HomeMy WebLinkAboutEconomic Advisory Commission - Minutes - 07/13/20111
Minutes
City of Fort Collins
Economic Advisory Commission
Regular Meeting
300 LaPorte Ave
City Hall
July 13, 2011
8:00 am – 10:30 am
For Reference:
Bill Timpson, Chair 493-3673
Council Liaison Wade Troxell
Mike Freeman, Staff Liaison 416-2259
Wendy Bricher, Minutes 221-6506
Commission members present: Commission members absent:
Stu MacMillan Michael Kulisheck
Christophe Febvre Channing Arndt
Jim Clark
Blue Hovatter
Kevin Shaw
Rick Price
Bill Timpson
Guests:
David Everitt, SFCBA
Ray Martinez, SFCBA
Jim Palmer, SFCBA
Ann Hutchison, FC Chamber of Commerce
Staff Present:
Josh Birks, Economic Advisor
Christina Vincent, Redevelopment Program Administrator
Wendy Bricher, Minutes
Agenda Item 1: Meeting called to order
Meeting called to order at 8:04 a.m.
Agenda Item 2: Approval of Minutes
Unanimous approval of minutes dated 06/15/11
Agenda Item 3: Public Comment
None
Financial Services
300 LaPorte Ave
PO Box 580
Fort Collins, CO 80522
970.221.6505
970.224.6107 - fax
fcgov.com
2
Agenda Item 4: Member Updates/Future Agenda Items Discussion
Blue Hovatter provided a brief overview of the Economic Advisory Commission Periodic Review from
the June 28 City Council Worksession. Other members of the Commission had reviewed the meeting on
FCGov.com as well.
Jim Clark commented on the upcoming issues regarding sign codes, specifically digital signs, in Fort
Collins. Jim agreed to report back and update the EAC regarding this issue at future meetings.
Josh Birks provided an update regarding the clusters in Fort Collins. He stated that each has
outperformed the national average as far as job creation, which confirms that this is a good place for us to
be spending our time. The City’s approach focuses on projects, and we are moving innovation forward
and making it easier for businesses to succeed within our community. The City will be possibly adding a
new engine and transportation industry cluster in the future.
Bill Timpson pointed out the joint session with the County Commissioners and PSD Boardmembers re:
Community Schools and Joint Learning scheduled on August 30, 2011. He stated that this is something
we should watch as decline in community schools correlates directly to neighborhood viability.
Josh Birks also provided an update regarding the funding for the Fort Collins Museum of Discovery. He
stated that Council has agreed to fund a three-month bridge loan to move the project forward at this time.
Agenda items for August will include the FCRP – Motion for Review and the Development Review Fees
& Building Permit Fees Motion for Review. In addition, the EAC will be discussing the Bike Program,
URA Citizen Advisory Group Memo Discussion & Recommendation, and the Downtown General
Improvement District Capital Improvement Plan.
Agenda Item 5: Follow-up discussion regarding previous meetings
FCRP – Motion for Review
Postponed until August
Development Review Fees & Building Permit Fees (Steve Dush/Ann Turnquist)-Motion for Review
Postponed until August
Agenda Item 6: Economic Action Plan – briefing and discussion with consultants
Consultants from TIP Strategies met with the EAC for the second time regarding the Economic Health
Action Plan approved by Council for 2011. Team members present included Jon Roberts (TIP Managing
Partner), Keeley Sullivan (Atlas Account Manager), and Kathleen Baireuther (TIP Consultant). TIP
Strategies provided a project update, findings from the assessment, SWOT Analysis, and suggested
Benchmarks. The discovery fieldwork is complete and the economic assessment and SWOT have been
drafted as well. Kevin Shaw asked how the focus groups were determined during the Discovery Phase,
and Josh Birks replied that the Focus Groups were recommended to TIP by City staff. Findings from the
assessment were discussed including growth, urbanization, unintended consequences, smart growth
principles, location quotients, and industry strengths. Josh Birks commented that an inflow/outflow
model had been completed in 2004 and showed a 35% inflow at that time. With an update completed in
2010, the inflow had decreased to 25%.
3
The draft SWOT Analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats) was evaluated by the
EAC as well. After thorough discussion, the EAC recommended the following additions be added to the
SWOT:
Strengths –
Quality of Life
Front Range Community College
Quality of schools
National publicity – best lists
Weaknesses –
Missing high end/low end workers (consequence of extending unemployment benefits)
Lack of local financing
Localization of investment – microloans, angel investment funds
Growing active retirement community – threat/opportunity? Jobs taken from youth?
Cheap, non-progressive utilities
Regional water capacity
Energy commodities
Suggested Benchmark Cities were also presented by TIP Strategies. It was noted that three
approaches could yield three very different results (by similarity, by aspiration, by competition).
Due to time constraints, TIP strategies asked the EAC to review the suggested lists in more detail
and to contact them directly with any additional recommendations.
Agenda Item 7: URA Citizen Advisory Group Memo Discussion – Christina Vincent
w/ South College Business Association members
Four options regarding the URA Midtown Citizen Advisory Group were provided by Christina Vincent to
the EAC for review. In addition, these options will be presented to Council with a final outcome to be
determined in September. Christina Vincent also provided a historical overview regarding the current
Citizen Advisory Group (CAG) for North College.
Three members from the South Fort Collins Business Association attended including Dave Everitt, Ray
Martinez, and Jim Palmer. The SFCBA has formally requested that Option 4 be adopted by the City
Council. After SFCBA’s feedback was provided, the EAC determined that they needed additional time to
review the options and feedback before making a recommendation to Council. Follow-up discussions are
scheduled at the August meeting.
Meeting adjourned at 10:46 am
The next meeting is scheduled on August 17, 2011 from 11:00 am – 1:30 pm
CIC Room, City Hall