Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCOUNCIL - AGENDA ITEM - 03/22/2022 - AQUATICS UPDATEDATE: STAFF: March 22, 2022 LeAnn Williams, Recreation Director Seve Ghose, Community Services Director WORK SESSION ITEM City Council SUBJECT FOR DISCUSSION Aquatics Update EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this item is to provide the Fall 2021 requested aquatics update, initiated from discussion on potential spending at Mulberry Pool. GENERAL DIRECTION SOUGHT AND SPECIFIC QUESTIONS TO BE ANSWERED In preparation for the FY 2023-2024 BFO process, staff is seeking feedback from Councilmembers on the following options related to Mulberry Pool and overall aquatics: 1. OPTION #1: Do not allocate any additional funds toward Mulberry Pool as it is past its lifetime of safe and great use by the community. We can continue to operate as currently and will close the facility when equipment fails. 2. OPTION #2: In addition to Option 1, also redirect the funds currently allocated toward the development of the SE Recreation and Innovation Center project set to begin in 2023. This will allow for an enhanced aquatic experience, in a public-pool deficit area of the City, possibly leveraging the funding to adding lap lanes and an expanded footprint. 3. OPTION #3: Replace Mulberry Pool with an equivalent pool on site to continue to resume offering a high level of service. This basic lap pool will cost between $15 - $20 million. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION This strategic decision-making step came to the forefront during the BFO process in 2021 for the one-year budget for FY2022, specifically related to Mulberry Pool. Mulberry Pool was originally opened in 1974 and now requires major work to bring it to standards associated with safe and appropriate use of the facility. Some work is underway related to the ADA access and annual maintenance, resourced by current allocations in the Facility Operations budget. The major work, which originally priced at over $3.5 million in 2020, includes HVAC, roof, building separations, and pool upgrades. The final cost will likely be higher than the initial estimate. When evaluated at Council in Fall 2021 as part of BFO discussions, it was decided that a thorough study should be conducted to determine the viability and efficiency of renovating an old facility like Mulberry Pool, alongside the overall aquatics needs in the community to make the most informed decision on future allocations. Staff engaged a consultant, Counsilman-Hunsaker, in late 2021 to perform the study. The consultant visited e ach existing site in our system, and evaluated them based on national and regional expectations for aquatics facilities, programs, and amenities. Councilman-Hunsaker issued the following guidelines: 1. The City’s aquatic system should provide the community with options for public lane swim, aquatic exercise, aquatic instruction, and other programs including specialized training and competitions. 2. When looking at recommended sizes, quantities, and locations of aquatic facilities, Counsilman -Hunsaker March 22, 2022 Page 2 recommends a balanced system to support all user groups. The one metric used is 110 square feet of water per 1,000 residents. This water expectation is for traditional lane usage and recreational needs. 3. The balanced system also includes both indoor and outdoor water, even in colder climes. Our existing system includes: Mulberry Pool Senior Center Pool City Park Pool Edora Pool Lap Lanes ✓ ✓ ✓ Family Aquatics ✓ ✓ Therapy pool or programs ✓ ✓ Competitive Aquatics Center ✓ 50M Lanes Instructional Programs ✓ ✓ ✓ Indoor Pool ✓ ✓ ✓ Outdoor Pool ✓ Geographically, the system is concentrated in the Northern region of Fort Collins, with no facilities south of Horsetooth Road, as illustrated in the map below: In addition to observations and metrics for each facility, Counsilman-Hunsaker reached the following key findings: 1. Need for aquatic amenities in the southeast quadrant of the city 2. Need for additional training (lap) lanes, 6 at current population and 8 based on 2025 projected pop ulation 3. Need for additional recreation water 4. Leverage the existing user group relationships to support the additional facilities and amenities 5. Additional investment in Mulberry pool not suggested The table below shows the current system capacity vs. standards provided by the consultant: Unit Current Standard Meeting Standard? Outdoor Water Sq Ft/1,000 pop 62.5 110  Indoor Water Sq Ft/1,000 pop 141.0 110 ✓ Training Water Lanes 26 45  Recreational Water Sq Ft/1,000 pop 110.7 110 ✓ March 22, 2022 Page 3 Although the current system is exceeding standards for indoor water, both outdoor water and training water capacity are below standard. Mulberry pool provides 6 of the training lanes currently in our system. Staff is in the early stages of drafting concept plans for the community-initiated Southeast Recreation and Innovation Center approved by voters in 2015. The ballot measure included an outdoor family aquatic center with a lazy river in the southeast section of the city, with anticipated completion by 2025. Al though not specifically listed in the ballot language, it may be opportune to add certain aquatics amenities to the project to better meet the service needs of the community. Adding the lap lanes will increase the cost of building the facility but reduce our gap vs. the recommended standard. NEXT STEPS Staff will continue developing plans for the Southeast Recreation and Innovation Center. If directed, staff will also develop BFO offers for the 2023/2024 Budget cycle to implement the preferred direction of Council. ATTACHMENTS 1. Master Plan Update (PDF) 2. Powerpoint Presentation (PDF) Aquatic Facility Master PlanATTACHMENT 1 •What do we like about our current community aquatics?•What programming amenities do we need to support the future of aquatics?•What don’t we need to include in the future of aquatic?•What other information do you want to share?QUESTIONS NEED FOR AN AQUATIC MASTER PLAN• Physical Obsolescence• Aging Facility• Codes and Standards• Functional Obsolescence• Definition of Aquatics• User Expectations AQUATIC USER GROUPSInstructionCompetitionWellness & TherapyRecreationp RECREATIONRRecreationalSwimmersTotsFamiliesTeensWarm WaterShallow – Medium Depth 5COMPETITION SWIMMERSAquatic fields of playTraining spaceCompetition SpaceCool WaterMedium – Deep Depth 66 25-yard lanesAQUATIC FIELDS OF PLAY 725-yard by 25-meter•11 25-yard lanes•10 25-meter lanesAQUATIC FIELDS OF PLAY 850-meter by 25-yard•8 or 10 (50-meter lanes)•17-22 (cross-course 25-yard lanes)AQUATIC FIELDS OF PLAY POOL SIZE BY DEMOGRAPHICSPool SizeCommunity SizeClub SizeSwimmers in 5 hrs. prime time6 Lane 25 Yards25,00050 – 751088 Lane 25 Yards50,00075 – 15015210 Lane 25 Yards50K – 100Kup to 200200 22 Lane 25 YardsјϭϬϬ<јϮϱϬ418 Learn to swim, life safety skillsLifeguard instructionSurvival swimmingScubaINSTRUCTIONWarm WaterShallow – Medium Depth AQUATIC PROGRAMSƒLessons – standardized swim lesson program for all agesƒSwim team – year-round or summer league with opportunity for off-season workoutsƒLifeguard – lifeguard certification courseƒJunior lifeguard – lifeguard course for ages 12-15 to prepare them for lifeguard certification at age 16ƒWater polo – intro to water polo class to teach basicsƒScuba – rent deep end to local scuba organizationƒKayak – provide intro to kayak lessonsƒWater exercise classes – aerobics, aqua core and cardio, aquatic fusion, flow and flex, gut buster and othersAquatic core express – abs workout in 20 minutesƒMasters swimming – US masters swimming clubƒTriathlons – swim training and competitionƒCommunity programs - dog swim, egg hunt, VIP night, dive in movies, theme nights, back to school bashes and moreƒCamps – weeklong camps emphasizing water safety, water skills, outside games and arts and craftsƒUnderwater hockey - the game is played on the bottom of the pool where players use a short stick to push a puck around their opponents to score goals at either end of the pool Fastest growing aquatic user groupTherapy programsWater aerobics classesWELLNESS AND THERAPYWarmest Water Shallow – Medium Depth MASTER PLANNING PROCESS• Existing Facility Review• Physical vs Functional Obsolescence• Market Analysis• Population Density• Age Distribution• Income Characteristics• Area Aquatic Providers• Concept Development and Cost Estimates• Conceptual Plan• Capital Cost• Operational Cost• Implementation Plan• Pool types and locations• Phasing AQUATIC SYSTEM•A city aquatic system should provide the citizens of Fort Collins with options for public lane swim, aquatic exercise, aquatic instruction, and other programs as well as support the desires to host various aquatic sport competitions and training. •When looking at recommended sizes, quantities, and locations of aquatic facilities, Counsilman-Hunsaker recommends a balanced system to support all user groups. CH uses a metric of 110 sq. ft. of water per 1000 residents; this amount of water should be available for traditional lane usage as well as recreational water activities. •A balanced system should also include both indoor and outdoor water. Even in colder climates, recreational swimmers prefer to be outdoors when the weather permits. Consideration needs to be given to the size due to the seasonal availability, but outdoor water still plays a critical role in a successful aquatic system.3/17/202214 EXISTING FACILITIES•Edora Pool Ice Center (EPIC)•Mulberry Pool•Senior Center Pool•City Park Pool3/17/202215 EDORA POOL ICE CENTER (EPIC)•Indoor 50-meter x 25-yard pool•Two 3-meter and two 1-meter diving boards•Separate warm water therapy and instructional pools3/17/2022162019Revenue $437,188Expense $276,314Net $160,874Enrollments 2,272 Enrolled Participation17,886 Drop-in 32,231 Rentals 118,644 Total Participation168,761 EPICAnnual EDORA POOL ICE CENTER (EPIC)ObservationsxStarting blocks and bulkheads are in good conditionxTile finish for all pools was reported to be replaced in sections as needed. Finish is in good condition but since most of it is originally from the 1980s it is recommended it be fully replacedxStaining was found in specific spots of the competition pool floor. The stains were circular and seemed to be present under the truss joins from the ceiling structure. Metal residue may be dripping into the water, sinking to the pool floor, and staining the tile. This should be addressed prior to pool tile replacement.xDeck slopes appeared to not drain the deck properly of pool water from swimmers exiting the poolxStanchion post for backstroke flags was slanted in its anchor, potentially due to overtightening of flags. This should be addressed to avoid permanent damage to the anchor and create need for a replacementxMechanical equipment is in good conditionxBecsys chemical controller reported to not meet expectations and may be replaced with a ChemtrolunitxThe acid tank is currently contained in a chemical containment cabinet in the same room as the liquid chlorine tanks. A solution to this issue was reported to be currently under study. The severity is this discrepancy puts it in first priority for resolution over the reported pool issues. 3/17/202217 MULBERRY POOL•Indoor 25-yard pool•1-meter diving board•Large shallow interactive play area•Separate 7-person spa•Birthday party room•Spectator seating•Zero entry pool3/17/2022182019Revenue $241,106Expense $194,798Net $46,308Enrollments 2,085 Enrolled Participation14,814 Drop-in 35,539 Rentals 27,746 Total Participation78,099 MULBERRY POOLAnnual MULBERRY POOL3/17/202219Observations• Keifer starting blocks are in good condition• Rust was found at the two lap swim corners of the pool walls, directly under the gutter• The only ADA access lift was portable, no anchored lifts present• The slope transition between the zero-entry to the diving area may not meet pool code• The spectator seating view of the lap lanes is obstructed by the existing play structure• Mechanical equipment is in good condition• Air recirculation may need to be addressed SENIOR CENTER POOL•Indoor Therapy Pool•Indoor Hot-tub3/17/2022202019Revenue $59,717Expense $147,891Net -$88,174Enrollments 3,085 Enrolled Participation28,652 Drop-in 2,360 Rentals - Total Participation31,012 SENIOR CENTER POOLAnnual SENIOR CENTER POOLObservationsxBoth bodies of water appear in great condition. xTherapy pool recently replasteredxAir quality was appropriate with assistance of large ceiling fansxMechanical equipment is in good condition3/17/202221 CITY PARK POOL•Outdoor pool•30-foot drop slide•Open curly slide•Lazy river, shallow water, geysers•Large play structure3/17/2022222019Revenue $251,503Expense $94,232Net $157,271Enrollments 88 Enrolled Participation981 Drop-in 41,958 Rentals 15,569 Total Participation58,508 CITY PARK POOLAnnual CITY PARK POOLObservationsxPlay structure recently recoated and repainted, still in good conditionxTile and plaster were replaced in 2021. Not visible during inspection due to snow but believed to be in good conditionxWaterslide tower PVC grating needs to be replaced. xWaterslide exposed piping may need to be replaced with SCH 80 PVC piping to prevent failure from corrosionxSurge tank and gutters were reported in need of new waterproofingxPotential groundwater issues since the pool is located next to a pond. No settlement reported but a structural audit may be necessaryxMechanical equipment is in good condition3/17/202223 AQUATIC MASTER PLAN – CURRENT SYSTEM•110 sq. ft. of water per 1,000 residents. •This amount of water should be available for traditional lane usage as well as recreational water activities. •A balanced system should also include both indoor and outdoor water. •Even in colder climates, recreational swimmers prefer to be outdoors during the summer months. •Consideration needs to be given to the size due to the seasonal availability, but outdoor water still plays a critical role in a successful aquatic system.3/17/202224Outdoor WaterSF 10,500.00 10,500.00 62.48 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 7,986 Indoor WaterSF 23,700.00 23,700.00 141.03 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet(5,215) Training WaterSF 15,600.00 15,600.00 92.83 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 2,886 Recreational WaterSF 18,600.00 18,600.00 110.68 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet (115) 168,050 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)2021 Estimated Population Outdoor WaterSF 10,500.00 10,500.00 46.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 14,250 Indoor WaterSF 23,700.00 23,700.00 105.33 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 1,050 Training WaterSF 15,600.00 15,600.00 69.33 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 9,150 Recreational WaterSF 18,600.00 18,600.00 82.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 6,150 225,000 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)Build-Out Population AQUATIC MASTER PLAN – W/OUT MULBERRY•110 sq. ft. of water per 1,000 residents. •This amount of water should be available for traditional lane usage as well as recreational water activities. •A balanced system should also include both indoor and outdoor water. •Even in colder climates, recreational swimmers prefer to be outdoors during the summer months. •Consideration needs to be given to the size due to the seasonal availability, but outdoor water still plays a critical role in a successful aquatic system.3/17/202225Outdoor WaterSF 10,500.00 10,500.00 62.48 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 7,986 Indoor WaterSF 17,700.00 17,700.00 105.33 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 786 Training WaterSF 12,300.00 12,300.00 73.19 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 6,186 Recreational WaterSF 15,900.00 15,900.00 94.61 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Need Exists- Square Feet 2,586 168,050 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)2021 Estimated Population Outdoor WaterSF 10,500.00 10,500.00 46.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 14,250 Indoor WaterSF 17,700.00 17,700.00 78.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 7,050 Training WaterSF 12,300.00 12,300.00 54.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 12,450 Recreational WaterSF 15,900.00 15,900.00 70.67 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 8,850 225,000 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)Build-Out Population 3/17/202226https://cho.maps.arcgis.com/apps/mapviewer/index.html?webmap=5d6b485da26c40a89040f3b7cb845ed4 3/17/202227AQUATIC MASTER PLAN•Service Area Gap Exists SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS•Need for aquatic amenities in Southeast quadrant of City. •Outside existing service area•Need for additional training lanes•6 lanes based on current population•8 lanes based on 2025 projected population•Need for additional recreation water to support growth•Consider local partnerships to support additional facilities•Recommendations•Add new indoor/outdoor multi-purpose aquatic facility to SE area of town.•Renovate / Replace existing facilities as needed over the next 20 years3/17/202228 SE MULTI-PURPOSE POOL3/17/202229 SE MULTI-PURPOSE POOL3/17/202230Description Unit Amount Opinion of CostPublic Spaces/Offices 4,800 $1,461,000.00Lobby Sq. Ft. 1,000Offices Sq. Ft. 1,200Guard Room / First Aid Sq. Ft. 400Storage Sq. Ft. 600Locker Rooms Sq. Ft. 1,200Family Changing Room Sq. Ft. 400Natatorium 26,000 $13,966,960.00Recreation Pool Sq. Ft. 6,232$2,056,560.00 Participatory Play Feature Allowance 1$125,000.00 Current Channel Addl. Cost 1$35,000.00 Vortex Addl. Cost 1$35,000.00 Waterslide Quantity 1$210,000.0025Y x 25 M Sq. Ft. 6,171 Diving Boards Allowance 2Therapy pool Sq. Ft. 730Spa Sq. Ft. 354Natatorium Sq. Ft. 26,000$9,100,000.00Meeting Room/Classroom 1,720 $464,400.00Training Rooms Sq. Ft. 320Dryland Training Sq. Ft. 1,000Therapy Room Sq. Ft. 400 OPINION OF PROBABLE COST SE MULTI-PURPOSE POOL3/17/202231Outdoor Leisure 8,964 $3,553,120Leisure Sq. Ft. 6,832Zero-depth entry pool Sq. Ft. 2,132 Play Structure Allowance 1 Tot Slide Allowance 1 Slide w/Structure Allowance 1 Spray features Allowance 1 Mushroom Allowance 1Support 26,892 $525,535Outdoor Deck Sq. Ft. 17,928Fence Ln. Ft. 656Overhead Lighting Sq. Ft. 26,892Shade Structures Quantity 4Building Support 1,250 $262,500Pool Mechanical Sq. Ft. 1,100Building Mechanical Sq. Ft. 150Efficiency 6,754 $1,688,500Circulation and Walls (20%) Sq. Ft. 6,754 SE MULTI-PURPOSE POOL3/17/202232Total Building Construction Costs Sq. Ft. 76,380 $21,922,015Site Construction Costs (landscaping, drainage, walks) $1,909,500.Furniture, Fixtures, Equipment $458,280Subtotal$24,289,795 Contingency 10.0% $2,428,979Inflation (1 Year) 10.0% $2,428,979Indirect Costs 10.0% $2,671,877Total Estimated Project Costs: $31,819,631Rounded $31,900,000Source: Counsilman-Hunsaker AQUATIC MASTER PLAN – NEW FACILITY•110 sq. ft. of water per 1,000 residents. •This amount of water should be available for traditional lane usage as well as recreational water activities. •A balanced system should also include both indoor and outdoor water. •Even in colder climates, recreational swimmers prefer to be outdoors during the summer months. •Consideration needs to be given to the size due to the seasonal availability, but outdoor water still plays a critical role in a successful aquatic system.3/17/202233Outdoor WaterSF 19,464.00 19,464.00 115.82 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet(979) Indoor WaterSF 37,187.00 37,187.00 221.29 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet(18,702) Training WaterSF 21,771.00 21,771.00 129.55 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet(3,286) Recreational WaterSF 34,880.00 34,880.00 207.56 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 18,486 Meets Standard - Square Feet (16,395) 168,050 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)2021 Estimated Population Outdoor WaterSF 19,464.00 19,464.00 86.51 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 5,286 Indoor WaterSF 37,187.00 37,187.00 165.28 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Meets Standard - Square Feet(12,437) Training WaterSF 21,771.00 21,771.00 96.76 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Need Exists- Square Feet 2,979 Recreational WaterSF 34,880.00 34,880.00 155.02 SF / 1,000 1,000 110.0 SF / 1,000 24,750 Meets Standard - Square Feet (10,130) 225,000 AQUATIC FACILITIES CURRENT Standards GAP (EXCESS)Build-Out Population Aquatic Facility Master Plan Aquatics Update03/22/2022Seve Ghose, Community Services DirectorLeAnn Williams, Recreation DirectorCounsilman/Hunsaker ConsultantsATTACHMENT 2 Strategic AlignmentCulture and Recreation:• 2.4. Maintain and enhance the current culture, recreation and parks systems• 2.5. Plan, design and implement citywide park, recreation and trail improvements. Actions Identified in Plan:• Provide recreational amenities according to level of service standards• Ensure facilities and programs continue to respond to changing user needsOngoing Offer:• 34.2 Mulberry PoolStrategic PlanParks & Recreation Master PlanBudget Question for Council3• Do not allocate additional funds to Mulberry pool but continue to operate the facility until current equipment failsOption 1AND• Redirect currently allocated funds to the development of the SE Recreation Center• Replace Mulberry pool with an equivalent pool onsiteOption 1Option 2Option 3What feedback do Councilmembers have on the 3 options for providing aquatics access? Overview of Existing Facilities4Mulberry Senior CenterCity ParkEdoraLap Lanes Family AquaticsTherapyCompetitiveInstructional Programs Indoor OutdoorOur existing facilities offer a mix of amenities and programming, but are concentrated in the northern half of the City Mulberry Pool Background• Opened 1974-former Lincoln Middle School gymnasium• 6 lap lanes and an aging playground• Limited current hours of operation• Serves PSD, Vortex swim club, lap swim and swim lessons• Requires major work to bring it to standards for safe and appropriate use• Some work is ongoing for ADA access and annual maintenance• Major work was original estimated at $3.5M but final cost will likely be higher• BFO direction to conduct a viability study to inform future allocations of resources5 6Key Findings by Counsilman-Hunsaker ConsultantsNeed for aquatic amenities in the southeast quadrant of the cityNeed for 6-8 additional training (lap) lanesNeed for additional recreation waterLeverage the existing user group relationships to support additional facilities and amenitiesAdditional investment in Mulberry pool not suggested 7Aquatic Master Plan – Current System CapacityWater available for traditional lane usage and recreational water activities • Standard training water need is one lane per 3,000 population• Other water needs are 110 sq ft per 1,000 population• Gap found in availability of outdoor water and training water/lap lanes• Recreational water availability is currently balanced, but projected population growth will require additional sq ft to continue to meet standardUnitCurrent StandardMeeting Standard?Outdoor WaterSq Ft/1,000 pop62.5 110Indoor WaterSq Ft/1,000 pop141.0 110Training WaterLanes26 45Recreational WaterSq Ft/1,000 pop110.7 110 8Southeast Multi-Purpose Pool• We are in the early stages of drawing concept plans• Adds aquatic amenities in the Southeast quadrant• Ballot measure calls for an outdoor family aquatic center with a lazy river• Due to gaps in current system capacity, the design should consider need for additional training lanes• 6 lanes based on current population• 8 lanes based on 2025 projected population• Would add significant cost to the project• Opportunity identified to redirect funding from Mulberry pool to support additional amenities at SE facilityEarly Concept- Final design will vary based on resources Question for Council9• Do not allocate additional funds to Mulberry pool but continue to operate the facility until current equipment fails• Do not allocate additional funds to Mulberry poolAND• Redirect those funds to the development of the SE Recreation Center• Replace Mulberry pool with an equivalent pool onsite• Basic lap pool costs are $15 – 20MOption 1Option 2Option 3What feedback do Councilmembers have on the 3 options for providing aquatics access?Staff Recommendation QUESTIONS? THANK YOU!