Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOUNCIL - COMPLETE AGENDA - 10/11/2022 - WORK SESSIONNOTICE: Work Sessions of the City Council are held on the 2nd and 4th Tuesdays of each month in the Colorado Room of the 222 Building. Meetings are conducted in a hybrid format, however there is no public participation permitted in a work session. City Council members may participate in this meeting via electronic means pursuant to their adopted policies and protocol. Fort Collins City Council Work Session Agenda 6:00 p.m. Tuesday, October 11, 2022 Colorado Room, 222 Laporte Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80521 How to view this Meeting:: Meetings are open to the public and can be attended in person by anyone. Meetings are televised live on Channels 14 & 881 on cable television. Meetings are livestreamed on the City's website, fcgov.com/fctv Upon request, the City of Fort Collins will provide language access services for individuals who have limited English proficiency, or auxiliary aids and services for individuals with disabilities, to access City services, programs and activities. Contact 970.221.6515 (V/TDD: Dial 711 for Relay Colorado) for assistance. Please provide 48 hours advance notice when possible. A solicitud, la Ciudad de Fort Collins proporcionará servicios de acceso a idiomas para personas que no dominan el idioma inglés, o ayudas y servicios auxiliares para personas con discapacidad, para que puedan acceder a los servicios, programas y actividades de la Ciudad. Para asistencia, llame al 970.221.6515 (V/TDD: Marque 711 para Relay Colorado). Por favor proporcione 48 horas de aviso previo cuando sea posible. Meeting agendas, minutes, and archived videos are available on the City's meeting portal at https://fortcollins-co.municodemeetings.com/ While work sessions do not include public comment, mail comments about any item on the agenda to cityleaders@fcgov.com City of Fort Collins Page 1 of 2 City Council Work Session Agenda October 11, 2022 at 6:00 PM Jeni Arndt, Mayor Emily Francis, District 6, Mayor Pro Tem Susan Gutowsky, District 1 Julie Pignataro, District 2 Tricia Canonico, District 3 Shirley Peel, District 4 Kelly Ohlson, District 5 Colorado River Community Room 222 Laporte Avenue, Fort Collins Cablecast on FCTV Channel 14 on Connexion Channel 14 and 881 on Comcast Carrie Daggett Kelly DiMartino Anissa Hollingshead City Attorney City Manager City Clerk CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION 6:00 PM A) CALL MEETING TO ORDER B) ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION 1. 2023-2024 Biennial Budget – Work Session #3. The purpose of this work session is to review the 2023-2024 Recommended Budget delivered to Council and the City Clerk on September 2, 2022 pursuant to provisions of Article V, Section 2 of the City Charter. This is a continuation of the overall budget discussion and Outcome review item discussed at the September 13 and September 27 Work Sessions. Two public hearings to gather input from the community about the 2023-2024 Budget have also been completed. The Recommended Budget is aligned with the adopted 2021-2023 Council Priorities, the 2022 Strategic Plan and community priorities. At the October 11, 2022 Work Session, staff will be looking for guidance on the changes to the City Manager’s Recommended Budget that Council would like to have incorporated into 1st Reading on November 1. 2. Our Climate Future Implementation. The purpose of this item is to provide Councilmembers with clear information about how the Fort Collins community can make progress towards the goals laid out in the Our Climate Future plan for waste, renewable electricity, and greenhouse gas (GHG) reductions. Based on greenhouse gas and waste forecasts between 2021 and 2030, staff has provided a “roadmap” of Council actions to be considered in the years ahead that advance strategies to help reach Council-adopted goals. Councilmembers will review the 2021 inventory of community greenhouse gas emissions along with forecasted emissions projections by sector and will be asked to use those fo recasts to offer guidance on where to set a 2026 interim GHG goal for the community. C) ANNOUNCEMENTS Page 1 City of Fort Collins Page 2 of 2 D) ADJOURNMENT Upon request, the City of Fort Collins will provide language access services for individuals who have limited English proficiency, or auxiliary aids and services for individuals with disabilities, to access City services, programs and activities. Contact 970.221.6515 (V/TDD: Dial 711 for Relay Colorado) for assistance. Please provide 48 hours advance notice when possible. A solicitud, la Ciudad de Fort Collins proporcionará servicios de acceso a idiomas para personas que no dominan el idioma inglés, o ayudas y servicios auxiliares para personas con discapacidad, para que puedan acceder a los servicios, programas y actividades de la Ciudad. Para asistencia, llame al 970.221.6515 (V/TDD: Marque 711 para Relay Colorado). Por favor proporcione 48 horas de aviso previo cuando sea posible. Page 2 City Council Work Session Agenda – City of Fort Collins Page 1 of 5 October 11, 2022 WORK SESSION AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY City Council STAFF Kelly DiMartino, City Manager Travis Storin, Chief Financial Officer Lawrence Pollack, Budget Director SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION 2023-2024 Biennial Budget – Work Session #3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this work session is to review the 2023-2024 Recommended Budget delivered to Council and the City Clerk on September 2, 2022 pursuant to provisions of Article V, Section 2 of the City Charter. This is a continuation of the overall budget discussion and Outcome review item discussed at the September 13 and September 27 Work Sessions. Two public hearings to gather input from the community about the 2023-2024 Budget have also been completed. The Recommended Budget is aligned with the adopted 2021-2023 Council Priorities, the 2022 Strategic Plan and community priorities. At the October 11, 2022 Work Session, staff will be looking for guidance on the changes to the City Manager’s Recommended Budget that Council would like to have incorporated into 1st Reading on November 1. GENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED 1. Which offers does Council have interest in including in first reading of the 2022 Budget, including preferred funding sources? 2. What clarifying questions does Council have on any of the Offers in the seven Outcomes discussed in the previous budget work sessions? BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION This creation of the 2023-2024 Recommended Budget was accomplished using a process called Budgeting for Outcomes (BFO), which is a form of priority-based budgeting. The process has included the following major steps: • Council adopted the 2022 Strategic Plan, which encompasses the adopted 2021-2023 Council Priorities. • City financial staff created revenue forecasts for fiscal years 2023 and 2024. Page 3 Item 1. City Council Work Session Agenda – City of Fort Collins Page 2 of 5 • City staff developed budget requests (offers) for individual programs and services to help achieve specific strategic objectives within the adopted strategic plan. The primary objective selected within the budget request determines which of the City’s seven key Strategic Outcomes the request is then submitted for consideration. • BFO Teams comprised of seven staff members each (one team per Outcome) reviewed the offers and negotiated with staff (aka Sellers) who submitted the budget requests. This unique aspect of BFO allows for a much deeper review and understanding of the programs and services being proposed. The teams each deliver a prioritized ranking of budget requests that would change the ongoing level of service. • Concurrently, public outreach began with a press release and ongoing communications through social media channels to invite the community to share their perspectives. The City’s online public engagement tool, called OurCity, allows individuals to provide various types of input based on their level of interest and the amount of time they have available. Initial feedback received in May and June helped inform the decisions for the recommended budget, and the remaining inputs through September will be shared with Council as final decisions are being made for the adopted 2023-2024 Budget. • A work session item on the status of the 2023-2024 budget process was discussed on June 28. This session included high-level assumptions within the budget, as well as conversation about the themes that were emerging. • The prioritized lists of funding recommendations from the BFO Teams were then reviewed by the City Manager and the rest of the Budget Leadership Team (BLT). The BLT deliberated similar to the BFO Teams, but they looked across all seven Outcomes holistically. This included conversations with each BFO Team, as well as a snapshot summary of the public input received between early May and early July. These inputs, along with other data and information discussed by the BLT, resulted in the decisions of what is recommended for funding in 2023 and 2024. Public Engagement Update The City’s Communications and Public Information Office was able to begin public engagement in May, just as it was prior to the onset of the pandemic, and that continued through September. A snapshot of results was analyzed and shared with the executive team to assist with funding decisions for the Recommended Budget. All results from that engagement is summarized in Attachments 1 through 3. New this year was an insightful collaboration with the Colorado State University Center for Public Deliberation (CPD). The engagement was two-fold. First, Community Guide volunteers were trained by CPD and then facilitated conversations with other local residents. Attachment 4 is a summary report of that initiative. The second aspect with CPD was a community event at the Senior Center on September 28 where residents participated in table-top discussions around a simulated budget exercise with the funded/unfunded offers in the Recommended Budget. Attachment 5 is a summary report of the insights from this community event. Changes to Offers originally included in the City Manager’s Recommended Budget Based on Council dialogue during the Budget work sessions on September 13 and 27, staff heard requests for funding various offers, some at a scalable level. Staff has reviewed this guidance and proposes the corresponding offers be grouped into the following categories (all values in $1,000s): Page 4 Item 1. City Council Work Session Agenda – City of Fort Collins Page 3 of 5 1) Offers to include for 1st Reading with specific funding source recommendations 2) Offers to include for 1st Reading funded by options available to Council (to be reviewed during the work session) Page 5 Item 1. City Council Work Session Agenda – City of Fort Collins Page 4 of 5 3) Offers of interest to Council – More discussion needed 4) Offers recommended to stay unfunded relative to other priorities 5) Offers for possible consideration in the 2024 Budget Revision process Page 6 Item 1. City Council Work Session Agenda – City of Fort Collins Page 5 of 5 Additionally, the following administrative changes are proposed for inclusion on 1st Reading: The 2023 Budget for the Downtown Development Authority (DDA) was approved by its Board of Directors on September 8, 2022. Offer 40.1 - Downtown Development Authority: Operating & Capital Budget has been updated to reflect the final DDA 2023 Budget, as approved by the Board. Principal and interest payments have been updated in Offer 34.2 - Urban Renewal Authority Debt Service to reflect the amounts of the debt payment schedule. Council Budget Meetings This work session concludes a series of work sessions scheduled in September and October to discuss the proposed 2023-2024 Budget, and will include Council discussion regarding overall priorities, policy issues and guidance on what changes Council wants included in First Reading of the 2023-2024 Budget. Council is scheduled to consider budget adoption on the following dates: Meeting Date Topic November 1, 2022 Regular Meeting First Reading of the 2023-2024 Budget and the 2023 Appropriation Ordinance November 15, 2022 Regular Meeting Second Reading of the 2023-2024 Budget and the 2023 Appropriation Ordinance NEXT STEPS The next step is First Reading on November 1, 2022. This will be followed by Second Reading on November 15, 2022. ATTACHMENTS 1.2023-2024 Budget Engagement Summary 2.2023-2024 Budget Feedback Emails 3.OurCity Full Text Comments 4.CPD - CoFC Budget Community Guides - Summary Report 5.CPD - CoFC Budget Process Event Summary 6.Presentation Page 7 Item 1. 2023-2024 Budget Engagement Summary Community Engagement Strategy: Engagement for the 2023-2024 budget built off of similar efforts for the 2021 and 2022 one-year budgets, and evolved to reflect best practices and lessons learned from other successful engagement efforts. The OurCity webpage offered a variety of feedback opportunities based on time and interest, on-demand learning, and self-service tools. In addition, this year the City partnered with CSU’s Center for Public Deliberation to host community-led conversations about budget priorities and a budget workshop focused on funding tradeoffs. Methods:  Animated Budget 101 videos in English/Spanish  Budget Workshop in partnership with the Center for Public Deliberation  OurCity project page with online engagement activities in both English/Spanish  Website and social media promotion  Public Hearings  Community Survey Participation:  OurCity: o 1,600 total page visits o 1,100 aware visitors, 599 informed visitors, 151 engaged o 128 survey responses o 118 ideas submitted  Social Media: o Facebook 24,000 impressions o Twitter 1,000 impressions o YouTube 3,400 views Feedback Summary - What we Heard: Survey Results: For each of the categories below, please select whether you think the City should invest more funding, the same amount, or less funding in 2023-2024. Outcome Area More Funding Same Level Less Funding Economic Health 36% 60% 4% Environmental Health 63% 27% 10% Neighborhood Livability & Social Health 47% 41% 12% Safe Community 20% 58% 22% Culture & Recreation 38% 60% 2% Transportation & Mobility 48% 45% 7% High Performing Government 10% 70% 20% Page 8 Item 1. OurCity Themes: Below are the most common theme areas for increased focus or funding, by Outcome Area.  Economic Health: childcare, education and workforce training  Environmental Health: air quality, water quality and river health, land conservation, climate  Neighborhood Livability & Social Health: affordable and attainable housing, homelessness services, poverty, U+2 and neighborhood quality  Safe Community: mental health, social services and co-responder program; park and trail safety; neighborhood safety re: homelessness; general policing and crime rates  Culture & Recreation: maintenance, infrastructure and asset management; local performing arts support; natural areas safety, maintenance and restoration  Transportation & Mobility: bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure and safety, increased and more effective transit, especially regionally  High Performing Government: staff pay, inflation and cost of living, especially for lower-wage workers; Council pay; cybersecurity; Equity Office staffing and programming Community Survey:  Top 3 outcome areas to be prioritized: o Environmental Health o Neighborhood Livability & Social Health o Transportation  Which outcomes should have more funding/effort o Environmental Health (64%) o Neighborhood Livability & Social Health (62%) o Transportation (51%)  Open question – top 3 themes (what’s the most important thing the City should be focusing on and why) o Affordable housing o Environmental issues o Growth and development issues Full Community Survey results memo from Sept. 6, 2022: https://records.fcgov.com/CouncilCorr/DocView.aspx?id=15545838&dbid=0&repo=FortCollins&searchid=6f047de3- 2414-4292-9cca-28d8b2522113 Attachments:  Letters to City Council  Full text submitted comments Page 9 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] Please support wildlife health and rehabilitation in the 2022 city budget Date:Wednesday, August 24, 2022 5:10:13 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Mariah McCulley <Mariah.McCulley@savinganimalstoday.org> Sent: Sunday, August 21, 2022 6:19 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Please support wildlife health and rehabilitation in the 2022 city budget Hello Fort Collins Leaders! I am writing today to ask that you prioritize and support local wildlife rehabilitation teams within the city’s 2022 budget. Our local licensed wildlife rehabilitation teams need the city’s support when it comes to supporting efforts to protect the biodiversity that makes our community beautiful! Thank you! -- Mariah McCulley Director of Operations Pronouns: she/her/hers Office Hours: Monday - Friday Direct: (970) 484-8516 Ext. 1114 mariah.mcculley@savinganimalstoday.org Mulberry Campus: 2321 E. Mulberry St. #1 Taft Hill Campus: 2200 N. Taft Hill Rd. Fort Collins, CO 80524 Main Line: (970) 484-8516 SavingAnimalsToday.org Page 10 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Chad Peeples; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Please support wildlife health and rehabilitation in the 2022 city budget Date:Wednesday, August 24, 2022 5:09:08 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Chad Peeples <chadpeeples91@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2022 2:00 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Please support wildlife health and rehabilitation in the 2022 city budget Hello Fort Collins Leaders! I am writing today to ask that you prioritize and support local wildlife rehabilitation teams within the city’s 2022 budget. Our local licensed wildlife rehabilitation teams need the city’s support when it comes to supporting efforts to protect the biodiversity that makes our community beautiful! The Northern Colorado Wildlife Center has helped thousands animals over few years running on donation alone. Finding room in the city budget would go a long way and save thousands of lives. Thank you! Page 11 Item 1. From:Lawrence Pollack To:Kelly DiMartino; Rupa Venkatesh; Amanda King Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Wednesday, August 31, 2022 1:59:58 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Litzinia Calva <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 1:25 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Litzinia Calva calvamel@colostate.edu 400 hickory st lot 55 Fort Collins , Colorado 80524 Page 12 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:keilly@coloradoimmigrant.org Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 1:30:48 PM From: Keilly Leon <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 2:39 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado Page 13 Item 1. las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Keilly Leon keilly@coloradoimmigrant.org 900 Constitution Ave Apt E50 Fort Collins, Colorado 80521 Page 14 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:hleon1314@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 1:53:36 PM From: Helen Leon <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 2:51 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Helen Leon hleon1314@gmail.com 261 Butler Ct. Longmont , Colorado 80504 Page 15 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:jessica.dyrdahl@colostate.edu Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 1:55:04 PM From: Jessica Dyrdahl <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 3:14 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Jessica Dyrdahl jessica.dyrdahl@colostate.edu 2828 Silverplume Drive, S 6 Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 16 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:dhayhow@bajabb.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:19:52 PM From: Debbie Hayhow <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 7:39 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF Fort Collins City Council, Dear Fort Collins City Council Members, As an almost 50 year resident of Fort Collins and Laporte, I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Sincerely, Debbie Hayhow Debbie Hayhow dhayhow@bajabb.com 3320 BUCKSKIN TRL LAPORTE, Colorado 80535-9313 Page 17 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:flennikenmarianne@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:21:44 PM From: Marianne Flenniken <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 8:18 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado Page 18 Item 1. las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Marianne Flenniken flennikenmarianne@gmail.com 3512 Buckskin Trail Laporte, Colorado 80535 Page 19 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:shaleenmorales@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:25:36 PM From: Shaleen morales <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 12:22 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Shaleen morales shaleenmorales@gmail.com 1325 Madison St Apt 3 Denver, Colorado 80218 Page 20 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:ahoeven@hoeveninc.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:26:41 PM From: Amy Marie Hoeven <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 1:15 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Page 21 Item 1. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Amy Marie Hoeven ahoeven@hoeveninc.com 2101 Stover Street Fort Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 22 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:bethadehaven@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Please Add Immigration LDF to City Budget Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:27:15 PM From: Beth DeHaven <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 2:57 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Please Add Immigration LDF to City Budget Fort Collins City Council, I am writing to urge you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023-2024 budget, making this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum going to obtain the legal status that will allow them to be welcome and productive members of our Fort Collins community. Thank you for taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Beth DeHaven bethadehaven@gmail.com 839 Sunchase Dr. Fort Collins, Colorado 80524-6029 Page 23 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:cjtraveler@msn.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:27:48 PM From: John Bisbee <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 3:56 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Fort Collins City Council, Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! John Bisbee cjtraveler@msn.com 713 Justice Dr Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 24 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:alarcon4444@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:28:29 PM From: Fernanda Alarcon <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 6:49 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Fernanda Alarcon alarcon4444@gmail.com 256 West Prospect Street, Apartment#62 Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 25 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:imperfectmachine33@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:29:38 PM From: Atlas Ojendiz <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 7:58 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Atlas Ojendiz imperfectmachine33@gmail.com 1025 Wakerobin ln. Apt B205 Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 26 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:lmahan78@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Legal Defense Fund Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 2:30:43 PM From: Linda Mahan <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 1, 2022 10:13 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Legal Defense Fund Fort Collins City Council, I appreciate the support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) given by the Council this summer. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's budget. Legal advice is so important to the success of an applicant and makes a big difference in navigating the immigration system. And, it fits with the emphasis of the City in measures around principles of diversity, equity and inclusion. Thank you for considering this request to continue support for legal resources. Linda Mahan lmahan78@gmail.com 708 Birky Pl Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 27 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:andreuyenny@yahoo.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Friday, September 2, 2022 3:05:43 PM From: Yenny Andreu-Vivas <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Friday, September 2, 2022 2:48 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Yenny Andreu-Vivas andreuyenny@yahoo.com 411 S. Court St. #61 Fort Collins, Colorado 80524 Page 28 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, September 5, 2022 6:49:31 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Linda Hamilton <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Saturday, September 3, 2022 11:36 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Linda Hamilton lhamilton229@gmail.com 3650 Full Moon Dr Page 29 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Date:Monday, September 5, 2022 6:49:36 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Linn Zink <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Saturday, September 3, 2022 9:45 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Fort Collins City Council, Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Through my own church and partnership through ISAAC, I and others I know are committed to helping supplement the city funds so that all immigrants here will have access to legal defense resources when needed. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Linn Zink lczink@gmail.com 3500 Swanstone Dr., Unit 42 Fort Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 30 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, September 5, 2022 6:49:41 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Joshua Crosslin <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 5, 2022 10:02 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, I personally know families who have legitimate rights and needs to be in the USA, and in Fort Collins in particular, who would not be able to afford the legal counsel they need on their own. Aside from the numbers, these families have unique stories and deserve the chance to stay and move forward together with legitimate legal status. For the families I know, a few meetings with an attorney and help with paperwork and filing fees can mean the difference between families staying together or being forced apart. I encourage you to increase the support for legal services available through the Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund. The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Joshua Crosslin joshua.crosslin@gmail.com 3016 Ringneck Dr Fort Collins, Colorado 80526 Page 31 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Blaragon@msn.com; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts Date:Monday, September 5, 2022 7:47:15 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Betty Aragon-Mitotes <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 6:07 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts Fort Collins City Council, (The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Betty Aragon-Mitotes Blaragon@msn.com 3375 Woodlands Way WELLINGTON, Colorado 80549 Page 32 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Yuvigv30@colostate.edu; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Monday, September 5, 2022 7:48:42 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Yuvi Gonzalez <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, August 31, 2022 2:39 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Page 33 Item 1. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Yuvi Gonzalez Yuvigv30@colostate.edu 2025 N College Ave Lot 74 FORT COLLINS, Colorado 80524 Page 34 Item 1. Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Park Shop 413 S. Bryan Avenue Fort Collins, Colorado Mayor Arndt, Mayor Pro Tem Francis, Councilmembers Gutowsky, Pignataro, Canonico, Peel, and Ohlson: The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board offers the following guidance for the prioritization of the Parks and Recreation Budget Offers for the 2023-2024 budget: These prioritized offers align with multiple Council Priorities, especially: • 27 – Access funding for parks, • 28 – Improve tree policies, • 25 – Affordable, Quality, and Accessible Childcare Infrastructure, and • 30 – Implementation of the 15-minute community concept. These offers are also directly aligned to the 2022 Strategic Plan’s recommendations for Culture & Recreation, the comprehensive Parks and Recreation Master Plan, and the City Park Central Core Master Plan. 60.4 Master Planning Existing Parks 60.6 9/11 Memorial at Spring Park 60.5 Traverse Park Community Garden 60.7 Traverse Park Community Garden 43.24 2.0 FTE Hourly conversion to classified certified childcare staff 43.25 2.0 FTE Hourly conversion to classified Recreation Specialists 43.26 3.0 FTE Classified Building Attendants 43.28 Customer Data Base and Registration Software Upgrade 59.44 Contractual Pruning of Large Diameter Trees 54.9 3.0 FTE Worker I, Parks and Trails Expansion 54.10 1.0 FTE Park Technician for Playground Maintenance 58.2 3.0 FTE New Streetscapes Maintenance 54.6 Rolland Moore Park Infrastructure Replacement 54.7 Parks Hard Surface Trails Infrastructure Replacement 54.8 Parks Landscape Conversion and Irrigation Infrastructure Replacement 54.12 Wallenberg Spur Trail-Pedestrian Bridge Replacement Partnership 54.13 Parks Accessibility Improvements Page 35 Item 1. Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Park Shop 413 S. Bryan Avenue Fort Collins, Colorado As a Board we encourage an emphasis on maintaining existing Park assets and investing in the Infrastructure Replacement Program (offers 59.44, 54.9, 54.10, 58.2, 54.6, 54.7, 54.8, 54.12, and 54.14). Offers 54.6, 54.7, 54.8, 54.12, and 54.14 direct funding to long-overdue infrastructure replacements at Rolland Moore Park, maintenance of trail surfaces, irrigation equipment, and landscape conversion, and enable accessibility improvements throughout all our City parks. The longer these particular cans are kicked down the road, the more unsafe conditions may become, and the more urgent and expensive repairs and maintenance will be. Offers 54.9, 54.10, and 58.2 help fund parks workers (including a playground maintenance technician and streetscape maintenance workers). As we have seen at Crescent Park, Rossborough Park, and other neighborhood parks, neighbors are willing to work side-by-side with Parks staff to help offset issues resulting from decreased staffing, but without the investment on behalf of the City, their efforts will be hindered by larger and larger needs that will quickly exceed the reach of local volunteer efforts. The City must maintain its growing list of assets and fund the replacement of those assets that are at the end of their useful life, especially as our City grows while more neighbors are utilizing the same assets, and neighbors must increasingly commute to their recreational amenities of choice. Similarly, we cannot understate the importance of appropriate staffing levels to keep normal and safe operations at our Recreation facilities. Offers 43.24, 43.25, and 43.26 are direct requests for increased staffing with that goal in mind. The Board also lends our support to the chorus of voices asking for the City of Fort Collins to raise the minimum wage for municipal jobs to $15 per hour. Put simply, at the wages the City is currently offering, we are not competitive with the private sector in the community. Offer 43.28 to acquire a contemporary Customer Database and Registration Application is the single- largest contribution the Parks and Recreation Department can make to the City to help achieve Council Priority 25 – Affordable, Quality, and Accessible Childcare Infrastructure. Funding this offer will drastically improve the user experience for both neighbors and staff, give Parks & Recreation insight into the demographics of the users while also making the data loading process easier. This offer directly removes systemic equity barriers to the registration process for neighbors in young family, low-income, or minority populations who have only a cell phone who cannot currently register using those devices, and highlight opportunities to bring a more diverse and representative neighbor base into our recreation programs. Page 36 Item 1. Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Park Shop 413 S. Bryan Avenue Fort Collins, Colorado This software will be used for all Recreator enrollments as well as field and shelter reservations for Parks, replacing two systems and will save the Parks and Recreation departments hours upon hours of staff time and our neighbors a lot of frustration and wasted effort. We believe this offer would pay for itself very quickly based on the investment of staff time on maintaining and training on the overly- difficult RecTrack software. Finally, with an eye to the future, we would also highlight offers 60.4, 60.6, 60.5, and 60.7. Offer 60.4 enables the Parks Planning Department to get ahead of the Infrastructure Replacement Plan and future refresh efforts through framework plan development at existing parks, a key recommendation of the Parks & Recreation Plan. Offers 60.5 and 60.7 place a key amenity identified in the Parks and Recreation Plan, a community garden, in Traverse Park. Offer 60.9 dedicates timely and necessary general fund supplementation to the 9/11 memorial at Spring Park, without which the project will likely fail. As you are making decisions on the 2023-2024 budget, please consider these recommended budget offers. Thank you, The Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Page 37 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:mgoehring@rmian.org Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Wednesday, September 7, 2022 10:05:18 AM From: Mekela Goehring <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Tuesday, September 6, 2022 2:20 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Page 38 Item 1. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Mekela Goehring mgoehring@rmian.org 7301 Federal Blvd., Suite 300 Westminster, Colorado 80030 Page 39 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:alyssarespo@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Wednesday, September 7, 2022 10:06:04 AM From: Alyssa Esposito <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Tuesday, September 6, 2022 7:45 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Alyssa Esposito alyssarespo@gmail.com 1610 Westbridge Drive, k63 FORT COLLINS, Colorado 80526 Page 40 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:terezagonzales33@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Wednesday, September 7, 2022 3:20:11 PM From: Tere González <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Wednesday, September 7, 2022 2:18 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Tere González terezagonzales33@gmail.com 400 hichory st lot 146, St lot 146 Fort collins, Colorado 80524 Page 41 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:jessicaoneal34@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Date:Friday, September 9, 2022 12:25:37 PM From: Jessie O'Neal <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Friday, September 9, 2022 11:01 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Fort Collins City Council, Good afternoon, Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for your consideration in taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need and deserve! Jessie O'Neal Jessie O'Neal jessicaoneal34@gmail.com 2818 Alan St Fort Collins, Colorado 80524 Page 42 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:Mark Kempton Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Budget feedback on offer 25.20 College and Trilby Date:Friday, September 9, 2022 5:04:20 PM From: Mark Kempton <marklkempton@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, September 9, 2022 4:38 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Budget feedback on offer 25.20 College and Trilby Hello Council Members, I was hoping that during the 2023/24 budget process that you could have the BFO team explain why the College/Trilby intersection improvements are ranked as unfunded. This intersection is in dire need of an upgrade. The half to three quarter mile traffic backups, the high accident rate, and the large amount of proposed development in the vicinity require urgent upgrades to the road. Please reconsider the non funding of this intersection and fund it for immediate improvement. City staff have been continuously messaging that the intersection will be improved next year and according to the recommended budget, there will be no improvements. Thanks Mark Kempton -- Mark Kempton Page 43 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:jenn.leijabonnart@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Monday, September 12, 2022 8:03:33 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Jennifer Leija-Bonnart <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 12, 2022 7:56 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Jennifer Leija-Bonnart jenn.leijabonnart@gmail.com 506 Peterson Street Fort Collins, Colorado 80524 Page 44 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:michael.lee.humphrey@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts Date:Monday, September 12, 2022 8:04:01 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Michael Humphrey <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, September 11, 2022 9:48 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts Fort Collins City Council, The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** This council is exciting, because you are aware of these needs and you have been brave in addressing pressing issues often left unseen in broad society. I hope this is another example of that vision. Mike Michael Humphrey michael.lee.humphrey@gmail.com 2621 Rigden Parkway, #H3 Fort Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 45 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:James Burtis; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Funding for West Elizabeth Enhanced Travel Corridor Date:Monday, September 12, 2022 8:05:47 AM Attachments:image001.png From: James Burtis <burtis.james@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, September 9, 2022 7:48 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Funding for West Elizabeth Enhanced Travel Corridor Dear Mayor Arndt, City Council Members, and Ms. DiMartino, My name is James Burtis and it has recently come to my attention that the current draft of the city budget put forward by our city manager does not recommend funding the full design of the West Elizabeth Enhanced Travel Corridor. I am contacting you to ask that you consider funding this project. The West Elizabeth corridor is one of the highest density areas in Fort Collins. It is also populated largely by students and middle class workers. Bus routes that move along this corridor currently have some of the highest ridership in the city. In addition to moving students and workers to and from CSU and improving multi-modal options, the BRT route in this plan would connect directly to the MAX. This would directly connect two of the city's highest density areas (Elizabeth and Old Town) and also connect both to the businesses along South College. I realize that the $2.5 million requested is a substantial investment, but strongly believe that it supports strategic outcomes (1.5, 4.1, 4.2, 6.1, 6.2, 6.3, 7.1) as outlined in the 2022 strategic plan. Timing is also critical, as the completion of the full design for this project will make it eligible for federal funding. Given the increase in funding temporarily available from the recent passage of the infrastructure and climate bills, this project should be prioritized, so that designs can be ready to apply for the new lines of funding created by these laws. It is possible that by 2025, when the next budget is drafted, it will be too late to take advantage of this new transportation funding. If our city truly wishes to hit our stated climate, community, and equity goals, we must invest in high quality public and multi-modal transportation options. I therefore strongly believe you should push to fund this project in 2023 as you consider revisions to the city manager's current draft of the budget. Thank you for your time and consideration, -James Burtis Page 46 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] Budget "23-"24: Request to fund three currently unfunded items Date:Tuesday, September 13, 2022 8:39:16 PM Attachments:image001.png Greetings, City Leaders! As you review the City budget for 2023-2024, I hope you will consider funding the following budget item requests. Their impact on equity and resilience is significant. Neighborhood Livability and Social Health: 24.6: ARPA Neighborhood-Led Resilience Programs & Projects: This program would be quite beneficial to historically underrepresented populations and communities, leading to a sense of empowerment and belonging for people who often feel marginalized, even within our very progressive city. Programs and projects such as this give a voice to people who often don't feel heard, or don't feel they have the right to be heard due to life experiences. By helping such residents envision and realize their best communities, we help not only these residents but our Fort Collins community as a whole. 24.12: Mobile Home Park Code Compliance Program: Code compliance within manufactured home parks currently involves much of the onus being placed on park residents to initiate complaints in a much more time-consuming fashion than for "regular" homes/neighborhoods. In addition, at least in our park, complaints over years to management about hazardous driveways/sidewalks went unresolved for the most part until a letter-writing campaign by residents to City building inspectors. [Though many of the driveways have been replaced, over a year later there are still a number untouched and hazardous.] Proactive code compliance in MHPs would be beneficial on many levels for residents and management, at little cost to the City. Environmental Health: 1.10 - ARPA - Manufactured Home Efficiency Acceleration Initiative: As I had previously mentioned in my August 19th email to you folks regarding support for this program, this project would help the City's environmental goals, and it will benefit the most vulnerable with higher quality of life and reduction in the risk of home displacement. I appreciate your consideration and service to our community. Thank you! Carol S. Mahoney 2211 W. Mulberry St., Lot 9 Fort Collins, CO 80521 (970) 420-0292 Sent with Proton Mail secure email. Page 47 Item 1. From:Lawrence Pollack To:Seth Stepleton Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: Fund Offer 50.15 Art to Live Date:Thursday, September 15, 2022 12:25:10 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Seth Stepleton <Seth.Stepleton@coloradoearlycolleges.org> Sent: Thursday, September 15, 2022 10:01 AM To: Lawrence Pollack <LPollack@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Fund Offer 50.15 Art to Live Hello! I am reaching out to encourage you to fund 50.15 ARPA Support for Individual Creatives in the Community (Art to Live). This important program would help artists afford housing, give artists the time and space to create, and keep artists in Fort Collins. Our city has so many programs supporting artists and this one is so important to fund the artistic process and turn Fort Collins into a cultural hotspot by supporting the livelihood of artists. We need to address issues in Fort Collins and our communities and this is the way forward for Fort Collins. Warmest regards, Dr. Seth Stepleton (This is a personal email and not endorsed by my school.) Seth E. Stepleton, Ph.D. • High School Science Teacher COLORADO EARLY COLLEGES WINDSOR 7640 Westgate Dr. • Windsor, CO 80528 P: 970-657-2860 ext. 18155 • F: 970-568-8132 seth.stepleton@coloradoearlycolleges.org Clifton Strengths: Intellect | Connectedness | Learner | Input | Relator Page 48 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:evitaem@hotmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, September 19, 2022 11:10:06 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Evangelina Escobar <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, September 18, 2022 2:51 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Evangelina Escobar evitaem@hotmail.com 1108 Robertson st Fort Collins, 80524 Page 49 Item 1. From: Rob Haas <wrobhaas@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, September 19, 2022 10:00 AM To: Shirley Peel <speel@fcgov.com> Cc: Jeni Arndt <jarndt@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Some needed repairs and budget input Hi Shirley, I had hoped to make it to your listening session on Saturday but wasn’t able to make it. I noticed that the city budget process has begun so I thought this would be a good time to reach out. I know most of the focus of the budget is on “big picture” type issues, but I think council needs to also keep their pulse on some of the details of how the city is run. Based on my experiences the city does a good job of managing planned projects, such as regular street paving. However, the city does a poor job of dealing with non-planned repairs. This has been the case for many years, but I’ll cite two current examples. The first is the state of the Spring Creek trail. The attached photo was taken just west of Drake Road, but a similar situation exists just west of Shields street. As you can see in the attached photo, the trail surface jumps up over 1”. It’s been this way for over a year and the city knows because someone has painted it. The second example is the safety railing over the Spring Creek trail tunnel on the west side of Taft Hill Road. This railing was damaged more than a year ago. Again, the photo shows that someone came out and put up a temporary fence. But it’s been so long that the temporary fence now needs repair. I think the vast majority of the community would agree that issues such as these should be fixed quickly. From a budget perspective, I think it’s also a slam dunk. For example, the city recently spent a sizable sum on a new traffic signal at Drake and Hampshire roads, just to improve cycling. The cost/ benefit of this new light is much less than the cost/benefit of taking care the repairs I listed. I think we need to address the underlying cause of these problems. Why is it that the city takes so long to repair problems that we would all like repaired quickly? Is it funding? Maybe, but neither of these issues are terribly expensive to fix. Is it the city’s “work order” process? Maybe. Or lack of productivity among city employees?Maybe, but maybe not. I don’t know, and I’m guessing you don’t know either. And that’s the point. I suggest that council finds out. I’ll leave it up to you and council how best to do that. If you determine that a consultant/auditor needs to be hired than now would be a good time to put some money in the budget for that. Thanks for all of your work on Council. Regards, Rob Haas 970-402-9236 Page 50 Item 1. Page 51 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:Joseph Miranda Cc:Amy Resseguie; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] In support of specific budget items at city council meeting today Date:Tuesday, September 20, 2022 8:41:49 AM From: Joseph Miranda <josephenrymiranda@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 8:33 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] In support of specific budget items at city council meeting today Hello! My name is Joseph Miranda, and I am a resident of Fort Collins. I am sending this email to support the following budget items for todays meeting. Support the legal defense fund more thoroughly! (Neighborhood Livability and Social Health: 24.8 - Immigration Legal Fund) Increase community engagement even more. (High Performing Government: Offer 20.8). This means provide more funding for this are! $30,000 is not enough. Maintain language justice (51.65, 28.6, and 28.9) Break down language barriers in the city. Make budget items and government work easily understandable by our community! Fund offer 50.15 Art to Live! As an artist myself I really think this offer needs support. It will directly impact and improve the lives of artists in our city, continuing to, and helping to aid the improvement of our overall health as a culture in Northern Colorado. Let's support a vibrant, beautiful, and meaningful City of Fort Collins! Thanks for reading, Joseph Miranda 970-310-7619 josephenrymiranda@gmail.com Page 52 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:Sabrina Herrick Cc:Amy Resseguie; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] City budget Date:Tuesday, September 20, 2022 9:48:53 AM From: Sabrina Herrick <sabrinamherrick@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 9:23 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] City budget To whom it may concern, I heard there will be a meeting today about next year's city budget. One thing I am very concerned about is addressing housing in Fort Collins. Housing prices are rising and many people are struggling as a result. I support any and all budget allocations for projects that will make housing more affordable for Fort Collins residents. Additionally, there are many people who are already unhoused in this town who are struggling to find housing. Many are being told that there is a several year wait list to get into affordable housing. In the meantime, they are living on the street and/or in their cars. While these people wait for assistance, they are being chased around town by the cops, getting threatened with tickets for "camping." So they move somewhere else, and then shortly thereafter, the cops turn up and threaten them with another "camping" ticket. Where are they supposed to go? Googling "Fort Collins homeless shelter" doesn't turn up a city run homeless shelter, only faith based non-profits. Additionally, I know from personal experience that one of the 1st 3 results that pops up isn't even a true homeless shelter, just a place that provides pamphlets and showers, and doesn't complain too much if people sit on their sidewalk at all hours. The city and our society in general are failing these people on so many levels and it is shameful. I support all budget allocations that will get unhoused people into housing. I do NOT support budget allocations that harass unhoused people for needing support that the city is not adequately providing. Thank you for your time, Sabrina Herrick 1001 Emigh st #208 Fort Collins, CO 80524 Page 53 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Sophia Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Regarding the meeting about next year"s city budget Date:Tuesday, September 20, 2022 3:28:27 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Sophia <sparmenphoto@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 2:34 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Regarding the meeting about next year's city budget To whom it may concern, One thing I am very concerned about is addressing housing in Fort Collins. Housing prices are rising and many people are struggling as a result. I support any and all budget allocations for projects that will make housing more affordable for Fort Collins residents. Additionally, there are many people who are already unhoused in this town who are struggling to find housing. Many are being told that there is a several year wait list to get into affordable housing. In the meantime, they are living on the street and/or in their cars. While these people wait for assistance, they are being chased around town by the cops, getting threatened with tickets for "camping." So they move somewhere else, and then shortly thereafter, the cops turn up and threaten them with another "camping" ticket. Where are they supposed to go? Googling "Fort Collins homeless shelter" doesn't turn up a city run homeless shelter, only faith based non-profits. Additionally, I know from personal experience that one of the 1st 3 results that pops up isn't even a true homeless shelter, just a place that provides pamphlets and showers, and doesn't complain too much if people sit on their sidewalk at all hours. The city and our society in general are failing these people on so many levels and it is shameful. I support all budget allocations that will get unhoused people into housing. I do NOT support budget allocations that harass unhoused people for needing support that the city is not adequately providing. Thank you for your time, Sophia Parmenter 918 Vanderbilt CT Ft Collins Page 54 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:Torin Kaletsky Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Budget Feedback Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 10:54:03 AM From: Torin Kaletsky <tkaletsky@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 6:55 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Budget Feedback Good evening Mayor and Council: Please find below my notes, which relate to the budget discussion. Thank you for not funding: 13.12 14 police officers NOT Funded 13.23 District One Office Buildout NOT Funded 13.37 Portable radios NOT Funded Thank you for funding: 24.3 mediation and restorative justice Funded 24.7 ARPA eviction legal fund Funded 31.1 Social Sustainability Leadership / Housing & Homelessness / Community Support Funded 31.2 Social Sustainability Leadership and Funding for Human Services & Affordable Housing Funded 31.3 Homelessness Initiatives/Programs Ongoing City Support Funded 31.4 Affordable Housing Capital Fund Funded 31.11 Homelessness Initiatives & Programs Increase Funded 31.12 ARPA - Homelessness Initiatives - Recovery & Stabilization Funded 31.13 ARPA - 1.0 FTE - Contractual Social Sustainability Recovery Specialist Funded 31.20 ARPA - Affordable Housing Land Bank Expansion Funded The following items I ask that you please reconsider: 13.42 4 police officers Funded - Since the police are achieving their self-published goals and since they are already having trouble filling vacant positions, I do not feel it necessary to increase the size of their workforce. 24.8 immigration legal fund NOT Funded - This item has the possibility to make Fort Collins a more welcoming place for our neighbors, and I think we should do everything we can to make that happen and make this city truly world class. 31.14 1.0 FTE - Affordable Housing Specialist NOT Funded 31.19 ARPA - Expansion of the Affordable Housing Fund NOT Funded 31.21 ARPA - Affordable Housing Fee Credit Fund NOT Funded 31.22 ARPA - Affordable Housing Utilities Fee Relief Program NOT Funded The above items will make this city more affordable at a time when affordability is absolutely critical for our community. Thank you, and best of luck in finalizing the budget. Cheers, Torin Kaletsky He him District 3 Page 55 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Michele Pullaro Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Flowers in Down Town Fort Collins Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 12:48:54 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Michele Pullaro <mmpullaro@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 10:50 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Flowers in Down Town Fort Collins Hello, I have watched the City Council meeting video that was held september 13. 2022. I am a Small Business Owner in DownTown Fort Collins. My store is: Peacock's Perch at 162 S. College Avenue. I am located on the corner of Oak and College on the Northeast corner. I would like to share my thoughts with you regarding funding of the flowers. My customers come from all over Colorado and neighboring states like Wyoming, Nebraska, and Kansas specifically to visit our downtown. They frequently comment that our downtown is not like any other downtowns that they have been to. They also frequently comment on how clean our city is and how much we care about the aesthetics. Which makes it a pleasure for them to visit. However, the crime rate has been increasing and I am concerned that if the flowers in downtown are not at least maintained then our businesses and livelihoods will be impacted because the appearance of the area will resemble the crime activity. It might seem like a far reach to equate flowers with crime prevalence. But, downtown is the "face" of Fort Collins and we should represent the good that we have to offer. The importance of presentation should not be underrated or ignored. I fully support funding of the flowers. The flowers are a symbol of downtown and our thriving community. They indicate to visitors that they have arrived in the heart of Fort Collins. Thank you for your time and consideration. -- Michele Pullaro Page 56 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Julia Houx Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] downtown flowers Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:30:37 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Julia Houx <julia@stpetes.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 1:48 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] downtown flowers Hello, I am writing this to express my support for continuing to fund the flowers downtown. It is something that truly enriches the downtown experience. We have countless comments from visitors at how wonderful the flowers are. They are beautiful, enjoyed by all, and keep folks employed. We hope we will continue to enjoy the flowers for years to come :) Julia Houx St. Peter's Fly Shop www.stpetes.com Old Town - 970-498-8968 South - 970-377-3785 Page 57 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Christie Rogers Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Fully find Downtown Flowers Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:31:51 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Christie Rogers <christie.alpine@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 2:49 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Fully find Downtown Flowers City leaders, as a long-standing downtown retailer I ask you to please fully fund the Downtown flowers in next year‘s budget. I get hundreds of comments on the flowers in Old Town from my customers, both local and visitors. There are many other ways I can think of to shave the budget and I am always one to support less government spending. But I ask that the flowers are maintained at the same level next year as they were so wonderfully this year. Thank you!-- Christie Rogers Alpine Arts- The Colorado Showcase 112 N. College Avenue Fort Collins, CO 80524 Page 58 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Brittany Engert Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Fund Art to Live - Offer 50.15 Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:33:28 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Brittany Engert <brittanyengert@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:10 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Fund Art to Live - Offer 50.15 Hello, My name is Brittany Engert and I am writing to you to ask you support Offer 50.15 - Art to Live in the City Budget for 2023-2024. The reason I believe this program is so important is because it helps to make existing housing affordable, gives artists time to create, and keeps artists here in our community. Please fund this program so we can make Fort Collins a cultural hotspot and support the livelihood of artists. I want to see new programs available to address issues in our community. Art to Live is what I want for Fort Collins. Thank you. Sincerely, Brittany Engert Brittany Engert, M.A. Pronouns: She | Her | Hers Academic Success Coordinator, Colorado State University (315)315) 867 Page 59 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Carol Cochran Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Reimagining the downtown (and other) flower displays Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:45:01 PM From: Carol Cochran <hicarolco@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:36 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Reimagining the downtown (and other) flower displays Hello, City Leaders, No doubt the Downtown flowers are stunning and impactful. I think it would be quite wise and forward-thinking for us to move forward in 2023 and beyond with more drought-tolerant perennials (which can also be stunning) and absolutely set the bar for what landscaping and decorating with those types of plants can be. I spent about 20 minutes trying to find the line-item in the proposed City budget for the flowers, to no avail. I’m not sure changing them out for low-water perennials in an equivalent abundance would be much cheaper, at least initially. I just think Fort Collins could and should lead the way on what a more water-responsible landscaping can look like, encouraging residents and visitors alike to reconsider how beautiful a lower-water, less intensively groomed display can be. Show us and all our visitors what we can do! Inspire us. Many drought-tolerant perennials will survive all but the coldest of winters in above-ground planters, too, and come back in future years with vigor and with showier blooms. If you were to set your talented groundspeople loose to tackle the best displays of low-water-use plants and flowers, I think what they come up with has the potential to be even more impressive than the current displays and might lead the way for other communities facing water and personnel shortages to beautify their cities with less — less water, less tending, and fewer people-hours. Thanks for considering moving in this direction with future disbursements to the Parks & Rec department for “flower” displays. Cheers, Carol Cochran (District 1) Page 60 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Heather Trantham Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: Downtown Flowers Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 5:05:11 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Heather Trantham <heather@coppermuse.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 12:35 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flowers Hello, I watched the city council meeting discussion about the flower displays in Old Town. I appreciated some of the commentary, but I also felt that some aspects of the conversation were lacking. 1. Unless you are a horticulturist, I don’t think you can make a determination about whether a plant is tropical or not. The fact that the species of plants that are planted downtown survive from spring to fall in an arid climate lead me to believe that these plants are not tropical. 2. I want to be a good climate steward, and I am willing to replace my lawn and use less water. But, isn’t it nice to have some places in the city that have expanses of grass (parks) and beautiful flower displays that can be enjoyed by everyone even if they can’t plant bluegrass at home? 3. The flowers downtown are a destination themselves. Many people come to downtown to enjoy the scenery as much as to dine and shop, and I think that this leads to more dining and shopping. 4. There needs to be a better understanding about how much of the budget is delegated to the actual plants, how much to water, how much to labor. Are we overstaffed? What percentage of the water that the city uses for all parks, parkways, other flower displays, etc. is the water for the downtown flowers? I think there needs to be a more educated discussion (based in fact, not personal interpretation) before the budget for the downtown flowers is cut. And, please involve the city’s horticulturist in the discussion about which plants are planted. Best regards, Heather Trantham, PE, PhD Owner CopperMuse distillery 244 N. College Suite 105 Fort Collins, CO 80524 Page 61 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Alan Jantzen Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: Downtown Flower Funding Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 5:09:42 PM Attachments:image002.png image003.png From: Alan Jantzen <alan@silvergrill.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 3:43 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding As you all know – our downtown is the most iconic part of our beautiful city. Citizens who live here, people who visit here all come to see our beautiful downtown. The Parks department over the years have raised the bar for all other cities! Keeping the downtown vibrant is key to our success as business owners which in turn furthers the success of our city. Over the years we have lost so much of the energy of our downtown – parades, concerts, events. The businesses downtown have rallied to keep up our services to stay competitive. Why would you even consider dropping flowers? The energy and tax basis we provide far outweighs this expense. There are far more important things which need to be debated that keeping our city in colorful flowers. Please don’t take this away from our beautiful downtown. Alan Jantzen 970.430.4324 Alan@Silvergrill.com Page 62 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Rob Haas; Melanie Clark Cc:Shirley Peel; Jeni Arndt; Kelly DiMartino; SAR Admin Team; CAO Senior Staff; Mike Calhoon; Seve Ghose; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Re: Response to: Some needed repairs and budget input (Council SAR#70051 Date:Wednesday, September 21, 2022 10:07:23 PM Attachments:image001.png Good evening, Rob – Thank you for your follow-up comments regarding budget prioritization. They have been noted and we appreciate your engagement. In addition, the City of Fort Collins has partnered with CSU’s Center for Public Deliberation to host a community wide conversation on the 2023-2024 budget. The event takes place on September 28th from 6-8pm at the Fort Collins Senior Center (1200 Raintree Drive). Spanish translation and interpretation available. Dinner will be provided and there is limited space so please register here if you would like to attend. Thanks in advance, Rupa Rupa Venkatesh Assistant City Manager City of Fort Collins, CO 970.221.6684 office 561.289.6176 cell From: Rob Haas <wrobhaas@yahoo.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 1:40 PM To: Melanie Clark <MCLARK@fcgov.com> Cc: Shirley Peel <speel@fcgov.com>; Jeni Arndt <jarndt@fcgov.com>; Kelly DiMartino <KDIMARTINO@fcgov.com>; SAR Admin Team <SAR-Admin-Team@fcgov.com>; CAO Senior Staff <CAOSeniorStaff@fcgov.com>; Mike Calhoon <MCALHOON@fcgov.com>; Seve Ghose <sghose@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: Response to: Some needed repairs and budget input (Council SAR#70051 Melanie and Mike, Thanks for your response. Page 63 Item 1. Shirley & Jeni, My input to this years budget process is that repairs such as these shouldn’t take over three months and should be given a priority. Perhaps that means spending a little extra money. So I would support moving funding from routine (and sometimes pre-mature) sidewalk replacements to projects such as these. Thanks, Rob On Sep 20, 2022, at 12:07 PM, Melanie Clark <MCLARK@fcgov.com> wrote: Dear Rob Haas, Thank you for your email regarding trail repairs. Please see the below information provided by Director of Parks, Mike Calhoon on behalf of Councilmember Shirley Peel and City Manager, Kelly DiMartino. Best, Melanie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MELANIE CLARK Executive Administrative Assistant City Manager’s Office City of Fort Collins 300 Laporte Ave 970-416-4312 office mclark@fcgov.com <image001.png> From: accessfortcollins=fcgov.com@mg.comcate.com accessfortcollins=fcgov.com@m g.comcate.com On Behalf Of Mike Calhoon Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 11:44 AM To: Melanie Clark MCLARK@fcgov.com Subject: [EXTERNAL] New notes have been added to case #70051 Hello Rob, Staff have been actively working on getting both the issues repaired / replaced with contractors, but have experienced delays with completion. The sections of trail that are heaving along the Spring Creek Trail west of Drake Road Page 64 Item 1. and also west of Shields Street have been marked, identified, and mapped with a trail grinding contractor. We typically develop a list of work that will meet the minimum work requirement for the contractor to report on-site (about once a year). We do mark the locations of heaving trail with orange paint until they are ground down. The underpass railing along the Spring Creek Trail at Taft Hill Road was significantly damaged by a car accident last year. The decorative rail is part of an Art in Public Places installation, and required specific coordination with that Department. The good news is that the concrete footer has been repaired earlier this year, and the bridge railing fabrication is complete. The railing is currently at a bronze foundry getting the Art in Public Places components added to the rail. Staff has checked back in with both the trail grinding contractor and metal fabricator about completing these issues along the trails with limited success. I understand the frustration from community members, and will continue to pursue completion in a more timely manner with the contractors and other departments. Please let me know if you have any further questions. Sincerely, Mike Calhoon Director of Parks Original Request From: Rob Haas wrobhaas@yahoo.com Sent: Monday, September 19, 2022 10:00 AM To: Shirley Peel speel@fcgov.com Cc: Jeni Arndt jarndt@fcgov.com Subject: [EXTERNAL] Some needed repairs and budget input Hi Shirley, I had hoped to make it to your listening session on Saturday but wasn’t able to make it. I noticed that the city budget process has begun so I thought this would be a good time to reach out. I know most of the focus of the budget is on “big picture” type issues, but I think council needs to also keep their pulse on some of the details of how the city is run. Based on my experiences the city does a good job of managing planned projects, such as regular street paving. However, the city does a poor job of dealing with non-planned repairs. This has been the case for many years, but I’ll cite two current examples. The first is the state of the Spring Creek trail. The attached photo was taken just west of Drake Road, but a similar situation exists just west of Shields street. As you can see in the attached photo, the trail surface jumps up over 1”. It’s been this way for over a year and the city knows because someone has painted it. The second example is the safety railing over the Spring Creek trail tunnel on the west side of Taft Hill Road. This railing was damaged more than a year ago. Again, the photo Page 65 Item 1. shows that someone came out and put up a temporary fence. But it’s been so long that the temporary fence now needs repair. I think the vast majority of the community would agree that issues such as these should be fixed quickly. From a budget perspective, I think it’s also a slam dunk. For example, the city recently spent a sizable sum on a new traffic signal at Drake and Hampshire roads, just to improve cycling. The cost/benefit of this new light is much less than the cost/benefit of taking care the repairs I listed. I think we need to address the underlying cause of these problems. Why is it that the city takes so long to repair problems that we would all like repaired quickly? Is it funding? Maybe, but neither of these issues are terribly expensive to fix. Is it the city’s “work order” process? Maybe. Or lack of productivity among city employees? Maybe, but maybe not. I don’t know, and I’m guessing you don’t know either. And that’s the point. I suggest that council finds out. I’ll leave it up to you and council how best to do that. If you determine that a consultant/auditor needs to be hired than now would be a good time to put some money in the budget for that. Thanks for all of your work on Council. Regards, Rob Haas 970-402-9236 Page 66 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:jodydeschenes@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Thursday, September 22, 2022 12:57:26 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Jody Deschenes <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2022 12:40 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Page 67 Item 1. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Jody Deschenes jodydeschenes@gmail.com po box 123 Ft Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 68 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Small Mountain Tattoo; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower displays Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 9:43:39 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Small Mountain Tattoo <booking@smallmountaintattoo.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 7:06 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower displays To whom this may concern, I am emailing in regards to the City Council work meeting where the possibility of not fully funding the downtown flower displays was discussed. As a business owner on Linden Street, the brand new giant flower areas impacted the design of the renovations. As the flowers are a great enhancement to downtown, it would be a big disappointment for them to be empty. Especially for our newly renovated Linden Street where we had no road for 8 months due to the renovations and some of the main aspects are the new flower beds. Please don't hesitate to let me know if you have any questions. Thank you for your time, Adam Fenner -- 218 Linden St. Fort Collins, CO 970-221-2340 Page 69 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 9:44:06 AM From: deb@garwoodsjewelers.com <deb@garwoodsjewelers.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 7:58 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding I urge you to consider continuing funding the flowers in downtown Fort Collins. They are beautiful each year and add to the atmosphere and overall beauty of our very special downtown. We have a very unique area here due to a combination of many factors - please don't take that away! Debbie Reider Garwood's Jewelers Page 70 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:lam_5225@yahoo.com; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 9:46:26 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Linda A Marquez <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2022 7:21 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I am not a resident of Fort Collins, unfortunately, but I reside in Longmont and do have friends and relatives who do live there. It is so important for the community, state, and country to help those who are pursuing a way to make it better for themselves as well as for the community. Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Page 71 Item 1. Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Linda A Marquez lam_5225@yahoo.com 828 S. Bross St. Longmont , Colorado 80501 Page 72 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Sue Ballou Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] City Budget Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 10:47:57 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Sue Ballou <sueballou@yahoo.com> Sent: Friday, September 23, 2022 9:43 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] City Budget Dear City Leaders, I know that the Budgeting for Outcomes process is arduous and there are many painful decisions to be made about what falls above and below the line. I am writing to advocate for one item that ultimately fell below the line; The expansion of the Mobile Home Park program in Neighborhood Services and an additional staff person was not funded. The people living in mobile home parks are among the most vulnerable in the City as MHP owners find new ways to increase profits at their expense. The work that the City has done so far has been extremely helpful but there's a lot more that can be done as parks defer or ignore maintenance, create unlawful rules, and work to obscure residents' rights. Unlike renters, who can move if the landlord is unjust, mobile home park residents are completely at the mercy of the park owners. Moving a mobile home cost $10,000 or more and many of the homes can't be moved at all. Rent increases and fees are becoming untenable. While additional funding for Neighborhood Services' program can't solve all of these issues, they can provide crucial watchdog and support services for these vulnerable residents. Please move this item above the line. Sincerely, Sue Ballou Sue Ballou she/her/hers sueballou@yahoo.com (970)970) 493-755 (970)970) 310-767 Page 73 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Linda Leonhard; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 11:19:25 AM From: Linda Leonhard <lindaleonhard3@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2022 3:31 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Hi I own Elliot’s Martini bar. I’m happy the construction has come to a close but I’m confused as to why you would install huge planters that you don’t intend to fill with flowers. Can you explain this please. Linda Leonhard Sent from my iPhone Page 74 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] Fully Funding Flowers Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 11:56:17 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Joseph James Streater <jj@oldtownrestaurantgroup.com> Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2022 2:08 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Fully Funding Flowers Dear City Leadership Team, I am aware that the cost of nearly everything has gone up since March of 2020, but there are two foundational items that the public has come to expect from Old Town Fort Collins. Flowers during the Summer and Christmas lights during the holidays. Our streets, alley ways and store fronts are elevated to that of a Choice City standard when the flowers are in full bloom. Don't cut funding in flower department and restrict hours for our Parks and Rec employees. Please continue the dedicated and focused work that is required to keep Old Town the go to destination in Fort Collins. The old town businesses need this commitment from you, and the citizens of Fort Collins expect this from you. JJ Streater Old Town Restaurant Group 334 E Mountain Ave Fort Collins, CO 80524 jj@oldtownrestaurantgroup.com Page 75 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Amy Resseguie Subject:FW: [EXTERNAL] RE: Seasonal Downtown flower display Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 11:58:40 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Holly Wright <holly@wrightlife.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2022 5:57 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] RE: Seasonal Downtown flower display Hello City Council and City Leaders, I would like to comment on the discussion of funding of the Downtown Botanical display and budget concerns with expanding it in the future. After watching the work session on this subject and listening to comments from your meeting I would agree that incorporating perennials and native plants is a smart idea that should result in lower water consumption, lower costs due to plants being viable for multiple years and showing that the City of Fort Collins is committed to water conservation publicly and in our private residences. Thank you for your consideration and hard work on behalf of the citizens of Fort Collins, Holly Wright The Wright Life 200B Linden Street Fort Collins, CO 80524 970-484-6932 holly@wrightlife.com Page 76 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:rreyes9022@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Friday, September 23, 2022 1:51:27 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Richard Reyes <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Friday, September 23, 2022 12:30 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Richard Reyes rreyes9022@gmail.com 1000 Strachan Dr Fort Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 77 Item 1. From:Rupa Venkatesh To:Allie Ogg; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flowers Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 11:46:05 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Allie Ogg <allieogg@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 10:05 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flowers Hello City Council Leaders! I love the downtown flower displays, and I hope that you continue to fund the beautiful displays. The flowers bring so much beauty to our Old Town, it would be sad to see them go. Thank you, Allie Ogg Page 78 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:MARYLEADODD303@GMAIL.COM Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 12:09:02 PM From: MARY LEA DODD <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 12:02 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! Fort Collins City Council, Dear Fort Collins City Council Member, I have watched Alianza's work from its inception when a small group of immigrants and American citizens began having workshops in the basement of Fort Colllins' churches. At these workshops Alianza members helped individuals prepare and submit Colorado Drivers License applications so these folks could get jobs and become productive members of the community. Since then, Alianza has grown in numbers and functions at a rate that has amazed me. Please support this hard working group of people continue their efforts of helping immigrants obtain access to legal representation so they can stay in this country and continue being good tax paying residents. Please support funding the Legal Defense Fund in the 2023-2024 budget. Thank you, Mary Lea Dodd MARY LEA DODD MARYLEADODD303@GMAIL.COM 5633 RIST CANYON ROAD BELLVUE, Colorado 80512 Page 79 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:Diane Findley Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Flower Funding Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 1:09:03 PM From: Diane Findley <dfindley1954@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 12:34 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Flower Funding I know there will never be enough money to do all the wonderful things we have in mind to ensure our status as a first class city. But I do hope there will be enough money to maintain our spectacular flower displays downtown. They bring so much interest and delight to our retail areas. Hardly a day goes by that customers at Trimble Court Artisans don’t comment on how lovely the flowers are. The happier the customers the more sales tax revenue we can pass along. Thanks for listening. I have my fingers crossed. With much appreciation Diane Findley President of Trimble Court Artisans Sent from my iPhone Page 80 Item 1. From:Dawn Kennedy To:arbaiten@hotmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 1:23:08 PM From: Rosa Leon <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 12:42 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Rosa Leon arbaiten@hotmail.com 6988 Pelican Cove Lane Wellington, Colorado 80549 Page 81 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:miy.mahran@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 3:03:12 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Miy Mahran <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 2:57 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Miy Mahran miy.mahran@gmail.com 1001 Logan Ave Bronx, 10465 Page 82 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:adrienne.birt@jacobcenter.org Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget Date:Monday, September 26, 2022 3:56:54 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Adrienne Birt <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 2:03 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget Fort Collins City Council, Hello, Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Adrienne Adrienne Birt adrienne.birt@jacobcenter.org 517 South Bryan Ave. Fort Collins, Colorado 80521 Page 83 Item 1. Indy Hart, Chair Cari Brown, Vice Chair Transportation Board DATE: September 22, 2022 TO: Mayor Arndt and City Councilmembers FROM: Indy Hart, Transportation Board Chair, on behalf of the Transportation Board CC: Kelly DiMartino, City Manager RE: 2023/24 City Manager’s Recommended Budget The Transportation Board has reviewed the 2023/24 City Manager’s Recommended Budget. The goal of the Transportation Board is to promote the implementation of a balanced transportation system that is consistent with the City’s sustainability goals and provides choice, mobility, access, congestion mitigation, and safety for all people. The Transportation Board would therefore like to emphasize their desire for Council to prioritize funding offers which support multi-modal transportation, addresses the climate emergency, and are equitable. The Transportation Board realizes that not all offers, despite their merits, can be funded. However, there are t wo unfunded offers that the Board feels should be considered for funding in the 2023/24 budget: 1. The Transportation Board supports funding offer 51.27, Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) System Upgrades scaled to $275,000 per year, which is in line with prior Council commitments. We feel this is a key initiative to continue the efforts to improve accessibility to everyone in the community. 2. The Transportation Board also supports funding offer 36.9, Neighborhood Traffic Mitigation Program Expansion. We see this offer as an important program to support neighborhoods and slow traffic. This program we feel helps improve conditions for bicycling and walking as well, which is an important part of the City’s multi-modal goals. The Transportation Board also wishes to highlight additional unfunded BFO offers as being priority for funding in the 2023/24 budget, as shown in the table below. BFO # BFO Offer Title Type 51.10 West Elizabeth Enhanced Travel Corridor Full Design 1-Time Enhancement 51.32 North College Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) 100% Design 1-Time Enhancement 27.14 School Transportation Safety Assessments and Strategic Infrastructure for Youth Continuing Enhancement 27.15 1.0 FTE Shift Your Ride Travel Options Program Professional Enhancement 54.7 Parks Hard Surface Trails Infrastructure Replacement: Asset Management - Enhanced Finally, the Transportation Board acknowledges the efforts of the Bicycle Advisory Committee over the past year and supports their budget recommendations as noted in the attached letter. Thank you for your consideration of funding these additional budget offers. Respectfully submitted, C. Indy Hart, Transportation Board Chair Page 84 Item 1. Memorandum To: City of Fort Collins Transportation Board From: Jordan Williams, Chair, City of Fort Collins Bicycle Advisory Committee (BAC) Date: September 21, 2022 Re: BAC Recommendations to support active modes-related BFO offers 2023-24 On behalf of the City of Fort Collins Bicycle Advisory Committee (BAC), I would like to offer our recommendations for several BFO offers put forth for the next budget cycle. The BAC’s overall purpose and mission is to review, recommend, and proactively identify capital improvements, educational initiatives, and Active Modes plan priorities while promoting bicycling, e-bikes, and other active modes as viable forms of transportation within our city and region. With the BAC work plan in mind, we have reviewed the City’s 2023-24 Budget Offers and discussed priority areas as they align with the BAC’s guiding principles. We support all the active modes-oriented offers listed in the budget proposal as they all, either directly or indirectly, enhance safe bicycling and help reduce motorized travel in our community. In addition to pledging support for all the active modes-related BFO offers being considered in this budget cycle, we would like to highlight a few specific offers that that we believe will have particularly significant impacts on the future of safe bicycling, multimodal transportation, and the achievement of the Climate Action Plan goals of the City of Fort Collins. These unfunded offers from the City Manager’s recommended budget are ranked in no particular order: • 27.14 - CONTINUING ENHANCEMENT - School Transportation Safety Assessments and Strategic Infrastructure for Youth: With the success of the original enhancement offer from 2022, continuing this program will help the City meet its Vision Zero goals from an equity-focused perspective that serves youth and other underrepresented communities. • 27.15 - ENHANCEMENT - 1.0 FTE Shift Your Ride Travel Options Program Professional: To reduce traffic and support the city’s climate goals, more people need to utilize active modes of transportation. While funding the Shift Your Ride program (27.13) is helpful, staff need more capacity to implement this initiative in conjunction with other partners such as the North Front Range Metropolitan Planning Organization. • 36.9 - CONTINUING ENHANCEMENT - Neighborhood Traffic Mitigation Program Expansion: The active modes infrastructure included in this offer provides a more complete streets/Vision Zero-friendly opportunity for the City budget to align with its goals surrounding equity and safety. • 54.7 - ASSET MANAGEMENT-ENHANCED - Parks Hard Surface Trails Infrastructure Replacement: As our trails receive increased usage for recreation and transportation, building more connections across our 15-minute communities is important, but we have to take care of the existing infrastructure. The scalability of this program could be helpful for initial implementation in this budget cycle. Thank you for your consideration of the BAC’s recommendations. Signed: Jordan Williams, BAC Chair Page 85 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Anaquiroz326@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Tuesday, September 27, 2022 9:45:17 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Anamaria Gandarilla <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Monday, September 26, 2022 5:11 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Anamaria Gandarilla Anaquiroz326@gmail.com 2036 1st Ave lot 262 Greeley, Colorado 80631 Page 86 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:liamgab82@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Tuesday, September 27, 2022 10:10:35 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Gaby Nunez <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Tuesday, September 27, 2022 9:49 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Gaby Nunez liamgab82@gmail.com 3406 Hampton Dr Fort Collins, Colorado 80525 Page 87 Item 1. Page 88 Item 1. Page 89 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Brian Stahl Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: New aquatics facility in SE FC Date:Wednesday, September 28, 2022 2:44:48 PM Attachments:image002.png image003.png From: Brian Stahl <brian@stahldevelopment.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 28, 2022 7:42 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] New aquatics facility in SE FC Dear City Council: We are significantly “ under pooled “ here in Fort Collins. It is getting worse every day. Please support the concept of a new, quality, 10 lane pool in the proposed SE Recreation Center. From life safety issues to high school swimming practice and events—a new pool will provide so many POSITIVES for our community and help alleviate capacity issues as we continue to grow our city. Thank you for your consideration of all… Brian Stahl Real Estate Investment - Real Estate Development brian@stahldevelopment.com 970-390-9164 Page 90 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Dr. Shaw Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Date:Thursday, September 29, 2022 5:06:26 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Dr. Shaw <dr.shaw@shawfamilypractice.com> Sent: Thursday, September 29, 2022 4:42 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding I absolutely love the downtown flowers. I would love to see them continue. If the budget has to be trimmed okay, but I would love to have them stay. Dr. JoNell Shaw DC, ND Schedule your visit 148 W. Oak Street, Suite C, Fort Collins, Colorado 80524 Phone: (970) 658-1281 Fax: +1 (970) 844-8884 Page 91 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:beathrizmthz13@gmail.com Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Friday, September 30, 2022 9:04:13 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Beatriz Martinez <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Thursday, September 29, 2022 6:28 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Page 92 Item 1. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Beatriz Martinez beathrizmthz13@gmail.com 6500 e 88th ave Henderson , Colorado 80640 Page 93 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Kevin Cross; Jeni Arndt; Susan Gutowsky; Julie Pignataro; Tricia Canonico; Shirley Peel; Kelly Ohlson; Emily Francis Cc:Tyler Marr; Lindsay Ex; Honore Depew; Molly Saylor; Adelle McDaniel; Kendall Minor; John Phelan; Brian Tholl; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] FCSG Statement on the Fort Collins 2023-2023 Recommended Budget Date:Friday, September 30, 2022 10:06:15 AM Attachments:image001.png From: Kevin Cross <jkevin87@comcast.net> Sent: Friday, September 30, 2022 6:20 AM To: Jeni Arndt <jarndt@fcgov.com>; Susan Gutowsky <sgutowsky@fcgov.com>; Julie Pignataro <jpignataro@fcgov.com>; Tricia Canonico <tcanonico@fcgov.com>; Shirley Peel <speel@fcgov.com>; Kelly Ohlson <kohlson@fcgov.com>; Emily Francis <efrancis@fcgov.com> Cc: Kelly DiMartino <KDIMARTINO@fcgov.com>; Tyler Marr <tmarr@fcgov.com>; Lindsay Ex <lex@fcgov.com>; Honore Depew <hdepew@fcgov.com>; Molly Saylor <msaylor@fcgov.com>; Adelle McDaniel <amcdaniel@fcgov.com>; Kendall Minor <kminor@fcgov.com>; John Phelan <JPHELAN@fcgov.com>; Brian Tholl <btholl@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] FCSG Statement on the Fort Collins 2023-2023 Recommended Budget Good morning, Mayor Arndt and Councilmembers Gutowsky, Pignataro, Canonico, Peel, Ohlson, and Francis – I’m sending you FCSG’s statement on the Recommended Budget, which is also available on our website. We are asking you to consider moving three unfunded offers “above the line,”which hold the potential for significantly increasing the amount of funding Ft. Collins mightobtain in the future from the Inflation Reduction Act. These offers are all relatively “small ticket” items and total about 0.05% of the total Recommended Budget. Sincerely, Kevin Cross Convener Fort Collins Sustainability Group P.O. Box 672 Fort Collins, CO 80522 Ph. 970-484-3141 https://focosustainability.org FCSG Statement on the Fort Collins 2023-2023 Recommended Budget Posted on September 30th, 2022 The Fort Collins Sustainability Group (FCSG) has reviewed both the Fort Collins 2023-2024 Recommended Budget and the staff memorandum dated September 8th, 2022 analyzing the impact of the Recommended Budget on the City’s “Our Climate Future” goals. Staff anticipates that the budget offers recommended for funding will reduce community greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions 5.4% from the 2005 baseline. In order to make steady progress to our 2030 goal, we would need to reduce GHG pollution 12% every two years between 2020 and 2030. Therefore, the recommended budget would achieve less than half the necessary reductions for steady progress toward the 2030 goal. Page 94 Item 1. As staff has previously pointed out, not all community GHG emissions reductions can be paid for out of the City budget. We will be interested to see what other initiatives staff believes will help close the gap during the “Our Climate Future” work session scheduled for October 11th. The following three initiatives that have NOT been recommended for funding may offer opportunities for moving more quickly toward the goal of 80% GHG emissions reductions by 2030. They all have an important equity component in addition to an environmental component. We urge Council to consider bringing them “above the line” prior to final budget approval. Offer 1.10: 1.0 FTE Contractual Project Manager & Manufactured Home Efficiency Acceleration Initiative ($376,176 over two years). This offer would help residents of manufactured homes make their homes more energy efficient and healthy, and could provide a springboard to getting more federal government funding for these purposes in future years. Offer 27.9: 1.0 FTE Contractual Planner & Electric Vehicle Readiness Program Funding ($237,538 over two years). This offer could catalyze the rapid adoption of EVs in the City and enable our community to obtain more federal funding in the effort to move away from fossil fuel powered transportation. Offer 27.11: Mobility Innovation Zones Plan ($150,00 in 2023 only). This offer would help identify ways to help people living in low-density areas of the City access transit options other than private cars. It may also identify opportunities for federal funding to pay for these transit options, which could include bicycles, e-bikes, scooters, and shuttle services. An important theme in our expression of support for these three unfunded offers is that they include the potential to uncover opportunities for connecting City residents to significant amounts of federal funding that will become available starting next year through the Inflation Reduction Act. A small investment now – these three offers total less than 0.05% of theRecommended 2023 – 24 budget – could provide big dividends later in terms of reducingour community GHG emissions and promoting public health and equity. Page 95 Item 1. From:Kelly DiMartino To:Joyce DeVaney Cc:City Leaders; Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Please continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund (LDF) Date:Friday, September 30, 2022 3:46:17 PM Attachments:image001.png From: Joyce DeVaney <jdevaney6@comcast.net> Sent: Friday, September 30, 2022 3:24 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Please continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund (LDF) I am grateful that the Fort Collins City Council approved $150,000 for the LDF in July, 2021. This fund has enabled trusted non-profit organizations to offer legal services, due process and dignity to immigrants in Fort Collins. This assistance supports what we all believe in: the fundamental constitutional right to due process and equal access to justice and representation. The LDF has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. We know that immigrants with this kind of legal representation are 10 times more likely to be able to stay in the U.S. Please continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the City's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means that families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Thank you for your consideration of this request and thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! Joyce DeVaney 2842 McKeag Drive Fort Collins, CO 80526 Page 96 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:lulyr22@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:06:35 AM From: Lourdes Ruiz <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 5:36 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Page 97 Item 1. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Lourdes Ruiz lulyr22@gmail.com 2500 E. Harmony Rd. Fort Collins, Colorado 80528 Page 98 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:agomezconst@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:06:08 AM From: Adalberto Gomez <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 4:40 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] DEI Efforts / Esfuerzos para la Diversidad, Equidad e Inclusion Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for supporting Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. s fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. Page 99 Item 1. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Adalberto Gomez agomezconst@gmail.com 835 franklin st Wray , Colorado 80758 Page 100 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:adrianacoronado53@yahoo.es; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:05:44 AM From: Adriana Coronado <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 3:37 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Adriana Coronado adrianacoronado53@yahoo.es 4190 Argonne st Denver , Colorado 80249 Page 101 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:maricruzsigala32@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:05:18 AM From: Maricruz Zapata <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 3:11 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Immigration LDF ~ Fondo para Defensa Legal Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) I would like to ask you to continue funding the Immigration Legal Defense Fund in the 2023- 2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Maricruz Zapata maricruzsigala32@gmail.com 506 E 25 st rd Greeley , Colorado 80631 Page 102 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:poboxalvaro@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:04:41 AM From: Alvaro Acevedo <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 1:12 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses. Page 103 Item 1. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Alvaro Acevedo poboxalvaro@gmail.com 2500 e harmony rd Fort Collins , Colorado 80528 Page 104 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:caceresdixi@gmail.com; City Leaders Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:04:05 AM From: Dixi caceres <info@sg.actionnetwork.org> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 12:57 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Add Immigration LDF to City Budget! ~ Agregue el fondo para Inmigrantes al Presupuesto! Fort Collins City Council, (Sigue en Español) Thank you for your support of a Fort Collins pilot Legal Defense Fund (LDF) on July 6th, 2021. The city's pilot program has laid the foundation for better immigrant integration in our community. Everyone, no matter who they are, should have the opportunity to present their case in a fair and just manner, by having someone who can advocate for their interests. I would like to ask you to continue funding the LDF in the 2023-2024 budget and make this a permanent part of the city's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion efforts this September and October as you solidify the city budget. It is critical that this important work continue without a gap in services. Your immediate support during the creation and approval of the budget will ensure that the trust that the community has developed with the legal service providers continues and that they can keep the momentum moving in the forward direction! The Fort Collins immigrant legal defense fund has given 109 immigrants access to legal representation, increasing their chances to successfully navigate the complex federal immigration system. Having access to a lawyer means families can stay together and ensures Fort Collins residents are guaranteed due process. Immigration proceedings are incredibly complex and difficult to navigate on your own and are the only legal proceeding in the country where someone is detained without the guarantee to a lawyer, even if they are a child or an asylum seeker. Thank you for considering taking this important step to support Fort Collins residents with the legal resources they need! *** Estimados miembros del Consejo, Gracias por su apoyo a un Fondo de Defensa Legal (LDF) experimental que aprobaron en Fort Collins el 6 de julio de 2021. El programa experimental de la ciudad ha sentado las bases para una mejor integración de los inmigrantes en nuestra comunidad. Todos, sin importar quiénes sean, deben tener la oportunidad de presentar su caso de manera justa, teniendo a alguien que pueda defender sus intereses.Page 105 Item 1. Me gustaría pedirle que continúe financiando el LDF en el presupuesto 2023-2024 y que lo convierta en una parte permanente de los esfuerzos de diversidad, equidad e inclusión de la ciudad este septiembre y octubre a medida que solidifica el presupuesto de la ciudad. Es fundamental que este importante trabajo continúe sin interrupciones en los servicios. ¡Su apoyo inmediato durante la creación y aprobación del presupuesto asegurará que la confianza que la comunidad ha desarrollado con los proveedores de servicios legales continúe y que puedan mantener el impulso en la dirección hacia adelante! El fondo de defensa legal de inmigrantes de Fort Collins ha brindado a 109 inmigrantes acceso a representación legal, aumentando sus posibilidades de navegar con éxito el complejo sistema de inmigración federal. Tener acceso a un abogado significa que las familias pueden permanecer juntas y asegura que los residentes de Fort Collins tengan garantizado el debido proceso. Los procedimientos de inmigración son increíblemente complejos y difíciles de realizar por su cuenta y son el único procedimiento legal en el país donde alguien es detenido sin la garantía de un abogado, incluso si es un niño o un solicitante de asilo. ¡Gracias por considerar dar este importante paso para apoyar a los residentes de Fort Collins con los recursos legales que necesitan! Dixi caceres caceresdixi@gmail.com 3100 palm ct4 Fort collins, Colorado 80526 Page 106 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:Janet Johnson; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:10:45 AM From: Janet Johnson <janetjohnson04@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, October 2, 2022 12:52 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Downtown Flower Funding Hello! I recently visited your beautiful city for the first time, and was overwhelmed by its beauty! The flower arrangements along the main street, as well as the plaza area in the historic district, took my breath away. I even sent pictures back to my gardening friends in Minnesota, to provide suggestions for stunning combinations of "Thrill, Fill, & Spill" planters. I heard from my Fort Collins associates that there was a potential for cuts to the floral budget. If the decision is already made, I certainly hope that you held adequate funds to continue providing such a beautiful benefit to your community. Visitors like me, and I suspect residents as well, appreciate and enjoy the multi-sensory experience of nature's beauty. If the budget was indeed reduced, please do the best with what is allotted for next year, and consider increasing (or reinstating) the funds in the future. Thanks for listening, and thanks for your hard work to make Fort Collins a wonderful year-round place to live or visit. Janet Johnson New Hope, MN Page 107 Item 1. From:Shana Salaff To:City Leaders Subject:[EXTERNAL] Funding flowers Date:Sunday, October 2, 2022 7:43:38 PM Hello, I am a 13 year resident of Fort Collins, and every year am filled with joy from the beautiful flower displays. I’m sure that these are expensive, yet I urge the city not to cut back on the budget for them. They are one of the reasons why Fort Collins is a tourist destination, and I suspect that they are paid for in tourism dollars that benefit the citizens of Fort Collins directly. Thank you, Shana Shana Salaff 3519 Stratton Dr, Fort Collins 80525 714-914-3009 www.shanasalaff.com Page 108 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:DAN KINNEY; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: Do Not Reduce Flower Budget Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 8:11:42 AM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . From: DAN KINNEY <kinnflowers@bajabb.com> Sent: Monday, October 3, 2022 6:39 AM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Do Not Reduce Flower Budget Hello. I'm writing to urge that the city budget for our downtown flower displays NOT be reduced in the future. Ft. Collins has become nationally known for its downtown flowers/art and I feel it would be detrimental to diminish either of these outstanding venues. Especially our downtown flowers plantings, which have now become part of the longstanding character of the old town area. Thank you for considering how many people would be upset and saddened by not have the this tradition continued at its beautiful current level. Sincerely, Joan Kinney (Ft. Collins resident) Page 109 Item 1. From:Sarah Kane To:Sharon Gloss; City Leaders Cc:Amy Resseguie Subject:RE: [EXTERNAL] Don"t Cut the Budget! Downtown Flower Funding Date:Monday, October 3, 2022 3:35:04 PM From: Sharon Gloss <scgloss@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, October 3, 2022 3:07 PM To: City Leaders <CityLeaders@fcgov.com> Subject: [EXTERNAL] Don't Cut the Budget! Downtown Flower Funding The display of color and blooms is a joy to all in Downtown Fort Collins and is a source of distinction for a beloved place in our community. Visitors and locals alike take daily pleasure in the visual delight ... why mess with a good thing? I work in a retail business in Old Town and the comments I've received are numerous "how beautiful it is in Old Town". At a time that we are all working to restore business to our independent retail shops, please support us in this effort of keeping people happy in that space. With appreciation, Sharon Page 110 Item 1. Idea Description I think we need to budget more to our probation team at the municipal court. They need more resources to help people in need in Ft. Collins. They need money to help people get food, purchase clothes, haircuts, and maybe even shelter. This is a team that works with disadvantaged groups directly, every single day. Great opportunity to help the people who need it most. They just need the help and budget. Priotitize more money to homelessness. A hand up to those who want it, care for mental illness, and guidance to the chronic. Really help homeless in need and guidance and a loving "push" to those who want a "free" lifestyle on public land toward a better life. Maybe move some advertising money from promoting FC to this kind of program. Please address break ins at trail heads. Security cameras and police presence would help. Also more severe consequences for the thieves . Let's stop throwing buildings away. There should be incentives to reusing or recycling buildings rather than replacing them. Every building that's thrown away means not only more waste in the landfill, but also more natural resources harvested, processed, hauled and installed, which involves a lot of energy use. Let's incentivize reuse and recycling of buildings. And find ways to make additions provide needed additional space without the intense energy and resource requirements of full building replacements. (Especially when the replacement does nothing to increase density and sometimes even reduces it!) Continue the bike paths north through Maple Hill to Wellington and more people with bike to work from the north part of Fort Collins.Expand the bike paths north Penalties for panhandling especially with children. If we want to keep our city safe and nice we need to stop encouraging vagrancy. Improvements to trails Install stretch and workout stations on Power Line trail and Fossil Creek trail. These installations would benefit walkers, runners and bicyclists. Provide free electrical service upgrades to facilitate the adoption of heat pumps Provide free electrical service upgrades to residential and commercial customers who are planning to upgrade from gas heating to heat pumps and do not currently have a large enough electrical service in order to do so. This will reduce pollution associated with burning natural gas indoors and will help the City meet its climate goals.Hi. Please invest in carefully reviewing all developments and attempt to preserve as much green space / open space as possible.Open Space preservation/ Development Continue to prioritize water storage, supply, and conservation. Are we positioned and funded to supply water to growing area. Water Conservation and Storage Require water heater replacements to be electric & cover electrical upgrade and NG capping fees.Reduce NG dependence & GHG emissions / improve interior air quality Require heater replacements to be electric & cover electrical upgrade and NG capping fees.Reduce NG dependence & GHG emissions / improve interior air quality Require new stoves / replacements to be electric and cover electrical upgrade & NG capping fees.Reduce NG dependence & GHG emissions / improve interior air quality I think the arts and culture offered in Fort Collins are a huge benefit to living here, and I would want City support for an Arts District Direct FC support to promote an Arts District like was tried several years ago Harmony underpass Harmony road needs a bike pedestrian underpass so bikers can ride to the power trail safely. Bike infrastructure will encourage more poke to bike, which will not only promote health, but will reduce harmful greenhouse emissions Invite (not tolerate) walking and biking on arterial streets Regarding capital project priority and design, the City already does a good job supporting walking and biking in most residential neighborhoods and has nationally- ranked recreational trails, but we fall just as short as most other American cities on making walking and biking a viable mode of transportation where it matters. Most practical destinations - the shops, restaurants, grocery stores, offices, and health care facilities we need to get to from home - are on arterial streets. Those same streets often have wide, fast travel lanes for cars and narrow or non-existent side- walks and bike lanes, barely a crosswalk every half mile, and little-to-no convenient transit service to extend walkable distances. Capital projects on municipal streets, especially arterials, should focus on traffic calming to slow cars down in more places (road diets [especially to add protected bike lanes and sidewalks], pedestrian bulb-outs, raised crosswalks, etc.), allowing people to cross the street in more places and with less wait times, and building walking and biking connectivity into our primary platform for generating wealth - our arterial streets. We now have several City plans that call for the city to be car-optional, but our street environment doesn't reflect that where it matters most, which is why, even on a pleasant spring day, our walk/bike/transit rideshare barely breaks 10% - for practical trips, walking, biking, and/or taking the bus just doesn't make logical sense. The advantage is that walking and biking infrastructure is incredibly cheap to build and maintain vs. automobile infrastructure, so there's a fiscal responsibility gain to that shift as well. We need to spend our capital dollars differently if we want to get a different outcome. Move the Murphy Center to a non-residential area. Ever since the Murphy Center was moved to Blue Spruce this street has turned into a makeshift homeless camp with trash, needles and addicts wandering the roads. Blue spruce has TWO school bus stops on it and one residential complex with children living in it. The city needs to relocate these services to an area of town that isn't so close to families and offer resources to homeless that encourage them to improve their lifestyle and not continue living it. We can no longer drive down this road to our home due to too many instances of homeless walking in the road without clothes, seeing homeless peeing/pooping on the side of the road, etc. Our local King Soopers parking lot and surrounding businesses have become filled with pandhandlers since this move. The Murphy Center needs to be relocated. While many residents of Fort Collins have compassion, we also deserve to have clean and safe neighborhoods to live in Hughes Open Space Support Northern Colorado Wildlife Center in their bid to get land in Hughes Open Space to provide care for Northern Colorado's injured, ill, and orphaned wildlife. Page 111 Item 1. Support mountain biking Many other cities I have traveled to have trails in their open spaces specifically for mountain bikes. I'm not talking about dirt jumps, I'm talking trails. Purpose-built trails. There are some good trails out of town to the west, but I would like to see more throughout town. Maybe one would be built at Fossil Creek Reservoir, Arapahoe Bend, or McMurray. Look to the suburbs of Minneapolis/St. Paul for good examples. Having Purpose-built mtb trails would encourage recreation and tourism, and it would lesson potential conflicts between other recreators. HALT Increases in Police Budget and Increase Funding to Equity Office Extend the trail system to NE FoCo Extend the trail system to NE FoCo for more accessibility of biking as transportation. Affordable housing and daycare Fort Collins is beautiful, but it has recently lost its place in the list of best places to live… by a lot. The primary factors seem to be cost of living related. Day care and housing must be addressed for our city to thrive and for its citizens to life life to the fullest. Restore and expand evening and weekend bus service Transfort has suffered low ridership since 2020, which has caused cut backs in service, further reducing ridership. Transfort has attempted to restore service, but has experienced difficulty in recruiting new drivers, in part due to the insufficient wages offered. Currently, bus drivers start at $20 per hour (~$41,600 annually). Unfortunately, this is not currently a liveable wage in Fort Collin or many of the surrounding towns. The cost of living across cities in the front range has increased dramatically, particularly over the past two years. I believe that we should increase the hourly pay of our bus drivers by $5 per hour across the board. This would cost the city approximately $1 million. This is a large investment, but a reliable public transportation system can directly address several of the city's strategic outcomes relating to economic opportunity and the environment (specifically, 1.3, 4.2, 6.3, 6.6, 7.1). A reliable public transportation system is a great equalizer. It reduces the costs of car ownership for the middle class and provides access to opportunities for those who cannot afford a car. Taking cars off the road is also the most effective way to reduce emissions and improve air quality locally. Fort Collins struggles with air quality issues, due in large part to our overreliance on single passenger vehicles for transportation. It is also worth mentioning that Fort Collins under-invests in its public transportation network relative to many college towns of similar size, including Madison WI, Eugene OR, Burlington VT, and Ann Arbor MI. The current draft of the 2023 - 2034 budget increases the operating budget for Transfort's fixed routes by 8.7%. This will keep pace with inflation, but will not provide funding needed to increase service or wages to the point where the bus system is a reliable mode of transportation for many across our city. Hence, I believe that more investment in the system is Better bike lanes and paths Although Fort Collins bike lanes and paths are already good, they can still be better. We could put money towards marking our bike lanes with paint and protecting them with horizontal and vertical buffers between the motor and bike lanes. Reallocate money from police budget to community improvement Denver news reported FC police giving out fake DUIs. Let's stop increasing their budget and use this money for the great ideas on this board. Review the city's systemic racism as noted in the Equity Indicators final report Prevent noise pollution by enforcing the existing noise ordinances-- e.g. stopping unmufflered motorcycles, trucks and cars. Reduce noise pollution Cease budget increases for FCPS; decrease and redirect policing and prison funds to the Equity Office and other social goods. Reports of false DUIs being issued by FCPS officers highlight the inefficiencies within the police department. Fort Collins residents deserve greater transparency; and the money currently invested in policing would be better spent on social goods (like affordable + sustainable housing) that keep our community well. Improve second sand volleyball court at Rolland Moore (net first and then more) The sand volleyball community in Fort Collins is growing and it is useful for pickup play to have two courts near each other. To my knowledge, Rolland Moore park has the best sand vball court of any Fort Collins parks and then a second decent nearby, but the second one has a very flimsy (and non-adjustable) net and rough sand. We are hoping that maybe a new better net could be added soon and then the net poles and sand could be improved in the future. Thank you! Please consider approving funding to support a reimagined Sustainable Business Program for Fort Collins businesses (budget offer 32.16). Based on the 20-year-old ClimateWise program that ended in 2019, the new program will aim to engage a greater spectrum of organizations and businesses in climate action, with special attention paid to racial equity, inclusion, and building cultures of belonging. Supporting wildlife rescue services I believe that a portion of the city budget should be used to support wildlife rescue services offered at no-charge the Fort Collins community members. This will ensure that the city's natural resources are further protected, and that community members are not exposed to animals that potentially have diseases or parasites. Please fund the sustainable business program. There is a gap in business support in this area. All citizens of the city benefit from it Fund Sustainable Business Program Sustainable Business Program Funding I would like to see funding approved for the Sustainable Business Program so we can help businesses and the local community operate more sustainably Parks and Rec City needs to dramatically increase pickleball play opportunities especially in Midtown. Get someone in charge of pickleball program and institute best practices for pickleball across the City. Now please Comment response to "Please address break ins at trail heads. Security cameras and police presence would help. Also more severe consequences for the thieves ." Not sure how common break-in are but judging by the sings it appears they happen. Security cameras would be good Comment response to "Penalties for panhandling especially with children. If we want to keep our city safe and nice we need to stop encouraging vagrancy." No. We shouldn't be wasting precious city funds on harassment of homeless people. Comment response to "Improvements to trails "Edit: Power Trail, not Power line Trail. Comment response to "Invite (not tolerate) walking and biking on arterial streets" Yes I would love to see capital improvement projects for bike infrastructure and road diets! Fort Collins is pretty good for walkabiliy and bikeability but we can do much better still! Page 112 Item 1. Comment response to "Invite (not tolerate) walking and biking on arterial streets" The solution to traffic is not more roads, it is to encourage other modes of transportation! Incentivize other forms of transportation and actively discourage driving! Limit parking and slow traffic down. Comment response to "Invite (not tolerate) walking and biking on arterial streets" Absolutely agree. Increasing accessibility for those who bike and walk along arterial roads is key to shifting people towards these modes of transportation to accomplish their everyday needs (work, shopping, school, etc.). Currently it is at best unpleasant to walk or bike along these roads and at worst it is downright dangerous. College avenue is particularly hostile and dangerous to anyone outside of a car, although Shields, Drake, and others are only slightly better. The lack of access requires those who walk or bike to take long circuitous routes to get where they are going, often making it much more time effective to drive. This, along with improvement in our public transportation network, must be addressed if the city is serious about reducing the number of cars on the road. Comment response to "Move the Murphy Center to a non-residential area. " And to note, we recently were driving down Blue Spruce and a homeless woman with no pants on was wandering aimlessly in the road shouting at cars- I had to slam on the brakes to avoid hitting her and same with the car behind me. We called the police to do a welfare check on her and the dispatch told me that the city won't allocate enough staff to that area unless they get enough calls from citizens. Which seems problematic to me since all it takes is a drive by to see this is an issue. That women could have been hit by a car and seriously injured. Rather than placing the burden on citizens or the police (that are overworked as it is!) step in and do something about it- this has been going on long enough and will only get worseComment response to "Hughes Open Space"Completely agree!!! Comment response to "Please consider approving funding to support a reimagined Sustainable Business Program for Fort Collins businesses (budget offer 32.16)."Agree! Comment response to "Please consider approving funding to support a reimagined Sustainable Business Program for Fort Collins businesses (budget offer 32.16)." This budget offer has massive potential to shift how businesses operate in Fort Collins in the future ensuring we keep the triple-bottom-line of people, planet and profit in mind! Economy: Includes economic planning and development activities, workforce training, childcare, education, employment opportunities If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding Childcare, Youth mental health, youth center More funding Childcare and education More funding Support for small businesses and recruiting new employers to the city More funding Child care and work force training. More funding The pottery studio employees and recreation people need more than minimum wage to be able to survive. More funding More for city staff, training, and development. Keep Investing in jobs that keep our city running smooth. From planning and development and parks and road maintenance. More funding Redirect funds from some existing services towards education, childcare, and employment training/assistance services More funding Childcare ,education and workforce training More funding Economic development, small business support More funding Childcare, employment opportunities for at risk demographics (like single moms, moms trying to leave dv situations, etc), more marketing of workforce development programs or even like temp to hire or intern to hire after a period of time (30-90 days) More funding Schools and libraries primary Parks and community service/police secondary More funding Supporting small business still recovering from the pandemic. More funding I support more monies that directly impact people directly. More funding Education and childcare. A lack of funding there will result in a total breakdown of anything the city wants to accomplish in a generation. More funding Childcare, education, and employment opportunities. More funding Education and childcare More funding Childcare and education More funding Education More funding Education and workforce training More funding Childcare and education More funding Bring new business to Fort Collins More funding Education, childcare More funding Childcare More funding Education More funding more for childcare, education, employment opportunities More funding Childcare, education and employment More funding Childcare needs to be much more highly prioritized. People can't work because they're watching their children. And if they can find help, it's very expensive. More funding Childcare More funding Childcare, education, NOT BUSINESSES. More funding Affordable childcare with shorter wait times More funding Employment opportunities. Working regionally with partners to attract large employers who pay well. More funding More funding for Childcare More funding education and employment More funding Offer 32.16 Sustainable Business Support Program looks very promising to promote the resilience of local businesses and the growth of a sustainability-minded business community! Less funding We have more employment than employees (at least in some areas), businesses do not need tax dollars they are booming. The only area in this category that should receive more funding is childcare and I would argue that childcare and education do not belong in the Economy category. Less funding For all. There are plenty of private services for all of these that the city shouldn’t be funding. Direct people to private services. Or partner with the private services to reduce tax payer costs. Page 113 Item 1. Less funding Employment opportunities. Less funding Overall, I don't think this is within the realm of the city's responsibilities Less funding Less funding on economic planning, less on economic incentives to businesses. Environment: Includes efforts to ensure good water resources, good air quality, land conservation, smart growth, the Climate Action Plan and an attractive community If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding Access to clean water; clean and viable Poudre river; and good/clean air quality. More funding More incentives for local business to reduce carbon footprint, use more eco friendly, recycled items (less styrofoam, etc.) More funding More funding to ensure Poudre River water flows through city and water quality. More funding Land acquisition, water and air quality improvements. More funding air quality, land conservation, smart growth; Buy open space to avoid overdevelopment on our infrastructure More funding land conservation, air quality More funding Air quality, climate change More funding Continue to push towards zero net carbon - lead by example. Fund grants/rebates/programs for homeowners and businesses to "go green". More funding We need to become more of an 'electric' community. We need to retro-fit our older housing stock. We need to reduce our green house gas emissions. We must actually work to protect the Cache la Poudre River. Our air quality is some of the worse in the nation - we must partner with Weld County to help encourage them to lower the amount of green house gas emissions they produce. Transit can't only mean more and more asphalt. Partner with Loveland and Longmont to make C3, a transit line that goes through each of those communities through their cores. More funding Land conservation, air quality (including eliminating preventable wood smoke) and the Climate Action plan. More funding to maintain and restore natural areas, more rangers to prevent degradation. "An attractive community" does not belong in this category, it cheapens the notion of real substantive action on our myriad environmental problems. There is no such thing as "smart growth!" The growth we are currently experiencing is not sustainable. The current population is already over the carrying capacity of this semi- desert region. We must reduce the absolute amount of water used in the city (regardless of which "provider" it is coming from - this means Montava, and all developments, should be a net- zero water users). More funding Air quality; electrification; energy and water efficiency and use. We must speed up the process to clean up our air and reduce greenhouse gases, through more electrification of our city, increased energy efficiency in our older stock, and better codes for our new stock of housing and commercial buildings. No longer allowing gas lawn equipment can go a long way...phase out the use of it in the next 3 years. We must increase land conservation as our City continues to grow. We should limit the grass areas for lawns. For lower income households, provide resources so that they can comply. More funding Services to help people reduce energy use, reduce indoor pollution, install solar, and help meet our climate goals. More funding Residential and commercial energy efficiency upgrades Rewards for improving water & energy conservation levels via defined levels/goals Residential and commercial building electrification Residential and commercial grey water updates Residential solar Electric vehicle charging infrastructure Electric busses and city vehicles More funding CAP and AQ should be top priorities in the next budget More funding Things that help keep people alive and healthy More funding Water usage education, more funding/ resources to expand xeriscaping programs. Hosted community clean ups More funding Fort Collins is growing too fast. Too much new building and people moving here creates poor air quality, homelessness, lack of jobs and a lack of affordable rentals. More funding Land conservation and attractive community. More funding Air quality More funding Climate More funding Land Conservation, Open Space, Parks, Bike Paths More funding Air quality More funding More funding for smart growth, land conservation and good air quality. More funding Improving air quality and climate action plan More funding The focus needs to be on reducing and eventually eliminating car dependency. Nothing else can be accomplished if that isn't. This will over time increase not only the environmental sustainability of the city, but the economic sustainability as well, and that means reduced long term costs. More funding More funding for climate action plans More funding Water resources and climate action plan More funding Water conservation and smart growth (more mixed use development!) More funding Land conservation and Climate Action Plan More funding Everything you listed in the question should be a priority. More funding Climate action plan and air quality More funding Always being sure we have good water More funding Air quality More funding those that are being so rapidly affected by the climate crisis and decisions made in the past when Fort Collins was much smaller and no one thought about the effects of the climate crisis on things like air and water - in other services essential for life for all More funding Air quality: reduce transport speeds, increase biking and walking accessibility including crossing options for neighborhoods cut off by traffic especially SE, reduce gas mowers and burning Page 114 Item 1. More funding Climate action More funding Ensuring good air quality, the Climate Action Plan More funding Air quality issues from high ozone levels and wildfires have a significant impact on quality of life. And, better planning for water resources seems prudent given what's happening in other parts of the west right now. More funding Water resources & land conservation. More funding 1) Water resources and quality 2) Land conservation More funding All! More funding Natural Area invasive weed attention. Litter control. (lids on trash barrels beside parking lots) Coon feeding stations with resulting waste scatter. Minimal cost and enhanced benefits. More funding All environmental concerns are important, but water is the most important. More funding Renewable energy More funding Spend less on land conservation. More spending on water and air quality. More funding more for curbing carbon emissions, air quality monitoring More funding Air quality and conservation More funding Land conservation and climate action More funding Sustainability needs to be Paramount. Local independence is the only way forward More funding Climate Action Plan More funding More air quality monitoring, needed emphasis on climate sustainability, not ‘resilience’ More funding Air quality and land conservation More funding protecting land as the cities population grows More funding All! More funding Land Conservation More funding good air quality, good water quality, land conservation More funding Air quality, water quality, land conservation, climate action plan. More funding water resources, good air quality, land conservation, smart growth, the Climate Action Plan More funding Please consider approving funding to support the development of a reimagined Sustainable Business Program for Fort Collins businesses (budget offer 32.16). Based on the 20-year-old ClimateWise program that ended in 2019, the new program will aim to engage a greater spectrum of organizations and businesses in climate action, with special attention paid to racial equity, inclusion, and building cultures of belonging. More funding city buildings need work. wheres the solar panels? make lights better outside (too much light pollution), take care of microplastics in the waterways, fund innovation funds, make some regenerative ag natural areas. More funding Wildlife rehabilitation and rescue More funding This is the quite possibly the most impactful issue facing us today. This needs to be a huge priority, literally almost every facet of life is at stake. I know some people (particularly some older folks who won't be around to see many of the devastating effects climate inaction will have) do not feel the urgency, or choose to ignore the urgency, but climate inaction is dooming my generation's future, as well as ALL future generations' futures. More funding Offer 32.16 Sustainable Business Support Program looks very promising to promote the resilience of local businesses and the growth of a sustainability-minded business community! More funding I would like to see funding to the Sustainable Business Program to help the community and businesses operate more sustainably More funding I would like to see more funding go to the Sustainable Business Program so we can help the community and businesses operate more sustainably Less funding Focus on smaller incremental personal choice initiatives Less funding This is too vague. How do we get “good “ water resources? What are “good “ water resources? What’s “smart growth “? Less funding Land conservation and climate action plan. Less funding Climate action Less funding Climate Action Plan-waste of tax dollars Less funding Less Climate Action Plan Less funding We already have great air, great water, and a eco supportive community. Less funding Sell that worthless piece of shit Soapstone. Less funding Climate Action Plan Less funding Overall, this type of activity is best left to the people, not the city Less funding less spending on small programs and initiatives like microfibers, etc. Neighborhood Livability and Social Health: Includes promoting good neighbor relationships, ensuring attractive neighborhoods, historic preservation, an adequate supply of quality housing for all socio-economic groups, addressing poverty and homelessness, creating an inclusive community If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding Affordable housing and providing services (mental health, housing, etc.) to homeless population. Access to programs that can provide services to help support people from becoming homeless in the first place. Specifically address better services for homeless youth including actual shelter for this population. More funding Primarily around adequate supply of quality housing for all socio-economic groups, addressing poverty and homelessness, creating an inclusive community. Historic preservation can be secondary. More funding safe neighborhoods, affordable housing More funding Make sure and keep U+2, or some other moniker that respects zoning, and doesn't create a kill zone in some of our oldest neighborhoods. Buck up, and partner with builders who can produce the sort of housing the City of Fort Collin's envisions, providing diversity, equity, and affordability. Page 115 Item 1. More funding The city needs to build more housing facilities for low-income and homeless populations. I would like to see more effort to eliminate the "unauthorized" homeless camps that seem to pop up in certain places. The city must stop relying solely on complaint-driven enforcement of nuisance codes including the occupancy ordinance (which should not be eliminated, more below). Equity arguments for removing occupancy ordinance are not valid. - Keeping some houses available for rent or purchase by families protects families, including members of the BIPOC and LGBTQ+ communities. - Removing the occupancy limits will create even more incentives for investors to buy available houses and for those who currently own rental properties to raise rents and rent to individual tenants by the bedroom, shutting out families who would otherwise buy or rent these homes. - Any expansion of occupancy limits should only be used to house income-qualified tenants for lower rents. Everyone deserves housing - Making houses more attractive to investors will not achieve the goal of housing more people affordably. --- Each bedroom will be rented for the current per-bedroom rental rate. --- Families with mortgages will not be able to compete with investors with cash --- Need to discourage investor takeover of neighborhoods. Home ownership is one of the most consistent paths to wealth and economic stability. Fort Collins’ rate of home ownership if far below the state and national rates. If occupancy ordinance is relaxed or removed we will fall farther behind. - Fort Collins: 55% - Colorado: 66% More funding We need a rental licensing program that can ensure the safety of those living in the house and ensure that neighborhoods are not negatively impacted by poor housing stock and yards. Better enforcement of U+2...it has improved the neighborhoods around CSU immensely. Don't let it lapse. Requiring developers to provide some percentage of affordable and attainable housing. Helping build truly affordable housing that will stay that way far into the future. More funding Adequate housing supply for and homelessness. More funding More equitable housing More funding Redirect some existing financed services towards affordable housing / improving quality of existing housing More funding Getting people appropriate housing and support services very needed. More funding Dealing with homelessness, making neighborhoods safe and attractive More funding More funding resources for affordable housing…parhways to purchase own homes, limits/ penalties to investment housing until more affordable housing and ownership opportunities available More funding It would be nice to have affordable housing for seniors on little or no budget. Social Security is hard to live on in Fort Collins. More funding Homelessness is a big one. More funding Address poverty and environmental racism More funding Promote neighborhood relations and attractive hoods More funding More affordable housing and low barrier access to housing. More funding Housing and addressing poverty. More funding Quality housing across price points. More funding More effort and funding must be put into working with developers to construct affordable housing. More funding Affordable housing is paramount if local businesses are going to be staffed. Working to eliminate poverty should be the goal of every level of government to even justify their existence. Poverty is always a policy failure. More funding Addressing poverty and homelessness More funding Increase funding for homelessness initiatives More funding Homelessness More funding Housing for lower economic groups and addresses homelessness and poverty More funding Poverty and homelessness More funding Adequate quality housing More funding Homelessness More funding Helping keeping up the parks and keeping them safe for children More funding Take over FCRM or work with them because they do their best, but the building is awful, and there needs to be more areas the unhoused can hang out during the day. More funding housing for all socio-economic groups - people who supply services that do not pay enough to live in Fort Collins also cannot afford to commute long distances to find housing More funding Mitigate unaffordable housing by requiring owner occupied new purchases and eliminating rental sales to foreign interests, repeal you plus two for inter generational living and affordability and aging in place and child care and equity More funding Housing first initiatives More funding Addressing poverty and homelessness, adequate housing for all socio-economic groups More funding affordable housing More funding I think affordable housing is a major concern given the high housing prices here. While I'm a homeowner right now, I wouldn't be at current market prices. I think the solution involves thinking of ways to build with more density rather than sprawl to be compatible with better air quality and other environmental goals. More funding more for reducing homelessness and providing homelessness services, more for Outreach Fort Collins to respond to calls in place of the police More funding Housing affordability and unhoused population support More funding U + 2 needs to go. And soon. It isn't helping anything and it is making life much harder for many people. More funding Addressing homelessness and creating an inclusive community Page 116 Item 1. More funding The City needs to increase its funding to provide its own services to the unhoused, rather than relying on non-profits. Job integration/training programs, go for a truly ‘housing first model’ and create housing that is truly affordable for our community members who make far less than the local median income. Drug addiction services, Mental health care, non-violent crisis intervention team to replace police interactions with most negatively impacted and most vulnerable community members. More funding Affordable housing More funding All of the above! More funding Creating an inclusive community, quality housing More funding quality housing for all socio-economic groups, addressing poverty and homelessness, creating an inclusive community More funding addressing poverty and homelessness More funding an adequate supply of quality housing for all socio-economic groups, addressing poverty and homelessness More funding Addressing poverty and homelessness as well as other facets of social health is not only positively impactful for those directly affected, but has a positive impact on everyone in the community. Less funding Supporting so many initiatives to support vagrants is bringing the entire city down (a bird feeder effect) rather than raising people up Less funding This would probably add more government intrusion into our lives. Creating an inclusive community means that conservatives are summarily excluded. Ensuring attractive neighborhoods? How would that happen? Another position for a “compliance” person or a brand new department? This is so broad and open-ended that it’s scary to think where this is going. Less funding Again lots of private services that people should be direcred to rather than tax other dollars. Also, HOAs and funding HOA needs privately are the best way to “beautify” neighborhoods. Less funding Ensuring attractive neighborhoods, thats up to the neighbors because they know each others lives better than a city emp in a car Less funding If you have a plan to do what no other city in the country has done, please explain. There will always be homelessness. Less funding All Less funding Social Health Less funding Less funding for creating an inclusive community; that should come naturally. Less funding I am very opposed to the city using taxpayer money to force ideologies and pseudo- religious indoctrination in the guise of being "equitable". There is no place for this in our city. Less funding The more money the city council keeps throwing at homeless folks the more we attract to FC. THere are many job opportunities of which many are not taking advantage. Good neighbor relationships? What does the city do about it? Nothing, in my estimation. It is not the job of FC residents to subsidize housing for those who aren't willing to work for it themselves. In the event of homeless veterans, those with disabilities, there are significant resources to be found. Less funding More funding to address the homeless issue in midtown. Much less spending on historic preservation. Less funding This is an area ripe for social engineering by the government. Need less micro-managing. Less funding focus less on social service programs that are not municipal responsibilities Safety: Includes police, fire, stormwater, emergency medical response, and building inspection If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding building inspection and stormwater More funding Fort Collins Leadership must tackle the issue of gun violence. Yesterday, 19 children were murdered; 7 year olds, who, instead of going to school to become successful later in life, became the targets of hate, and brutally murdered. No nation that is so willing to kill each other with such disregard can be called civilized. More funding Desperately need snow and ice removal especially at intersections More funding As a tile installer who is certified through CTEF and a member of the NTCA, I am absolutely appalled that we do not require inspection of wet space backer/tile installation. In the last few years the number of calls I get to look at failing shower pans is unbelievable. I would also recommend having all in floor heat systems (installed by tilers) considered an inspected part of our trade. I have had a forensic tile rep come and identify a floor that was installed so poorly that it was a fire hazard. Even weld county inspects shower pans, and requires flood testing. I see about one shower a month that is failing, causing mold and other issues. It’s time to step up the building inspection game! More funding Parks and trails are becoming more and more unsafe More funding Police and fire More funding Police More funding Anyone willing to risk their lives for others deserves so much! More funding More police presence in neighborhoods dealing with homeless issues. Library park area is not safe. More funding Police, first responders More funding The crime in Ft Collins has gotten bad, mostly due to liberal policies that do not make criminals responsible for thier actions and restict Police authority. More funding Fire and police More funding Police. The growing crime climate in this city is beyond shameful. Starting with little to no traffic law enforcement, theft and vandalism are now impacting virtually every neighborhood. Open your eyes. More funding All More funding Police and fire More funding Further funding for the FCPS mental health, traffic, and investigations units to hire more personnel. More funding All except police. Decease police funding. Increase funding in community alternatives to policing; Denver and Portland have good models! More funding Safety is a the key role of government. We are threatened by wildfire, flooding, etc. Less funding Leave building inspections out of private rentals Less funding More funding collaboration for mental health services instead of police/ EMT interventions Page 117 Item 1. Less funding Less funding for police, already too much (not abolish police, just lessen) Less funding Redirect funding from the police to these other services and to other parts of the budget. In the US, the police are arming and training far right white supremacy terrorist groups, and this is not protecting or benefiting our cities. Less funding Police. Less funding Reduce the amount of funding for the police administration at all levels. 16 million each year for just patrol services is too much. Less funding Less police Less funding All Less funding Police Less funding reduce police funding!!! Police currently makes more money in training than a teacher that has in the district for 15 years!!! Less funding less for police patrol, office of the chief of police, police enhancements Less funding Less police funding. Less funding Less for police services Less funding The police should have its funding repurposed. I think that if we spent that money on fire fighting we wouldn't have as many dead people. Less funding Police Less funding Policing, specifically the areas of patrol, office of the Chief, and also no increases to the police force (I do see they’re wanting 7 more officers in 2023, and another 7 in 2024–no thanks!) Less funding We need less funding towards the police and more towards community services Less funding We do not need SROs in schools and we don’t need more cops on the streets. Park Ranger Geoff is super aggressive and harassed many Parks staff and citizens. We need more money funneled into better wages for city employees, protections for our undocumented neighbors— who I know contracts with the city and are underpaid— grants for alternative forms of mental health like Yarrow Collective and diversity initiatives like funding Black owned companies, businesses and collectives. As a social worker who works with students with disabilities in our schools I find that a majority of our students are the ones interacting with the SRO. We need better training for staff— training in trauma informed responses and not just a few boring day long trainings— no years long integration of trauma informed teaching in our schools. I know that most students who are penalized by the PSD system are Black or otherwise marginalized— that is not okay and in fact counter to the rich diversity our city claims to have. We need to also defund crisis pregnancy centers. Less funding Less funding for police Less funding Less funding to the police, no increase to the police force and no 3 million dollar raise to the office of the chief, and not increased funding to patrols. Less funding Less to law enforcement agencies. Primarily Fort Collins Police Department Less funding Less funding for police Less funding Police Less funding Police force Less funding Less funding to police departments, more funding to all other services. Less funding The police in the city of Fort Collins need less funding. New police cars all the time, tactical gear fit for a special ops military unit, and other spending in no way benefits the City or the people who live in it. The few times that I have needed police services, they've been dismissive, unwilling to help, or simply inadequate. More funding is not the answer. Fort Collins is a relatively safe community, but in order to improve safety for everyone, we need more funding for mental health services and professionals. Police are not the ones who should deal with mental health crises. They are not trained or equipped to deal with such crises, nor are many officers willing or able to take an approach other that aggression and detainment. The shifting of funding from traditional police services towards more mental health professionals and social workers would greatly benefit our community. Regarding new equipment purchases, the Fort Collins police seems to always have new squad cars, tons of fancy new tactical military gear, long rifles, etc. None of this seems necessary. Police shouldn't possess the kind of gear that the military possesses. The National Guard exists for a reason. While some specialized units, like drug units and SWAT, have a use case for some of this equipment, most officers don't. In regards to the other services in the question, I believe they should receive more funding. I think this question may be written in a way that leads to misleading results, since it includes police services along with many other services in the writing of the question. Culture, Parks and Recreation: Includes operating and improving recreational facilities, Lincoln Center, Gardens on Spring Creek and the Museum of Discovery; providing recreational, arts and cultural programs and public art; maintaining parks, trails and cemeteries; and improving natural areas If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding Parks, trails, and natural areas have seen increased use during COVID and with a growing population. More funding Operating and improvements to facilities, trail maintenance and park maintenance as well as enhancements to natural areas. More funding Youth Activity Center(s) More funding More trails and recreation infrastructure instead of buying more land. Support/maintain the facilities we have instead of building more. More funding Address the potholes, striping, and yellow/orange safety striping in the roads, trails, and parking lots inside the parks/recreation areas; keep the trash bins emptied regularly in parks and on the trails. Mow on a regular schedule. More funding Improving natural areas - but very specifically. I don't mean building more trails or access for high-intensity recreation (no mountain-bike specific trails). Money should be used to restore areas where the natural environment has been degraded, to improve resilience of native plant and wildlife species. Adding rangers to enforce closures, dog regulations, and trail sharing should also be part of the budget. More funding City staff working in the recreation department are currently under payed. A compensation audit specifically for those working in the pottery studio would be a helpful place to start. More funding Pottery studio employees Page 118 Item 1. More funding More for small local arts groups still recovering from pandemic; like Fort Fund funding. More funding Fund further expansion of the recreational trail network to reduce car dependency and meet CAP commitments More funding Fund arts More funding More funding for the arts. More funding Natural areas More funding Parks and trails need more More funding Bike/walking trails! More funding Focus on Trails and Parks. More funding Parks and trails maintenance More funding Trails and natural areas not only help make the city easier to get around in without a car, but they help the local ecosystem and bring tourism. More funding Improving natural areas. More rangers to enforce proper trail use, leash law, etc More funding Arts and Cultural programs, improving rec facilities and programs More funding All of these things make this a more appealing place to live. I say fund them all a little more! More funding Lincoln Center More funding Colorado is all about being outside let’s keep that all safe and looking nice More funding Parks are not being kept up More funding Take care of our youth — the YAC is inadequate and Alslan northside; our midtown and majority youth populations are vastly underserved for a town the size of Fort Collins. Consider creative options such as partnering with YMCA, ywca if the city cannot equitably serve our youth. More funding Complete the missing segments of bike trail system, maintaining parks and natural areas. More funding 1) Complete the missing segments of bike trail system 2) Maintain parks and natural areas More funding Public Art/Lincoln Center - Community Engagement/Partnerships with non-profits, private sector, etc. More funding more for parks and recreation More funding Bohemian nights was a big asset to this community and we need to see its like again. More funding All of the above! Specifically earmark funding in parks department for planting + maintaining native perennials so as to incentivize their use. More funding More funding of natural areas and maintaining natural areas More funding Turf conversions, better irrigation systems in parks, get rid of mulberry pool and replace it with beautiful building, more trails. More funding Only increases to improving natural areas More funding Parks and recreation as a whole deserves more funding. The parks in this City are Beautiful, and the recreation program has always tried the hardest with the funding they get. With more funding to keep our parks amazing and possibly build more parks or improve parks in need of improvement, our community will improve. More funding more funding for maintenance of existing infrastructure Less funding Cemeteries, improving natural areas Transportation and Mobility: Includes transportation planning and development, maintaining roads and traffic operations, Transfort operations, and bicycle and pedestrian safety, Northern Colorado Regional Airport If more or less funding, which services specifically? More funding I would like the focus to be on bicycle and pedestrian safety, Northern Colorado Regional Airport More funding Bicycle and pedestrian safety, more mass transit options More funding More pedestrian and cycling infrastructure - improve safety of our streets for users other than cars. More funding The City of Fort Collins must partner with Loveland and Longmont to create C3, a core to core, to core transit line that runs through the cores of these 3 communities. No place in the nation has built itself out of sprawl - and Fort Collins won't become the first. We must design transportation vis a vis public transit, that serves the most vulnerable, workers, and our community. More funding I'm not necessarily advocating for more funding here, but rather that funding in this category should be directed to transit -- including a robust regional system that allows people to commute into Fort Collins from other cities in the area, and to improving bicycle and pedestrian conditions more holistically, not just safety. This means completing missing sidewalks, and providing adequate street crossings, making bicycle education part of every communication -- letting both motorists and bicyclists (and would-be bicyclists) know that bikes are allowed to use the entire road system (including taking a lane) except on S. College between Laurel and Harmony. More funding Northern Colorado Regional Airport More funding Expansion of bus service, purchase of more electric busses. More funding Improving bicycle safety features (such as barricades, bumpers/disks, stanchions, bollards, colored road, ...) on high traffic roads where bike trails like Mason, Powerline, Spring Creek, Poudre, Fossil Creek are not an option. Save lives, promote more biking. Seek more bike/pedestrian-only trails away from roads that offer more safe & enjoyable connections through the city. While biking on/next to major roads should be available and safe, it still sucks to breath in all the car exhaust and listen to the cacophony of internal combustion engines. More funding Restore Transfort service to pre-pandemic levels More funding Making biking safe by separating bikes from cars More funding Again ice and snow removal on streets More funding It would be nice to have an available airport!! More funding Bike and pedestrian safety More funding Bicycle infrastructure More funding More funding for transfort and biking and walking routes- complete poudre trail connection under i25 and add bike lanes on Ketcher Road from Fossil ridge high school to CR5 More funding Fixing potholes and roads in general More funding More public transportation modeled after the Max Page 119 Item 1. More funding Public transportation needs improvement, particularly for disabled and poor individuals. More funding Bike/pedestrian under- and overpasses. Higher pay for the amazing city workers. More funding Transfort funding should be increased and there should be outreach campaigns to promote bus service. Transfort is having trouble hiring drivers, so their starting salaries should be increased. More funding Bicycle and Pedestrian Safety needs to be a priority. More funding Fort Collins is known for its mobility and needs to invest more heavily More funding More bicycle investment, same or less emphasis on cars More funding Bicycle infrastructure to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and improve air quality More funding Money should temporarily be redirected to bike, pedestrian, and public transit infrastructure. These require significantly less maintenance than car infrastructure, so in the long run funding can be redirected from urban development to other areas. More funding Transfort operations More funding Maintaining roads and traffic operations More funding Less to airport. More for bike and public transit. More funding Definitely the roads. Also the alleys. The roads and alleys in my immediate neighborhood are shameful. More funding Bicycle and pedestrian safety More funding Airport, traffic More funding Make this a bike town. We're on our way to being so, but the lanes on the roads we need to use most (Ex. Drake, College, Prospect) are way too dangerous to use. Paint lines aren't enough. Look at Long Beach, CA and their bike lanes. More funding Roads can’t handle all the traffic. More funding Pay drivers so that the buses can run. Our students, elderly, disabled, and poor are really struggling with the drastic reduction in bus service. More funding Transfort, bicycle and pedestrian safety More funding Keep all buses fee free and expand the network, or add fees back and give all bus drivers a higher wage More funding Less car dependency. Whichever services oversee pedestrian and cyclist safety and infrastructure. More funding Public transportation is insufficient for many people, although that's kind of a chicken and egg problem. Bicycle infrastructure improvements could make a big impact to both increase commuting and improve safety. More funding Improve traffic operations and biking safety. More funding Maintenance More funding More bike trails More funding Further funding towards encouraging alternative transportation and ensuring the airport continues on a trajectory towards becoming a regional asset. More funding Need more bike trails that are not on main roads connected to all schools More funding Bicycle support is good here, but could always be better. Reducing dependency on cars should be a goal. More funding Mass transit and non car oriented transit should be prioritized. More funding Northern CO regional airport and public transportation More funding Public transportation. Public transportation! Please. Also if there’s a way to increase funding for the Denver light rail that was supposed to already come thru to Fort Collins, that would be amazing. More funding Transportation is a perpetual disaster in Fort Collins. Implement the Transportation Master Plan. More funding bicycle and pedestrian safety, more public transportation to reduce reliance on automobiles. More funding EVs. Where are the EVs and charging stations and hubs? We are falling behind. More funding We desperately need more effective public transport. Transfort has some good offerings, but not nearly enough stops, routes, or high enough frequency to be an effective replacement for a personal vehicle. Transport funding ties in directly with climate action. Transport is severly lacking in Fort Collins. The city could also have a hand in the Front Range Passenger Rail program (They do already but I feel they could use their influence as representatives of one of the most populous cities in the state to encourage the pursuit of the project). Less funding Many of these are underutilized after years of effort. Max and bike initiatives Less funding Buses don’t have enough passengers as it is. Get better routes (shuttles). Less funding Transfort should be dismantled. It’s a stress on the environment and tax payers for a limited use service (often buses are empty). Some of the Money should be shifted to private services to help limited mobility people safely travel within city limits. The airport should have increased funding to expand commercial flights so NoCo is more accessible and flying/traveling for residents is more convenient and safer. Less funding If you want to fix the homeless problem, stop making it easier to be homeless. Less funding Public transportation in this city is a ridiculous waste , cut everything. Less funding Reduce spending on transfort, especially on the Mason Street corridor. This sees very limited use, people don't want it, and it affects very few people. Less funding less funding across the board General Government: Includes internal support functions, City management, Council, boards and commissions, volunteers, technology, communicating with community members and building maintenance and repair If more or less funding, which services specifically? Less funding Council, boards and commissions More funding I want the city to fund an ombudsman who will help neighborhoods participate substantively and productively in the development process (maybe the funds for this position can come from eliminating any Baldridge-required or inspired nonsense). The city needs to be much more inclusive in allowing input (e.g. no more industry-specific stakeholder groups). Funding for general communication should include more paper mailings for households who are not connected to social media. More funding Increase pay for city council. More funding Keep cyber security well funded and pay council and all staff to inflation rates. More funding Building maintained and repair. Specifically updating older building to be more efficient. More funding Increase council pay Page 120 Item 1. More funding I support increased salaries and benefits for the mayor and city council. I think less should be spend on land use policy/regulations, less on community code enforcement. More funding If this is where you’re considering the Equity Office funding to be, than yes, we specifically need more funding to the Equity Office which has been incapable of doing really anything meaningful with the data they have from the Equity Indicator Report. The office is clearly understaffed, does not have necessary program or project managers that are needed. More funding Building maintenance and repairs. More funding more funding for the operation of city buildings to make them more sustainable and energy efficient and healthier. More funding Volunteers, technology, communication, building maintenance, and internal support. Not sure if City Management needs more funding, I think salaries are relatively good. However, I do recognize that Council members have very low salaries. They could potentially be increased to attract talent and to allow members to focus on their job on the council, and maybe not have to have another full time job to get by. More funding Core support services need to grow at the same rate as overall spending to ensure quality customers services and support to employees. Less funding Close offices and shift to true community meetings in spaces where the community actually enjoys being. Less funding I don't know what you could cut, but it seems as though we have no limit to our population growth. I think we should cap the growth by stopping the greed and the endless building. Less funding Way to many committees for special interest subsections that represent maybe 1-5% of the community. This is not a sustainable practice financially. Less funding Less funding to make up for librarian theft up the audits to per paycheck or montly Less funding City management Less funding You make enough money already. You do not get a raise on the edge of a recession. Less funding Everything. especially police. Less funding Consider recruiting from our professional workforce for high powered and highly capable volunteers. Less funding Government is getting too big for their britches, they forget they work for the citizens! and we DO NOT live in Boulder, nor do we want to! Stop trying to make Ft Collins like Boulder. Boulder sucks! Less funding It is disingenuous of city council to vote themselves a pay raise. How many of us volunteer at least as many hours to worthy causes within the city and area? If they don't want to volunteer they shouldn't bother running. For many, anyway, it seems to be a real ego trip. Less funding Enough. Less funding Less to Council Less funding less funding across the board Is there anything else you'd like to share? Protect our river and recreational/natural areas that make Ft. Collins unique. Promote smart growth that prioritizes ownership - not renting. Build up along major transportation corridors with non-car transportation prioritized. Protect Old Town business area from chain stores. Smart development of North College area. It'd be nice to keep the trails in town top notch. Connecting as many neighborhood (and shopping areas) would be great. Tunnels for the bikes would really increase bike commuting. I think housing developers are leaving us in a precarious position where they develop more units to make a profit and then leave the city with more drain on infrastructure (more people puts more strain on our water, safety (police, fire), our recreation (trails, reservoir, etc), and transportation. It seems that one of the better ways to combat this is to use tax dollars to buy more land and create open space. Voters seems to be in favor of this whenever it happens and when it doesn't people seem to complain about overdevelopment. Fort Collins is a great place to live. I've been very happy with the city government in the 11 years I've lived here - just tweak the funding a bit to make things even better. Based on what I read in The Coloradoan, I'm supposed to expect "shabby" parks and recreation areas this year? Please, please - do not skimp in this category. I'd rather see less funding of and fewer routes on TransFort than skimp on parks/rec. Fort Collins has long had the 'it' factor. We seem to be languishing, becoming the kind of community that also has 'it' in it. Our leaders should show passion for protecting our natural environment, to sheltering our most vulnerable, to creating revenue streams that are dependable and sustainable, and to putting the residents of this community ahead of investment opportunities for the rich and powerful. The role of city government is to provide public goods -- things that are not produced in adequate amounts by markets. This means focusing on environmental protection, protection of neighborhood quality of life, safety. Business development is a market good and should be left to businesses. No thank you. Keep pay in city to match inflation. Meeting CAP goals through investment in car-reduction strategies should be the top priority until emission reduction commitments have been met. Mental health, mental health, mental health. Therapists are in high demand and people are not able to access needed therapy due to cost issues and a lot of therapists not taking insurance (probably due to the hassle and underpayment of insurance, I’m a doctor in town and it is a serious issue). There are also very limited psychiatrists. The inpatient mental health is totally overwhelmed and patients are not getting set up with any follow up besides there PCP - Not setting up with psychiatrist appt nor therapist. It’s especially worse with adolescents/kids. The community is seriously struggling with mental health - leading to people not working or taking leave of absences, substance use issues, interpersonal conflicts - all things that impact our community in every possible aspect, including the economy.Good Luck! I know I'm not the only person who sees our fair city becoming overrun with people hoping to move here and finding it too expensive. We now have a rise in crime and disrespect for people's personal belongings and property. It's sad. Thanks for asking for input. Page 121 Item 1. Homeless population needs to be addressed Please finish the power trail The city needs to be able to pay a fair wage so that normal working class people can be involved in policy, but there are other priorities that are required to ensure the city is economically sustainable. Please add more funding for mental health care, defund police and use that funding for care teams during mental health crisises. Homelessness needs to be addressed Include more funding for mental health care and include care teams for mental health crisises separate from the police. Pay for it by decreasing development subsidies. Housing prices are market-driven, not cost- driven. Long term solution to housing issues is to enable infill and allow higher densities and require high quality housing stock. Letting developers slap cookie cutter neighborhoods on farmland is not helping. I’d love to see Northeast FtCo given some money/attention. Annexing Mulberry area, getting a bike trail connection to Poudre Trail, and a larger community park is all desperately needed. If the city plans to continue to issue housing permits in that area they need to upgrade the infrastructure to match the growth. Stop putting so much money towards being a green city, when other programs desperately need the money. My neighborhood area of over 3,000 residents is cut off despite being right next to Linton elementary for decades. The city traffic engineer has dismissed our requests for safe passage to the Poudre River trail at each contact. Neighbors call the police each week to complain about average speeds of 50-70 mph on east Horsetooth. It’s dangerous to drive and impossible to bike or walk. We need a light at Caribou or Kingsley and some speed mitigation. It’s only safe to ride on the trails due to traffic, and we cannot get there safely. Similarly, the Rigden Farm area of 1,000+ residents also has no safe crossing to get to the Poudre River Trail. City responsiveness is an issue. More people out and about here would also reduce property crime.Most cities have a transit signal priority. This would be difficult to implement for some routes, but for the max route it wouldn't be very difficult and would speed up service, also depending on budget, transforming the MAX line into a LRT would be more sustainable and be a good step in showing fort collins is committed to continued public transportation development I'd like to see Fort Collins look less like what's south of Drake, (i.e. a suburban, developed hellscape that's totally car-dependent) or even worse Timnath/Windsor and more like Amsterdam which uses vertical space efficiently, bike paths, pedestrian routes, and most importantly public transit (I.e. bus, trolley) for commutes and transportation. Government should BUTT OUT of citizens lives. The plan to try to have one trash removal company is ABSURD, as is the ban on plastic bags! Spend your time working on cleaning up the homeless and drug abuse problems. Leave the law abiding citizens, who pay taxes, alone. Never hurts to simply spend for justifiable causes as opposed to spend for spending's sake. Help make sure drugs and homeless have free options to improve their situation More for business and economic development. Lobby the state to make the new lane on I-25 free. A toll lane is NOT going to solve the traffic problem as few people will use it. the proposed budget offers for the police are offensively high. the numbers they're requesting for enhancements alone could fully end homelessness in Fort Collins if we spent it more wisely The police budget needs to be reallocated to community programs that people would benefit from. We don't feel safe with more cops, we feel safe because of people like outreach fort Collins. Yes—where are the questions related to your Equity Office? We need more funding to this office. So far, it doesn’t appear that the Root Cause Analysis for the Equity Indicator Report is being funded in this budget when it most definitely needs to be. There also needs to be funding provided for further staff, specifically program managers, and project managers to actually do anything with this Office. I do see there is a Equity Indicator Project and Community Specialist position being sought, however, this is not the most needed position at this time. They first need a root cause analysis, then an action plan, before needing a PR specialist to communicate such items. The Equity Office in the survey should get more funding for the root cause analysis, program and project managers and other staff. The Equity Office needs funding to address these issues in our community, not the police which create issues in our community. Do something different than you've typically done, if you don't try you won't know the difference it can make. Thank you for all you do for our city! a program to help homeowners care for their trees. its so expensive to care for trees and when you dont they cause damage with falling limbs. this is also important for emerald ash borer. The City can do everything right but the homeowners with Ash trees can ruin it because they dont know or can't afford to care for the trees. N/A Offer 32.16 Sustainable Business Support Program has a lot of potential to give businesses the power to make lasting changes for Fort Collins future! Page 122 Item 1. City of Fort Collins Budget Community Guides Summary Report Sabrina Slagowski-Tipton Prepared for the City of Fort Collins by the Center for Public Deliberation with assistance from Sidra Aghababian Acknowledgements: We would like to thank all the Community Guides who hosted these conversations, collected this data, and in some cases entered the data themselves as well as the participants throughout our local community who joined in these conversations. Page 123 Item 1. Executive Summary This report synthesizes the comments from members of the Fort Collins community who engaged in conversations for our Community Guide process from July 14, 2022-August 30, 2022. In total, 7 Community Guides led conversations with 40 community members about budget priorities and how the city can best engage the community in the budget process in the future. Below, we report the primary themes that participants gave in response to five questions that asked them to reflect on their level of comfort interacting with the budget and priorities they had in specific outcome areas. Participants also provided feedback on things that could be improved in the budget itself and in the city’s engagement efforts. The analysis portion of this report contains four main sections: Reactions to the Budget Process, Discussion of Budget Outcomes, Reflections on the Engagement Process, and Advice for Future Engagement. The main themes from each section are briefly summarized below, though the full report provides a more thorough accounting of how community members expressed each theme. Reactions to the Budget Process When asked to reflect on how they felt about the budget process and the outcomes and priorities, participants noted a few main themes: • Difficulty understanding the budget process itself which often left participants feeling confused or frustrated. Many felt uncomfortable interacting with the budget, feeling as though they didn’t have enough information or the correct resources to engage. • Budget outcome areas and priorities that didn’t seem to align with community sentiment in their small group conversations. • Need for more access to the budget process in earlier stages and a need for more educational resources about how the budget process works. Discussion of Budget Outcomes In each conversation, participants were asked to identify which outcomes/priorities felt most important to them and which ones felt less important. In our data, the following outcome areas were mentioned most often as most important: • Environmental Health • Neighborhood Livability and Social Health While these came up most often as less important: • Safe Community (specifically funding for policing) Page 124 Item 1. • Recreation 1 Reflections on the Engagement Process Participants raised several key themes when they discussed the engagement process itself: • Lack of accessibility to the engagement process: participants felt the City’s current efforts around budget engagement could be vastly improved and hoped more work would be spent on this engagement in future budget cycles. • Value of small group, informative conversations: numerous participants noted they felt more informed and comfortable after their small group conversation with the Community Guides and expressed a desire for similar opportunities to share their input. • Lack of transparency and communication of impacts: many participants noted concern that their feedback would not have an impact and hoped the city would be more transparent about how this information is used. Advice for Future Engagement Based on the responses from participants when they discussed how the city could best engage the community in conversations about the budget, we identified several suggestions: • More robust use of social media to keep the public informed about Council priorities and discussions. • Improving community outreach by continued connection with groups like the CPD and other grassroots organizations throughout the community who are already doing some of this work. • Consistency and accessibility: participants expressed a desire for the City to provide consistent and transparent updates about the budget process through various channels, provide multiple opportunities for people to engage, and implement compensation plans for those who participate. 1 Recreation and Culture represent one outcome area in the budget itself, but in these conversations, participants purposefully discussed only recreation when identifying outcomes that felt less important. Page 125 Item 1. Methodology The Center for Public Deliberation solicited community members who were interested in hosting conversations on issues related to budget outcomes and priority areas. Community Guides completed a brief application and attended a four-hour training session that prepared them to conduct and facilitate conversations within their own communities utilizing a common questionnaire. They then hosted conversations throughout the City of Fort Collins. Generally, these were small group conversations with members of similar communities, though on occasion these were conducted in a one-on-one setting. Guides were instructed to ask participants to talk about their experiences according to each main question. These questions were designed by the Center for Public Deliberation with feedback from the City of Fort Collins. After each question, guides gave participants a few moments to write their reflections on provided worksheets. The discussions and worksheets asked participants to respond to the following questions: 1. What are some initial reactions you have to the overall budget process? 2. What do you feel are the most important priorities for the 2023-2024 budget? 3. Which budget priorities feel less important? 4. How comfortable do you feel discussing and engaging with the city’s budget? 5. What are the best ways for City Council to keep the community involved in decisions and ongoing conversations about the budget? The data in this report was collected during conversations hosted by seven Community Guides conducted between mid-July and late-August 2022.2 Guides who could connect with historically under-served populations were provided a small stipend for their work. The resulting dataset includes 40 surveys total. After data entry each comment was thematically coded by a team of researchers, who reviewed themes across questions and respondents. In the sections below, major themes are organized roughly according to the frequency with which they appeared in the surveys, taking into account that some Community Guides had conversations with a greater number of individuals and thus those communities may over-represented in the data. 2 Some of the work of the Community Guide program was disrupted by illness and scheduling issues. A few Community Guides had to cancel planned meetings due unforeseen circumstances. Others had a more difficult time soliciting participants due to a shortened timeline for engagement. Page 126 Item 1. Of those participants who provided responses to demographic questions, 52% identified as female, 35% as male, and 12% as gender non-conforming. Seventy percent of respondents identified their race as white, 15% as Hispanic or Latinx, 5% as black or African American, 5% as two or more races, 2% as Asian, and 2% as American Indian or Alaska Native.3 Guides engaged participants between the ages of 19-69 in conversation. Forty percent of respondents were between the ages of 19-29, 25% were between 30-39, 7.5% were between 40-49, 2% were between 50-59, 2% were between 60-69, and 2% were between 70-79. When reporting household income, 7% reported making less than $10,000 per year, 2% between $10-000 and $15,000, 17% between $15,000-$25,000, 10% between $25,000 and $35,000, 7% between $35,000 and $50,000, 12% between $50,000 and $75,000, 7% between $75,000 and $100,000, and 10% more than $100,000. 3 Where the numbers do not equal 100, the remainder of respondents declined to specify. Page 127 Item 1. Reactions to the Budget Process Participants began their conversation by discussing their initial reactions to the budget process itself. The following themes were identified in the data from this section: Difficulty understanding the process. Participants across several guide conversations felt as though the information they currently had about the budget process was not enough for them to fully engage in conversation about it or make any clear decisions. Many wondered how community members were being plugged into the process and how each of the outcome areas were decided on. This limited information led to some frustration among participants, leaving some feeling as though the City wasn’t being transparent in their engagement efforts or was not trying hard enough to get useful information out to different areas throughout Fort Collins: “The process is hard to navigate and be a part of. The people giving feedback are a privileged set of individuals that have ample time and energy! e.g. clicking multiple links to find the budget in the first place.” Additionally, several participants felt as though the information provided for the outcome areas and different offers was too vague to fully understand. Here, there seemed to be a distinct tension between providing information that is too complex and confusing, and not enough information for folks to understand the true intent of each outcome area and its goals. In our data it appeared that the participants who had ample time and resources felt comfortable engaging with the budget and had a good working knowledge of the process, but those who had limited time did not know where to begin and felt uncomfortable and even sometimes overwhelmed engaging with a lot of the information. This tension is highlighted well with these two quotes from different participants: “I have only spent an hour or so going through some of the docs, and there are thousands of pages of budget docs—so not feeling like I have a high level of comprehension.” “[I am] somewhat comfortable, but it has taken about 2 years to have any good idea on how this process operates.” Page 128 Item 1. Outcome areas and priorities not in line with community needs. There was also robust discussion among many Community Guide groups surrounding how the outcome areas were identified and priorities within them established. Numerous participants mentioned that these various outcomes and priorities did not fully reflect what the community needed, especially in conversation about the Safe Community outcome area. Here, participants felt that a safe community needed equal access to necessities like water, housing, and community wellbeing and felt those items being in other outcome areas did not make sense. Furthermore, some participants noted that the Economic Health outcome should include things like a living wage and support for job creation. They expressed some frustration that most of the items in this outcome area seemed to focus more heavily on the economic health of larger businesses and the City itself: “The community has different understandings/definitions of the budget outcomes. For example, Social Health to us (those present today) includes mental health, whereas we do not consider mental health a safety priority.” Need for more, and earlier, access to the process. Participants in these conversations also noted various barriers to their accessing and participating in the different stages of the budget process. Some of these reasons included: no access to childcare for working parents, limited English proficiency and lack of items available in other languages, limited access to reliable internet, and limited access to transportation. These reveal the continued barriers community members are facing when it comes to fully engaging in processes with the City and other entities about important issues. Some also felt the opportunities available to them were too time intensive and often required those who work full time to either miss out on the opportunities or try to get time off work, which for many is not possible. Additionally, folks noted they had not received much information about any opportunities prior to the Community Guide process other than a community survey. They expressed a desire for there to be more engagement on the front-end of the budget process and many were frustrated that their feedback was being solicited so late in the process when they felt as though it wouldn’t have as much of an impact. “…the community engagement portion of this process needs to be less time intensive, compensated, and conducted by local leaders and organizations that are trusted by community and whose reach extends to diverse populations.” Page 129 Item 1. Discussion of Budget Outcomes In the next section, each participant was asked which outcomes in the budget felt most important to them (and their community) and which outcomes felt least important. In the data, we identified that Environmental Health, and Neighborhood Livability and Social Health were discussed most often in this section. There was also helpful and robust discussion about what each outcome area meant to the participants which allowed them to identify priorities and services they felt belonged in different outcome areas than they are currently listed in. Important: Environmental Health. Numerous participants across each Guide conversation listed environmental health in 1st or 2nd on their list of most important outcomes. In these discussions, issues of water use, air quality, and sustainability in local business came up quite often. Overall, these discussions focused on how we can focus funding on services that help keep our local community clean, or air safe to breathe, and how we can deal with ongoing issues related to climate change. Here, as well as in other outcome areas, numerous participants noted that certain things under the outcome of Safe Community made more sense in the environmental and/or social health outcome areas of the budget: “I think that livable communities [are] huge as well as environmental health. I do not appreciate that things like flood mitigation and recreation management is lumped in with community safety.” Important: Neighborhood Livability and Social Health. Conversations about social health focused heavily on conversations on housing affordability throughout the city as well as how to make the community more connected. Here, numerous conversations also included issues of transportation and safety which are their own distinct outcome areas. Various participants noted that, at least for them, social health and livability of our neighborhoods hinged on the ability to feel safe and have access to robust transportation services throughout the city so that they did not feel disconnected from the rest of the community. Other participants noted that increasing diversity and access to cultural events was something they felt belonged in this outcome area as well. “Social health and environmental health. Not necessarily in the way the City describes them, but in terms of true sustainability, equity, and justice in terms of livable wages, land justice, [and] not putting profits and City awards over social and land/climate justice.” “Social health: arts and social cohesion, mental health services. Neighborhood livability: mixed income housing. Many of these are not currently housed in these specific categories of the budget but should be. This further reflects incongruencies between City definitions and community definitions.” Page 130 Item 1. Less Important: Safe Community. When participants prioritized this near the bottom, they noted that while a safe community was something important to them, the way it was defined in the outcome and services being funded did not reflect what they felt “safe community” meant. The most common theme in discussions about safe community was the idea that policing did not make the participants present at these events feel safe and rather they wished more funding would be shifted into items like mental health care, housing affordability, and cultural connections. Here we see participants continued to find disconnections in how they viewed outcomes compared to the way the budget process currently organizes them. In various groups, there was also discussion about how funding could potentially be used differently to help communities feel safer: “Continuing to over-fund the police instead of redirecting those efforts towards social workers will only create a culture of fear. We need a culture of community based on qualified professionals designated to each issue.” Less Important: Recreation. Here, participants deliberately separated culture from recreation, which could be a larger reflection on earlier conversations about how budget outcome areas didn’t necessarily align with the community definitions of them. Many also felt that improvements in the overall culture of our community would come from increased investment in things like neighborhood livability and social health. “Recreation (keeping culture separate though), if culture, environment, and transportation are funded, recreation will occur naturally.” Page 131 Item 1. Reflections on the Engagement Process In their responses, participants identified various issues tied to the current engagement process as well as ongoing needs to feel more included. Lack of accessibility to the engagement process. Numerous participants across conversations seemed to feel as though the City had not put the necessary amount of effort into engaging the public during earliest stages of the budget process. Much of the conversation focused on the idea that a large amount of the opportunities for engagement available required participants to physically go to a space or reach out to City entities to volunteer. They expressed a desire for more City representatives to go into communities and engage directly where they are rather than expecting them to continually show up to outside spaces where they feel less comfortable or have less access. Some participants also mentioned the community survey that was sent out to a random sample throughout the City, stating they felt this was not the most helpful way to gather feedback about such a complex process: “The initial survey, which I took, was designed to skew results and the options were vague enough to not prioritize what residents want. I also think that the accessibility of participation was not there. I wonder who was reached out to, how much time was required to participate, and how clear were the questions.” Value of small group, informative conversations. Respondents spent some time in their groups discussing how beneficial these small group conversations were not only for clarifying some of the complexities of the budget process itself but creating more accessibility and equity in conversations. Some felt as though the current, larger processes tended to privilege the loudest voices and often only reach out to what they called the “usual suspects”. Others noted that while the City did try to make sure to invite diverse audiences, they felt as though only “token minorities” were asked about their experiences. Many felt that small group conversations that included an informative element as well as an opportunity to discuss experiences and priorities were one effective way to try and work against some of these issues and barriers. Over a few groups, we saw mentions in notes that participating in the small Community Guide conversations helped people feel more informed about the budget and more comfortable interacting with it. One key here seemed to be that this process brought our Guides into various communities rather than the other way around. “[I’m] grateful that you would like to hear my voice; I urge you to continue listening to others without my privilege.” “This method of sharing information with the community makes the budget more understandable and accessible.” Page 132 Item 1. Need for increased transparency and communication of impacts. This is a continued trend across various engagement efforts we have participated in throughout the last several years. Conversation among participants was similar in expressing a desire that the City communicate more transparently about how public input is being used to inform decisions. We see this often in small group conversations: participants feel wary about sharing their input because there is a lack of communication about how their voices will materially impact the outcome or decisions. Some participants in these conversations also felt the selection process for the community survey could have been communicated more clearly while others needed more information about how their input was going to be used by the City going forward. Additionally, folks shared their experience with previous input processes (whether they were organized by the City, CSU, or another entity in the community) and how they felt frustrated at the result. “I love the fact that the City is organizing these sessions, but I do wonder if the information will actually have an impact.” “Honestly, I love the idea of making changes and getting the public’s opinion, but this happened with the CSU stadium (survey was given to the public and the majority said no thanks but they built it anyway).” Page 133 Item 1. Advice for Future Engagement Our final question in this process asked participants to provide feedback on how the City could work to improve their engagement processes around the budget. The answers here were various, which serves to reflect the unique engagement needs throughout the community. As practitioners, we know there is not a single solution to many engagement barriers, but we were able to identify three main suggestions reflected in the data. More robust use of various media and personal outreach efforts. Participants belonged to various communities throughout the City and because of this diversity, we heard a variety of answers tied to the type of media people were best able to engage with. Numerous participants shared social media as one of the best ways to keep people throughout the Fort Collins aware of engagement opportunities. However, various other participants said they interacted more easily with hard media like flyers and other items hanging in places throughout the City they visit most often. Some also expressed interest in an email list that would send updates when engagement reports are available or when specific changes are made based upon community input. In addition to this, participants across several meetings also noted a need for City representatives to be more present within the local community. They mentioned that City leaders and others should prioritize time in examining which communities most need outreach and then intentionally working to build connections within those communities by visiting them in person and spending time talking about upcoming opportunities for engagement and information. Increase connections with grassroots organizations/community groups. Another suggestion we saw often in the data encouraged the City to spend more time identifying grassroots and community organizations throughout the City and giving them the funding and tools to do engagement. Many noted that an expansion of the Community Guide process could be a useful tool to make this more successful. Participants stated that many groups within our community are already doing some of this work, but they often lack the funding or other resources to do in on the scale they would like to. “Work with community [organizations]. We have so many connections in the community, are doing work to help meet city priorities, and we’re always overlooked for the help we could provide. We’re here—use us!” Page 134 Item 1. Consistency, accessibility, and transparency. Overall, an underlying theme in most of our guide conversations was tied to needing more consistent engagement opportunities that were accessible to diverse populations across the City and maintaining transparency about the budget process itself as well as where community input goes and what material impacts it has. In terms of accessibility, participants had numerous suggestions like offering more virtual events, scheduling in-person events at various times during the week, offering childcare stipends, and making sure interpretation and translation services were available. The most common suggestion we saw throughout the data was the need for compensation/stipends for participant time. In many conversations, respondents noted how time intensive the budget process could be and highlighted how challenging it can be for many local community members to volunteer time in the process. They stated that one of the most effective ways to remove this barrier would be to make sure people who participate in engagement processes are compensated for their time. Ultimately, participants in these conversations wanted to see what changes their input was making in local decisions and they were hopeful the City could be more consistent in communicating those impacts. The participants our guides engaged throughout this process expressed a strong desire to be more consistently included in engagement opportunities throughout the City, but wanted to feel like their time was valued, their voice would have an impact, and that the end result would be a reflection of their needs and input. A note on engagement fatigue. Throughout the community, we have seen a continued trend of engagement fatigue: community members wanting to have their voices heard and have an impact on local decisions, but also feeling overwhelmed by various overlapping engagement opportunities and perhaps frustrated at a lack of clear communication about how their input is having an impact. We have seen lower than average turnout in several events in last 1-2 years. This can be connected to several factors: continued impacts of COVID-19 on participant comfort during in person events, the complexity of the issue, over engagement across multiple channels, and various barriers like lack of transportation, lack of available childcare, etc. In the sections above, there are various recommendations to addressing these issues which are helpful to consider as we work to engage our community around important issues like this one. There is no one cause of lower attendance but recognizing these various issues and constraints while working to provide the most accessible engagement possible is vital. We can do this work by doing things like: utilizing a Language Justice model in our events, working to identify ways to provide compensation for participants, and identifying ways we can provide transportation access and childcare so more community members are able to participate. Page 135 Item 1. Conclusion We would like to reiterate our deep gratitude to the Community Guides who participated in this process. We deeply value their dedication and the time they spent crafting their conversations, inviting participants, and coordinating data drop off. None of the work we do in these spaces would be possible without passionate and committed community members like these. It was clear through the data that these conversations had a positive impact on their participants, and many left their conversations feeling more informed about the process itself. Most importantly, they were able to sit down together and have important conversations with others in our community. That is vital. Engaging the community on complex issues like the budget is incredibly challenging, but our participants also provided us with helpful feedback on how we can all continue to improve the work we do to in engagement spaces. We are hopeful this input is put to good use as the City continues to work on adopting the 2023-2024 budget. Page 136 Item 1. City of Fort Collins Budget Process Summary Sabrina Slagowski-Tipton Prepared for the City of Fort Collins by the Center for Public Deliberation Page 137 Item 1. Executive Summary On Wednesday, September 28th, the Center for Public Deliberation (CPD) and City of Fort Collins partnered to host an event for community members to interact with budget offers and work through an activity-based budget process with other participants. 29 community members attended this event and approximately 20 CPD students serviced as facilitators, note takers, and in some cases stayed to observe or participate in the conversations themselves. Each table also had one City employee whose task was to help clarify or explain specific budget offers as participants worked through the activity. During the meeting, community members worked together to select an outcome area they wanted to discuss and then CPD student facilitators led them through an activity which asked them to look through current funded and unfunded offers in the recommended budget and decide where they might shift funding. The process utilized colored poker chips: green for funded offers and yellow for unfunded offers which were separated into two piles. In each outcome, there was a maximum number of offers that could receive funding and each group’s task was to decide which offers to fund and unfund through group consensus. Once decisions were made, participants could move chips over into the pile of funded offers. After the activity, participants were asked reflection questions about the process itself and also how the City could better engage the local community conversations about the budget. This summary will focus on recommendations for future engagement that were taken from table notes, student comments in their process reflections, and responses to a post event survey sent to all participants. Advice for Future Engagement Utilize Language Justice Consistently. We translated all participant materials and surveys into Spanish for this event, and incorporated Language Justice interpretation during the event. Five Spanish speakers registered to attend, though a few had to cancel their RSVP on the day of the event due to conflicting responsibilities. Reflections in the table notes show that Spanish speaking participants generally still feel excluded from numerous City engagement opportunities, and this is especially true for opportunities around the budget due to lack of available Spanish resources. For example, none of the budget offers or budget summaries were available in Spanish, the CPD had to translate these various materials for the purpose of the activity. Going forward, it may be useful to make sure all public-facing aspects of the budget can be available in both English and Spanish. Page 138 Item 1. Additionally, Spanish speakers at the table noted their frustration in having to request Spanish interpretation at City events rather than simply having it available. The table discussion and student reflections of the process noted how this often creates additional barriers for community members who want to engage but are unsure events will be accessible to them. It also places the burden on our community members to make sure they have the interpretation services they need rather than having the same access as English speakers. Incorporating Language Justice into community engagement events takes considerable time and effort, as well as the associated cost, but in our work throughout the community we have seen how offering translation and interpretation as a standard practice has increased access to our events and has helped many participants who often feel unwelcome or uncomfortable feel as though they can truly have a voice in important community discussions. The Value of Activity Based Interactions. In table conversations, student reflections, and the post event survey, participants discussed ways the City could better engage the community around the budget. Invariably we heard “more events like this”. The process itself was complex and at times confusing (which reflects the complexity of the budget itself) but participants at each table noted they felt the exercise and conversation element helped them understand the complexity a bit better. Additionally, for some participants it helped them understand how much they didn’t know about the budget. Many participants also noted the value of having this activity to help them understand the difficult decisions that come with funding various services and offers across the City. At one table, their decisions were made more difficult by the realization that many of the offers listed had jobs attached to them. If they removed funding, they would also be removing a job. The activity helped participants not only understand the complexity of the budget itself, but also the human element behind many of the offers. Some groups were only able to move one chip or reallocate funding from 1 or 2 budget offers. Participants noted this was because once they fully understood what the offer was funding, it became incredibly difficult to grapple with the potential tradeoffs of removing funding. Others noted the activity and collaboration element helped diffuse tensions that sometimes come up in conversations about the budget and participants were grateful for the work done by table facilitators to ensure all voices were heard and everyone had an opportunity to learn from one another. After the event, a brief survey was sent to all participants to better understand their experiences and solicit advice for how we could improve our activity for future events. Participants were asked to rank their responses to the following questions on a 4-point scale: 1. The process helped me understand the budget a bit better: Average 3.27 2. The facilitated conversation felt useful and robust: Average 3.45 3. City officials at the table helped clarify complex points: Average 3.63 As of 10/4/2022 we had received 11 responses to the survey. Page 139 Item 1. Overall, participants felt this activity was a good use of their time and they left the event feeling more informed. Many also mentioned that having City officials sitting down amongst participants at tables was encouraging; they appreciated having the ability to have a face-to-face interpersonal conversation. This is reflected not only in responses to the post event survey, but also in table notes and student comments about the process. A Need for More Accessible/Less Complex Information. During the activity, participants often struggled to figure out what each budget offer was funding, and they mentioned the names of the offers were quite confusing. Many mentioned it would be helpful for the names to be a bit clearer so folks could understand them briefly without having to reference other materials. Across numerous tables, our participants mentioned a need for more accessible information to the innerworkings of the budget so they could then work together to make a more informed decision. Often, we heard our participants say they simply did not have enough information about what each budget offer meant to truly decide about whether it should be funded or not. This was echoed in facilitator reflections as well. Our student facilitators noted a big challenge in making sure the conversation continued flowing and didn’t become and question and answer session with the City official at the table. This was a struggle because of the complexity of many of the offers. Most of our facilitators mentioned this process would have been easier if the names of the budget offers were more self-explanatory or if there was a single-sentence explanation of each offer so they could rely less on the City experts and spend more time in the activity. There was a strong desire to have this information condensed and clarified in a way that would be accessible for the average community member, not only in the language used but in the time it takes to read through all of the material that is currently available. Overall, participants were Page 140 Item 1. After the budgeting activity, each table was asked to provide three words to describe their process. They are reflected in the above image pleasantly surprised at how transparent the City was being about information in the budget, but they wanted that information to be simplified considerably. Additionally, numerous participants noted they weren’t aware of all the ways they could learn about and engage around the budget, so they hoped for more clear communication about all those opportunities as well. This was especially true about earlier stages of the budget process. Participants at this event asked often how they could become involved in these engagement opportunities before the budget offers were set and the recommended budget was created. Going forward, it will be helpful for the City to clarify those opportunities and perhaps provide more activity-based events to help community members interact with the budget throughout the creation and adoption processes. When asked how the City could communicate this information more effectively, participants mentioned a variety of modes: social media, newsletters, a larger presence on CSU’s campus and hard media in grocery stores and other areas. Final Thoughts In our Community Guide conversations over the summer and during this event, we recognized the passion many in our local community have about discussing the budget as well as the various reasons why they are unable to fully engage during different stages of the process. We are hopeful that the time our community members spent in these important conversations and their feedback will be considered as the City continues to work on improving engagement around the budget and numerous other issues. Page 141 Item 1. 2023-2024 Budget Review City Council Work Session #3 –October 11, 2022Page 142 Item 1. 22022 Council Meetings on the 2023-2024 Budget September 13th Work Session •Culture and Recreation •Economic Health •Neighborhood Livability and Social Health September 27th Work Session •Transportation and Mobility •Environmental Health •Safe Community •High Performing Government September 20th Council Meeting •Budget Public Hearing #1 of 2 October 11th Work Session •Budget Public Hearing #2 of 2October 4th Council Meeting •General Discussion –Final Council Direction November 1st Council Meeting •First Reading November 15th Council Meeting •Second Reading We are here Page 143 Item 1. 3Public Engagement Summary •Methods: –Animated Budget 101 videos in English/Spanish –Collaboration with CSU Center for Public Deliberation (CPD) o Community guided conversations o Interactive community event on September 28 –OurCity project page with online engagement activities in both English/Spanish –Website and social media promotion o Budget-in-Briefs provide more accessible information –Public Hearings –Community Survey Budget in Brief –Published in Spanish and English –24 pages –Available in hard copy –www.fcgov.com/budget Page 144 Item 1. 4Public Engagement Summary •Participation: –OurCity o 1,600 total page visits to https://ourcity.fcgov.com/23-24budget o 1,100 aware visitors / 599 informed visitors / 151 engaged visitors o 128 survey responses o 118 ideas submitted –Social Media o Facebook 24,000 impressions o Twitter 1,000 impressions o YouTube 3,400 views –Center for Public Deliberation (CPD) o Community Guides: 7 guides led conversations with 40 community members o Community Event: 29 community members and 20 CPD participants Page 145 Item 1. Community Survey Overview •Spring administration: April-May •3,800 random households •134 vacancy returns •652 completed (18% response rate) •Online opt-in version •Open for two weeks •185 responses •Demographic & geographic comparisons •Three questions specific to strategic planning and funding 5 Page 146 Item 1. 6Community Survey Results Top 3 Priorities Page 147 Item 1. 7Community Survey Results Outcome Area More Effort Same Effort Less Effort Economy 49%49%3% Environment 64%31%4% NLSH 62%30%8% Safe Community 22%72%6% Culture & Rec 26%72%2% Transportation & Mobility 51%47%2% General Government 18%75%7% Page 148 Item 1. 1.Affordable housing 2.Environmental issues 3.Growth and development issues Other common themes: -Traffic and roads -Transportation improvements -Cost of living/economy/jobs -Safety/police/homelessness -Government policies, spending, service delivery -Diversity, equity & inclusion 8Open-ended responses What’s the most important thing to focus on and why? “As a young professional, I find it difficult to find affordable housing. The lack of affordable housing will reduce the diversity of the city.” “While affordable housing is high on my list, climate change is quickly and severely impacting our area. Water conservation, solar energy, electric cars should be a priority.” Page 149 Item 1. 9Additional Considerations City Park Train: –$350K of voter-approved funding is insufficient for the current estimated cost of $5.1M due to necessary relocation of tennis/pickleball. –Staff will bring a Council Resolution concurrent to the Budget recommending the project be declared financially infeasible Minimum Wage: –Current budget is based on $15/hour; moving to $19 in a future budget cycle is estimated to increase ongoing costs by $3.0M, including the impact of wage compression. Page 150 Item 1. 10 Offers of Interest by City Council Page 151 Item 1. 11Additional Offers of Interest by Council •City Council has expressed interest in finding a way to fund a number of budget requests (offers) that were not included in the 2023-2024 City Manager’s Recommended Budget •Staff has reviewed these requests comprehensively and organized them into five categories A.Offers to include for 1st Reading with specific funding source recommendations B.Offers to include for 1st Reading funded by options available to Council C.Offers of interest to Council –More discussion needed D.Offers recommended to stay unfunded relative to other priorities E.Offers for possible consideration in the 2024 Budget Revision process Page 152 Item 1. 12A) Offers to include for 1st Reading with specific funding sources All values in 1,000s * * Indicates offer scaled down from unfunded amount in Recommended Budget* 2023 2024 2023 2024 C&R Offer 43.28 - Customer Database and Registration Software Upgrade 274-Recreation Fund: Reserves 80 80 ECON Offer 2.20 - Utilities: Light & Power - 2.0 FTE Electrical Engineer (Scaled down to 1.0 FTE)501-Light and Power Fund: Ongoing Revenue 129 135 T&M Offer 27.15 - 1.0 FTE Shift Your Ride Travel Options Program Professional (Scaling proposal: Add 1.0 FTE into Offer 27.13, but keep offer total at $200k by reducing programming dollars)Not applicable - - 129 135 80 80 Outcome Offer Number and Title Funding Source(s)` Ongoing Costs One-Time Costs Page 153 Item 1. 2023 2024 2023 2024 C&R Offer 54.8 - Parks Landscape Conversion and Irrigation Infrastructure Replacement 100-General Fund: Reserves - 65 NLSH Offer 24.8 - Immigration Legal Fund 100-General Fund: Reserves 250 250 NLSH Offer 31.17 - ARPA - Social Services Recovery Grants (Scaled down to $180k per year) 100-General Fund: ARPA (freed up from shifting partial funding for Offer 17.10-ARPA - Future of Work to General Fund Reserves) 180 180 NLSH Offer 23.26 - Advancing Accessible Permitting 100-General Fund: ARPA (freed up from shifting partial funding for Offer 17.10-ARPA - Future of Work to General Fund Reserves) 158 - NLSH Offer 24.12 - Mobile Home Park Code Compliance Program 100-General Fund: Reserves 50 50 T&M Offer 27.14 - School Transportation Safety Assessments and Strategic Infrastructure for Youth 100-General Fund: Reserves 100 61 ENV Offer 1.24 - Household Hazardous Waste Collection (Scaled down to one event in 2023) 100-General Fund: Reserves ($102k) 504-Stormwater Fund: Reserves ($82k) 184 - ENV Offer 35.13 - Legislative Management System Evaluation and Implementation 100-General Fund: Reserves 150 100 250 250 822 456 One-Time Costs Outcome Offer Number and Title Funding Source(s)` Ongoing Costs 13B) Offers to include for 1st Reading funded by options available to Council All values in 1,000s Indicates offer scaled down from unfunded amount in Recommended Budget Indicates offer shifted out by one year ** * ** * * Page 154 Item 1. 14C) Offers of interest to Council –More information needed All values in 1,000s *** * * *** Indicates offer scaled down from unfunded amount in Recommended Budget Indicates offer shifted out by one year*** 2023 2024 2023 2024 C&R Offer 50.16 - Museum of Discovery Artifact Housing Furniture TBD if guided by Council to fund 300 - NLSH Offer 23.17 - 1 FTE - Historic Preservation Surveyor Specialist TBD if guided by Council to fund 60 84 NLSH Offer 23.20 - 2.0 FTE Landscape Inspectors - Development Review (Scaled down to 1.0 FTE starting in 2024)TBD if guided by Council to fund - 105 NLSH Offer 59.6 - Urban Forest Strategic Plan TBD if guided by Council to fund 231 - NLSH Offer 71.1 - Assessment of Citywide Organizational Practices and Structure to Deliver on Compliance with Local Policies TBD if guided by Council to fund 90 - T&M Offer 36.13 - School Zone Safety Flasher Upgrade (Scaled down to $100k)TBD if guided by Council to fund 100 - T&M Offer 7.10 - 1.0 FTE Street Sweeper Operator TBD if guided by Council to fund 76 93 T&M Offer 36.9 - Neighborhood Traffic Mitigation Program Expansion (Scaled in half each year)TBD if guided by Council to fund 65 65 ENV Offer 32.12 - Innovate Fort Collins Challenge (Scaled down to $100k only in 2024)TBD if guided by Council to fund - 100 SAFE Offer 4.54 - Utilities: Water Quality Services - 1.0 FTE Watershed Specialist TBD if guided by Council to fund 83 104 284 451 721 100 Outcome Offer Number and Title Funding Source(s)` Ongoing Costs One-Time Costs Page 155 Item 1. 15D) Offers recommended to stay unfunded relative to other priorities All values in 1,000s 2023 2024 2023 2024 C&R Offer 54.13 - Fossil Creek Synthetic Turf Field Conversion 420 4,200 C&R Offer 54.4 - 2.0 FTE Infrastructure Replacement Program Data Management 179 219 ECON Offer 33.8 - ARPA 1.0 FTE Contractual Econ Specialist, Small Business & Impacted Sector Grants 1,065 1,081 ECON Offer 26.3 - 1.0 FTE Contractual to Classified Civil Engineer I for Broadband/Small Cell Design 18 30 NLSH Offer 23.18 - 3.75 FTE - Building Services Staffing (2 FTE Building Inspectors, 1.75 FTE BDRT) 186 276 NLSH Offer 23.11 - On-Call Contract for Building & Development Review Professional Services 60 - ENV Offer 1.10 - ARPA - Utilities Light & Power: 1.0 FTE Contractual Project Manager & Manufactured Home Efficiency Acceleration Initiative 188 189 ENV Offer 32.19 - 1.0 FTE - Municipal Industrial Recycling Senior Specialist 95 122 SAFE Offer 4.48 - Utilities: 1.0 FTE Construction Inspector 67 34 HPG Offer 82.2 - Municipal Innovation Program 100 100 833 970 1,545 5,281 Outcome Offer Number and Title Ongoing Costs One-Time Costs Page 156 Item 1. 16E) Offers for possible consideration in the 2024 Budget Revision process All values in 1,000s 2023 2024 2023 2024 C&R Offer 54.6 - Rolland Moore Park Infrastructure Replacement 2,879 ENV Offer 15.11 - City Facility Exterior Lighting: Dark Sky Assessment and Conversion to LED 150 150 SAFE Offer 68.9 - Municipal Court - 2.0 FTE Court Clerks (1 FTE added per year) 64 139 214 289 - 2,879 Outcome Offer Number and Title Ongoing Costs One-Time Costs Page 157 Item 1. 17 Funding Options Page 158 Item 1. 18Available Funding •The executive team convened to discuss all available funding options •Increasing the Sales Tax revenue forecast is not a recommended option •Funding Options –Repurpose $200k per year of Conservation Trust moneys –Decrease Immigration Legal Fund by $100k per year to the current level of funding of $150k per year –Deeper use of General Fund reserves, which takes away from future budget cycles (see table on next slide) •The Recommended Budget includes $1.95M of reductions to Ongoing Offers •Staff re-evaluated Recommended Offers for trade-off opportunities and stand by the initial recommendations •All Enhancement Offers are trade-off opportunities, generally without decreasing current levels of service Page 159 Item 1. 19General Fund Reserve Overview •2021 Year end Unassigned = $5.7M of which none is remaining •2021 Year end Assignments = $13.1M of which $7.3M is still available •Historic practice is to not use anticipated current-year (2022) reserve increases in the subsequent year’s budget –i.e., 2023-24’s budget would only use “known, in -the-bank” reserves from 2021 –Current-year reserve generation would typically be available to the 2024 Revision process and/or the 2025-2026 BFO Cycle –Current year forecasts indicate a potential $9.0M financial favorability, net of critical City asset investments and an estimated cost of $400k for the November 2022 elections •Staff recommends limiting additional reserve usage to $3.3M •Funding offers in Categories A and B in 1st Reading would utilize $1.9M of that $3.3M Page 160 Item 1. 20Questions for City Council 1.Which offers does Council have interest in including in 1st reading of the 2023-2024 Budget, including preferred funding sources? 2.What clarifying questions does City Council have on any of the Offers in the seven Outcomes discussed in the previous budget work sessions? Page 161 Item 1. 212022 Council Meetings on the 2023-2024 Budget September 13th Work Session •Culture and Recreation •Economic Health •Neighborhood Livability and Social Health September 27th Work Session •Transportation and Mobility •Environmental Health •Safe Community •High Performing Government September 20th Council Meeting •Budget Public Hearing #1 of 2 October 11th Work Session •Budget Public Hearing #2 of 2October 4th Council Meeting •General Discussion –Final Council Direction November 1st Council Meeting •First Reading November 15th Council Meeting •Second Reading We are here Page 162 Item 1. 22 Backup Slides Page 163 Item 1. 23Summary of Council Requested Follow Ups Request Received # of Requests Sept 13 work session 20 Emails 35 Sept 27 work session 14 Total 69 Responded # Answered Sept 22 Packet Memo 18 During work session (emails)5 Sept 29 Packet Memo 5 Oct 6 Packet Memo 41 Total 69 * * 2 requests were answered in a single response Page 164 Item 1. 24 2020 2021 Appropriat ed, Min. Policy, o r Sch edu led Available but w ith some Constraint s Availab le f or Nearly Any Purp ose Assign ed - Min imum 60 day Policy 31.0$ 34.2$ 34.2$ -$ -$ No n-sp end able Landbank inv entor y 2.8 2.5 2.5 - - Udall Endowment 0.1 0.1 0.1 Rest rict ed T ABO R Emer genc y 6.7 7.7 7.7 - - Polic e Radio Network 0.2 0.3 0.1 0.2 - Donations & Mis c 0.6 1.0 0.4 0.6 - Co mmit ted T r affic Calming 0.1 - - - - Cultur e & Rec reation 0.3 0.3 - 0.3 - Affordable Hous ing Land Bank 0.1 0.1 - 0.1 - Polic e Regional Tr aining F ac ility 0.1 0.1 - 0.1 - Assign ed Pr ior Year Pur c has e O rder s 4.0 6.9 6.9 - - Manufac turing Us e Tax Rebate 0.4 0.2 0.2 - - Digital Equity - 0.1 - - 0.1 G olf Ir r igation Sy s tem 0.4 0.4 0.4 - - Camer a Radar 1.4 1.2 - - 1.2 Was te Innov ation 0.2 0.2 - - 0.2 Cultur al Serv ic es 0.4 0.5 - - 0.5 Reappropr iation 0.9 0.8 0.8 - - Budgeted us e of r es er v es 7.9 5.5 5.5 - - Child Care Needs 0.3 0.3 - - 0.3 Polic e Programming 0.6 0.6 0.6 - - Hughes Land Purc has e - 2.0 - - 2.0 ERP Replac ement - 2.5 - - 2.5 Munic ipal Court Renov ation - 3.0 0.7 - 2.3 Inflation Contingenc y - 4.0 - - 4.0 Un assigned 4.3 12.0 6.3 - 5.7 Year End T otal 62.8$ 86.5$ 66.4$ 1.3$ 18.8$ General Fund - Year End 2021 - $86.5M General Fund summary of reserves as of year-end 2021 Page 165 Item 1. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 1 of 6 October 11, 2022 WORK SESSION AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY City Council STAFF Honoré Depew, Climate Program Manager John Phelan, Energy Services Manager and Policy Advisor Molly Saylor, Lead Specialist, Waste Reduction and Recycling SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION Our Climate Future Implementation. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this item is to provide Councilmembers with clear information about how the Fort Collins community can make progress towards the goals laid out in the Our Climate Future plan for waste, renewable electricity, and greenhouse gas (GHG) reductions. Based on greenhouse gas and waste forecasts between 2021 and 2030, staff has provided a “roadmap” of Council actions to be considered in the years ahead that advance strategies to help reach Council- adopted goals. Councilmembers will review the 2021 inventory of community greenhouse gas emissions along with forecasted emissions projections by sector and will be asked to use those forecasts to offer guidance on where to set a 2026 interim GHG goal for the community. GENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED 1. How does the content and timing of the Council Action Roadmap align with Councilmember priorities? 2. What target would Councilmembers like to consider for the 2026 interim GHG goal at the October 25 meeting? BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION The decade ahead is a critical time for the action local governments must take to address the climate emergency. During Council’s Our Climate Future (OCF) Work Session (in April 2022), Councilmembers reviewed the extensive, leading-edge engagement work that led to developing Our Climate Future as a visionary, guiding framework for the Fort Collins community. Councilmembers expressed that they understood OCF to represent an actionable community vision and a “roadmap” was requested for clear steps that could be considered in the coming years to help Fort Collins do its part to: Page 166 Item 2. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 2 of 6 1. Minimize the worst impacts of the Climate Emergency (emissions mitigation); 2. Adapt to climate impacts that are increasing in frequency and severity (resilience); and 3. Transition to a cleaner, healthier future in a just and fair way (equity). OCF is a framework for accomplishing community and Council environmental priorities using a data - informed, systems-based approach. The robust modeling tool staff has developed to organize and track strategies and outcomes and also maps out important decision points and milestones for Council actions along the way. Our Climate Future Background Adopted by Council in April 2021, OCF is an integrated update of the Climate Action Plan, Energy Policy, and Road to Zero Waste that articulates the community’s vision for a sustainable future. OCF reinforces Fort Collins’ deep commitment to mitigating and adapting to climate change and meeting energy and waste goals with a people-first systems approach. This means community members’ voices and priorities are at the center of solutions and are summed up in the Big Moves attachment including 13 visionary outcomes. Specific strategies associated with the Big Moves are called Next Moves. These actionable strategies are evaluated for their impact on goals, benefits and costs, potential results for improving equity and resilience, and what it will take to implement them. Next Moves also have defined implementation mechanisms and defined roles for the City and other stakeholders. That modeling of the Next Moves is what informs both the Pathways to 2030 and the Council OCF Action Roadmap, described in the following sections. 2021 Community GHG Inventory The Community GHG Inventory is one tool used to track climate action efforts made by the City and community. Results reflect these actions as well as external factors that influence GHG emissions (e.g., COVID-19 in 2020). For 2021, the Community Inventory shows 24% from the 2005 baseline, which is a slight loss of progress from 2020 (also reported as 24% below 2005 baseline), based on the following factors:  Vehicle use and transportation emissions increased compared to 2020, though still below 2019 levels (increase in emissions)  Utility-scale renewable electricity continued to increase (decrease in emissions)  Abatement of Industrial Process and Product Use (IPPU) emissions increased (decrease in emissions) GHG inventories continually evolve as sources and methodology are updated. Please note that final waste and IPPU emissions are not yet included in this estimate. The Pathways to 2030 GHG Reduction Goals  Pathways are groups of Next Moves (strategies) that drive towards a specific outcome (e.g., the transportation pathway, which includes Next Moves for transit, active modes, and vehicle electrification). They are high-impact strategies that include, though not limited to, Council actions.  The current total estimated potential from all the quantified Pathways is a 70% GHG emissions reduction by 2030. See Figure 1 below.  The gap between this projection and the 80% by 2030 target will primarily need to be addressed by additional community/partner action and will also be influenced by external factors. The Pathways depicted below focus mainly on mitigation. At the same time, equitable processes and outcomes, community partnerships, and building community resilience are woven into the strategies and Page 167 Item 2. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 3 of 6 are often synergistic. Staff is also committed to using this pathways framework to explore equity and resilience focused strategies in the coming years. Figure 1: Pathways towards the 2030 Greenhouse Gas Reduction Goal The attached OCF Pathways - Descriptions & Methodology describes each of the Next Moves that were included in the Pathways and their respective estimated GHG reduction potential. Staff approached these estimates with the following methodology:  Referencing existing plans and commitments (e.g., Transit Master Plan, City Plan) and potential impact of strategies;  Checking these assumptions with staff experts across the City;  Gathering data and assumptions from other trusted sources (e.g., North Front Range Metropolitan Planning Organization’s transportation model);  Projecting historical trends (e.g., average household electricity consumption); and  Determining reasonable forecasts for participation and efficacy rates, usually based on Fort Collins ’ and/or other communities’ results. Interim GHG Goal In support of Council establishing an additional interim goal between now and 2030, staff have projected the community GHG inventory for 2026. If all the strategies in the pathways modeled above were implemented, the expected community inventory in 2026 will be approximately 43% below the 2005 baseline. (This is an estimate due to many variables affecting our community inventory; the range is between 28% and 48% below baseline.) Pathways Electricity Buildings Industrial Manufacturing Transportation Waste Land Use Undetermined to Goal 2030 24.5% 15.0% 4.5% 4.0% 0.9% 0.1% 10% Page 168 Item 2. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 4 of 6 Figure 2: Interim Greenhouse Gas Target, 2026 That possible target of 43% assumes policy and infrastructure investments that will require hard decisions and tradeoffs. If Council wishes to create an even more ambitious stretch goal, staff analysis shows that additional strategies will need to be identified, existing strategies will need to be accelerated, and/or additional community leadership and action would be needed. While there are likely more strategies that can be identified, those in the modeled pathways represent the most significant interventions, so additional strategies may not deliver the same levels of impact. If a Resolution is adopted, staff recommends choosing 2026 as the target year for an interim goal because it falls halfway between the current year and 2030, allowing for two full City budget cycles before and after the interim goal year. Pathways to Zero Waste by 2030 Figure 3: Pathways to 2030 Zero Waste Goal 15% Landfilled Page 169 Item 2. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 5 of 6 The three identified pathways are highlighted in Figure 3 above, and additional detail about the strategies within each pathway are described in the Pathways - Descriptions & Methodology attachment. Key waste pathway assumptions and context:  Waste policy conversations are dependent upon infrastructure projects, which must be in place for waste diversion to occur.  Staff determined milestone years using available planning information and similar projects’ timelines.  If key infrastructure (e.g., a composting facility for yard trimmings, etc.) is constructed later than indicated in planning materials, policy work and related waste diversion would also shift.  Two key pieces of infrastructure are currently unscheduled in regional planning materials: the composting facility for food scraps and the construction and demolition materials sorting facility. o Staff modeled these projects conservatively and as occurring in the latter half of the decade. When more specific timing information is available, staff will update modeling accordingly. Identified pathways get Fort Collins to 27% of waste being landfilled in 2030 (otherwise known as a diversion rate of 73%). Addressing the remaining 27% of materials requires action in two distinct areas, each making up roughly half of the needed diversion:  Community participation: once regional infrastructure and policies are in place, individuals and businesses need to fully utilize the programs to ensure the system achieves its full potential. o Community leadership, supported by City programs, will be required to close participation and efficacy gaps in current and new recycling systems.  Addressing challenging materials: cities with zero waste goals are collectively experiencing a “ceiling” of around 15% materials that are not feasible to recycle. These materials include complex consumer products not designed to be recyclable, hazardous and contaminated materials, etc. o This 15% line is indicated on Figure 3 o These materials are best addressed by specialized strategies, for example:  Building upon the recently adopted Expanded Producer Responsibility (EPR) legislation at the state level to incentivize recyclable product design;  Expanding circular economy industry leadership (starting with circular economy focus in the current update to the Economic Health Strategic Plan); and  Supporting community leadership to reduce consumption and increase reuse. Council OCF Action Roadmap For decades, those serving on Council have reflected community desire for environmental leadership by adopting ambitious goals for climate, renewable electricity, and waste and supporting strategies to advance towards those goals. That long history of leadership to use environmental lenses in planning and policy development means implementation strategies across the organization already align with OCF outcomes, as do many of the specific priorities set by Council. This alignment is reflected in: Page 170 Item 2. City Council Work Session Agenda Item Summary – City of Fort Collins Page 6 of 6  Council’s current workplan, which directly supports OCF Big Moves; and  Councilmembers request for clear actions to reach 2030 waste, energy, and climate goals. Council regularly works at all levels to enact sustainability measures, from passing building code changes (direct impact) to funding rebate programs (incentivizing) to serving on regional boards and committees (Regional Wasteshed, Platte River Power Authority, etc.) and everything in between. The Council OCF Action Roadmap is a tool for confirming, organizing, and sequencing important Council decision points. The actions on the roadmap are not exhaustive of everything Council, staff or the community will do to achieve the 2030 goals – they represent Council’s highest impact tools (policy making, infrastructure, and funding). Council also employs other tools that will be critical in the success of OCF overall, including fostering partnerships and educational behavior change. Community Action and Going Beyond the Roadmap Council acts as a major leader on climate, waste, and energy in the Fort Collins community and beyond - - reaching adopted goals will require new leaders to join in. Solidifying Council’s workplan will help give shape to City-led efforts over the next decade and help expand focus to scaling community-led action, as well as building the skills needed to lead together (co-led action). Once the City’s most impactful levers, as described in the Roadmap, have been pulled, much of the remaining potential rests in scaling community action and leadership. Council has already helped strengthen this element of OCF through the 2023/24 budget and staff will continue to work with the community and Council to grow this capacity. NEXT STEPS • October 18 • Land Use Code Update – Phase I • October 25 • Interim GHG Goal Resolution • Active Modes Plan Work Session • 15-minute City Work Session • November 1 • 2023/24 City Budget Adoption • December 6 • Active Modes Plan Adoption • December 13 • Sustainable Revenue Work Session ATTACHMENTS 1. Big Moves 2. Pathways - Descriptions & Methodology 3. Council OCF Action Roadmap 4. Presentation Page 171 Item 2. WELCOME TO FORT COLLINS’ OUR CLIMATE FUTURE PLAN This Plan is our community guide to creating the carbon neutral, zero waste and 100% renewable electricity future we desire while improving our community equity and resilience. Our Climate Future articulates an unwavering commitment to mitigating and adapting to climate change with a comprehensive approach that puts people first. Our Climate Future implementation intensifies our efforts towards these primary environmental goals: •Reduce 2030 greenhouse gas emissions by 80% below 2005 baseline levels; •Provide 100% renewable electricity by 2030 with grid and local sources and •Achieve zero waste, or 100% landfill diversion, by 2030. PUTTING PEOPLE FIRST Our Climate Future recognizes that if everyone is to benefit from these efforts, we must intentionally put people at the center of the work to harness the skills and passion of the residents and businesses who call Fort Collins home. When we redesign our efforts to put people, their respective communities and community-defined priorities at the center of our approach, with technical solutions serving and uplifting those priorities, climate action becomes a catalyst for addressing many of our challenges, from affordable housing, to a healthy economy, to convenient ways to get around. Our Climate Future embodies a systems-approach for solutions which address climate, energy and waste goals while positively impacting the daily lives of residents, business operations and supporting community-defined sustainability priorities. Together, Big and Next Moves increase community capacity to: •Draw down greenhouse gas emissions, waste and energy use, while increasing renewable electricity, carbon sequestration and waste prevention; •Co-create and share community leadership to develop partnerships for implementation; •Adapt to a changing climate to improve community resilience; •Plan for investment in a portfolio of strategies which provide net benefits; •Ensure all parts of the community are included and see themselves in the solutions proposed; and •Track the goals to measure success and progress toward achieving sustainability and resilience. BIG AND NEXT MOVES Big Moves is the Our Climate Future way of describing the transformational outcomes which connect our specific goals for climate, energy and waste with the community’s definition of a sustainable Fort Collins. Next Moves are the specific strategies and tactics that lead to transformational outcomes of the Big Moves. Each Big Move has an associated set of Next Moves. The Next Moves are evaluated for their impact on goals, benefits and costs, potential results for improving equity and resilience. OCF PLAN AND BIG MOVES Page 172 Item 2. THIRTEEN BIG MOVES FOR OUR CLIMATE FUTURE11 BETTER TOGETHER 1 - Shared Leadership and Community Partnership: Centered in equity and leading with race, all parts of our community lead, implement and benefit from Our Climate Future. 2 - Zero Waste Neighborhoods: We can all share and reuse so we don’t have to buy things we won’t regularly use and are able to recycle or compost the rest. 3 - Climate Resilient Community: People, buildings, watersheds and ecosystems are prepared for the threats of climate change. LIVE BETTER 4 - Convenient Transportation Choices: It is safe, easy, fast and affordable to get around without a car. 5 - Live, Work and Play Nearby: No matter where we live, we all can meet our basic daily needs without driving across town. 6 - Efficient, Emissions Free Buildings: Everyone lives and works in healthy energy and water efficient buildings which transition to become emissions free. 7 - Healthy Affordable Housing: Everyone has healthy, stable housing they can afford. 8 - Local, Affordable and Healthy Food: Everyone has access to healthy and affordable food, sourced or rescued from local and regional producers. RESOURCE BETTER 9 - Healthy Local Economy and Jobs: The community supports a healthy innovative local economy with new opportunities for all people and businesses to thrive. 10 - Zero Waste Economy: Business, industry, institutions, and government collaborate to recirculate resources and eliminate waste. BREATHE BETTER 11 - Healthy Natural Spaces: We all are stewards of healthy natural spaces and honor the deep and historical human connection to this land. 12 - 100% Renewable Electricity: Everyone in the community receives affordable and reliable 100% renewable electricity, including from local sources. 13 - Electric Cars and Fleets: Residents can afford and use electric cars, including shared electric cars, and conventional fleets are converted to electric. 1 The Big Move numbering is for easy referencing; the order does not imply priorities of any kind. OUR CLIMATE FUTURE AND YOU This plan is about you and is an invitation to lead. Because this plan is about all of our futures, it will take all parts of our community to ensure the future is equitable, climate resilient, carbon neutral, renewable, and zero waste. Whether you are a resident, business owner, community institution, or visitor, consider this an invitation to get involved and find your place of action and leadership in Our Climate Future. See the Our Climate Future Action Guide for a starting point of ideas to get started. Auxiliary aids and services are available for persons with disabilities. V/TDD: 711 21-23703 Page 173 Item 2. OCF Pathways – Descriptions and Methodology The tables below summarize each of the Next Moves (strategies) that was quantified and included in one of the six pathways, including greenhouse gas or waste potential reduction, the tool or implementation mechanism, and the City’s role in that strategy. Staff developed a tool called the Moves Assessment to complete these quantifications, and which also holds progress updates and status, links to Big Moves and Pathways, funding, project lead, and several classifications (e.g., implementation mechanism as shown below). The reports below are the outputs of this tool, and are easily adjusted as staff receives new data and assumptions. Staff can provide more information about this tool if requested. Table 1: Greenhouse gas reduction potential of Pathways. Pathway Next Move Implementation Mechanism City's Role in Implementation Community Emissions Avoided in 2030 (MTCO2e) Buildings 350,796 Construction 0043: Develop and Implement an energy performance path for new construction to zero carbon building by 2030 Regulatory Direct 7,889 Electrification 0045: Continue to provide and expand on programs for electrification of space and water heating Economic Incentivize 6,471 Performance 0044: Continue to provide and expand home and business efficiency programs Economic Incentivize 237,531 0077: Add performance standards to Building Energy and Water Scoring program Regulatory Direct 81,752 0088: Implement residential Home Energy Score point of listing requirement Regulatory Direct 4,017 0091: Implement a rental licensing or registry with minimum standards for health, safety, stability, and efficiency Regulatory Direct 13,136 Electricity 579,944 Local Renewables 0015: Continue to implement and expand distributed solar programs Economic Incentivize 34,476 Utility Renewables 0012: Add utility-scale renewables to increase non-carbon generation Infrastructure Influence 545,468 Land Use 1,256 Capacity 0040: Evaluate and implement land use opportunities that encourage “15 minute neighborhoods” Planning Direct 1,256 Industry 98,430 Manufacture 0042: Support incentives and regulation to reduce industrial (air pollution) emissions Partnership Influence 98,430 Page 174 Item 2. Transportation 106,237 Active Modes 0035: Continue to build bicycle facilities as identified in the Bicycle Master Plan Infrastructure Direct 38,146 0468: Implement a Transportation Demand Management (TDM) program Infrastructure Influence 2,576 Electrification 0019: Transition to emissions-free public transit Infrastructure Direct 1,481 0020: Support market driven adoption of electric cars Infrastructure Inform 58,761 Transit 0037: Expand local public transit coverage and frequency Infrastructure Direct 5,273 Waste 38,544 Organics 0023: Implement a Composting Ordinance and Related Composting Infrastructure/Facilities for Food Scraps Regulatory Influence 20,200 0024: Implement a Composting Ordinance and Related Composting Infrastructure/Facilities for Yard Trimmings Regulatory Influence 18,344 Total 1,175,207 Table 2: Reduction of landfilled material from Pathways. Pathway Next Move Implementation Mechanism City's Role in Implementation Community Waste Avoided in 2030 (short tons) Waste 62,374 Industrial Diversion 0008: Further reuse and recycle soil from City projects Infrastructure Direct 7,505 0075: Increase compliance of existing construction and demolition waste regulations Regulatory Direct 12,106 0467: Implement construction and demolition waste policy to direct materials to new facility Infrastructure Influence 40,354 Organics 0023: Implement a Composting Ordinance and Related Composting Infrastructure/Facilities for Food Scraps Regulatory Influence 9,249 0024: Implement a Composting Ordinance and Related Composting Infrastructure/Facilities for Yard Trimmings Regulatory Influence 17,241 Total 86,455 Page 175 Item 2. Descriptions and brief methodology of each the Next Moves included in the Pathways above: Next Move ID Name Description 0008 Further reuse and recycle soil from City projects Based on findings from earlier evaluation, protect existing soil storage areas for managing and processing City-generated soils and explore additional temporary or permanent sites. Explore process changes and other tools to divert material from the landfill. Future work could look at other industrial materials beyond soil. 0012 Add utility-scale renewables to increase non-carbon generation Platte River’s 2022 integrated resources plan shows reaching nearly 90% non-carbon resources by 2030. Forecasting for this next move is updated regularly using the latest information for changes in PRPA resources. 0015 Continue to implement and expand distributed solar programs Continue and expand rooftop solar through general solutions for rates, incentives and interconnection (residential and commercial) 0019 Transition to emissions-free public transit This Next Move is based on phase one of Transfort’s Fleet Electrification Planning Project, intended to find the most feasible technology to adopt to successfully transition the transit fleet to 100% zero emission – battery electric buses (depot charging and/or on route charging), hydrogen electric or a mixed fleet. 0020 Support market driven adoption of electric cars EV adoption scenario scales the state goals to Fort Collins based on population. The adoption rates over time uses a 40% annual increase each year between 2022 and 2030. 0023/0024 Implement a Composting Ordinance and Related Composting Infrastructure/Facilities for Food Scraps Continued exploration of a Composting Ordinance and related facilities entails: • Collaborating through Regional Wasteshed to identify opportunities to accelerate development of yard trimmings and food scraps composting facilities. • Commencing policy development regarding yard trimmings and food scraps per Council direction Two key elements are required to move this forward: 1) having a compost facility near Fort Collins that accepts food scraps 2) having policy for yard trimmings and / or food scraps. 0035 Continue to build bicycle facilities as identified in the Bicycle Master Plan This Next Move bridges the 2014 Bicycle Master Plan and the Active Modes Plan that is currently being updated. 0037 Expand local public transit coverage and frequency This Next Move references the expansion of local transit described in the 2019 Transit Master Plan. 0040 Evaluate and implement land use opportunities that encourage “15 minute neighborhoods” With a variety of housing options, access to services and amenities, walkable infrastructure, and proximity of housing to jobs 0042 Support incentives and regulation to reduce industrial (air pollution) emissions This is a State role, but aligns with current AQ work regarding advocacy for State/Federal policy and voluntary emissions reductions. This Next Move assumes more direct engagement and collaboration with the private sector, particularly big companies with a high contribution to climate change. 0043 Develop and implement an energy performance path for new construction to zero carbon building by 2030 Enhance building codes likely exceeding the current pace of the International Energy Conservation Code (IECC) code adoption process. Performance based codes, also referred to as outcome-based codes, require that building design and engineering meet specific building energy use standards, which is verified through modeling. 0044 Continue to provide and expand home and business efficiency programs Continue and expand investment in energy efficiency equipment and other strategies within business and homes. Continue to leverage Platte River, State, and Federal funding and optimize utilities procedures and standards to drive increased achievements. 0045 Continue to provide and expand on programs for electrification of space and water heating An incentive driven approach for residential and commercial community members to upgrade their building to all-electric. Analysis includes the potential fuel switching from promoting existing heat pump and heat pump water heater incentives Page 176 Item 2. in both the existing residential and commercial building stock. This is in addition to the energy codes which would require new construction and major renovations be carbon free by 2030. 0075 Increase compliance of existing construction and demolition waste regulations Ordinance requires that C&D debris must be recycled or reused. This strategy improves compliance through additional compliance staffing to make site visits and increase proactive compliance. 0077 Add performance standards to Building Energy and Water Scoring program The Building Energy and Water Scoring program currently requires building owners to track their energy use using Energy Star Portfolio Manager online tool, and it is subsequently made public for increased market transparency. A building performance standard could enhance the program by establishing minimum energy requirements for commercial buildings, likely a % reduction from a baseline year. 0088 Implement residential Home Energy Score point of listing requirement Require the disclosure of residential building performance at the time of home sale. This would provide additional information to the market and also influence home performance upgrades, ultimately resulting in a better residential building stock. Other cities and judications across the country have this requirement, including Portland, Oregon. 0091 Implement a rental licensing or registry with minimum standards for health, safety, stability, and efficiency Implementing City-wide rental licensing that is regularly checked/enforced for meeting minimum energy, health and safety codes. This strategy would likely be developed with a community stakeholder group to evaluate such things as required energy assessments, or minimum requirements using the Home Energy Score developed by Department of Energy. Other cities and jurisdictions across the country have required similar efforts, including Boulder, Colorado. 0467 Construction and Demolition waste policy This strategy would ensure material from Fort Collins reaches the new regional sorting facility. This policy has already been enacted in the Building Code and is triggered by the operation of the sorting facility. Staff recommends a final and routine policy check before the policy begins directing material to the facility. 0468 Implement a Transportation Demand Management (TDM) program The Shift Your Ride Travel Options program is currently funded in the 2023-24 City Manager’s recommended budget. Shift Your Ride is a Transportation Demand Management (TDM) program, which employs policies, programs, information, services, and tools to reduce drive-alone trips and facilitate a shift to sustainable transportation choices. Potential GHG reductions were modeled using a standard VMT calculator. Page 177 Item 2. Council Action Roadmap The Council OCF Action Roadmap is a tool for confirming, organizing, and sequencing important Council decision points. The actions on the roadmap are not exhaustive of everything Council, staff or the community will do to achieve the 2030 goals – they represent Council’s highest impact tools (policy making, infrastructure, and funding). Near-term Council Action Roadmap BFO and Next Moves Workplan Cycle BFO and Next Moves Workplan Cycle Page 178 Item 2. Medium-term Council Action Roadmap BFO and Next Moves Workplan Cycle BFO and Next Moves Workplan Cycle Page 179 Item 2. Presented by: Our Climate Future Implementation 10-11 -2022 Honore Depew Climate Program Manager John Phelan Energy Services Manager and Policy Advisor Molly Saylor Lead Specialist, Waste Reduction and Recycling Page 180 Item 2. 2Our Climate Future –Council Questions How does the content and timing of the Council Action Roadmap align with Councilmember priorities? What target would Councilmembers like to consider for the 2026 interim GHG goal at the October 25 meeting?​ Page 181 Item 2. 3Our Climate Future Alignment Strategic Objective 4.1: Intensify efforts to meet 2030 climate, energy and 100% renewable electricity goals that are centered in equity and improve community resilience Page 182 Item 2. Our Climate Future Big Moves 4 BETTER TOGETHER RESOURCE BETTER LIVE BETTER BREATHE BETTER • Shared Leadership and Community Partnership • Zero Waste Neighborhoods • Climate Resilient Community • Convenient Transportation Choices • Live, Work and Play Nearby • Efficient, Emissions Free Buildings • Healthy Affordable Housing • Local, Affordable and Healthy Food • Healthy Local Economy and Jobs • Zero Waste Economy • Healthy Natural Spaces • 100% Renewable Electricity • Electric Cars and Fleets Mitigation –Resilience –Equity Page 183 Item 2. 5Shared Leadership and Community Partnership Italics = as desired by community City-led Co-led Community-led •Council’s current work and priorities advance Our Climate Future •infrastructure & policy (e.g., bike lanes, building codes, land use, etc.) •Partnerships •State and Federal legislation •Leadership at every level Page 184 Item 2. 6Continuous Calibration and Goal Setting •Community GHG Inventory –2021 GHG Pathways –2030 Forecast Interim GHG Goal –2026 Target Waste Pathways –2030 Forecast City Council OCF Action Roadmap Page 185 Item 2. 7 2020 Inventory2021 Inventory Highlights •Small increase from 2020 •Progress in most areas •Transportation back near pre-covid level, but below 2019 Community Emissions Inventory Inventory continuously evolving, with year-round updates Page 186 Item 2. 8 Community Emissions Forecast Inventory continuously evolving, with year-round updates 2030 “Do Nothing More” Forecast •Includes population growth, weather, existing regulations and resource changes •Range based on historic variation Page 187 Item 2. 92030 Pathways Based on Next Moves (active or pending) -Grouped by sector strategy -Quantifiable reductions for GHG and/or waste between now and 2030 -Defined implementation mechanisms and City roles Big Moves & Goals Electricity Pathway Local renewables Utility renewables Buildings Pathway Construction Performance Electrification Industrial Manufacturing Pathway Local Transportation Pathway Active modes Transit Electrification Waste Pathway Industrial diversion Organics Land Use Pathway Capacity Page 188 Item 2. 10 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 Pathways •Quantified pathways result in a 70% carbon emissions reduction by 2030 Page 189 Item 2. 11 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 Last 10% requires additional community leadership action Pathways Electricity Buildings Industrial Manufacturing Transportation Waste Land Use Undetermined to Goal 2030 24.5% 15.0% 4.5% 4.0% 0.9% 0.1% 10% Page 190 Item 2. 12 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 Collaboration with Platte River essential for the electricity pathway Pathways Electricity Utility Renewables Local Renewables Buildings Industrial Manufacturing Transportation Waste Land Use 2030 24.5% 23.0% 1.5% 15.0% 4.5% 4.0% 0.9% 0.1% Page 191 Item 2. 13 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 Majority of savings from improving existing buildings Pathways Electricity Buildings Performance Construction Electrification Industrial Manufacturing Transportation Waste Land Use 2030 24.5% 15.0% 14.0% 0.5% 0.5% 4.5% 4.0% 0.9% 0.1% Page 192 Item 2. 14 Interim Goal Context 2026 Forecast with Pathways ≈ 43% reduction from 2005 Page 193 Item 2. 15 Community Waste 1% loss of progress but significant progress on recycling 2021 Highlights •49% landfilled (51% diversion) •Community Recycling Ordinance increased recycling significantly •More residential and commercial materials landfilled •Temporary drivers tapering off Page 194 Item 2. 16 Community Waste 2030 Forecast •Assumes both recycling and landfilling increase slightly, based on recent trends Page 195 Item 2. 17 Community Waste Pathways to 2030 Significant progress through pathways and leadership needed at all levels Pathways •Quantified pathways drop landfilled materials to 28% (72% diversion) •15% of material being landfilled is a common “ceiling” for cities •Remaining potential •Recycling behavior •System design (Circular Economy, Extended Producer Responsibility, more reuse, etc. 15% Landfilled Page 196 Item 2. 18 Community Waste Pathways to 2030 Progress accelerates with regional composting and C&D infrastructure Pathways Construction and Demolition Materials Recycling Food Scraps & Yard Trimmings Composting City Industrial Materials Recycling Remaining potential (e.g., behavior change, circular economy, extended producer responsibility, etc.) 2030 12% 6% 2% 27% 15% Landfilled Page 197 Item 2. 2022 •Adopt Land Use Changes •Develop Rental Registration •Adopt Active Modes Plan •Develop Sustainable Funding •Develop contracted residential waste collection including expanded yard trimmings 2023 •Develop Building Performance Standards •Develop home energy listing requirement •Adopt contracted residential waste collection including expanded yard trimmings 2024 •Adopt Building Performance Standards •Adopt Home listing requirements •Develop energy code step towards net- zero carbon •Adopt Land Use Phase 2 •Start residential waste collectio n including yard trimmings •Develop/adopt commercial & industrial policy for yard trimmings 2025 •Adopt Energy code •Start home energy listing requirements •Start commercial/ industrial policy for yard trimmings 2026 •Start building performance standards (large buildings) •Start West Elizabeth Bus Rapid Transit 19City Council OCF Action Roadmap Buildings Land Use Mobility Waste Page 198 Item 2. 20City Council OCF Action Roadmap 2027 •Start building performance standards (small & mid- size buildings) •Develop net- zero carbon energy code 2028 •Adopt Energy Code •Start energy requirements for rental properties •Start North College MAX 2029 2030 •Start higher building performance standards for all buildings 2026 •Food scraps policy •Construction & demolition materials policy Unscheduled Buildings Land Use Mobility Waste Page 199 Item 2. 21 Beyond the Roadmap Page 200 Item 2. 22Shared Leadership and Community Partnership Italics = as desired by community City-led Co-led Community-led •Council’s current work and priorities advance Our Climate Future •Partnerships •State and Federal legislation •Leadership at every level •Many businesses, organizations and community members in Fort Collins leading the way •10 businesses certified as B Corps •Glass Recycling Coalition co- founded by New Belgium •Poudre Food Partnership•Many existing community partnerships, e.g., Larimer County Conservation Corps, Bike Fort Collins •2023-2024 Budget •32.9 Disposable Bag Implementation •32.16 Sustainable Business Program •32.17 Increasing Community Leadership for OCF •Many examples from ongoing offers Page 201 Item 2. 23Our Climate Future –Council Questions How does the content and timing of the Council Action Roadmap align with Councilmember priorities? What target would Councilmembers like to consider for the 2026 interim GHG goal at the October 25 meeting?​ Page 202 Item 2. 24Our Climate Future –Additional Information Additional Information Page 203 Item 2. 25Next Steps •October 18 •Land Use Code Update –Phase I •October 25 •Interim GHG Goal Resolution •Active Modes Plan Work Session •15-minute City Work Session •November 1 •2023/24 City Budget Adoption •December 6 •Active Modes Plan Adoption •December 13 •Sustainable Revenue Work Session Page 204 Item 2. 26 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 ? Mechanisms Infrastructure Economic Regulatory Partnership Planning 2030 27.5% 12.0% 5.5% 3.9% 0.1% Page 205 Item 2. 27 Community Emissions Pathways to 2030 ? City’s Role Influence Incentivize Direct Inform 2030 28.0% 12.0% 6.5% 2.5% Page 206 Item 2. 28 Community Emissions Inventory “Drivers of Change” Direct savings countered by weather and growth of the community • Direct & Influenced categories based on OCF Next Move results Page 207 Item 2.