HomeMy WebLinkAboutTransportation Board - Minutes - 08/19/2020
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
August 19, 2020, 6:00 p.m.
Virtual Meeting Via Zoom
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 1
FOR REFERENCE:
Chair: Indy Hart
Vice Chair:
Council Liaison:
Nathalie Rachline
Kristin Stephens
Staff Liaison: Aaron Iverson
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Hart called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM.
2. ROLL CALL
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT:
Indy Hart, Chair
Nathalie Rachline, Vice Chair
Jerry Gavaldon
York
Ellen Boeke
Kevin Borchert
Cari Brown
Matt Liberati
BOARD MEMBERS ABSENT:
None
CITY STAFF PRESENT:
Drew Brooks
PUBLIC PRESENT:
None
3. AGENDA REVIEW
Iverson stated the City budget update will need to be rescheduled.
4. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
None.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – JULY 2020
Iverson stated he made a wording change per York's request.
York made a motion, seconded by Rachline, to approve the July 2020 minutes as amended.
The motion was adopted unanimously.
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 2
6. UNFINISHED BUSINESS
None.
7. NEW BUSINESS
a. City Budget Update – Noelle Currell
(**Secretary's Note: This item will be rescheduled.)
b. Transfort – COVID Impacts to Transit Service – Drew Brooks
Drew Brooks, Transfort, discussed ridership numbers noting they were down about
91% on April 30th and are still down about 74% as of last week. He noted college
towns nationwide have seen the most dramatic decreases in ridership.
Brooks stated fare collection stopped on March 19th in order to help keep operators
safe. Additionally, chain separators have been installed and all loading is done at the
rear of the bus unless an individual with a mobility device is boarding.
Brooks stated an emergency regulation was signed April 18th to dramatically reduce
Transfort service and regional service was also dramatically decreased in order to
decrease regional spread of the coronavirus. He stated there has been a 17%
reduction in service hours. He noted a no charge taxi service is available for
individuals needing transportation. He stated transit centers have also been closed.
Rachline asked how the taxi service was advertised. Brooks replied it is one of the
rotating banners on the Transfort website, each bus stop contains information, and
the service was advertised on social media and in press releases.
Liberati asked about the delta between the 17% reduction in service hours and the
much larger reduction in ridership. Brooks replied the reduction in service was meant
to have the least amount of impact to riders and be somewhat easy to understand.
Brooks discussed the CARES Act funding that was earmarked for transit and
discussed likely increases in service that will be occurring once CSU resumes
classes next week. He also noted parking could be impacted as students may opt to
drive individual cars and park in neighborhoods near campus rather than ride
Transfort.
Brooks noted there have been few COVID outbreaks that have been traced to public
transit use. He discussed a transit survey that is currently ongoing.
Boeke commented on the messaging around using Transfort only for essential trips.
Rachline asked if route changes have been considered to get people to essential
destinations. Brooks discussed micro-transit and stated some of those options have
been discussed; however, those options are more expensive than running fixed route
service.
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 3
Borchert asked how the management of mask wearing is occurring. Brooks replied
masks are being provided for individuals without them. He went on to detail the
cleaning procedures being used for busses.
Rachline asked if coordination with neighboring municipalities is occurring regarding
resuming service. Brooks replied in the affirmative and noted the Flex route was one
of the first to resume.
Brooks discussed the difficulty in hiring and training new drivers. He stated he is not
anticipating operating at full service in 2020. He discussed projects that are moving
forward due to grant funding including the West Elizabeth bus rapid transit 30%
design project, the North College transit-oriented development study, and the
installation of electric busses.
Gavaldon asked if Transfort is still receiving contributions from its partners and how
the loss of fare dollars has impacted the budget. Brooks replied fares account for
around $600,000 per year and fares have not been collected since March. He stated
CSU has not asked for a credit for any of its contributions despite the loss of service
and stated there will likely be credits as part of next year's agreements with Flex
partners.
Brooks discussed parking impact of COVID noting parking enforcement ceased in
March with the exception of public safety and ADA violations. He stated parking
enforcement officers helped bolster staffing in other City departments including Parks
and dealing with new outdoor dining options.
Boeke asked how long the outdoor dining spaces will be allowed and whether they
could become permanent. Brooks replied it may not be permanent, but could be
retained as a regular program.
Brown asked if the curbside pickup spaces in Old Town allow for users to get out of
their cars. Brooks replied in the affirmative but noted Parking Services is not actively
policing those spaces.
Borchert asked who is funding the concrete barriers around outdoor restaurant
spaces. Brooks replied it is a partnership and may be able to be reimbursable with
CARES funding.
Brooks discussed the parking space occupancy monitoring program and stated
normal enforcement with some discretion resumed August 3rd. He discussed the
current parking garage rates, which include the first three hours being free, noting
they are designed to incentivize drivers to use the proper parking space for their use.
Boeke asked about the plan for addressing the park and ride lot at Drake and
College. Brooks replied staff is not convinced that the majority of people parking in
that lot are riding Transfort and stated consideration has been given to charging a fee
for use of the lot. He stated a survey of lot users was planned but is on hold due to
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 4
COVID.
York stated a survey should include information as to trip origins as well as
destinations. He asked when data regarding the success of new parking garage fees
will be available. Brooks replied the free three hours began in mid -July; however,
there was no parking enforcement at that time. He stated he anticipates having some
data by the end of August but a couple of months of data will be needed to determine
whether the free hours are affecting change.
Chair Hart commended the work on the Linden Street project in terms of acquiring
data from businesses.
Borchert asked if the parking space sensors are embedded in the asphalt. Brooks
replied in the affirmative.
Liberati asked if there are plans for congestion pricing. Brooks replied there are no
on-street paid spaces currently; however, that could be considered if an on-street
pricing model were adopted. He stated congestion pricing may be counterproductive
in garages if it does not exist on-street. He commented on the contentious nature of
managing the two-hour timeframe that currently exists and noted paid on -street is
easier to manage.
Chair Hart suggested the Board discuss Liberati's emailed question from earlier in the
day. Liberati questioned whether CSU is paying its fair share of Transfort service.
Brooks replied CSU accounts for slightly more than 50% of Transfort's ridership and it
pays slightly more than 10% of the total operating budget. From a fare per spective,
Transfort gets about a 20% recovery from CSU rides; however, on the rest of the
system, that number is less than 8%. Therefore, the cost per ride is higher for the
rest of the system. Brooks discussed the positive impacts of pulling vehicles of f
streets which is an associated benefit of serving CSU. He also noted CSU students
contribute to the local economy and sales tax revenue which is a primary source of
funding for Transfort.
York commented on CSU students being members of the community a nd stated they
are taxing themselves more than the rest of the population for the same service.
Gavaldon suggested the overall fare system may need to be examined in order to
strike a fair balance of contributions.
Brown stated the CSU contribution is more of a political rather than policy decision
and CSU could always opt to not provide additional funding. Brooks noted CSU has
provided funding for other things that are not just operating budget oriented. For
example, the West Elizabeth corridor 30% design project is being 25% funded by
CSU.
Chair Hart noted CSU staff also benefit from Transfort service.
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 5
York discussed the Roaring Fork Transportation Authority and its multiple funding
sources.
8. BOARD MEMBER REPORTS
Borchert asked about the status of the Reimagining Boards and Commissions project.
Iverson replied there have been no final decisions but stated transportation staff would like
its associated Boards to work more closely on a liaison or Chair level.
Chair Hart noted the Transportation Board's minutes regarding the Timberline expansion
project were part of Council's meeting packet.
Boeke commented on the high use of the whitewater park.
Liberati asked if there is a repository for documents and/or a schedule listing when major
things happen such as plan updates. Iverson replied there is a location where all plans are
stored and he will send that link to the Board. He stated the City Clerk's Office keeps a
record of all plans and update schedules.
Rachline suggested members begin thinking about what questions they would like to ask at
the budget discussion next month.
Brown stated the City Manager's recommended budget will be released September 1st
electronically and will be a one-year budget this year due to the pandemic.
York reported on the City's surveys related to the Climate Action Plan update noting one is
related to transportation. He reported on the recent Planning and Zoning Board work
session during which the Reimagining Boards and Commissions process was discussed.
He noted the City Clerk's Office has all City plans available for reference on its webpage.
9. OTHER BUSINESS
a. Bicycle Advisory Committee Report
Chair Hart noted the Bicycle Advisory Committee's minutes regarding the Timberline
expansion project were also part of Council's meeting packet.
Gavaldon reported on the BAC discussion of the Timberline expansion project and
noted it received $2.9 million in grant funding. He expressed concern regarding the
maintenance of the Mulberry protected bike lanes and stated staff will be looking at
that prior to the Timberline project being completed.
Gavaldon outlined the agenda for the next BAC meeting and stated the Committee
should be receiving more details on the September bike month.
Iverson stated the September bike month has an overarching theme of 'shift your
ride' and will include some types of low-key events.
Borchert noted volunteers can sign up on Engage to be part of the annual bike
TRANSPORTATION BOARD
TYPE OF MEETING – REGULAR
8/19/2020 – MINUTES Page 6
counts. He asked what the BAC is doing regarding electric bikes on trails. Gavaldon
replied enforcement has not been detailed; however, only type 1 and 2 E -bikes are
allowed and are to follow rules of the road.
Rachline noted it is not necessarily an E-bike issue on trails, but rather a speed issue
of all riders.
b. City Council 6-Month Calendar Review
Iverson reported Council will discuss the Parks and Recreation Master Plan at the
August 25th worksession and noted the first set of hearings for the budget are in
September. He also stated there will be a worksession in October looking at the E -
scooter program and the Our Climate Future plan update will be discussed in
November.
c. Staff Liaison Report
Iverson reported on the impacts to traffic during the pandemic quarantine. He stated
traffic has been about 10% less than usual since things have begun to reopen and
peak hours have changed slightly.
Liberati asked if there have been any traffic light adjustments resulting from the
changing traffic patterns. Iverson replied adjustments are constantly ongoing.
Borchert asked how City employees are faring in light of the pandemic. Iverson
replied most seem to be fairly optimistic and commended the ability of the City to
protect jobs.
York noted Joe Olson and Martina Wilkinson left the City organization to start their
own company, and given the current situation wherein the City is not hiring from
outside the organization, there are several interim positions in place. Iverson stated
Nicole Hahn is the current interim Traffic Engineer.
York noted the Board's annual report and work plan will be due shortly.
10. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 8:22 p.m. by unanimous consent.