Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutLandmark Preservation Commission - Minutes - 01/19/1994C KVI )T UIIV.'i;i ;i�C� ;k�l:Yr Ci7:i Adjourned Regular Meeting January 19, 1994 Council Liaison: Gerry Horak Staff Liaison: Joe Frank SUMMARY OF MEETING: The Commission approved the December 3, 1993 minutes. Members approved the proposed trim painting at Still Magnolias, X3 Old Town Square. The Commission reviewed a proposed demolition delay ordinance and suggested changes. The Commission decided to postpone discussion of proposed Amendments to the Appeals Provision of the City Code to the next scheduled meeting. Plaques were presented to former LPC members Brian Janonis and Kirk Jensen in recognition of their service. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL: Commission Chair Jennifer Carpenter called the meeting to order at 5:40 p.m., 281 North College Avenue. Secretary Diane Slater called the roll. Commission members Jennifer Carpenter, Per Hogestad, Richard Hill, and James Tanner were present. Member Bud Frick arrived at 6:05 p.m. Jean Kullman and Ruth Weatherford were absent. Joe Frank and Carol Tunner represented staff. GUESTS: Maggie Kunze, owner of Still Magnolias, #3 Old Town Square; Paul Eckman, Deputy City Attorney; Brian Janonis and Kirk Jensen, past LPC members. AGENDA REVIEW: None. STAFF REPORT: Ms. Tunner mentioned that the bylaws currently state that members missing more than four regular meetings should reconsider their commitment. Mr. Frank noted that the Waycott House received National Historic Register designation. Ms. Tunner remarked that two more buildings will be coming up soon for designation: the IS Building on the CSU campus and 329 South Sherwood. She then reported on a recent tour of the Linden Hotel with: Dave Veldman and Mitch Morgan of Veldman/Morgan; Dennis Simtett of Sinnett Construction; Mr. Frye of Vaught/Fryc Architects; and James Stratis, Historic Preservation Specialist for the Colorado State Historic Society. Mr. Stratis made suggestions regarding the historical integrity of the buildings. He was particularly interested in the exterior arch -top windows, noting that they should be saved. However, the interior cove ceiling may have to go, since it was added in the 1920's. Since Mr. Stratis is the liaison for the Park Service and the Limited Stakes Gambling Fund grant, which requires purview over the interior restoration, changes could affect some grant funds. Ms. Tunner noted that local citizens are concerned about moving a Frank Miller painting on an interior wall, if the walls are removed as proposed. Landmark Preservation Commission Adjourned Regular Meeting Minutes January 19, 1994 Page 2 COMMISSION MEMBERS' REPORTS: None. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: W. Hill moved approval of the December 3, 1"3 minutes as read and Mr. Tanner seconded the motion. The minutes were approved 4-0. Ayes: Carpenter, Hill, Hogestad, Tanner. CURRENT DESIGN REVIEW: Ms. Tunner showed slides of Still Magnolias' facade at k3 Old Town Square and passed around samples of the proposed color for the four kickplates and two door panels. Ms. Kunze's first choice is "Queen's Choice"; her second choice is "Soft Plum". The kickplates are less than a foot tall. She would like to differentiate her store from the business next door. Ms. Tunner noted that Victorian colors were generally darker than modem colros,and that the existing Old Town infill buildings were purposely made of a darker cast of purple brick. Maroon and burgundy colors are used throughout Old Town. Mr. Hill asked about current changes going on at Coopersmith's and Ms. Kunze replied that these are all interior changes and will not affect the exterior. Mr. Hill commented that the new color will add life to the facade. Ms. Kunze will check with Mr. Stoner of Foxfire Property Management for permission. Mr. Tanner moved to approve the color scheme as presented, using the first choice, "Queen's Choice." Mr. Hogestad seconded the motion. The motion passed, 4-0. ITEMS: Demolition Delay and Minimum Maintenance Ordinance Mr. Frank introduced the discussion by stating that it appears unlikely that this ordinance will come up at the originally scheduled February 15 City Council meeting. It will probably be on the March 1 agenda. Responding to LPC input, he wrote an ordinance to reflect the LPC's concerns -- for example, adding a new provision which would require landmark -eligible structures to maintain the structural elements in order to avoid future situations such as the advanced deterioration of the Linden Hotel. He spoke with Felix Lee, Director of Building Permits and Zoning, since this ordinance will impact the UCBC and that department. At LPC request, the Building Inspector may respond by investigating a property for possible violations and issue a ticket if required by the situation.. The LPC will recommend rather than enforce, which is done by the Building Permits Department. The LPC discussed the proposed ordinance and recommended that Mr. Frank and Mr. Eckman review the following sections for wording: Sec. 14-60. "No structure fifty (50) years of age or older... "to the end of the paragraph needs to be reworded to align with Sec. 14.61.--1. • Landmark Preservation Commission Adjourned Regular Meeting Minutes January 19, 1994 Page 3 Sec. 14-61.--(a) Specify that the process begins after the applicant has filed a complete application, including support materials. Sec. 14-61.--2.(b) Insert two phrases: "The applicant shall", not later than seven Cl) working dW prior to the hearing, "submit information as the" Planning Director "believes is necessary...". Sec. 14-61.--5. Change "30 days" to 45 days. • • _ 1 1 • . • •.1 • . • • I I Ir • ! • � 11 .. 1 • I l� • _ log 1 � • • I ! • ..y•.. • - • _I- 11 !' � lief• Sec. 14-61. The LPC wanted to require that a plan be in hand before demolition be allowed. Mr. Frank noted that on the average, about 5 demolitions of buildings with pQ historic merit occur each year. He recommended a public meeting before submitting the ordinance for City Council consideration. Some members were concerned that holding a meeting prematurely would trigger demolitions. The LPC discussed the merits of requesting a moratorium during public discussion. Mr. Frick moved that a public meeting be held on February 16 for the Demolition Delay and Minimum Maintenance Ordinance. Mr. Tanner seconded the motion. The motion failed, 2-3. Ayes: Frick, Tanner. Nayes: Carpenter, Hill, Hogestad. The Commission asked Jennifer Carpenter to contact Council member Horak about his thoughts on having a public meeting. H he recommends one, then staff will schedule it for February 16. All agreed. Mr. Eckman explained that Option A essentially leaves the process as it is. Option B will allow more appeals and Option C will generally deny appeals. The $75 fee was questioned as inadequate. Mr. Frick moved that the LPC recommend Option C. There was no second so the motion failed. The LPC decided to continue discussion to the following meeting. Landmark Preservation Commission Adjourned Regular Meeting Minutes January 19, 1994 Page 4 OTHER BUSINESS: Ms. Carpenter presented plaques to former LPC members Brian Janonis and Kirk Jensen in recognition of their efforts on behalf of historic preservation and service to the Landmark Preservation Commission. The meeting adjourned at 8:20 p.m. Submitted by Diane Slater, Secretary.