Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAGENDA ITEM SUMMARY - 7/29/2019- CODE CHANGE,COMPLAINT,ETHICS BOARD,MEETING TIME,TROXELLAgendc,i Itern 3 STAFF Carrie Daggett, City Attorney SUBJECT Consideration of whether there should be a change to the timeframe stated in City Code Sec. 2- 569(d) (1) regarding the meeting time deadline after a complaint has been filed with the City Clerk. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this item is for the Ethics Review Board to discuss and consider making a recommendation regarding a change to City Code Section 2-569(d)(1) regarding the timeframe the Ethics Review Board must meet to consider a filed complaint. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends, that the Board consider a Code change to broaden the timeframe which the Ethics Review Board must gather and meet to consider a filed complaint. BACKGROUND / DISCUSSION Under City Code Section 2-5691(d)(1), after a complaint is filed with the City Clerk, "no more than ten (10) working days after the date of filing of the complaint, the Review Board shall meet and consider the complaint." The ten (10) working days' time period is proving to be burdensome and constraining due to the challenges to coordinate of Staff and Review Board members' schedules to get a meeting day and time set within the current timeframe and prepare materials for the Board's consideration in advance of the meeting. A couple alternatives to this language are proposed as follows: a. Option 1: A proposed change to City Code Sec, 2-569(d)(1) would state, ". . . No more than twenty (20) [or some other number] working days after the date of filing of the complaint, the Review Board shall meet and consider the complaint. . . ." Ki b. Option 2: A proposed change to City Code Sec. 2-569(d)(1) would state, ". . - NO-m-Gre than ten (10) working days-after-4he. date -044;,Rg-of-the-Go m-plajRt-, The Review Board shall endeavor (or use it's best efforts) to meet and consider the complaint promptly ... ATTACHMENTS 1. City Code Section 2-569 (d)(1) 7/24/2019 Sec. 2-569. - Board of ethics. Fort Collins, CO Municipal Code (a) In order to assist the Councilmembers and board and commission members in interpreting and applying the definitions, rules and procedures pertaining to ethics established by the Charter and Code and by the applicable provisions of state statute, there is hereby created a Board of the City to be known as the Ethics Review Board, hereafter referred to in this Division as the "Review Board." (b) The Review Board shall consist of three (3) Councilmembers elected by the City Council, one (1) of whom shall be elected by the Review Board to serve as a chairperson. One (1) alternate shall also be appointed by the City Council to serve in the event that a regular member of the Review Board is unavailable or in the event that any particular complaint or inquiry is directed towards a member of the Review Board. (c) Subject to the provisions of Subsection (d) below, the duties and responsibilities of the Review Board shall be as follows: (1) To review and investigate complaints of unethical conduct filed against Councilmembers or board and commission members by any person; (2) To review and investigate actual or hypothetical situations involving potential conflicts of interest presented by individual Councilmembers or board and commission members; (3) After review and investigation, to render advisory opinions or interpretations pertaining to such complaints or inquiries under the relevant provisions of the Charter and Code and the applicable provisions of state law, if any, and to make written recommendations to the City Council and any affected board or commission concerning the same; and (4) To propose any revisions to the provisions of the Charter or Code or other regulations, rules or policies of the City pertaining to ethical conduct as the Review Board may deem necessary and appropriate in the best interests of the City. (d) Complaints and inquiries shall be submitted to the Review Board only according to the following procedures: (1) Complaints. a. Any person who believes that a Councilmember or board and commission member has violated any provision of state law or the Charter or Code pertaining to ethical conduct may file a complaint with the City Clerk, who shall immediately notify the chairperson of the Review Board, the Councilmembers or board and commission members named in the complaint and the City Council. The complaint shall be promptly scheduled for consideration by the Review Board. No more than ten (1 B) working days after the date of filing of the complaint, the Review Board shall meet and consider the complaint. All Councilmembers or board and commission members named in the complaint, as well as the complainant, shall 113 7/24/2019 Fort Collins, CO Municipal Code be given written notice of such meeting at least three (3) working days prior to the meeting. A notice of the complaint, including the identity of the complainant shall be posted along with the meeting notice. b. Upon receipt of any such complaint, the Review Board shall, after consultation with the City Attorney, decide by majority vote whether to formally investigate the complaint. In making such determination, the Review Board shall consider the following: (1) whether the allegations in the complaint, if true, would constitute a violation of state or local ethical rules; (2) the reliability and sufficiency of any facts asserted in support of the allegations; and (3) any other facts or circumstances that the Review Board may consider relevant. If the Review Board determines that the complaint does not warrant investigation, the Review Board shall send written notice to the complainant of its determination and the reasoning behind that determination, and shall provide a copy of such notice, together with a copy of the complaint, to all Councilmembers or board or commission members named in the complaint, as well as the City Council. c. In the event that a complaint is filed with the City Clerk under the provisions of this Subsection which alleges a violation on the part of two (2) or more members of the Review Board (including the alternate), such complaint shall not be referred to the regular Review Board for review but shall instead be submitted to an alternate Review Board consisting of all remaining Councilmembers who are not named in the complaint; provided, however, that if five (5) or more Councilmembers are named in the complaint, the alternate Review Board shall also include as many members of City boards and commissions as are necessary to constitute a seven - member board. Said Board and commission members shall be selected at random by the City Clerk within ten (10) working days of the date upon which the complaint is filed with the City Clerk. Any board and commission members selected by the City Clerk who elect not to serve on the alternate Review Board shall immediately so notify the City Clerk, who shall thereafter select as many additional board and commission members as are necessary to constitute the seven -member alternate Review Board. The procedures utilized by the alternate Review Board for reviewing and investigating the complaint and rendering an advisory opinion and recommendation shall be as provided in Subsections (b) and (e) of this Section, except that: (i) the opinion and recommendation of such Board shall be final and shall not be submitted to the City Council for review or adoption by the City Council unless at least three (3) Councilmembers remain available to consider and take action on the opinion and recommendation; and (ii) the City Council and City staff shall, upon request by the alternate Review Board, make available to such Board all information in the possession of the city that is relevant 7/24/2019 Fort Collins, CO Municipal Code to the Board's investigation, including, without limitation, tape recordings of any relevant executive sessions, unless the release of said information is prohibited by state or federal law; and, in reviewing and discussing such information, the Board shall abide by any local, state or federal confidentiality requirements that might limit or prohibit the release of such information to third parties. (2) City Council inquiries. Any Councilmember may present directly to the Review Board any inquiry regarding the application of ethical rules of conduct under state statute or the Charter or Code to any actual or hypothetical situation of a Councilmember or board and commission member. (e) In performing its review and investigation of any complaint or inquiry submitted in accordance with Subsection (d) hereof, the Review Board shall afford all affected Councilmembers or board and commission members an opportunity to present their interpretations of the facts at issue and of the applicable provisions of law before rendering its opinion and recommendation. The Review Board may also request such additional materials or information from City staff or members of the public which it considers reasonably necessary or helpful to its deliberations. In addition, in the case of a complaint, the Review Board shall have the power to compel by subpoena the attendance and testimony of witnesses and the production of such documents as the Review Board may consider necessary to its investigation. After investigation, the Review Board shall forthwith issue an advisory opinion and recommendation to the City Council, which shall immediately thereafter be filed with the City Clerk and be available for public inspection. Said opinion and recommendation shall be submitted to city Council at a regular City Council meeting, at which time the City Council shall determine whether to adopt the same. Any whose conduct or circumstance is the subject of the opinion shall refrain from participating in any deliberations of the City Council regarding the opinion. (f) The City Attorney shall provide legal advice to the Review Board and shall prepare and execute all advisory opinions and recommendations of the review board. (g) Compliance with the applicable provisions of the Charter and Code and the provisions of state law, as well as decisions regarding the existence or nonexistence of conflicts of interest and the appropriate actions to be taken in relation thereto, shall be the responsibility of each individual Councilmember or board and commission member, except as provided in Subparagraph 2-568(c)(1)(g). An opinion adopted by the City Council under Subsection (e) of this Section shall constitute an affirmative defense to any civil or criminal action or any other sanction against a Councilmember or board or commission member acting in reliance thereon. (Ord. No. 112, 1989, § 1, 8-1-89; Ord. No. 17, 1993, 2-16-93; Ord. No. 64, 1993, 7-20-93; Ord. 132, 2001, § 2, 9- 18-01; Ord. No. 110, 2002, §§ 1-3, 8-20-02; Ord. No. 144, 2014, 11-4-141 3/3