and public agencies (e.g. Poudre School District, Larimer County) for housing and other programs such as historic preservation, yard waste and recycling. (Good Neighbor Relationships & Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing) 10. Improve neighborhood parking management through voluntary methods in addition to enforcement plus provide great customer service. (Attractive Neighborhoods and Good Neighbor Relationships). 11. Maintain and improve an interconnected system of corridors that provides habitat essential to the conservation of plants, animals, and their associated ecosystems, while allowing for recreational opportunities and natural viewsheds. (Community Functionality and Attractive Design) 12. Address sustainability and consider the social, financial and environmental impacts. We encourage proposals that include customer service and innovation related to programs, services, etc. (All four Primary Factors). Sources & Reports  Council Workshop, 2012  2010 Community Scorecard, City of Fort Collins  Affordable Housing Office  City of Fort Collins, Advanced Planning Department  Fort Collins Municipal Code  City of Fort Collins Neighborhood Services Office  Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice, Draft, Spring 2012  US Department of Housing & Urban Development Related Major Plans  City Plan Fort Collins, 2010  City of Fort Collins Organizational Strategic Plan, 2011  Affordable Housing Strategic Plan, 2010  Consolidated Housing and Community Development Plan 2010-2014 1 • Provide a range of public engagement methods • Provide opportunities for community involvement • Communicate effectively • Promote collaboration • Support volunteerism • Inform citizens of city services, policies plans, and direction • Provide a range of public engagement methods • Provide opportunities for community involvement • Communicate effectively • Promote collaboration • Support volunteerism • Inform citizens of city services, policies plans, and direction • Transparent and accountable • Maintain public trust • Fiscal strength • Support elected officials • Outstanding customer service • Promote civility, inclusion & diversity • Value continuous improvement and innovation • Provide exceptional support services • Forge partnerships to create opportunities • Safeguard community assets • Transparent and accountable • Maintain public trust • Fiscal strength • Support elected officials • Outstanding customer service • Promote civility, inclusion & diversity • Value continuous improvement and innovation • Provide exceptional support services • Forge partnerships to create opportunities • Safeguard community assets • Create a culture of innovation • Embrace organizational core values • Cultivate diverse, effective leadership • Foster knowledge transfer • Promote succession planning • Value sustainable work/life balance • Invest in professional and personal development • Provide competitive, fair compensation • Invest in employee health and safety • Create a culture of innovation • Embrace organizational core values • Cultivate diverse, effective Updated 4/5/2012 Page 1 of 6 High Performing Government Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Carol Webb, Utility Services Budget Liaison: Jolene Buxman, Financial Services Communications Liaison: Carol Workman, Police Services Members: Tracy Ochsner, Operation Services Ginger Purvis, Light and Power Operations Services Lindsay Ex, Community Development & Neighborhood Services Clint Andrews, Information Technology Stacy Baumgarn, Citizen Participant Result Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government Introduction/Summary of Results Map The High Performing Government Results Team focused on aligning the Request for Results Map with Plan Fort Collins and the 2012-2014 Organizational Strategic Plan. To determine performance measures and targets, we reviewed the 2010 Citizen Survey, the Q14 Employee Survey, and the Community Scorecard. Various strengths and opportunities for improvement, highlighted within the 2011 Rocky Mountain Performance Excellence Feedback Report, are woven throughout the indicators and associated measures and targets to provide a systematic approach to continuous improvement. We approached the Request for Results both as employees and as citizens keeping in mind our responsibility to the public and the trust they place in our hands. We focused on fiscal strength, transparency in our business practices and collaboration and partnerships. Human Resources provided insights on employee engagement and innovation. They provided a report by BlessingWhite on how employee engagement is the responsibility of the entire workforce. We also reviewed the 2010 HR Strategic Planning and Performance Measurement document. The team saw importance in recognizing diversity in our community and organization and reviewed the 2004 Diversity Plan. We discussed the Internal Support Services Survey as it directly relates to the delivery of exceptional support services. Furthermore our team felt it was necessary to discuss and mention the importance of supporting our elected officials and how collaboration and partnerships are critical to our organizations success. Indicators Indicator 1: Citizens are engaged [listened to, informed and involved] in local government. Inform and engage all citizens utilizing innovative and diverse engagement methods designed to be timely, inclusive, accessible and incorporate world-class technology. Updated 4/5/2012 Page 2 of 6 Measures: 1. Citizen Survey: Ratings of City Government  The job the City does at informing citizens  The job the City does at welcoming citizen involvement  The job the City does at listening to citizens Target: 70% or greater very good or good ratings and above or much above national and front range comparisons 2. Participation in Boards and Commissions  Vacancy rates for Boards and Commissions  Number of applications for open positions Target 1: Boards and Commissions vacancies filled within 3 months Target 2: At least two applications for every vacant position 3. Citizen Volunteers and volunteer hours Target: Increase over current 75 Full Time Equivalents (FTE’s) volunteer hours Indicator 2: The City provides exceptional customer service to an exceptional community Measures: 1. Access Fort Collins Requests Target: Median resolution time of 2.5 business days for cases with a maximum of 10 business day resolution time. 2. Utilities Customer Survey  A company you can trust  Overall quality of customer service Target: 80% or better “A” or “B” ratings 3. Citizen Survey: Ratings of City Government  The overall quality of City Services  The job City employees do making you feel valued as a customer Target: 70% or greater good or very good ratings and above or much above national and front range comparisons. Indicator 3: The City balances desired service levels against changing costs and revenues and promotes a diverse revenue stream. Measures: 1. City Bond Credit Rating - A bond credit rating is an indicator of the City’s overall financial strength, the amount of debt, the fund balance reserves, and the confidence in the City’s revenue stream. Target: A City Bond Credit Rating equal to Standard & Poor’s AAA Credit Rating for Municipal Bonds. 2. Citizens Survey – Ratings of City Government  The job the City is doing at providing efficient operation of programs and services Target: 70% or greater good or very good ratings and above or much above national and front range comparisons. Updated 4/5/2012 Page 3 of 6 Indicator 4: The City attracts, engages and retains a high quality creative workforce with a diverse set of skills. Measures: 1. Employee Survey (Q14) – Employee engagement  Question 3 – I believe my opinions are valued  Question 5 – I have a trusted friend in the City in whom I can confide  Question 6 – I have the materials, equipment and information to do my job  Question 7 – I get a chance to do what I do best, almost every day in my job  Question 11 – Within the last six months, the City has provided me opportunities to learn and grow Target: 75% or greater somewhat agree or strongly agree ratings 2. Citizen Survey - City Employee Ratings:  Courtesy  Knowledge  Overall impression  Making you feel valued  Promptness Target: 70% or greater good or very good ratings and above or much above national and front range comparisons. Indicator 5: Succession planning and knowledge management practices, where appropriate, are embedded in the organization. Measures: 1. Promotional rates  Percentage of positions posted internally versus externally  Percentage of internal vs. external hires Target - 50% of identified positions are initially advertised internal to the organization. Indicator 6: Leadership is effective when it drives employee engagement and facilitates outstanding performance. Measures: 1. Employee Survey (Q14) - Leadership  Question 1 – I know what my supervisor needs from me  Question 2 – My supervisor, or someone in the City, cares about me  Question 3 – I believe my opinions are valued  Question 4 – I believe my supervisor, or someone at work, is committed to my career development  Question 8 - My work team is recognized for their efforts  Question 12 - I can see a clear link between my job and the city’s vision and mission Target: 75% or greater somewhat agree or strongly agree ratings 2. Leadership Assessment Target: 75% or greater rating on individual 360 leadership assessments Updated 4/5/2012 Page 4 of 6 Indicator 7: A safe and well workforce is essential to achieving operational excellence. Measures: 1. OSHA Recordable Accident Frequency (RAF) rate Target: Equal to or better than the industry benchmark 2. Employee Well Days wellness program participation  Number of employees who participate in the Well Days program  Average number of Well Days earned per program participant  Average annual health claim cost for employees participating in the Well Days Incentive Program vs. employees not participating in Well Days Target 1: At least 70% of employees participating in Well Days Target 2: At least 2.5 average Well Days earned per program participant Indicator 8: Effective, efficient, innovative internal services facilitate world-class outcomes. Measure: 1. Internal Services Survey  Overall quality of the support service provided  Overall timeliness of the support service provided  The overall performance of the support service provided Target: 75% or greater good or excellent ratings and above benchmark comparison Purchasing Strategies We are looking for offers that: 1. Align with the City’s organizational strategic plan, support the key strategic priorities of operational excellence and a culture of innovation, and contribute to achieving key strategic plan measures and targets.  Effective Local Governance  Engaged and Innovative Workforce  Active and Engaged Community 2. Incorporate the “Triple Bottom Line” of environmental, economic and social concepts of sustainability and provide appropriate services at sustainable levels.  Effective Local Governance  Engaged and Innovative Workforce  Active and Engaged Community 3. Leverage outside funding and resources, are self-sustaining or implement a cost recovery model.  Effective Local Governance 4. Foster engagement, equity and diversity across Boards, Commissions and other volunteer endeavors.  Active and Engaged Community 5. Develop and enhance key partnerships that are mutually beneficial, provide opportunities for innovation, maximize efficiency and support a learning community. Such partnerships may include educational institutions, public and private organizations and adjacent local governments. Updated 4/5/2012 Page 5 of 6  Active and Engaged Community  Effective Local Governance 6. Provide long-term solutions to address challenges and opportunities related to fiscal sustainability – balancing revenues, expenditures, risk (liability), and community expectations, specifically addressing diversification of the revenue base and building long-term financial strength.  Effective Local Governance 7. Establish and enhance a culture of outstanding customer service while delivering services that are responsive to customer needs.  Effective Local Governance 8. Provide opportunities to promote civility, inclusion and diversity within our government and in the community.  Effective Local Governance  Engaged and Innovative Workforce  Active and Engaged Community 9. Improve the ultimate customer experience, e.g., proactive solutions, response times, reliability and accessibility.  Effective Local Governance  Engaged and Innovative Workforce 10. Build leadership capacity in the organization, improve leadership effectiveness and communication skills and support leadership development.  Engaged and Innovative Workforce  Effective Local Governance 11. Reward high performance and encourage performance improvement in creative and innovative ways.  Engaged and Innovative Workforce 12. Promote and invest in employee health and safety.  Engaged and Innovative Workforce 13. Provide productive workspaces for employees to think creatively and including alternative and flexible workplace options.  Engaged and Innovative Workforce  Effective Local Governance 14. Provide and support learning and training opportunities that invest in the workforce to achieve desired organizational outcomes and assist employees in career development.  Engaged and Innovative Workforce 15. Support and maintain systems to track and report on key organizational measures and outcomes  Effective Local Governance Sources, Reports and Related Major Plans The High Performing Government Results team reviewed a variety of sources to identify the components that will ensure Fort Collins, as described by City Council, exemplifies an efficient, Updated 4/5/2012 Page 6 of 6 innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government. These sources, as indicated in the introduction, include:  Citizen Survey  Community Scorecard  Internal Support Services Survey  Human Rights Resolution  Community Scorecard  Diversity Plan  2011 Rocky Mountain Performance Excellence (RMPEx/aka CPEx) Feedback Report  Council Workshop Notes, 2012 Major City plans that relate to the High Performance Government area include:  Plan Fort Collins  The 2012-2014 HPG/Organizational Strategic Plan The team also invited representatives from Human Resources, Community and Public Involvement, and the Performance Excellence Program Manager to share their insights on related topics. In addition, the team consulted with Risk Management, Finance, and Wellness staff to determine appropriate measures and targets for the key indicators. We are guided by the fact that our City Vision, Mission and Values underscore what is expected of every City employee as he/she goes about serving our community:  Our Vision: We are passionate about creating a vibrant, world class community  Our Mission: Exceptional service for an exceptional community  Our Values: Outstanding service, innovation and creativity, respect, integrity, initiative, collaboration and teamwork, stewardship 1 • Multi-purpose design elements in public infrastructure • Sage design and inspection • Well-lit buildings, streets, parking lots • Well-maintained facilities and streets • Flood control structures • Clean, well-kept non-residential areas • Safety oriented utility system design • Multi-purpose design elements in public infrastructure • Sage design and inspection • Well-lit buildings, streets, parking lots • Well-maintained facilities and streets • Flood control structures • Clean, well-kept non-residential areas • Safety oriented utility system design • Innovative technology • Utilize volunteer • Collaboration with local, state and federal entities, • Victim assistance • Contract services: mental health, animal control, human services • Community problem solving • Regional initiatives, Public- private partnerships • Innovative technology • Utilize volunteer • Collaboration with local, state and federal entities, • Victim assistance • Contract services: Safe Community Request for Results Team Members Chairperson: Ann Turnquist, City Manager’s Office Budget Liaison: Tricia Muraguri, Police Services Communications: Cathy Blakeman, Human Resources Members: Mike Trombley, Police Services Susie Gordon, Environmental Services Ron Simms, Poudre Fire Authority Daylan Figgs, Natural Areas Gary Thomas, Citizen Participant Josh Jones, Intern City Manager’s Office Result Fort Collins provides a safe place to live, work, learn and play Introduction/Summary of Results Map Ensuring that Fort Collins is a safe place to live, work, learn and play can be addressed by many services and programs provided by the City and collaborative partners such as the Poudre Fire Authority. Many of these actions are envisioned in City Plan’s Safety and Wellness Section. Residents often identify immediate actions from Police and Fire as key parts of their sense of safety. In addition, citizens who are pleased with the quality of the interactions they have with Police and Fire every day have an enhanced sense of security. If they trust the fairness and competence of police and fire staff, they are more likely to report crime when they are victimized, more likely to cooperate during investigations, more involved in partnerships to resolve neighborhood disorder, and more likely to appear as a witness. The definition of a safe community is broader than simply police or fire assistance. It also extends to the City-provided utilities including a safe and reliable electric power system and a state-of-the-art stormwater system which minimizes the risk of flooding. City Plan also envisions a built environment which is designed with safety in mind (see also City Plan Policy LIV 12.1) The Safe Community Team will evaluate offers based on how well they address one or more of the following factors. These factors are ranked, in priority order: 1) Prevention 2) Responsiveness 3) Planning, Preparedness and Recovery 4) Community Involvement and Partnerships 5) Infrastructure and Design All offers should address a Safe Community, Operational Excellence and a Culture of Innovation. Indicators Indicator 1: Incidents of Serious Crime Measures:  Decrease Part I Violent Crimes Per 1,000 Residents  Decrease Part I Property Crimes Per 1,000 Residents  Improve Average Response Time to Priority I Calls for Service These measures are used to compare Fort Collins with data provided by other cities and counties. Indicator 2: Incidents Due to Fire and Other Emergency Situations Measures:  Decrease Number of Fires  Decrease Average Response Time  Decrease Fire Extension Beyond Room of Origin  Increase Cardiac Arrest Survival These measures support the Poudre Fire Authority strategic plan and are considered to be indicators of fire service effectiveness. Where possible, these indicators should be benchmarked to other jurisdictions. Incidents include deaths, injuries, and direct/indirect losses which are related to a variety of emergency situations. Indicator 3: Level of Emergency Preparedness Measures:  Increase LETA 911 Participation - % of City residents registered  Increase FEMA Community Rating System Rating to 3,500 points (Stormwater)  Increase number of participants in disaster/emergency preparedness programs and activities These measures show two aspects of the general level of emergency preparedness in Fort Collins. The Larimer Emergency Telephone Authority (LETA) system, or reverse 911, quickly apprises registered residents of emergency situations. The FEMA Community Rating System (CRS) figure is a reflection of the effectiveness of our community’s floodplain management. The National Flood Insurance Program's (NFIP) CRS is a voluntary incentive program that recognizes and encourages community floodplain management activities that exceed the minimum NFIP requirements. A prepared community can sustain the impact from a disaster better than those which are not prepared. Indicator 4: Traffic and Mobility Safety Measures:  Increase Rate of Voluntary Speed Compliance  Decrease number of collisions by type (auto, bike, pedestrian) Safety on the roads, trails and sidewalks is important to community members and visitors alike. This indicator will help show the effectiveness of measures designed to promote responsible driving and bicycling. Indicator 5: Citizen Perception of Safety Measures:  Increase % of residents who feel safe in the community overall  Increase % of residents who feel safe in downtown Fort Collins during the day  Increase % of residents who feel safe in downtown Fort Collins at night  Increase % of residents who feel safe in their neighborhood The results will provide a collective picture of the attitudes, behaviors and experiences of the respondents relative to safety in Fort Collins. These measures also indicate residents’ perception of safety in the downtown area and other areas, which is a key focus of safety design activities such as alley-way improvements. Indicator 6: Reliability and Safety of Electric Infrastructure Measures:  Improve Average System Availability Index (ASAI)  Improve Customer Average Interruption Duration Index (CAIDI)  Improve System Average Interruption Frequency Index (SAIFI) These measures provide the percentage of time electric service is available, the average outage duration that any given customer would experience, and the units of interruptions per customer over the course of a year. In general, these three measures depict the overall reliability of our electric infrastructure. Purchasing Strategies 1. Education and Outreach Actions that Promote Community Safety We are looking for offers that encourage and support Prevention, and are proactive, not just responsive to safety concerns. Specifically offers for/that:  Provide programs that promote responsible driving and bicycling  Prevention programs to reduce crime  Fire prevention and education programs  Provide programs for youth involvement  Provide programs which address visible signs of disorder 2. Response to Safety Issues We are looking for offers that encourage and support Responsiveness to collisions, crimes, fires, emergency medical services (EMS) and utility emergencies. Specifically offers for/that:  Provide for well-equipped, timely, trained, caring response teams  Promote coordination and response by appropriate agencies  Provide for prompt restoration of services and infrastructure in emergency situations  Address community safety issues before they become significant problems 3. Disaster Resistant Community We are looking for offers that encourage and support Planning, Preparedness and Recovery, implementing planning and preparations to become a disaster resistant/resilient community. Specifically offers for/that:  Enable appropriate staging of plans, personnel and equipment to deal with natural disasters, extreme weather, utility outages and significant community events  Leverage the use of State and Federal Funding by regional agencies  Lead community disaster preparedness and aid in recovery 4. Community and Partner Involvement We are looking for offers that encourage and support deliberate Community Involvement and Partnerships that make our community safer and stronger. Specifically offers for/that:  Maximize the resources of local, regional and federal agencies to address safety issues  Provide for victim assistance  Reduce recidivism of juvenile offenders (repeat offenders)  Increase citizen accountability, awareness and involvement in public safety  Improve community safety and human assistance in the areas of animal control, detoxification, mental health, and substance abuse by leveraging contract resources  Foster public-private partnerships to address community safety issues  Build a sense of community pride and involvement  Leverage community volunteers as cost effective staff resources and citizen advocates  Adapt emerging technologies which improve the ability of citizens to be engaged in response to emergencies (e.g. Smartphone apps for citizen responders, LETA 911 notification system) 5. Safety in the Built Environment We are looking for offers that encourage and support promoting safety through Infrastructure and Design and provide a sense of security and safety in public and private spaces. Specifically offers for/that:  Provide a safe built environment including well-lit buildings, streets, parking lots, safe design and inspection of facilities, clean well kept non-residential areas, and visible presence of safety personnel.  Ensure reliable, efficient electric power  Provide adequate flood management  Focus on enhancing safety in the downtown areas through safety conscious design  Compliance with local safety code requirements Sources, Reports and Related Major Plans  Poudre Fire Authority Strategic Plan  PFA Annual Report  Stormwater Master Plan  City Plan  Community Scorecard  Staff interviews with subject matter experts  Benchmark Cities Survey  FBI Uniform Crime Report  Futures Committee Data Inventory 1 1 2013-14 Budgeting for Outcomes Results Map and Request for Results (RFR) Review April 10th 2012 Council Work Session 2 Economic Health Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values. Environmental Health Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. Transportation Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities. Culture and Recreation 2013-14 BFO Outcomes ATTACHMENT 3 2 3 High Performing Government Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government. Fort Collins provides a safe place to live, work, learn, and play. Safe Community Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods. Community and Neighborhood Livability 2013-14 BFO Outcomes 4 Ginny Sawyer, Chairperson Community Development & Neighborhood Services Jessica Ping-Small Finance Jill Mueggenberg Recreation Josh Birks Economic Development Bill Whirty Parks Dean Cunningham Police Services Timothy Wilder Advance Planning McCabe Callahan Citizen Economic Health Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values. 3 5 • Balance talent/workforce • Encourage retail mix/opportunities • Recruit unique businesses • Support target industry clusters • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Balance talent/workforce • Encourage retail mix/opportunities • Recruit unique businesses • Support target industry clusters • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Strengthen business retention & expansion • Foster transparency • Ensure retail sales diversity • Maintain effective/efficient City processes • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Strengthen business retention & expansion • Foster transparency • Ensure retail sales diversity • Maintain effective/efficient City processes • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote incubation & recruitment • Foster intellectual property • Minimize barriers to business • Support access to capital • Encourage collaboration and partnerships 4 7 Lucinda Smith, Chairperson Environmental Sustainability Barb Brock Natural Areas Lori Greening Human Resources Craig Hibbard Water Reclamation Bob Adams Recreation Kevin Cronin Patrol Lance Smith Utilities Finance and Budget K-Lynn Cameron Citizen Environmental Health Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. 8 • Water treatment* • Pollution Prevention* • Wastewater treatment* • Stormwater treatment* • Watershed & floodplain management* • Water supply and conservation* • Climatic conditions & adaptation* • Water treatment* • Pollution Prevention* • Wastewater treatment* • Stormwater treatment* • Watershed & floodplain management* • Water supply and conservation* • Climatic conditions & adaptation* Primary Factors Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources Secondary/Casual Factors Excellent Air Quality Excellent Air Quality Exemplary Land Conservation & Stewardship Exemplary Land Conservation & Stewardship • Open lands* • Land use* • Built environment (green buildings)* • Healthy & bio-diverse habitat • Community buffers • Access & engagement* • Scenic views 5 9 • Overall Changes: – Reviewed and edited the Result Map/RFR to reflect current conditions & add focus on the stewardship of natural resources • Result Map Changes: – Changed “Good Water Resources” to “Exceptional Stewardship of Water Resources” – Changed “Good Air Quality” to “Excellent Air Quality” Environmental Health 10 • Indicator Changes: – Split the water indicator into two • #1 = focus on water quality (protection & treatment) • #2 = focus on water quantity (conservation) – Clarified that air quality addresses both outdoor and indoor – Added an indicator on energy consumption and renewables – Added more specific measures to most indicators Environmental Health 6 11 • Purchasing Strategy Changes: – Combined all generic statements into one strategy – Added specific bullet points under each strategy – Split the water strategy into quality and quantity – Created a new purchasing strategy focusing on greenhouse gas reduction – Added a new strategy for energy conservation, efficiency and renewables – Added a strategy to increase community resiliency & preparedness for changing climate/weather patterns Environmental Health 12 Ken Mannon, Chairperson Operation Services Delynn Coldiron Community Development & Neighborhood Services Kim Newcomer Communication & Public Involvement Jon Haukaas Water Systems Engineering Joe Olson Traffic Lisa Voytko Water Production Darren Moritz Streets Rick Reider Citizen Transportation Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. 7 13 Secondary/Causal Factors • Capacity Improvements • Traffic light timing • Parking • Signs & directions • Routes & zones • Capacity Improvements • Traffic light timing • Parking • Signs & directions • Routes & zones • Maintenance • Capital improvements • Design standards • System connectivity • Safety and efficiency improvements • Technology infrastructure • Maintenance • Capital improvements • Design standards • System connectivity • Safety and efficiency improvements • Technology infrastructure • Planning • Funding sources • Demand forecasting • Partnerships & collaboration • Planning • Funding sources • Demand forecasting • Partnerships & collaboration • Mass/para 8 15 • Acknowledgement of major changes (established and potential) – Mason Corridor – Colorado State University Stadium • Continued focus on efficiency and innovation – Responsibility of delivering on Keep Fort Collins Great commitments Transportation 16 Beth Sowder, Chairperson Community Development & Neighborhood Services Dawna Gorkowski Parks Rita Davis Police Services Wayne Sterler Utility Services Craig Foreman Park Planning Steve Lukowski Parks Marc Virata Engineering Carol Ann Hixon Citizen Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities. Culture and Recreation 9 17 • Offer high quality and diverse culture and recreation programs and opportunities • Support arts, culture, and recreation educational programming • Develop arts, culture, and recreation partnerships • Promote visibility of arts, culture, and recreation opportunities • Offer high quality and diverse culture and recreation programs and opportunities • Support arts, culture, and recreation educational programming • Develop arts, culture, and recreation partnerships • Promote visibility of arts, culture, and recreation opportunities • Provide well-maintained, attractive, functional, and safe facilities, lands, parks, and recreational trails • Demonstrate environ- mental sustainability • Utilize effective and innovative partnerships • Adapt to change in community needs and interests • Support an interconnected and regional and local system of parks, trails and open lands. • Provide well-maintained, attractive, functional, and safe facilities, lands, parks, and recreational trails • Demonstrate environ- mental sustainability • Utilize effective and innovative partnerships • Adapt to change in community needs and interests • Support an interconnected and regional and local 10 19 • Indicator Changes: – Indicators 1 & 2 were changed to encourage continuous improvement of customer service and responsiveness – Indicators 3 & 4 were changed to improve measures, identify targets, and encourage more specific and useful data – Indicator 5 was removed because the ICMA performance measure currently lacks consistency (Colorado versus national) Culture and Recreation 20 • Purchasing Strategy Changes: – Focused on Plan Fort Collins’ principles and policies to ensure that offers reflect the priorities of the community – Streamlined the purchasing strategies with more concise language – Emphasized the goals of the City’s Organizational Strategic Plan Culture and Recreation 11 21 Matt Zoccali, Chairperson Regulatory & Government Affairs Janice Saeger Recreation Susan Herlihy Cultural Services Kurt Clow Police Services Tim Buchanan Parks Patty Netherton Municipal Court Polly Lauridsen Community Development & Neighborhood Services Kristin Kirkpatrick Citizen Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods. Community and Neighborhood Livability 22 • Quality Design/Building Standards • Sustainable/ Attainable Housing • Integrate a Variety of Housing Types, Densities and Locations • Ownership Opportunities • Quality Design/Building Standards • Sustainable/ Attainable Housing • Integrate a Variety of Housing Types, Densities and Locations • Ownership Opportunities Primary Factors Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing Adequate and Diverse Supply of Quality Housing Attractive Neighborhoods Attractive Neighborhoods Good Neighbor Relationships Good Neighbor Relationships Community Functionality 12 23 Definition: Community is defined as a cohesive, integrated whole, made up of a sum of individual neighborhoods and developments, commercial and employment activity centers, streets, parks, and public works, which fosters positive interactions among people. Community and Neighborhood Livability 24 • Results Map Changes: –4th Factor Added: Community Functionality & Design – Secondary Factors were added to address: • Integrated and Diverse Housing Types, Densities and Location (Special Needs, Students, etc) • Prioritized Infill and Target Redevelopment • Unique Gateways and Coordinated Edges • Multi-Modal Connections • Mixed Use Community Centers Community and Neighborhood Livability 13 25 • Indicator Changes: Revised to Align with Plan Fort Collins – Indicator 1: Included Human Services What makes a good Affordable Housing measure? • Net gain/loss: not able to track with certainty • Resourcing/Allocation of funds may prove better measure (align w/ Affordable Housing Strategic Plan) – Indicator 2: Graffiti abatement measure added – Indicator 4: Related to new 4th Primary Factor Community and Neighborhood Livability 26 • Purchasing Strategy Changes: – #5 “gateways” added – #8 strategic support for key identified human services – #11 nature “visible and accessible”, connectedness and the conservation of natural ecosystems Community and Neighborhood Livability 14 27 Carol Webb, Chairperson Regulatory & Government Affairs Jolene Buxman Finance Carol Workman Police Services Tracy Ochsner Operation Services Clint Andrews Information Technology Ginger Purvis Light and Power Lindsay Ex Community Development & Neighborhood Services Stacy Baumgarn Citizen High Performing Government Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government. 28 • Provide a range of public engagement methods • Provide opportunities for community involvement • Communicate effectively • Promote collaboration • Support volunteerism • Inform citizens of city services, policies plans, and direction • Provide a range of public engagement methods • Provide opportunities for community involvement • Communicate effectively • Promote collaboration • Support volunteerism • Inform citizens of city services, policies plans, and direction • Transparent and accountable • Maintain public trust • Fiscal strength • Support elected officials • Outstanding customer service • Promote civility, inclusion & diversity • Value continuous improvement and innovation • Provide exceptional support services • Forge partnerships to create opportunities • Safeguard community assets • Transparent and accountable • Maintain public trust • Fiscal strength • Support elected officials • Outstanding customer service • Promote civility, inclusion & diversity • Value continuous improvement and innovation • Provide exceptional support services • Forge partnerships to create opportunities • Safeguard community assets • Create a culture of innovation 15 29 • Aligned Results Map with: – Plan Fort Collins – Organizational Strategic Plan • Primary Factor Changes – Significant changes to all Primary Factors • Secondary Factor Changes – Incorporated Plan Fort Collins policies & principles and the Organizational Strategic Plan Objectives – Focused on critical factors related to an effective local government High Performing Government 30 • Re-evaluated Indicators – Asked ourselves, “We know we have achieved it when…” – Developed statements regarding elements critical to success • Purchasing Strategies: – Would like to attract offers that integrate key elements of Plan Fort Collins & Organizational Strategic Plan • Innovation, ultimate customer experience, operational excellence, financial strength, sustainability High Performing Government 16 31 • Performance Measures/Targets: – Key measures that may be influenced by multiple offers – Focused on results vs. activities and those measures that have established benchmarks – Utilized Citizen and Customer Surveys – Consulted subject matter experts High Performing Government 32 Ann Turnquist, Chairperson City Manager's Office Tricia Muraguri Police Services Cathy Blakeman Human Resources Susie Gordon Environmental Services Mike Trombley Police Services Ron Simms Poudre Fire Authority Daylan Figgs Natural Areas Josh Jones City Manager's Office Gary Thomas Citizen Fort Collins provides a safe place to live, work, learn, and play. Safe Community 17 33 • Multi-purpose design elements in public infrastructure • Sage design and inspection • Well-lit buildings, streets, parking lots • Well-maintained facilities and streets • Flood control structures • Clean, well-kept non-residential areas • Safety oriented utility system design • Multi-purpose design elements in public infrastructure • Sage design and inspection • Well-lit buildings, streets, parking lots • Well-maintained facilities and streets • Flood control structures • Clean, well-kept non-residential areas • Safety oriented utility system design • Innovative technology • Utilize volunteer • Collaboration with local, state and federal entities, • Victim assistance • Contract services: mental health, animal control, human services • Community problem solving • Regional initiatives, Public- private partnerships • Innovative technology • Utilize volunteer • Collaboration with local, state and federal entities, • Victim assistance 18 35 • Purchasing Strategies Realigned with Primary Factors – Resiliency and Leveraging of New Technologies were Added to the Purchasing Strategies – Focus on volunteers • Indicators and Measures Updated – Stronger Focus on Outcome Measures – Significant Input From Citizen Team Member Safe Community • Contract services: mental health, animal control, human services • Community problem solving • Regional initiatives, Public- private partnerships • Highly trained emer- gency personnel • Effective comm- unications systems • Reliable electric power • Appropriate equip- ment & technology • Response/recovery to natural disaster & outages events • Strategic problem solving • Pre-incident plans • Strong relationships with funding partners • Highly trained emer- gency personnel • Effective comm- unications systems • Reliable electric power • Appropriate equip- ment & technology • Response/recovery to natural disaster & outages events • Strategic problem solving • Pre-incident plans • Strong relationships with funding partners Secondary/Casual Factors • Restored community services in emergencies • Timely response • Professional well- equipped, caring responders • Flexible responses to community safety issues • Coordination among agencies • Response by appropriate agency • Innovative approaches • Restored community services in emergencies • Timely response • Professional well- equipped, caring responders • Flexible responses to community safety issues • Coordination among agencies • Response by appropriate agency • Innovative approaches • Visible presence of safety personnel • Roadway behavior and traffic safety • Youth involvement programs • Data collection & trend analysis • Prevention and education Programs • Graffiti/ vandalism abatement • Visible presence of safety personnel • Roadway behavior and traffic safety • Youth involvement programs • Data collection & trend analysis • Prevention and education Programs • Graffiti/ vandalism abatement Primary Factors Prevention Prevention Responsiveness Responsiveness Planning Preparedness and Recovery Planning Preparedness and Recovery Community Involvement and Partnerships Community Involvement and Partnerships Infrastructure and Design Infrastructure and Design Safe Community Fort Collins provides a safe place to live, work, learn, and play. 34 • Aligned with City Plan Principals – Added “Infrastructure and Design” as a New Primary Factor • Met with new Police Chief, Poudre Fire Authority Chief, and Utilities Executive Director Safe Community • Embrace organizational core values • Cultivate diverse, effective leadership • Foster knowledge transfer • Promote succession planning • Value sustainable work/life balance • Invest in professional and personal development • Provide competitive, fair compensation • Invest in employee health and safety • Create a culture of innovation • Embrace organizational core values • Cultivate diverse, effective leadership • Foster knowledge transfer • Promote succession planning • Value sustainable work/life balance • Invest in professional and personal development • Provide competitive, fair compensation • Invest in employee health and safety Primary Factors Active and Engaged Community Active and Engaged Community Effective Local Governance Effective Local Governance Engaged and Innovative Workforce Engaged and Innovative Workforce Secondary/Causal Factors High Performing Government Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government. and Attractive Design Community Functionality and Attractive Design Secondary/Casual Factors Community and Neighborhood Livability • Attractive Public Places • Clean and Maintained • Code Compliance • Graffiti-free • Historic Preservation • Parking • Attractive Public Places • Clean and Maintained • Code Compliance • Graffiti-free • Historic Preservation • Parking • Collaboration/ Outreach • Occupancy Standards • Reasonable Noise Levels • Informal Networks/HOAs • Conflict Resolution • Inclusive and Diverse Neighbors • Collaboration/ Outreach • Occupancy Standards • Reasonable Noise Levels • Informal Networks/HOAs • Conflict Resolution • Inclusive and Diverse Neighbors • Economic, Social, and Environmental Sustainability • Efficient Supply of Infrastructure and Services • Prioritized Infill and Targeted Redevelopment • Unique Gateways • Coordinated Edges and Growth Management Areas • Multi-Modal Connections • Mixed-Use Community Centers • Economic, Social, and Environmental Sustainability • Efficient Supply of Infrastructure and Services • Prioritized Infill and Targeted Redevelopment • Unique Gateways • Coordinated Edges and Growth Management Areas • Multi-Modal Connections • Mixed-Use Community Centers Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods. Community and Neighborhood Livability system of parks, trails and open lands. • Demonstrate effective and innovative financial sustainability • Offer fee-based and free programs • Provide opportunities in convenient locations citywide • Provide a variety of operating hours • Demonstrate effective and innovative financial sustainability • Offer fee-based and free programs • Provide opportunities in convenient locations citywide • Provide a variety of operating hours • Serve diverse customer needs and expectations • Provide innovative and effective programming and practices • Maintain/enhance quality staffing • Utilize efficient and innovative technologies and communication strategies • Offer programmed and non-programmed opportunities • Serve diverse customer needs and expectations • Provide innovative and effective programming and practices • Maintain/enhance quality staffing • Utilize efficient and innovative technologies and communication strategies • Offer programmed and non-programmed opportunities Primary Factors Customer Service Customer Service Secondary/Causal Factors Convenient & Affordable Convenient & Affordable Quality Facilities & Lands Quality Facilities & Lands Culture & Recreation Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities. Quality Programming Quality Programming 18 • Map Changes: – Added 4th Primary Factor: “Quality Programming” – Added Secondary Causal Factors related to “Quality Programming” – Causal Factors remained substantively the same with edits for clarification and alignment with Plan Fort Collins and the City’s Organizational Strategic Plan Culture and Recreation transit • Bicycling • Walking • Carpooling • Car sharing • Online/ telecommuting • Wheelchair & disability access • Mass/para transit • Bicycling • Walking • Carpooling • Car sharing • Online/ telecommuting • Wheelchair & disability access • Outreach & education • Incentives • Citizen involvement • Environmental impact • Outreach & education • Incentives • Citizen involvement • Environmental impact Primary Factors Traffic Flow Traffic Flow Quality Travel Surfaces & Infrastructure Quality Travel Surfaces & Infrastructure Integrated Land Use & Transportation Planning Integrated Land Use & Transportation Planning Mobility / Travel Mode Options Mobility / Travel Mode Options Citizen Awareness Citizen Awareness Transportation Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. 14 • Increased focus on environmental impacts • Refinement of indicators – More specific – Aligned with master plans and Organizational Strategic Plan – Addition of goals Transportation • Natural heritage • Open lands* • Land use* • Built environment (green buildings)* • Healthy & bio-diverse habitat • Community buffers • Access & engagement* • Scenic views • Natural heritage • Waste generation, recycling & diversion* • Greenhouse gas emissions* • Renewable energy* • Mobile sources* • Energy use & conservation • Transportation* • Indoor air quality • Commercial/industrial activities • Waste generation, recycling & diversion* • Greenhouse gas emissions* • Renewable energy* • Mobile sources* • Energy use & conservation • Transportation* • Indoor air quality • Commercial/industrial activities Environmental Health Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. Note: Secondary factors that influence multiple Primary Factors are designated with an asterisk (*) • Promote incubation & recruitment • Foster intellectual property • Minimize barriers to business • Support access to capital • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote housing affordability • Support community values • Champion local businesses • Ensure access/usability of business centers • Provide safety • Protect local aesthetics • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote housing affordability • Support community values • Champion local businesses • Ensure access/usability of business centers • Provide safety • Protect local aesthetics • Encourage collaboration and partnerships Primary Factors Create Diversity Create Diversity Ensure Resiliency Ensure Resiliency Provide Opportunity Provide Opportunity Preserve Place Preserve Place Economic Health Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values. Secondary/Causal Factors 6 • Simplified Focus Aligned with Plan Fort Collins and the Economic Health Strategic Plan – Diversity: Retail mix, workforce, industry clusters – Resiliency: Retention, retail sales, efficiency – Opportunity: Incubation, recruitment, minimize barriers – Place: Safety, aesthetics, community values – Overall & ongoing desire for collaboration and innovation Economic Health mental health, animal control, human services • Community problem solving • Regional initiatives, Public- private partnerships • Highly trained emer- gency personnel • Effective comm- unications systems • Reliable electric power • Appropriate equip- ment & technology • Response/recovery to natural disaster & outages events • Strategic problem solving • Pre-incident plans • Strong relationships with funding partners • Highly trained emer- gency personnel • Effective comm- unications systems • Reliable electric power • Appropriate equip- ment & technology • Response/recovery to natural disaster & outages events • Strategic problem solving • Pre-incident plans • Strong relationships with funding partners Secondary/Casual Factors • Restored community services in emergencies • Timely response • Professional well- equipped, caring responders • Flexible responses to community safety issues • Coordination among agencies • Response by appropriate agency • Innovative approaches • Restored community services in emergencies • Timely response • Professional well- equipped, caring responders • Flexible responses to community safety issues • Coordination among agencies • Response by appropriate agency • Innovative approaches • Visible presence of safety personnel • Roadway behavior and traffic safety • Youth involvement programs • Data collection & trend analysis • Prevention and education Programs • Graffiti/ vandalism abatement • Visible presence of safety personnel • Roadway behavior and traffic safety • Youth involvement programs • Data collection & trend analysis • Prevention and education Programs • Graffiti/ vandalism abatement Primary Factors Prevention Prevention Responsiveness Responsiveness Planning Preparedness and Recovery Planning Preparedness and Recovery Community Involvement and Partnerships Community Involvement and Partnerships Infrastructure and Design Infrastructure and Design Safe Community Fort Collins provides a safe place to live, work, learn, and play. leadership • Foster knowledge transfer • Promote succession planning • Value sustainable work/life balance • Invest in professional and personal development • Provide competitive, fair compensation • Invest in employee health and safety Primary Factors Active and Engaged Community Active and Engaged Community Effective Local Governance Effective Local Governance Engaged and Innovative Workforce Engaged and Innovative Workforce Secondary/Causal Factors High Performing Government Fort Collins exemplifies an efficient, innovative, transparent, effective and collaborative city government. • Parking • Attractive Public Places • Clean and Maintained • Code Compliance • Graffiti-free • Historic Preservation • Parking • Collaboration/ Outreach • Occupancy Standards • Reasonable Noise Levels • Informal Networks/HOAs • Conflict Resolution • Inclusive and Diverse Neighbors • Collaboration/ Outreach • Occupancy Standards • Reasonable Noise Levels • Informal Networks/HOAs • Conflict Resolution • Inclusive and Diverse Neighbors • Economic, Social, and Environmental Sustainability • Efficient Supply of Infrastructure and Services • Prioritized Infill and Targeted Redevelopment • Unique Gateways • Coordinated Edges and Growth Management Areas • Multi-Modal Connections • Mixed-Use Community Centers • Economic, Social, and Environmental Sustainability • Efficient Supply of Infrastructure and Services • Prioritized Infill and Targeted Redevelopment • Unique Gateways • Coordinated Edges and Growth Management Areas • Multi-Modal Connections • Mixed-Use Community Centers Fort Collins provides a high quality built environment and supports quality, diverse neighborhoods. Community and Neighborhood Livability open lands. • Demonstrate effective and innovative financial sustainability • Offer fee-based and free programs • Provide opportunities in convenient locations citywide • Provide a variety of operating hours • Demonstrate effective and innovative financial sustainability • Offer fee-based and free programs • Provide opportunities in convenient locations citywide • Provide a variety of operating hours • Serve diverse customer needs and expectations • Provide innovative and effective programming and practices • Maintain/enhance quality staffing • Utilize efficient and innovative technologies and communication strategies • Offer programmed and non-programmed opportunities • Serve diverse customer needs and expectations • Provide innovative and effective programming and practices • Maintain/enhance quality staffing • Utilize efficient and innovative technologies and communication strategies • Offer programmed and non-programmed opportunities Primary Factors Customer Service Customer Service Secondary/Causal Factors Convenient & Affordable Convenient & Affordable Quality Facilities & Lands Quality Facilities & Lands Culture & Recreation Fort Collins provides diverse cultural and recreational amenities. Quality Programming Quality Programming • Bicycling • Walking • Carpooling • Car sharing • Online/ telecommuting • Wheelchair & disability access • Mass/para transit • Bicycling • Walking • Carpooling • Car sharing • Online/ telecommuting • Wheelchair & disability access • Outreach & education • Incentives • Citizen involvement • Environmental impact • Outreach & education • Incentives • Citizen involvement • Environmental impact Primary Factors Traffic Flow Traffic Flow Quality Travel Surfaces & Infrastructure Quality Travel Surfaces & Infrastructure Integrated Land Use & Transportation Planning Integrated Land Use & Transportation Planning Mobility / Travel Mode Options Mobility / Travel Mode Options Citizen Awareness Citizen Awareness Transportation Fort Collins provides for safe and reliable multi-modal travel to, from, and throughout the city. • Renewable energy* • Mobile sources* • Energy use & conservation • Transportation* • Indoor air quality • Commercial/industrial activities • Waste generation, recycling & diversion* • Greenhouse gas emissions* • Renewable energy* • Mobile sources* • Energy use & conservation • Transportation* • Indoor air quality • Commercial/industrial activities Environmental Health Fort Collins promotes, protects, and enhances a healthy and sustainable environment. Note: Secondary factors that influence multiple Primary Factors are designated with an asterisk (*) incubation & recruitment • Foster intellectual property • Minimize barriers to business • Support access to capital • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote housing affordability • Support community values • Champion local businesses • Ensure access/usability of business centers • Provide safety • Protect local aesthetics • Encourage collaboration and partnerships • Promote housing affordability • Support community values • Champion local businesses • Ensure access/usability of business centers • Provide safety • Protect local aesthetics • Encourage collaboration and partnerships Primary Factors Create Diversity Create Diversity Ensure Resiliency Ensure Resiliency Provide Opportunity Provide Opportunity Preserve Place Preserve Place Economic Health Fort Collins has a healthy, sustainable economy reflecting community values. Secondary/Causal Factors ATTACHMENT 2 Lindsay Ex Comm Dev & Neighborhood PPT Services New Citizen Stacy Baumgarn New Transportation Role Name Department Service Area Status Team Leader Ken Mannon Operation Services Comm & Ops Services Continuing Budget Liaison Delynn Coldiron Comm Dev & Neighborhood PPT Services Continuing Communications Kim Newcomer CPIO Emp & Comm Services Continuing Jon Haukaas Water Systems Engineering Utility Services Continuing Joe Olson Traffic PPT Services Continuing - new team Lisa Voytko Utility Water Production Utility Services Continuing - new team Darren Moritz Streets PPT Services New Citizen Rick Reider New ATTACHMENT 1