Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutHistoric Preservation Commission - Minutes - 12/15/2021Historic Preservation Commission Page 1 December 15, 2021 Meg Dunn, Chair Location: Kurt Knierim, Vice Chair This meeting will be held Michael Bello In Chambers, 300 LaPorte Walter Dunn And remotely via Zoom Kevin Murray Anne Nelsen Jim Rose Staff Liaison: Vacant Seat Maren Bzdek Vacant Seat Interim Historic Preservation Manager Regular Meeting December 15, 2021 Minutes CALL TO ORDER Chair Dunn called the meeting to order at 5:33 p.m. ROLL CALL PRESENT: Mike Bello, Meg Dunn, Walter Dunn, Kurt Knierim, Anne Nelsen, Jim Rose ABSENT: Kevin Murray STAFF: Maren Bzdek, Jim Bertolini, Claire Havelda, Aubrie Brennan Chair Dunn read the following legal statement: “We are holding a remote meeting today in light of the continuing prevalence of COVID-19 and for the sake of the health of the Commission, City Staff, applicants and the general public. Our determination to hold this meeting remotely was made in compliance with City Council Ordinance 79 2020.” AGENDA REVIEW No changes to posted agenda. CONSENT AGENDA REVIEW No items were pulled from consent. Historic Preservation Commission DocuSign Envelope ID: 962ACF66-D78C-4317-8071-CE13FF526771 Historic Preservation Commission Page 2 December 15, 2021  STAFF REPORTS ON ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA Ms. Bzdek discussed a grant from the State Historical Fund received by the Historic Preservation Department. She stated the grant will be used to develop a civil rights historic context for Fort Collins.  PUBLIC COMMENT ON ITEMS NOT ON THE AGENDA None.  CONSENT AGENDA [Timestamp: 5:39 p.m.] 1. CONSIDERATION AND APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 17, 2021 The purpose of this item is to approve the minutes from the November 17, 2021 regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission. Co-Chair Knierim moved that the Historic Preservation Commission approve the Consent Agenda of the November 17, 2021 regular meeting as presented. Member Nelsen seconded. The motion passed 6-0. [Timestamp: 5:40 p.m.]  DISCUSSION AGENDA 2. STAFF YEAR IN REVIEW REPORT TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION The purpose of this item is to present the Colorado Certified Local Government Annual Report for 2021. Ms. Bzdek discussed the Certified Local Government Annual Report submitted by the City related to Historic Preservation program activities in the prior fiscal year. She provided additional details on the Certified Local Government designation and highlighted accomplishments of the program over the past year, including the landmarking of 308 Cherry Street. 3. STAFF DESIGN REVIEW DECISIONS ON DESIGNATED PROPERTIES Staff is tasked with reviewing projects and, in cases where the project can be approved without submitting to the Historic Preservation Commission, with issuing a Certificate of Appropriateness or a SHPO report under Chapter 14, Article IV of the City’s Municipal Code. This item is a report of all such review decisions since the last regular meeting of the Commission. 4. 1433 S. OVERLAND TRAIL – LANDMARK NOMINATION DESCRIPTION: This item is to consider the request for a recommendation to City Council for landmark designation of the Maxwell Rock House at 1433 South Overland Trail. APPLICANT: Ponds at Overland Trail (HOA); Timothy A Johnson, President Disclosures Chair Dunn noted Member Murray has recused himself from the discussion of this item due to a conflict of interest and noted she knows Lyn Iannuzzi; however, that will not bias her decision in any way. Staff Report Mr. Bertolini presented the staff report regarding the landmark designation nomination for 1433 South Overland Trail, which is supported by the property owner, the Ponds at Overland Trail HOA. He discussed the location of the property and noted most of the area has lost its historic context; therefore, the designated area for the nomination is just the building and its immediate environment. DocuSign Envelope ID: 962ACF66-D78C-4317-8071-CE13FF526771 Historic Preservation Commission Page 3 December 15, 2021 Mr. Bertolini stated the property is being nominated under two standards: for persons and groups for association with Paul and Emerald Maxwell, and for design and construction as a strong and rare example of vernacular stone construction for a farmhouse. He stated this is one of only two known rock farmhouses in the Fort Collins area. Mr. Bertolini discussed the historical significance and contributions of the Maxwell family. He showed photos of the property and commented on the role of the Commission in voluntary designations. He stated the two public comments received were both in support of the landmark designation. Applicant Presentation Tim Johnson, Ponds at Overland HOA President, gave the Applicant presentation. He noted the Ponds and Overland development was built out around the Maxwell Rock House. He commented on the installation of the metal roof to help maintain the integrity of the structure and noted winterization repairs on the rock work have begun. He stated dollars have been set aside to work on renovation beginning in the spring with the ultimate goal of the building being something neighborhood residents could use. Public Input Lyn Iannuzzi stated Paul and Emerald Maxwell were her grandparents and she discussed her memories of spending time in the home. She noted the metal roof was funded by a family member and was installed over the original roof in order to salvage the home. She expressed support for the designation. Karen Maxwell commented on her memories of the home and expressed support for the designation. Marie Wright clarified that Emerald lived in the house until 1983. Commission Questions and Discussion Chair Dunn asked if the original roof shingles are still under the metal roof. Ms. Iannuzzi replied in the affirmative. Members Nelsen and Bello expressed support for the nomination and stated they are glad to see the property saved. Co-Chair Knierim stated this is a timely request in that it is a good opportunity to start to rehabilitate the home with some financial assistance. Chair Dunn asked if the HOA will be able to sell tax credits as it is a non-profit. Mr. Bertolini replied in the affirmative. Ms. Iannuzzi stated the original roof shingles on the house were painted green, which is why the green metal roof was chosen. Mr. Bertolini stated he would get all research on the house transferred to the HOA. Chair Dunn commented on a letter received from Michael Murphy who stated this house is included in Fort Collins historic tours. Commission Deliberation Member Bello moved that the Historic Preservation Commission recommend that City Council adopt an ordinance to designate the Maxwell Rock House at 1433 S. Overland Trail, as a Fort Collins Landmark, finding that this property is eligible for its significance to Fort Collins under Standard 2, Persons/Groups, and Standard 3, Design/Construction, as supported by the analysis provided in the staff report and Landmark nomination dated December 15, 2021, and that the property clearly conveys this significance through all seven aspects of integrity to a sufficient degree; and finding also that the designation of this property will promote the policies and purposes of the City as specified in Chapter 14 of the Municipal Code. Member Nelsen seconded. The motion passed 6-0. [Timestamp: 6:22 p.m.] DocuSign Envelope ID: 962ACF66-D78C-4317-8071-CE13FF526771 Historic Preservation Commission Page 4 December 15, 2021 5. 900 S. COLLEGE AVE – NATIONAL REGISTER REVIEW DESCRIPTION: This item is to provide a recommendation to the State Historic Preservation Officer regarding the nomination of the Scott Apartments and Garage to the National Register of Historic Places. As a Certified Local Government, both the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC) and the Mayor provide a written recommendation. APPLICANT: Steve Levinger (owner); State Historic Preservation Office Staff Report Mr. Bertolini presented the staff report noting this is a nomination to the National Register of Historic Places coming at the request of the property owner, Steve Levinger. He discussed the property, which has been a designated City landmark since 2002, noting the nomination falls under two criteria: A for events and trends in providing residential housing for working class professionals, and C for design and architecture as an example of an early 20th century apartment. He stated the building has strong integrity under all seven aspects and showed photos of the property. He commented on the role of the Commission. Applicant Presentation Steve Levinger gave the Applicant presentation. He stated he previously rehabilitated the Armstrong Hotel and looks forward to doing the same for the Scott Apartments. He commented on the symmetry of the building. Public Input None. Commission Questions and Discussion Member Bello stated this is a good candidate for the National Register. Member Rose stated the presentation summarized the value of the property and it has everything needed to be eligible for inclusion in the National Register. Chair Dunn stated she had not realized there was an armory in the area and stated the Scott Apartments are a good example of the buildings that were in the area. She commented on the role of A.W. Scott in the community. Commission Deliberation Co-Chair Knierim moved that the Historic Preservation Commission recommend to the Colorado State Historic Preservation Officer that the Scott Apartments and Garage at 900 South College Avenue is eligible for the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A and C, as supported by the analysis provided in the transmitted National Register nomination form dated November 5, 2021, and directing the Chair to complete the appropriate section of the Review Report Form indicating the Commission’s recommendation. Member Rose seconded. The motion passed 6-0. [Timestamp: 6:41 p.m.] DocuSign Envelope ID: 962ACF66-D78C-4317-8071-CE13FF526771 Historic Preservation Commission Page 5 December 15, 2021 OTHER BUSINESS Chair Dunn noted this was Member Bello’s last meeting. ADJOURNMENT Chair Dunn adjourned the meeting at 6:43 p.m. Minutes prepared by TriPoint Data and respectfully submitted by Aubrie Brennan. Minutes approved by a vote of the Commission on __________________. _____________________________________ Meg Dunn, Chair January 19, 2022 DocuSign Envelope ID: 962ACF66-D78C-4317-8071-CE13FF526771